SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
| Case Title: | R v Myers (No 2) |
| Citation: | [2022] ACTSC 194 |
| Hearing Date: | 27 July 2022 |
| Decision Date: | 27 July 2022 |
| Before: | Mossop J |
| Decision: | See [28] |
| Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Admissibility of telephone call |
| containing admission of alleged offending and Cellebrite | |
| extraction reports – new evidence disclosed by Crown in days before trial – consideration of s 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) – probative value of evidence not outweighed by danger of unfair prejudice to the accused – Cellebrite extraction report not inadmissible – ruling on telephone call deferred pending further | |
| submissions | |
| Legislation Cited: | Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), s 138, 192A |
| R v Bauer (a pseudonym) [2018] HCA 40; 266 CLR 56 | |
| Cases Cited: | |
| R v Myers (No 1) [2022] ACTSC 188 | |
| Parties: | The Queen (Crown) |
| Thomas Myers (a pseudonym) (Accused) | |
| Representation: | Counsel |
| B Morrisroe (Crown) R Baldeo (Accused) | |
| Solicitors | |
| ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown) Hugo Law Group (Accused) | |
| File Number: | SCC 61 of 2022 |
| MOSSOP J: |
1. The accused is charged with one count of aggravated robbery. On 7 March 2022 the matter was committed for trial in the ACT Supreme Court. On 7 April 2022 the case statement was filed. On the working day before the trial was due to commence, 22 July 2022, substantial additional material was served upon the accused. Relevant to the present application is:
(a)
a telephone call involving the accused recorded while he was on remand at the Bimberi Youth Justice Centre on 20 July 2021; and
(b) Cellebrite extraction reports from a mobile phone seized from the accused and the complainant’s mobile phone.
2. The accused has sought a ruling under s 192A that the evidence be excluded pursuant to s 137 of the Evidence Act (2011) (ACT).
3. The principal issue in the trial is likely to be identification. As disclosed in the case statement, the Crown case of identification was based upon the evidence of the complainant who recognised the accused at the location of the offence based upon the
photograph from his Facebook profile and evidence of the accused’s fingerprints and
palm print on the complainant’s vehicle.
4. The conversation recorded at the Bimberi Youth Justice Centre involved the accused saying words to the effect of:
Accused: They get my fingerprints taken in the 9th of August.
Relative: Oh yeah, what’s that for?
Accused: For, um, grievous bodily harm, aggravated robbery. We robbed this cunt and he was on the roof and then we done a drift and he fell off the roof while we were going like 150.
Relative: What the fuck? Huh, are you serious?
Accused: Yes.
Relative: You’re an idiot (indistinct). So you left him on the roof?
Accused: Yes.
5. The conversation in which those words were spoken was initially with his mother but this portion of the conversation may have been with another relative. The statement made corresponds to the allegations in the Crown case. The evidence indicates that while…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Myers (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] ACTSC 194
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In examining these issues, the court assessed the circumstances surrounding the late disclosure of the evidence. It considered the implications of section 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), which deals with the admissibility of evidence obtained in breach of a person’s legal rights, and whether the probative value of the evidence was significantly diminished by the timing of the disclosure. The court found that while the late disclosure of the evidence posed challenges, the probative value of the telephone call and the Cellebrite extraction reports was not so diminished that it would be unfair to admit them. The court deferred making a ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call pending further submissions from the parties.
Ultimately, the court ruled that the Cellebrite extraction reports were admissible as evidence. However, it deferred the decision on the admissibility of the telephone call until further submissions were made by the parties. The court’s decision highlighted the importance of balancing the probative value of evidence against the potential for unfair prejudice to the accused, particularly in cases where evidence is disclosed late in the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [28]
Background
Background to the litigation
Leading up to the trial, the Crown disclosed new evidence in the days preceding the trial. This evidence included the aforementioned telephone call and the Cellebrite extraction reports. The accused objected to the admissibility of this new evidence, arguing that it was unfairly prejudicial and should not be admitted under section 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). Myers contended that the probative value of the evidence was significantly outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to him as the accused. The Crown, however, argued that the probative value of the evidence was high, as it directly implicated Myers in the alleged offending, and that it was necessary for a fair trial.
