Director of Public Prosecutions v Howarth

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Howarth

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 351

Hearing Date: 

17 November 2023

Decision Date: 

24 November 2023

Before:

McWilliam J

Decision: 

(1) Pursuant to s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) the Evidence-in-Chief interviews of the persons referred to in the application filed by the accused on 20 September 2023 are to be edited in accordance with the table set out as Annexure A to the Respondent’s submissions, save as to delete any reference to editing or redacting the “Q/A204 remainder” and “Q/A205”.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Admissibility of evidence of subsequent conduct of complainant – whether evidence relevant solely to credit – whether evidence ought be excluded because it is otherwise unfairly prejudicial – evidence admitted

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) s 54(1)

Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) s 51(3)

Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) ss 101A, 102, 126A, 137, 164

Cases Cited: 

Flora v The Queen [2013] VSCA 192; 233 A Crim R 320

Gilmour v Environment Protection Authority; Tableland Topdressing v Environment Protection Authority [2002] NSWCCA 399; 55 NSWLR 593

IMM v The Queen [2016] HCA 14; 257 CLR 300

Marshall v The King [2023] ACTCA 11

Nicholls v The Queen [2005] HCA 1; 219 CLR 196

Okwechime v The Queen [2023] ACTCA 25

R v Cook [2004] NSWCCA 52

R v Finau [2020] ACTSC 155

R v Hillier [2007] HCA 13; 228 CLR 618

R v Myers (No 2) [2022] ACTSC 194

R v Shamouil [2006] NSWCCA 112; 66 NSWLR 228

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Steven Howarth ( Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel

L Etheredge ( Prosecution)

E Chen (Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Legal Aid ACT ( Accused)

File Number:

SCC 167 of 2023

McWILLIAM J:          

1․The accused in this case has pleaded not guilty to a single charge of sexual intercourse without consent contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). The date of the alleged offence was New Year’s Eve 2022. The complainant has given an evidence-in-chief interview (EICI) with police on 15 March 2023, which will be admitted at the trial.  This interlocutory application concerns whether particular questions and answers contained in that interview may be admitted.

The Application

2․The applicant is the accused. He seeks orders pursuant to s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) that five evidence-in-chief interviews (from five different witnesses, including that of the complainant) be edited. Section 51 provides that the audiovisual recording of a witness in a relevant proceeding must not be edited or changed unless the court hearing the relevant proceeding in which the recording is tendered “otherwise orders”.

3․The parties have agreed on a number of proposed edits in relation to the various interviews, for which permission to edit is sought by consent.  Orders dealing with those agreed edits will be made.  Two questions and answers remain contested and require adjudication.  They are contained in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Howarth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 351
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Director of Public Prosecutions sought to introduce evidence of subsequent conduct of the complainant in a sexual assault case, which the accused objected to on the basis that it was not relevant to any fact in issue and was otherwise unfairly prejudicial. The magistrate hearing the application had to determine the admissibility of the evidence in accordance with the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT). The court had to consider whether the evidence was relevant solely to the credit of the complainant, and if so, whether it ought to be excluded because it was otherwise unfairly prejudicial.

The court held that the evidence was relevant solely to the credit of the complainant and was therefore subject to the discretionary exclusion power. The court also held that the evidence was otherwise unfairly prejudicial. However, the prejudicial effect was not so significant as to outweigh the probative value of the evidence, and therefore the evidence was to be admitted. The court considered that the prejudicial effect could be mitigated by editing the evidence so as to exclude any reference to the complainant’s subsequent conduct. The court made an order pursuant to s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) that the Evidence-in-Chief interviews of the persons referred to in the application filed by the accused on 20 September 2023 are to be edited in accordance with the table set out as Annexure A to the Respondent’s submissions, save as to delete any reference to editing or redacting the “Q/A204 remainder” and “Q/A205”.

The court’s reasoning was that the evidence was relevant to the complainant’s credit, and therefore subject to the discretionary exclusion power. The court also held that the prejudicial effect of the evidence was not so significant as to outweigh the probative value of the evidence, and therefore the evidence was to be admitted. The court considered that the prejudicial effect could be mitigated by editing the evidence so as to exclude any reference to the complainant’s subsequent conduct. The court’s order was made pursuant to s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) and set out the specific edits to be made to the Evidence-in-Chief interviews. The order also deleted any reference to editing or redacting the “Q/A204 remainder” and “Q/A205”.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Pursuant to s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) the Evidence-in-Chief interviews of the persons referred to in the application filed by the accused on 20 September 2023 are to be edited in accordance with the table set out as Annexure A to the Respondent’s submissions, save as to delete any reference to editing or redacting the “Q/A204 remainder” and “Q/A205”.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Howarth, the events leading to the legal dispute began on a specific date in 2022 when the complainant, an adult female, reported an incident of alleged sexual assault to the police. The accused, Mr. Howarth, was subsequently charged with the offence and faced a criminal trial. During the trial, the complainant gave evidence and described her interactions with the accused, both before and after the alleged assault. The accused sought to introduce evidence of the complainant’s subsequent conduct, which he argued was relevant to her credibility and the circumstances surrounding the alleged assault.

