Egan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Egan and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 2705 (14 December 2017)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL  )

)          No: 2016/3271

GENERAL DIVISION  )

Re: Finian Egan
Applicant

And: Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
Respondent

ORDER

TRIBUNAL:               The  Hon. Justice  Stevenson, Deputy President

DATE:   24 January 2018

PLACE:                     Sydney

IT IS DIRECTED, in accordance with subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, that the text of the decision in this application is to be altered such that the reference to “5 May 2014” in paragraph [1] be replaced with “5 May 2016.”

..............................[sgd]................................................

The  Hon. Justice  Stevenson, Deputy President

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2016/3271

Re:Finian Egan

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. Justice Stevenson, Deputy President

Date:14 December 2017

Place:Sydney

For these reasons, I conclude that it would not be contrary to the public interest that the applicant retain his Australian citizenship. Accordingly, I will set aside the decision of the Minister.

............................[sgd]................................................

The Hon. Justice Stevenson, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – Citizenship – Applicant granted Australian  citizenship – Applicant later convicted of serious sexual offences – Applicant’s Australian citizenship revoked by the Minister – Whether it would be contrary to the public interest for the Applicant to remain an Australian citizen – Tribunal finds that  the  correct  and preferable decision is to allow the Applicant to retain his Australian citizenship  – Tribunal  finds it would not be contrary to the public interest that the Applicant retain his Australian citizenship – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007, ss 3, 34(2)

CASES

DPP v Smith [1991] 1 VR 63

McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2005] 145 FCR 70

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT [1999] FCA 1197

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Justice Stevenson, Deputy President

14 December 2017

THE PROCEEDINGS

  1. The applicant seeks a review of a decision made on 5 May 2014 by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection whereby his Australian citizenship was revoked pursuant to section 34(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 ("the Citizenship Act").  The  Minister  made  this  decision  following  the  conviction  of  the  applicant  by  a  jury on several counts of sexual assault of three female minors. On 20 December 2013, Tupman DCJ sentenced the applicant to a term of imprisonment for eight years, with a non-parole period of four years.

  2. Section 34(2) of the Citizenship Act provides as follows:

    (2)The Minister may, by writing, revoke a person's Australian citizenship if:

    (a)the person is an Australian citizen under Subdivision B of Division 2  (including because of the operation  of  section 32); and

    (b)any of the following apply:

    (i) the person has been convicted of an offence against section 50 of this Act, or section 137.1 or 137.2 of the Criminal Code , in relation to the person's application to become an Australian…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Egan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2705
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of an applicant whose Australian citizenship was revoked by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection following his conviction for serious sexual offences. The applicant, who was born in Ireland in 1934 and became an Australian citizen in 1993, contended that it would not be contrary to the public interest for him to retain his citizenship and sought the Tribunal's discretion in his favour. The Minister, conversely, argued that the applicant's continued citizenship would be contrary to the public interest.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether it would be contrary to the public interest for the applicant to retain his Australian citizenship, given his convictions for serious offences committed prior to his citizenship application. If the Tribunal found that retention would be contrary to the public interest, it then had to decide whether to exercise its discretion to affirm or set aside the Minister's decision. The Tribunal was bound by established legal principles that it could not challenge the applicant's criminal convictions or sentence.

Justice Stevenson, the Deputy President, reasoned that the term "public interest" is multifaceted and requires a careful evaluation of competing considerations. The Minister's decision-making framework, which included the seriousness of the offending, impact on victims, mitigating factors, risk of reoffending, ties to Australia, and the impact of revocation, was accepted. The Tribunal noted the applicant's continued assertion of innocence, but acknowledged that it could not impugn the convictions. Crucially, the Tribunal attached significance to the support and supervision the applicant would receive from his superior in the Catholic Church, including mechanisms for the protection of children, and balanced this against the factors favouring revocation.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the correct and preferable decision was to allow the applicant to retain his Australian citizenship. This decision was reached after a delicate balancing exercise of weighty considerations, with the existence of supervision mechanisms and the support from the Catholic Church being significant factors in determining that it would not be contrary to the public interest for the applicant to remain an Australian citizen. Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the Minister's decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

