Emeco International Pty Ltd v O'Shea [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   EMECO INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD -v- O'SHEA [No 2] [2012] WASC 348

CORAM:   EDELMAN J

HEARD:   4, 5 SEPTEMBER 2012

DELIVERED          :   20 SEPTEMBER 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2310 of 2012

BETWEEN:   EMECO INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

BRENDAN O'SHEA
Defendant

Catchwords:

Restraint of trade - Employment contract - Non-competition clause  - Non-solicitation and non-service of client restraints - Employee resigning and entering employment contract with competitor of former employer - Whether employee can be restrained from competition, solicitation or service of employer's clients - Effect of words in restraint permitting release from restraint with the prior written consent of the employer - Restraint against employment with a competitor reasonable - Non-solicitation restraint and client restraint unreasonable - Injunction to be granted in terms to be decided

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Injunction in terms to be decided

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr K J Mony De Kerloy

Defendant:     Mr T Saunders (4 September 2012) Mr I Neil SC and Mr T Saunders (5 September 2012)

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Freehills

Defendant:     Keystone Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

AGA Assistance Australia Pty Ltd v Tokody [2012] QSC 176

Allison & Anor v BDO (NSW-Vic) Pty Ltd [2010] VSC 35

Amoco Australia Pty Ltd v Rocca Bros Motor Engineering Co Pty Ltd [1973] HCA 40; (1973) 133 CLR 288

Attwood v Lamont [1920] 3 KB 571

Ausdale Enterprises Pty Ltd As Trustee for The Lovett Family Trust (ACN 060 607 650) & Anor v Sandford [2006] WASCA 191

BDO Group Investments (NSW-Vic) Pty Ltd v Ngo [2010] VSC 206

Bing! Software Pty Ltd v Bing Technologies Pty Limited (No 1) [2008] FCA 1760

Brightman vLamson Paragon Ltd [1914] HCA 90; (1914) 18 CLR 331

Buckley v Tutty [1971] HCA 71; (1971) 125 CLR 353

Burke v Corruption and Crime Commission [2012] WASCA 49

Business Seating (Renovations) Ltd v Broad [1989] ICR 729

Cash Orders (Amalgamated) Ltd v Haynes (1937) 37 SR (NSW) 157

Community First Credit Union Ltd v Khan (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, 30 August 1995)

Davies v Davies (1887) 36 Ch D 359

Dawnay Day & Co Ltd v D'Alphen [1998] ICR 1068

Dyer's case (1414) 2 Hen V, f 5

Elsley v J.G. Collins Insurance Agencies Limited [1978] 2 SCR 916

Emeco International Pty Ltd v O'Shea [2012] WASC 282

Fitch v Dewes [1921] 2 AC 158

G W Plowman & Son Ltd v Ash [1964] 1 WLR 568

Harris/D-E Pty Limited v McClellands Coffee & Tea Pty Ltd [1999] NSWSC 128

Herbert Morris, Limited v Saxelby [1916] 1 AC 688

IceTV Pty Ltd v Ross [2009] NSWSC 980

IF Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Galbally [2003] VSC 192

Integrated Group Limited v Dillon [2009] VSC 361

J W Chafer Ltd v Lilley [1947] LJR 231

Jardin and Jardim Investments Pty Ltd v Metcash Ltd [2011] NSWCA 409

John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v Birt [2006] NSWSC 995

Kerchiss v Colora Printing Inks Ltd [1960]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Emeco International Pty Ltd v O'Shea [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Emeco International Pty Ltd brought an action against Mr O'Shea, who had recently resigned from his employment with Emeco to take up a position with a competitor, NPE. The dispute centred on the enforceability of various restraints in Mr O'Shea's employment contract with Emeco, including non-competition, non-solicitation, and non-service of client restraints. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The primary legal issue was whether the restraints in Mr O'Shea's employment contract were enforceable. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the non-competition, non-solicitation, and non-service of client restraints were reasonable and, if so, what the appropriate relief would be. The court also needed to consider the implications of the wording of the restraint provisions and the circumstances in which Mr O'Shea had resigned and taken up a position with a competitor.

The court found that the non-competition restraint, which prohibited Mr O'Shea from working for or providing products or services to any dry hire company that competes with Emeco in Western Australia for six months, was reasonable. The court also found that the non-solicitation restraint, which prohibited Mr O'Shea from soliciting Emeco's employees or clients, and the non-service of client restraint, which prohibited Mr O'Shea from providing services to Emeco's clients, were not reasonable. The court noted that the restraints were only necessary to protect Emeco's legitimate business interests, and that the restraints should not go further than was necessary. The court granted an injunction to enforce the non-competition restraint and dismissed the application to vary the terms of the injunction.

The court also considered the costs application. The court found that the appropriate order for costs was that Mr O'Shea pay 90% of Emeco's costs to be taxed, if not agreed, on a party and party basis. The court dismissed the application for indemnity costs, finding that there was no justification for such an order.

