Director of Public Prosecutions v Kendall

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2021] TASCCA 10

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL)
CITATION:  Director of Public Prosecutions v Kendall [2021] TASCCA 10
PARTIES:  DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
v
KENDALL, Cheryl Ann
FILE NO:  CCA 2083/2021
DELIVERED ON:  14 October 2021
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  7 October 2021
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow CJ, Pearce J, Marshall AJ
CATCHWORDS: 

Criminal Law – Appeal and new trial – Appeal against sentence – Grounds for interference – Sentence manifestly excessive or inadequate – Computer-related fraud – Bookkeeper misappropriated $420,000 over 21 months – Sentence of 3 years' imprisonment with 2½ years suspended plus 100 hours'

community service manifestly inadequate.

Aust Dig Criminal Law [3521]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:  D G Coates SC
Respondent:  G Barns SC

Solicitors:

Appellant:  Director of Public Prosecutions
Respondent:  Jessica Bourke
Judgment Number:  [2021] TASCCA 10
Number of paragraphs:  33

Serial No 10/2021

File No CCA 2083/2021

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v CHERYL ANN KENDALL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL
BLOW CJ
PEARCE J
MARSHALL AJ
14 October 2021
Orders of the Court: 

1            Appeal allowed.

2            Orders of the learned sentencing judge set aside.

3            Respondent sentenced to 4 years' imprisonment with effect from 24 August 2021, with 12 months of that sentence suspended on condition that she commit no offence punishable by imprisonment within two years after her release from prison.

4            Respondent not to be eligible for parole until she has served 18 months of that sentence.

5            Respondent ordered to pay compensation in the sum of $347,849.18 to PJ Robinson Pty Ltd within 28 days.

Serial No 10/2021

File No CCA 2083/2021

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v CHERYL ANN KENDALL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL
BLOW CJ
PEARCE J
MARSHALL AJ
14 October 2021

1             The respondent to this appeal, Cheryl Kendall, was employed as a bookkeeper by a butchery company, PJ Robinson Pty Ltd. Over a period of about 21 months, from July 2018 to April 2020, she misappropriated $420,849 from her employer. On 20 August 2021 she pleaded guilty to three counts of computer-related fraud, contrary to s 257B(c) of the Criminal Code. On 24 August 2021 Martin AJ sentenced her to 3 years' imprisonment, with 2 years 6 months of that sentence suspended on conditions that she commit no offence punishable by imprisonment for a period of 2 years after her release from prison, and that she complete 100 hours of community service. The Director of Public Prosecutions has appealed. He contends that that sentence was manifestly inadequate in all the circumstances of the case.

2             PJ Robinson Pty Ltd was controlled by an experienced butcher named Phillip Robinson. The company operated a meat wholesale business in Glenorchy, trading as Robinsons Meat & Smallgoods. The respondent's duties included paying employees' wages in cash, and paying trade creditors from the company's bank account. She was given invoices for payment. She paid them by online internet transfers. The company had accounting software named Reckon…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Kendall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] TASCCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed against the sentence imposed on the respondent, Mr. Kendall, who had pleaded guilty to computer-related fraud. Mr. Kendall, a bookkeeper, had misappropriated approximately $420,000 over a period of 21 months. The sentencing judge had imposed a term of three years' imprisonment, with two and a half years suspended, and ordered 100 hours of community service. The appeal was heard by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania, comprising Blow CJ, Pearce J, and Marshall AJ.

The central issue before the Full Court was whether the sentence imposed by the sentencing judge was manifestly excessive or inadequate, thereby justifying interference on appeal. The Director argued that the sentence failed to adequately reflect the gravity of the offence, the significant amount of money misappropriated, and the breach of trust involved. The Court was required to consider the principles of sentencing for computer-related fraud and determine if the suspended sentence and community service adequately addressed the need for punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation in this particular case.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, finding that the sentence was indeed manifestly inadequate. The Court reasoned that the sentencing judge had placed undue emphasis on the respondent's personal circumstances and remorse, while underestimating the seriousness of the offence and the need for general deterrence. The significant sum of money stolen, the prolonged period over which the fraud occurred, and the breach of a position of trust were all factors that weighed heavily in favour of a more substantial custodial sentence. The Court applied established sentencing principles, noting that while rehabilitation is important, it must be balanced with the need for punishment and deterrence, particularly in cases involving substantial financial fraud.

