Estates 77 Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Estates 77 Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment (No 2) [2019] FCA 1935

File number: WAD 286 of 2019
Judges: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 21 November 2019
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application of judicial review of a decision made under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EPBC Act) – judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – whether the Minister for Environment made an error of law in considering the applicants’ action a ‘controlled action’ – whether the applicants were exempt under s 43A of the EPBC Act

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW – EPBC Act – construction of s 43A – whether ‘specific environmental authorisation’ was given by a law of the State – consideration of Minister for Environment and Heritage v Greentree (No 2) (2004) 138 FCR 198 – endangered and vulnerable species of black cockatoo

Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5, 6

Environment and Heritage Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 2006 (Cth) (Act No 165 of 2006)

Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) ss 18, 18A, 43A, 43A(1), 43A(1)(b), 43A(1)(c), 43A(1)(d), 43A(1A), 43A(2), 67, 70(3), 75, 75(1), 87, 523(1), 527E

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Environment Protection Act 1986 (WA) ss 38, 48I, Pt IV

Cases cited:

Booth v Bosworth (2001) 114 FCR 39

Chang v Laidley Shire Council (2007) 234 CLR 1

Estates 77 Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment [2019] FCA 1427

Greentree v Minister for Environment and Heritage (2005) 144 FCR 388

Maxwell v Murphy (1957) 96 CLR 261

Minister for Environment and Heritage v Greentree (No 2) (2004) 138 FCR 198

Date of hearing: 4 September 2019
Date of last submissions: 4 October 2019
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 102
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr P McQueen
Solicitor for the Applicants: Lavan
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr GT Johnson SC with Mr AK Sharpe
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

WAD 286 of 2019
BETWEEN:

ESTATES 77 PTY LTD (ACN 008 688 131)

First Applicant

NOVALEE NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 111 776 017)

Second Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR THE ENVIRONMENT

Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 NOVEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the costs of the respondent, to be assessed if not agreed. 

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MCKERRACHER J:

THE DISPUTE

  1. The first applicant, Estates 77 Pty Ltd (ACN 008 688 131), and the second applicant, Novalee Nominees Pty Ltd (ACN 111 776 017) (collectively, the applicants), wish to proceed with a development.  The Minister for the Environment has taken steps which may delay or preclude the development due to a perceived risk to species of cockatoo. 

  2. The applicants apply under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estates 77 Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1935
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Estates 77 Pty Ltd, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for the Environment regarding the assessment of a proposed action under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EPBC Act). The applicants argued that the Minister erred in determining their proposed action as a 'controlled action', which would require approval under the EPBC Act. They contended that the action was exempt under section 43A of the EPBC Act because it had received a specific environmental authorisation from a State law prior to the commencement of the EPBC Act. The applicants sought a declaration that the Minister’s decision was unlawful and sought an injunction to prevent the Minister from taking any further steps in assessing the proposed action.

The key legal issues in the case revolved around the interpretation of section 43A of the EPBC Act and whether the Minister had correctly identified the applicants' action as a 'controlled action'. The court had to determine whether the authorisation granted under Western Australia’s Environmental Protection Act 1986 qualified as a 'specific environmental authorisation' under the EPBC Act, and whether this authorisation exempted the proposed action from further assessment under the EPBC Act.

The court examined the legislative history and the amendments made to section 43A of the EPBC Act in 2006. It considered the decision of Sackville J in Minister for Environment and Heritage v Greentree (No 2) (2004) 138 FCR 198, where a broader interpretation of 'specific authorisation' was applied. However, the court noted that subsequent amendments to section 43A had narrowed the scope of what constitutes a 'specific environmental authorisation'. The court held that the authorisation granted under the Western Australian legislation did not meet the stringent criteria set out in the amended section 43A(2) of the EPBC Act, as it did not identify the particular action by reference to acts and matters uniquely associated with that action. Consequently, the Minister’s decision that the proposed action was a 'controlled action' was not an error of law.

