Dwight v Merrimans Local Aboriginal Land Council

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Dwight v Merrimans Local Aboriginal Land Council [2024] FedCFamC2G 440

File number: SYG 1559 of 2022
Judgment of: JUDGE D HUMPHREYS
Date of judgment: 17 May 2024
Catchwords:  INDUSTRIAL LAW – Multiple contraventions of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – Nature of employment relationship – Characterisation of employment relationship – Employee or tenant – Whether applicant employee of respondent – Right to control – Right to subcontract or assign – Where applicant and respondent entered into in a caretaker arrangement – Contracts – Contractual terms – Contractual interpretation – Where respondent in business as local Aboriginal land council – Application allowed – Applicant held to be part-time employee.
Legislation:

 Australian Constitution s 51(xx)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 13, 14, 15A, 45, 87, 90, 323, 536

Independent Contractors Act 2006 (Cth)

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act1992 (Cth) s 12

Land Rights Act 1983 (NSW) s 51

Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW)

Fair Work Ombudsman, Amusement, Events and Recreation Award 2010, MA000080, 1 January 2010

Fair Work Ombudsman, Amusement, Events and Recreation Award 2020 MA000080, 1 June 2020

Cases cited:

Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia (Inc) v Lawrence (No 2) (2008) 252 ALR 136

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited v Finance Sector Union of Australia (2001) 111 IR 227

Australian Mutual Provident Society v Chaplin (1978) 52 ALJR 407

Australian Woollen Mills Pty Ltd v Cth (1953-1954) 92 CLR 424

Braxton v Mendelson (1922) 233 NY 122

Burrows v Shire of Esperance (1998) 86 IR 75

CFMEU v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1

Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd v Producers and Citizens Co-operative Assurance Co of Australia Ltd (1931) 46 CLR 41

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker (2014) 253 CLR 169

Connelly v Wells (1994) 55 IR 73

Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v Selfridge & Co Ltd (1915) AC 847

Efex Group Pty Ltd v Bennett [2024] FCAFC 35

Fair Work Ombudsman v Transpetrol TM AS [2019] FCA 400

Hart v Mills (1846) 15 LJ Ex 200

Hollis v Vabu (2001) 207 CLR 21

James Turner Roofing Pty Ltd v Peters [2003] WASCA 28

J H Nelson Pty Ltd (1947) 74 CLR 629

JMC Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2022] FCA 750

L’Estrange v F Graucob Ltd [1934] 2 KB 394

Lend Lease Real Estate Investments Ltd v GPT RE Ltd [2006] NSWCA 207

Lehigh Valley Coal Co v Yensavage (1914) 218 F 547 (2nd Cir)

Manchee v BTIG Australia Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 813

Marshall v Whittaker’s Building Supply Co (1963) 109 CLR 210

Merritt v Merritt [1970] 1 WLR 1211

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Limited v Wright Prospecting Pty Limited [2015] HCA 37

Poletti v Ecob (No 2) (1989) 31 IR 321

R v Foster; Ex parte The Commonwealth Life (Amalgamated) Assurances Ltd (1952) 85 CLR 138

Ray v Radano [1967] AR (NSW) 471

Solle v Butcher [1950] 1 KB 671

Taylor & Ors v Johnson (1982–1983) 151…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dwight v Merrimans Local Aboriginal Land Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dwight v Merrimans Local Aboriginal Land Council involved the determination of the employment status of the applicant, who served as a caretaker for the Umbarra Cultural Centre. The applicant contended that he was an employee of the respondent, Merrimans, while the respondent argued that their relationship was one of tenancy or at most a tenancy agreement and a contract for casual employment. The central issue was whether the applicant was an employee for the purposes of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth), and a worker under the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW). The Court needed to decide whether the relationship was one of employment or another form of contractual arrangement.

The Court found that the written agreement between the parties, signed by both the applicant and the respondent's CEO, formed the basis for the contractual relationship. Despite the respondent's argument that the characterisation of their relationship should not be determined by the written agreement alone, the Court held that it should consider the terms of the contract, both express and implied, in light of the surrounding circumstances. The Court recognised that the relationship's characterisation should not solely rely on the parties' actions but must focus on the rights and duties outlined in the Agreement.