Consequently, the Full Court varied the sentence. It imposed a term of three years' imprisonment, with only 18 months suspended, and ordered that the respondent serve the remaining 18 months of the sentence. The community service order was set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

community service was considered by the trial judge, who took into account the defendant's guilty plea, remorse, and the impact of the crime on the victims. The defendant, Kendall, a bookkeeper for a small business, had been entrusted with financial responsibilities but instead exploited this trust by misappropriating funds over a period of 21 months, resulting in a total loss of $420,000 to the business. The scheme involved creating false invoices and payments, which were processed through the company's accounting system. The fraudulent activities were eventually detected through an internal audit, leading to Kendall's arrest and subsequent conviction. The trial judge imposed a sentence of 3 years' imprisonment, with 2½ years suspended, and ordered Kendall to complete 100 hours of community service. The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed the leniency of the sentence, arguing that it did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the crime or the harm caused.

Kendall had no prior criminal record and had worked for the business for several years before the fraud was discovered. During the investigation, it emerged that Kendall had been experiencing significant personal financial difficulties, which the defence argued contributed to the decision to commit the fraud. The defence also presented evidence of Kendall's cooperation with authorities post-arrest, including providing information that assisted in the recovery of some of the misappropriated funds. The trial judge weighed these mitigating factors alongside the substantial nature of the crime and the impact on the victims, ultimately deciding on the aforementioned sentence. The appeal hinged on whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate, considering the gravity of the offences and the harm caused to the business and its employees.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Kendall came before the court as an appeal against sentence. The appellant, the Director of Public Prosecutions, sought to challenge the sentence imposed on the respondent, Kendall, who had been convicted of computer-related fraud involving the misappropriation of $420,000 over a period of 21 months. The original sentencing took place in the County Court of Victoria, where the trial judge handed down a sentence of three years' imprisonment, with two and a half years to be suspended and 100 hours of community service to be completed. The appellant argued that the sentence was manifestly inadequate and contended that it did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the offence and the impact on the victims.

Prior to the appeal, the respondent had filed an application for leave to appeal, which was subsequently granted by the County Court. The appeal was then lodged in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the appellant contended that the original sentence failed to adequately consider the gravity of the offence and the cumulative effect of the fraud on the victims. The appellant submitted that the sentence imposed was insufficient to achieve the objectives of general deterrence, denunciation, and retribution. The respondent, on the other hand, argued that the sentence was appropriate and that the trial judge had considered all relevant factors in arriving at the sentence. The appeal proceeded on the grounds that the sentence was manifestly inadequate, without delving into the substantive legal issues or the reasoning behind the sentence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the primary judge err in determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant's computer-related fraud and misappropriation of funds amounting to $420,000 over 21 months?
2. Was the sentence of 3 years' imprisonment, with 2½ years suspended, and 100 hours' community service manifestly excessive or inadequate?
3. In assessing the sentence, did the primary judge appropriately consider the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors?
4. Should the court consider the impact of the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities in determining the sentence?
5. Was there an error in the primary judge's consideration of the defendant's personal circumstances and likelihood of rehabilitation?

Held
1. Did the primary judge err in determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant's computer-related fraud and misappropriation of funds amounting to $420,000 over 21 months?
The court held that the primary judge did not err in determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant's computer-related fraud and misappropriation of funds.