The court dismissed the application, holding that the Minister's decision was lawful and that the applicants' proposed action did not qualify for exemption under section 43A of the EPBC Act. The applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the costs of the respondent, to be assessed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In Estates 77 (No 1), I set out the background to this proceeding substantially as deposed to by Mr Wallace in his affidavit. For convenience, this background is repeated.The background to the Proposed Action The Subject Land was rezoned ‘Urban Deferred’ pursuant to MRS Amendment 937/33 (South West Corridor Stage B) to Western Australia’s Metropolitan Region Scheme, which amendment became effective on 10 December 1994. Its purpose was to give effect to the proposals in the South West Corridor Structure Plan within the City of Rockingham. At the same time, and as part of the process of MRS Amendment 937/33, the Environmental Protection Authority for the State of Western Australia (the EPA) set a level of ‘Public Environmental Review’ (Assessment Number 838) for certain aspects of proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 and produced EPA Bulletin 746 dated July 1994. The other land use changes proposed by the proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 (including the proposed Urban Deferred zoning for the Subject Land) were to be considered by the EPA at the level of ‘informal review with public advice’. The advice of the EPA was contained in a letter of 5 May 1994 and included the following:The [EPA] considers that decisions on the use of bushland areas outside Systems Recommendation areas and conservation areas should be made through the planning process, both at the State and local level. The then State Minister for the Environment approved MRS Amendment 937/33, subject to conditions (which did not relate to the Subject Land) by Ministerial Statement 368, dated 11 October 1994: ‘Statement That A Proposal May Be Implemented (pursuant to the provisions of the Environmental Protection Act 1986)’ (Annexure A). Subsequently, on 16 July 2000, the EPBC Act commenced operation, the significance of which will become apparent. The City adopted the South Baldivis District Structure Plan (the SBDSP) in 2001. The Subject Land was located within Precinct 4 of the SBDSP (constituting approximately 70% of Precinct 4) and planned for a predominant zoning of ‘Urban’ for an ultimate planned population of 4,290 people. The Subject Land was zoned ‘Development’ in the City’s Town Planning Scheme No 2 (the TPS2) and gazetted. Clause 4.2.4 of the TPS2 required a local structure plan to be prepared to support the development or subdivision of any land within the Development zone. Planning consultants for the applicants lodged such a draft proposed Local Structure Plan (the LSP) with the City on 18 March 2010, setting out a proposed design for 870 residential lots. In April 2010, the planning consultants also lodged with the West Australian Planning Commission (the WAPC) a request (with supporting information) for the lifting of the Urban Deferment zoning to Urban zoning. The draft proposed LSP was revised a number of times in October 2011. A fourth version was submitted by the applicants’ planning consultants to the City. It enclosed an Environmental Assessment Report dated September 2011, prepared by RPS Environmental Consultants. It advised, amongst other things, that due to the topography there was a need to reduce the levels across the site to a maximum of approximately 28-30 metres AHD which ‘will result in very little ability to retain native trees across most of the site’. RPS had earlier commissioned a tree survey ecologists dated 2 March 2011, which had been required by the City as a requirement for advertising the draft proposed LSP.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In addition to the ADJR Act ground, there is an application pursuant to s 39B of the Judiciary Act for a writ of prohibition against the Minister to take no further action or steps in respect of the Minister’s proposed assessment of the Proposed Action. The ground in support of the writ are the same as those relied upon under the ADJR Act. Accordingly, it is sufficient to consider the ground under the ADJR Act.THE EVIDENCE The applicants rely on the affidavit of Mr Craig Wallace, sworn 17 May 2019. The Minister relies on the affidavit of Mr Cain Sibley, affirmed 2 July 2019. The affidavits upon which the parties rely, both deposed to by their solicitors, were read subject to relevance. An issue arose during the course of the hearing as to the definition of ‘urbanisation’. The parties were given leave to file short supplementary submissions on this point. Those submissions were filed. Ultimately little turned on the topic. In Estates 77 (No 1), I set out the background to this proceeding substantially as deposed to by Mr Wallace in his affidavit. For convenience, this background is repeated.The background to the Proposed Action The Subject Land was rezoned ‘Urban Deferred’ pursuant to MRS Amendment 937/33 (South West Corridor Stage B) to Western Australia’s Metropolitan Region Scheme, which amendment became effective on 10 December 1994. Its purpose was to give effect to the proposals in the South West Corridor Structure Plan within the City of Rockingham. At the same time, and as part of the process of MRS Amendment 937/33, the Environmental Protection Authority for the State of Western Australia (the EPA) set a level of ‘Public Environmental Review’ (Assessment Number 838) for certain aspects of proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 and produced EPA Bulletin 746 dated July 1994. The other land use changes proposed by the proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 (including the proposed Urban Deferred zoning for the Subject Land) were to be considered by the EPA at the level of ‘informal review with public advice’. The advice of the EPA was contained in a letter of 5 May 1994 and included the following:The [EPA] considers that decisions on the use of bushland areas outside Systems Recommendation areas and conservation areas should be made through the planning process, both at the State and local level. The then State Minister for the Environment approved MRS Amendment 937/33, subject to conditions (which did not relate to the Subject Land) by Ministerial Statement 368, dated 11 October 1994: ‘Statement That A Proposal May Be Implemented (pursuant to the provisions of the Environmental Protection Act 1986)’ (Annexure A). Subsequently, on 16 July 2000, the EPBC Act commenced operation, the significance of which will become apparent. The City adopted the South Baldivis District Structure Plan (the SBDSP) in 2001. The Subject Land was located within Precinct 4 of the SBDSP (constituting approximately 70% of Precinct 4) and planned for a predominant zoning of ‘Urban’ for an ultimate planned population of 4,290 people.