Background

Background to the litigation

Emeco International Pty Ltd (Emeco) sought to enforce a non-competition clause in an employment contract with Mr O'Shea. The clause included restraints against competition, solicitation, and service of Emeco's clients. Mr O'Shea resigned from Emeco and entered into employment with NPE, a competitor of Emeco. Emeco argued that Mr O'Shea should be restrained from competing with Emeco, soliciting Emeco's employees, and servicing Emeco's clients. The restraint clauses allowed for release with Emeco's prior written consent. Mr O'Shea contended that the restraints were unreasonable and unenforceable. The primary judge found that the restraint against employment with a competitor was reasonable, but the non-solicitation and client restraints were unreasonable. The case proceeded to a hearing on the terms of the injunction and costs.

The matter came before the court following a primary decision in Emeco International Pty Ltd v O'Shea [No 2] [2012] WASC 348. In the initial decision, the primary judge found that certain clauses in Mr O'Shea's employment contract with Emeco were enforceable and unreasonable. The primary judge ordered that an injunction be issued to restrain Mr O'Shea from competing with Emeco, soliciting Emeco's employees, and servicing Emeco's clients. The terms of the injunction were to be determined in further proceedings. The court heard submissions from both parties on the appropriate terms of the injunction and costs. Emeco sought an oral hearing on costs, while Mr O'Shea did not. The court dismissed the application to vary the terms of the injunction and determined the appropriate costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether an injunction should be granted to restrain Mr O'Shea from competition, solicitation, and servicing of Emeco's clients.
2. What are the appropriate terms of the injunction to be issued against Mr O'Shea?
3. What order should be made regarding costs between the parties?

Held
1. An injunction should be granted to restrain Mr O'Shea from competition, solicitation, and servicing of Emeco's clients, specifically concerning his work with NPE in Western Australia for a six-month period.
2. The terms of the injunction should be decided by the parties. If they cannot agree, the court will decide on the appropriate terms based on the submissions and evidence presented.
3. Mr O'Shea should pay 90% of Emeco's costs, to be taxed on a party and party basis. The application for indemnity costs was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is also unclear why Emeco has rewritten the terms of the Competitor Restraint which prohibit Mr O'Shea from providing products or services to 'a business competitive with the business of Emeco' into the different language of 'any dry hire company which competes with the business of [Emeco]'. There was no submission, nor any direct evidence, which suggested that there was any threat that Mr O'Shea might perform work for, or provide products or services, to a business competitive with the business of Emeco other than NPE. The only evidence of a request for 'prior written consent' by Mr O'Shea to perform work for a competitor concerned Mr O'Shea's employment with NPE.[222] An injunction should not go further than the circumstances of the case require.[223][222] Exhibit 17. [223] Tobacco Institute of Australia Ltd v Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc (1992) 38 FCR 1, 18 (Sheppard J). I have not heard any submissions precisely on the point, but from the submissions at trial I can see no difficulty with an injunction which restrains Mr O'Shea from 'working for or provid[ing] products or services to NPE' in Western Australia for the six month period of the restraint. In combination with the undertaking which Mr O'Shea has given to the court, the terms of such an injunction would protect the legitimate interests of Emeco by reference to the enforceable terms of Mr O'Shea's employment contract with Emeco. The Competitor Restraint is enforceable and an injunction should be issued to restrain conduct inconsistent with that restraint. The parties should confer on the appropriate terms of an injunction and any other orders to give effect to these reasons. If agreement can be reached, an agreed minute of orders should be sent to my associate by 4pm on Friday 21 September 2012. Absent agreement, each party should submit a minute of proposed orders and I will deal with the issues which arise on the papers or at a short hearing to follow. On 20 September 2012 I delivered my primary reasons for decision in this matter.[224] At the conclusion of my reasons I said that the parties should confer on the appropriate terms of an injunction and any other orders to give effect to the reasons. I indicated that in the absence of agreement about the orders, each party should submit a minute of proposed orders and I would deal with the issues which arose on the papers or at a short hearing to follow.[224] Emeco International Pty Ltd v O'Shea [No 2] [2012] WASC 348. The parties both submitted proposed terms for the injunction. Emeco sought to have an oral hearing in relation to costs, but Mr O'Shea did not. Neither party sought to make any submissions about the terms of the injunction which were sought. The injunction was ordered in terms which reflected the Competitor Restraint. I gave short unpublished reasons explaining the grant of the injunction in these terms. At the hearing this morning, Mr O'Shea applied to vary the terms of the injunction, and both parties both made submissions about the appropriate costs orders. Emeco sought an order for indemnity costs based on Calderbank offers made to Mr O'Shea. The application to vary the terms of the injunction was dismissed for the reasons below. The indemnity costs application should also be dismissed. The appropriate order for costs is that Mr O'Shea pay 90% of Emeco's costs to be taxed, if not agreed, on a party and party basis.