The Court concluded that an employment relationship existed between the applicant and the respondent. It held that the applicant was engaged in Merrimans' business and was therefore an employee. The Court rejected the respondent's argument that the applicant was running his own business, emphasizing that this was a key element in determining employment status. The Court granted the applicant's claim for a declaration that he was an employee of the respondent from 8 May 2014 to 5 November 2021, and it rejected the respondent's argument that the applicant performed work voluntarily. The Court directed the parties to assess damages and the hours worked by the applicant during his employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principal question in these proceedings is whether the applicant was an “employee” for the purposes of the FW Act, the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act1992 (Cth) (“the SGA Act”) and a “worker” for the purposes of the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) (“the LSL Act”). BACKGROUND The applicant held the position of “caretaker” of the Umbarra Cultural Centre (“the Centre”) in the Wallaga Community, pocketed in the South Coast of NSW, some 14 kilometres north of Bermagui. The applicant held the position of a caretaker between 8 May 2014 and 5 November 2021, during which he also resided at the accommodation owned by Merrimans. He did not pay any rent for that accommodation. The relationship between the applicant and respondent was governed by a document, Exhibit A, entitled “Position Description” (“the Agreement”). The identity of the contracting parties is not in dispute. In May 2014, the parties signed the Agreement. The nature and meaning of the Agreement are disputed by both parties. The applicant alleges that it is an employment contract. The respondent claims that it is something else entirely - a simple tenancy with some additional duties, or at most, a tenancy agreement and a contract for casual employment. Prior to the signing of the Agreement, the respondent’s then Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”), Anne Greenaway, engaged in oral discussions with the applicant regarding the applicant moving into rent-free accommodation which was owned and operated by the respondent. This provision of free accommodation would come in exchange for the applicant offering caretaking services at the Umbarra Parcel of Land managed by the respondent. The oral conversations between Ms Greenaway and the applicant catalysed the exchange of the Agreement for the applicant’s consideration. It was expressed to the applicant that any subsequent contractual relationship between the parties would first require approval from the Board of Merrimans. On 1 May 2014, Ms Greenaway provided the Agreement to the applicant. Within the Agreement, it was conveyed to the applicant that the respondent was offering to codify the earlier oral agreement between the parties. That is, as a matter of quid pro quo, the applicant would live in the agreed upon rent-free accommodation in exchange for undertaking caretaker duties for the respondent. On 8 May 2014, the applicant provided Ms Greenaway with a signed copy of the Agreement. It is undisputed that the Agreement was in written form and signed by both Ms Greenaway and the applicant. It was alleged by the applicant that at around 11:00pm on 15 July 2021, someone entered the property and maliciously caused serious damage to the applicant’s motor vehicle. The applicant held the respondent liable for that damage. The respondent refused to pay any compensation for the damage caused to the applicant’s motor vehicle. On 20 August 2021, the applicant left the Centre and subsequently, on 28 September 2021, the respondent wrote to the applicant to effectively terminate the Agreement. THE EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 20 August 2021, the applicant left the Centre and subsequently, on 28 September 2021, the respondent wrote to the applicant to effectively terminate the Agreement. THE EVIDENCE This matter was heard as a one-day trial, commencing on 13 March 2024. Following the completion of evidence, closing submissions were filed by both parties. Evidence was called from the following witnesses: (a)The applicant; (b)Ms Anne Greenaway;(c)Mr Terrence Mark Hill; and (d)Ms Dianne McVeity. The applicant presented as a broadly credible witness, albeit introducing information at times that did not fit easily with the rest of his story. The applicant’s situation and other factual issues are discussed at length in both the background and proceeding sections. Ms Greenaway was the CEO of Merrimans between August 2010 and August 2017. As CEO, Ms Greenaway was responsible for hiring employees on behalf of Merrimans. Ms Greenaway admitted during oral evidence that she signed multiple contracts with employees on behalf of Merrimans, including cleaners, administration officers, as well as trainees and casuals. The Court notes that Ms Greenaway is an experienced CEO and currently holds board positions and directorships in her area of expertise, including being on the Board of SEARMS – an Aboriginal housing management service. Ms Greenaway has tertiary qualifications, including a Bachelor of Arts and a Masters of Letters, a Diploma in Business Management and a Certificate IV in Governance. Mr Hill was the CEO of Merrimans between February 2018 and December 2020. During his oral evidence, Mr Hill agreed that the Centre was a “valuable” community asset. Ms McVeity was employed by Merrimans as a Financial Officer and Office Manager from July 2018. Ms McVeity was acting CEO of Merrimans between 10 November 2020 and January 2021. From January 2021 until her retirement on 10 March 2023, Ms McVeity was the permanent CEO of Merrimans. Ms McVeity gave oral evidence that she was not involved in the drafting of any contracts or contractual arrangements made prior to 2018, including those concerning Merrimans and the applicant.The background of the Agreement The