There was no issue that the applicant was convicted of "a serious offence” for the purposes of section 34 of the Citizenship Act. The applicant contended that it would not be "contrary to the public interest" that he retain his Australian citizenship and sought that this Tribunal exercise its discretion in his favour. The respondent contended that it would be contrary to the public interest that the applicant remain an Australian citizen and sought confirmation of the decision of the Minister.BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 8 November 1934 in the Republic of Ireland and is presently 83 years of age. He was ordained as a priest in the Catholic Church in June 1959, at the age of 25 years, and came to Australia in September 1959. The applicant has lived in Australia since 1959 and since has returned to Ireland only for relatively short holiday periods. The applicant retired as a parish priest in January 2000 and ceased to perform all priestly duties in 2009. In these proceedings, the applicant has the support of the most Reverend Peter Comensoli, the Bishop of Broken Bay, who indicated that he is "the church authority responsible for [the applicant]". On 8 October 1992, the applicant made an application for Australian citizenship, which was granted on 29 October 1992. He became an Australian citizen on 26 January 1993. The first group of criminal convictions of the applicant related to offences which took place in 1961 and 1962, when he was approximately 26 or 27 years of age and the complainant a girl of [Omitted pursuant to s 35, Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (“Omitted”)]. The second group of convictions concerned offences which took place in October 1971 and January 1972, when he was aged 36 or 37 years and the complainant a girl of [Omitted]. The third group of convictions related to offences which took place in 1987, when the complainant was aged 52 years and the complainant a girl of 16 years. The applicant was charged with these offences in 2012 and stood trial in the District Court of New South Wales in 2013. As noted, he was sentenced to a term of imprisonment in December 2013. At all times, the applicant has maintained that he is innocent of these offences. At his criminal trial, as was his right at law, he pleased 'not guilty' and elected to give no evidence. In these proceedings, the applicant maintained that he is innocent of the offences for which he was convicted in 2012. In his affidavit of 15 December 2016 he deposed, inter alia:7. …I pleaded not guilty to all charges and still maintain that I was wholly innocent, of all those charges … In his oral evidence the applicant said words to the effect:I confirm that I have never accepted the correctness of my convictions and maintained my innocence. It is well established that this Tribunal cannot impugn the convictions or sentence of the applicant in the present proceedings: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT [1999] FCA 1197; Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385. I did not understand the applicant to offer any challenge to that proposition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I attach significance to the fact that both Bishop Comensoli and Father Casey considered that there is a need for supervision of the applicant and the protection of children, upon his release from prison. There was no evidence of any alternative source of such supervision and protection.CONCLUSION The outcome of these proceedings is by no means straightforward or clear-cut and involves an exercise of discretion. Ultimately, I conclude that "the correct and preferable decision" is to allow the applicant to retain his Australian citizenship. A significant consideration in my determination is the support and supervision which the applicant will receive from his superior in the Catholic Church and, consequently, the existence of mechanisms for the protection of children. I have balanced this consideration against the factors which were relied upon by the respondent and also taken into account the additional mitigating matters to which I have referred above in these reasons. The outcome of these proceedings has involved a delicate balancing exercise of very serious and weighty considerations. For these reasons, I conclude that it would not be contrary to the public interest that the applicant retain his Australian citizenship. Accordingly, I will set aside the decision of the Minister.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 13 October 2016, the applicant submitted a "Declaration of Alienage", by which he attempted to relinquish his Irish citizenship. During the hearing before me, senior counsel for the applicant said words to the effect that he "does not submit that he is a stateless person now".CONSIDERATION As noted, it was common ground that the applicant was convicted of "a serious offence” for the purposes of section 34 of the Citizenship Act. He was convicted of the offences in 2013, which is well after his application for Australian citizenship dated 8 October 1992. He was sentenced to imprisonment for a period in excess of 12 months, which is the statutory definition of the term "serious prison sentence".[1] He committed the offences before he applied for Australian citizenship.[1] Section 3 of Citizenship Act. Accordingly, the first issue for determination is whether it would be contrary to the public interest for the applicant to retain his Australian citizenship. If I am satisfied that the applicant's retention of his Australian citizenship would be contrary to the public interest I am then required to determine whether I should exercise my discretion so as to affirm or set aside the decision of the Minister. In DPP v Smith [1991] 1 VR 63, the Supreme Court of Victoria defined the term "public interest" as follows:The public interest is a term embracing matters, among others, of standards of human conduct and of the functioning of government and government instrumentalities tacitly accepted and acknowledged to be for the good order of society and the well-being of its members. The interest is therefore the interests of the public as distinct from the interest of an individual or individuals. In McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2005] 145 FCR 70, Tamberlin J stated as follows, in relation to the term "public interest":The public interest is not one homogeneous, undivided concept. It will often be multifaceted and the decision maker will have to consider and evaluated the relative weight of these facets before reaching a final conclusion as to where the public interest resides … In some circumstances, one or more considerations will be of such overriding importance that they prevail over all others. In other circumstances, the competing considerations will be more finely balanced so that the outcome is not so clearly predictable. In his Statement of Reasons for Revocation of Australian citizenship, the Minister wrote inter alia:15. In determining whether it is contrary to the public interest for [the applicant] to remain an Australian citizen; it is reasonable for my consideration to include, amongst other things, the nature and the seriousness of [the applicant’s] offending, the impact of the offending on the victims, mitigating factors and any risk of reoffending, ties to Australia and the impact revocation of Australian citizenship would have on [the applicant]. I take no issue with this statement of principle. I have referred above to the views expressed by Tupman DCJ as to the seriousness of the offences committed by the applicant. Her Honour had the assistance of Victim Impact Statements from all three complainants, in which they addressed the effects upon them of the applicant's offences.