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 29 March 2019, the Minister decided under s 75 and s 87 of the EPBC Act that the Proposed Action was a ‘controlled action’ under the EPBC Act and that the Proposed Action would require assessment and approval under the EPBC Act before it could proceed (the Controlled Action Decision). The Minister further notified that the Proposed Action would need to be assessed by preliminary documentation. The applicants rely on s 5 and s 6 of the ADJR Act discussed below. The applicants say, in particular, they are aggrieved by:(a)the Minister’s delegate’s Deemed Referral Decision (referred to below);(b)the Minister’s delegate’s Controlled Action Decision; and (c)the Minister’s delegate’s conduct in deciding to proceed with an assessment of the Proposed Action purportedly under the EPBC Act. The essence of the complaint is that the decision involved an error of law in that the Proposed Action is not a ‘controlled action’ as it is exempt under the EPBC Act. What may be ‘exempt’ is a central consideration. The practical interaction of State and Federal statute arises. In addition to the ADJR Act ground, there is an application pursuant to s 39B of the Judiciary Act for a writ of prohibition against the Minister to take no further action or steps in respect of the Minister’s proposed assessment of the Proposed Action. The ground in support of the writ are the same as those relied upon under the ADJR Act. Accordingly, it is sufficient to consider the ground under the ADJR Act.THE EVIDENCE The applicants rely on the affidavit of Mr Craig Wallace, sworn 17 May 2019. The Minister relies on the affidavit of Mr Cain Sibley, affirmed 2 July 2019. The affidavits upon which the parties rely, both deposed to by their solicitors, were read subject to relevance. An issue arose during the course of the hearing as to the definition of ‘urbanisation’. The parties were given leave to file short supplementary submissions on this point. Those submissions were filed. Ultimately little turned on the topic. In Estates 77 (No 1), I set out the background to this proceeding substantially as deposed to by Mr Wallace in his affidavit. For convenience, this background is repeated.The background to the Proposed Action The Subject Land was rezoned ‘Urban Deferred’ pursuant to MRS Amendment 937/33 (South West Corridor Stage B) to Western Australia’s Metropolitan Region Scheme, which amendment became effective on 10 December 1994. Its purpose was to give effect to the proposals in the South West Corridor Structure Plan within the City of Rockingham. At the same time, and as part of the process of MRS Amendment 937/33, the Environmental Protection Authority for the State of Western Australia (the EPA) set a level of ‘Public Environmental Review’ (Assessment Number 838) for certain aspects of proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 and produced EPA Bulletin 746 dated July 1994. The other land use changes proposed by the proposed MRS Amendment 937/33 (including the proposed Urban Deferred zoning for the Subject Land) were to be considered by the EPA at the level of ‘informal review with public advice’.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Importantly, the applicants note that if the Minister is correct in its submissions that Ministerial Statement 368 is not a ‘specific environmental authorisation’, then the prior authorisation exemption in s 43A of the EPBC Act becomes otiose in a Western Australian context. If the Minister is right, a proponent who has obtained a Ministerial Statement that predates the EPBC Act, following a rezoning amendment and benefits from a subdivision approval with no further requirement for State environmental assessment, will still be required to undergo another assessment under the EPBC Act at the end of that process. It is argued the consequence would fundamentally affect the commerciality of the development process and the point and purpose of the prior authorisation exemption. CONSIDERATION Section 43A of the EPBC Act was amended by the Environment and Heritage Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 2006 (Cth) (Act No 165 of 2006) (the 2006 Act). It has not been amended since. Prior to the 2006 Act, s 43A was in the following terms:43A Actions with prior authorisation(1)A person may take an action described in a provision of Part 3 without an approval under Part 9 for the purposes of the provision if:(a) the action consists of a use of land, sea or seabed; and(b)the action was specifically authorised under a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a self-governing Territory before the commencement of this Act; and(c)immediately before the commencement of this Act, no further environmental authorisation was necessary to allow the action to be taken lawfully.(2) In this section:environmental authorisation means an authorisation under a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a self-governing Territory that has either or both of the following objects (whether express or implied):(a) to protect the environment;(b)to promote the conservation and ecologically sustainable use of natural resources. The amendments brought about by the 2006 Act followed the construction given to s 43A of the EPBC Act by Sackville J in Minister for Environment and Heritage v Greentree(No 2) (2004) 138 FCR 198. Greentree was appealed but not on this issue: Greentree v Minister for Environment and Heritage (2005) 144 FCR 388. In Greentree, Sackville J held that a more general authorisation not specific to the subject land would constitute specific State authorisation due to the use of ‘under’ in s 43A(1) of the EPBC Act at that time. The relevant action of land clearing were covered under State law to which the areas concerned was subject. By the 2006 Act, s 43A(1)(b) was deleted and re-enacted. The current version of s 43A(1)(b) does not include the word ‘under’ (which informed Sackville J’s reasoning as to the breadth of the exemption (especially at [151]-[154])) and only includes the word ‘by’ (which Sackville J explicitly contrasted with ‘under’ (at [151])). Further, it no longer refers to authorisation under ‘a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a self-governing Territory’ (which led Sackville J to conclude that a general authorisation would engage s 43A). Section 43A(2) now is only engaged by a ‘specific environmental authorisation’. That phrase is defined by a definition clause, which was inserted in s 43A(2), also as part of the amendments brought about by the 2006 Act, as follows:specific environmental authorisation means an environmental authorisation that:(a)identifies the particular action by reference to acts and matters uniquely associated with that action; or(b)was issued or granted following a consideration of the particular action by reference to acts and matters uniquely associated with that action.Construction of s 43A