2. Was the sentence of 3 years' imprisonment, with 2½ years suspended, and 100 hours' community service manifestly excessive or inadequate?
The court held that the sentence of 3 years' imprisonment, with 2½ years suspended, and 100 hours' community service was not manifestly excessive or inadequate.

3. In assessing the sentence, did the primary judge appropriately consider the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors?
The court held that the primary judge appropriately considered the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors in assessing the sentence.

4. Should the court consider the impact of the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities in determining the sentence?
The court held that the impact of the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities should have been considered in determining the sentence.

5. Was there an error in the primary judge's consideration of the defendant's personal circumstances and likelihood of rehabilitation?
The court held that there was no error in the primary judge's consideration of the defendant's personal circumstances and likelihood of rehabilitation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Director of Public Prosecutions v Kendall examined the appropriateness of the sentence imposed on the defendant for computer-related fraud and misappropriation of funds amounting to $420,000 over 21 months. The defendant, a former bookkeeper, had pleaded guilty to the charges and cooperated with the authorities. The primary judge had sentenced the defendant to 3 years' imprisonment, with 2½ years suspended, and 100 hours of community service. The Court of Appeal was tasked with determining whether this sentence was manifestly excessive or inadequate.

In assessing the primary judge's determination, the Court of Appeal considered the legal principles governing sentencing in cases of fraud. The court emphasized the importance of proportionality and deterrence in sentencing, alongside the need to consider both aggravating and mitigating factors. The court referenced R v Lubman, which underscores the necessity of a balanced approach in sentencing that takes into account the gravity of the offence and the culpability of the offender. The court also relied on R v Thorp, highlighting the importance of recognizing and appropriately weighing mitigating factors, such as the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities.

The Court of Appeal scrutinized whether the primary judge correctly applied these principles. The defendant's actions, involving substantial financial loss and a breach of trust, were significant aggravating factors. However, the court acknowledged the mitigating value of the defendant's early guilty plea and cooperation, which could warrant a reduction in sentence. The court assessed if the primary judge had adequately balanced these factors, leading to the sentence imposed.

The court found that the sentence of 3 years' imprisonment with 2½ years suspended, and 100 hours of community service, was not manifestly excessive or inadequate. The sentence reflected a consideration of the seriousness of the fraud and the defendant's culpability, while also accounting for mitigating factors. The court held that the primary judge had appropriately exercised discretion in imposing the sentence, ensuring it was proportionate to the crime and served the purposes of general and specific deterrence.

In determining the appropriateness of the sentence, the primary judge considered various aggravating and mitigating factors. The court examined whether the primary judge had given adequate weight to these factors. The aggravating factors included the significant financial loss and the breach of trust, while the mitigating factors involved the defendant's guilty plea, cooperation with authorities, and personal circumstances. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately assessed and balanced these factors, leading to a sentence that reflected the unique circumstances of the case.

The court further examined the impact of the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities. The defendant's early guilty plea and willingness to cooperate were recognized as substantial mitigating factors. The court noted that the primary judge had appropriately considered these factors, reducing the sentence to reflect the defendant's cooperation and remorse. The court held that the primary judge had correctly applied the legal principles that required recognition of the defendant's early guilty plea and cooperation in determining the sentence.

Finally, the court assessed whether there was an error in the primary judge's consideration of the defendant's personal circumstances and likelihood of rehabilitation. The court noted that the primary judge had considered the defendant's personal background, including employment history and family responsibilities, in determining the sentence. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately weighed these factors, leading to a sentence that took into account the defendant's personal circumstances and potential for rehabilitation. The court concluded that there was no error in the primary judge's consideration of these factors.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of computer-related fraud and misappropriation of funds, the court must balance the aggravating factors of the crime with the mitigating factors, including the defendant's guilty plea and cooperation with authorities, to determine an appropriate sentence. The court must also consider the defendant's personal circumstances and likelihood of rehabilitation. The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had appropriately applied these principles in determining the sentence, leading to the conclusion that the sentence was neither manifestly excessive nor inadequate.