following is taken from the evidence provided to the Court by the witnesses, intending to shed light on the background of the Agreement. The contractual situation came into fruition after the applicant had a conversation with Mr Fergus McWhirter, the Vice President of the Bermagui Men’s Shed, regarding future caretaking prospects: Applicant: Do you know anyone that would be looking for someone who could look after a property? The applicant recalled during his oral evidence that he had this discussion with Mr McWhirter in relation to whether any caretaker opportunities existed, as he wanted to stay in the area. Counsel for the respondent, Mr Meagher, also asserted that the applicant was looking to move to a property where he may be able to maintain it for other persons. During cross-examination, the applicant was asked the following: Mr Meagher: How well do you recall that conversation which occurred 10 years ago?Applicant: Like it was yesterday.Mr Meagher: Is there a reason you recall that conversation from 10 years ago so well?Applicant: Well, he told me about an opportunity and that ended up being the Umbarra Cultural Centre. Mr Meagher: Could I suggest to you that you said to him that you mentioned you needed somewhere to live and that he just suggested that Merrimans might have somewhere that you can live. Could that have been what occurred? Applicant: Yeah…it had accommodation, it was vacant and on the balance of them having sheds with long equipment, tools etc. He said to go and see Anne Greenaway and that it would be good to have a caretaker here to look after our sheds as well. And I said okay. He said go up and see Anne, so I did.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Court will hear from the parties as to the appropriate penalties to be imposed for the breaches found to have been proved at a separate penalty hearing.CONCLUSION Based on a consideration of all of the relevant evidence, the Court is satisfied that there was an employment relationship between the applicant and the respondent. Because the parties have somewhat comprehensively outlined the terms of their relationship within the written Agreement before this Court, and accepted that its validity is not in dispute, the characterisation of their relationship cannot constitute anything other than that of part-time employment. The applicant is entitled to a declaration that between 8 May 2014 to 5 November 2021 he was an employee of the respondent. Further, the Court rejects the proposition that the applicant performed work voluntarily. What must now follow is an assessment by the parties in relation to damages and the hours worked by the applicant during the course of his employment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Based on the High Court’s approach in both Personnel Contracting and Jamsek, this Court is of the view that where a written contract exists between the parties, the Court should be limited to considering the terms – both express and implied – of the contract, with regard to the surrounding circumstances and not to consider how the parties subsequently acted in the performance of the contract in question: (see; Personnel Contracting at [45]). However, that is not to say that the characterisation process should not pay heed to the “totality of the relationship between the parties” against the indicia of employment established in different authorities (Personnel Contracting at [61]). In the current case, it is important to recognise that regard must be had to the rights and duties propounded by the parties in the Agreement, and not simply the way the parties have purported to act devoid of any regard to their contractual obligations. CONSIDERATIONWas an employment relationship created? It is not doubted that the parties were free to contract upon the rights and obligations to which they are now bound, however, this Court is required to determine the character of the relationship upon which those rights and obligations are constructed: (see; R v Foster; Ex parte The Commonwealth Life (Amalgamated) Assurances Ltd (1952) 85 CLR 138 at [151]). Opinions on how this Court should construe the law and insights on matters of law, as provided by both parties, should not be afforded great weight because “the opinion of the parties on a matter of law is irrelevant”: (see; Personnel Contracting at [66]). The respondent’s submissions had some merit when stating that the “label” prescribed by the parties to describe their relationship will rarely assist the Court. This was made clear in Personnel Contracting at [66]; that even if it is a case where “descriptive language” is selected by the parties, and that language can inform the objective understanding of the terms of the contract, parties’ descriptions of their respective relationship nonetheless will not greatly assist the Court. This is why the Court must have regard to consider, independently, the relationship between the parties with reference to their rights and obligations. In determining whether an employment relationship was created, the High Court in Personnel Contracting stated at [36]:The value of the “own business/employer’s business” dichotomy in determining whether a person engaged to undertake work for another is an employee of that other has long been recognised. It follows that this Court will characterise the relationship between the parties based on a determination of whose “business” the applicant was engaged in at the time: (see; Braxton v Mendelson (1922) 233 NY 122 at [124]). That analysis follows on below. Running one’s “own business”: The applicant served Merrimans The respondent maintained that in determining if the applicant was running his own business or working in Merrimans’ business was not a matter of “central importance”. That is misguided. In order to rationally determine whether the applicant was an employee of the respondent, it is crucial to consider one of the prime elements of employment itself: whether the applicant was carrying on business on his own account.