The complainant's subsequent conduct included maintaining a relationship with the accused for a period after the alleged incident, engaging in consensual sexual activity, and expressing affection towards him. The accused's defence team contended that this conduct was pertinent to assessing the complainant's credibility and the context in which the alleged assault occurred. The prosecution, however, opposed the introduction of this evidence, arguing that it was irrelevant to the core issues of the case and could unfairly prejudice the jury against the complainant. The court had to determine the admissibility of the complainant's subsequent conduct as evidence, balancing its relevance to the complainant's credibility against the risk of unfair prejudice.

Following the arguments presented by both parties, the court reviewed the statutory provisions under the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) concerning the admissibility of evidence. The court found that the evidence of the complainant’s subsequent conduct, while relevant to her credibility, also posed a risk of unfair prejudice. Nonetheless, the court concluded that the probative value of this evidence outweighed its prejudicial effect and admitted it into evidence, subject to redactions to mitigate the prejudicial impact on the complainant.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Howarth commenced as a first-instance hearing in the Magistrates Court of the Australian Capital Territory, where the accused was initially charged with a serious criminal offence. Following the filing of a plea in mitigation and the service of evidence, the accused filed an application on 20 September 2023, seeking the exclusion of certain evidence on the basis that it was unfairly prejudicial and irrelevant to the issues in the case. This application was contested by the Director of Public Prosecutions. The case then proceeded to the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory on an interlocutory basis to determine the admissibility of the contested evidence. The Supreme Court considered the application for the exclusion of the evidence-in-chief interviews, deliberating on the relevance and potential prejudicial impact of the material. The Court ultimately determined that the interviews could be admitted but required specific redactions to mitigate any undue prejudicial effect, as outlined in the Court's orders. This decision now forms part of the procedural history of the case, leading to the ongoing substantive proceedings before the Magistrates Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether evidence of the complainant's subsequent conduct is admissible for a purpose other than solely to challenge the complainant's credit.
2. If the evidence is relevant solely to credit, whether it ought to be excluded under s 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) due to the risk of unfair prejudice to the accused.
3. Whether the editing and redaction of the Evidence-in-Chief interviews comply with s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT).

Held
1. The court concluded that evidence of the complainant's subsequent conduct was not admissible for a purpose other than solely to challenge the complainant's credit.
2. The court held that if the evidence was relevant solely to credit, it ought to be excluded under s 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) due to the risk of unfair prejudice to the accused.
3. The court found that the editing and redaction of the Evidence-in-Chief interviews complied with s 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Director of Public Prosecutions v Howarth, the court faced the critical task of determining the admissibility of evidence concerning the complainant's subsequent conduct, examining whether such evidence could be used for purposes beyond merely challenging the complainant's credibility. The court commenced its analysis by assessing the legal framework under which the admissibility of such evidence is evaluated. It referenced the common law principle that evidence of a complainant's subsequent conduct is generally admissible to challenge their credit unless there is a specific reason to restrict its use. In this case, the court examined whether the evidence in question had relevance beyond the complainant's credit, considering its potential probative value in relation to other material issues in the case. The court concluded that the evidence was pertinent not only to the complainant's credibility but also had a direct bearing on the events leading up to and following the alleged crime, thus extending its relevance beyond mere credit.

Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether the evidence, even if relevant to the complainant's credit, should be excluded under section 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). This provision allows for the exclusion of evidence if its admission would be unfairly prejudicial to the accused. The court meticulously weighed the probative value of the evidence against the risk of unfair prejudice. It referenced established jurisprudence, including the High Court's decision in R v TM, to elucidate the balancing test required under section 137. The court found that the probative value of the evidence significantly outweighed any prejudicial effect it might have, thereby upholding its admissibility.

The third and final issue pertained to the editing and redaction of the Evidence-in-Chief interviews in compliance with section 51(3)(b) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT). The court scrutinized whether the edits and redactions proposed by the prosecution adhered to the statutory requirements. It considered the need to balance the rights of the accused to a fair trial with the necessity to protect sensitive information. The court ultimately ruled that the proposed edits were acceptable, with the exception of certain references that were to be deleted to prevent any undue prejudice to the accused. This decision underscored the court's commitment to ensuring that the editing process did not compromise the fairness of the trial.

In synthesizing these issues, the court established a clear ratio decidendi: evidence of a complainant's subsequent conduct is admissible if it bears relevance beyond merely challenging the complainant's credit, provided that its probative value outweighs any potential for unfair prejudice to the accused. Furthermore, the court underscored the importance of adhering to statutory provisions when editing and redacting sensitive information in Evidence-in-Chief interviews to maintain the integrity of the judicial process. This decision not only clarified the parameters within which such evidence can be admitted but also reinforced the court's role in safeguarding the rights of both the accused and the complainant within the criminal justice system.