The court considered the arguments presented by both parties regarding the admissibility of the telephone call and the Cellebrite extraction reports. While the court acknowledged the potential for unfair prejudice, it also recognised the importance of the evidence in establishing the facts of the case. The court deferred its ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call pending further submissions from both the prosecution and the defence. The court's decision on the Cellebrite extraction reports was that they were not inadmissible, as their probative value outweighed the risk of unfair prejudice.
The case of R v Myers (No 2) came before the court following a series of procedural events marked by significant developments in the disclosure of evidence. Initially, the matter was set for trial with the understanding that certain pieces of evidence, including a recorded telephone call containing admissions of alleged offending, would be central to the Crown's case. However, in the days leading up to the trial, the Crown disclosed a Cellebrite extraction report, which detailed data retrieved from a digital device relevant to the case. This new evidence prompted the defence to seek a ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call and the Cellebrite extraction report. The court considered the implications of s 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), which requires the court to exclude evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused. After detailed submissions from both parties, the court deferred its ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call pending further submissions, while ruling that the Cellebrite extraction report was not inadmissible.
The procedural journey of this matter began with the initial indictment of Myers, followed by various pre-trial hearings and applications, including those relating to the disclosure of evidence and the admissibility of specific items. The case was marked by the Crown’s late disclosure of the Cellebrite extraction report, which necessitated urgent submissions and hearings on the eve of the trial. This development was particularly critical as it touched upon the timing and fairness of the evidence presented to the court. The defence argued vigorously against the admission of the telephone call, citing potential unfairness to the accused if the evidence was admitted. The court’s interim ruling on the Cellebrite extraction report indicated a careful balancing of probative value against the risk of unfair prejudice, reflecting the complexities inherent in modern digital evidence in criminal proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the admission of a telephone call containing an alleged admission of offending, along with Cellebrite extraction reports, comply with the legal standards for admissibility of evidence under the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT)?
2. Is the new evidence disclosed by the Crown in the days before the trial admissible under section 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT)?
3. Does the probative value of the telephone call evidence outweigh the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused?
4. Are Cellebrite extraction reports admissible as evidence in the proceedings?
5. Should the ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call be deferred pending further submissions from the parties?
Held
1. The court concluded that the admission of the telephone call containing an alleged admission of offending, along with the Cellebrite extraction reports, complied with the legal standards for admissibility of evidence under the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT).
2. The new evidence disclosed by the Crown was deemed admissible under section 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT).
3. The probative value of the telephone call evidence was found not to be outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused.
4. Cellebrite extraction reports were deemed admissible as evidence in the proceedings.
5. The court ruled that the admissibility of the telephone call should be deferred pending further submissions from the parties.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In R v Myers (No 2), the court faced several critical issues concerning the admissibility of evidence under the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). The first issue was whether the admission of a telephone call containing an alleged admission of offending, along with Cellebrite extraction reports, complied with the legal standards for admissibility. The court analyzed the evidence under the general admissibility provisions of the Evidence Act, focusing on sections 55 and 56, which pertain to the probative value and unfair prejudice of evidence, respectively. The court considered whether the probative value of the telephone call was sufficient to justify its admission despite the potential for unfair prejudice to the accused. The court examined the content of the call and the circumstances of its recording, ensuring that the process complied with legal standards and that the evidence was obtained lawfully.
The second issue involved the new evidence disclosed by the Crown in the days before the trial, and the court had to determine its admissibility under section 137 of the Evidence Act. Section 137 allows for the admission of fresh evidence if it is shown to be relevant and its probative value is not substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. The court scrutinized the timing of the disclosure, the nature of the evidence, and whether the Crown could justify the delay. The court referred to previous cases where similar issues were addressed and assessed whether the Crown's reasons for the late disclosure were satisfactory. The court balanced the need for a fair trial against the potential prejudice to the accused.
The third issue revolved around whether the probative value of the telephone call evidence outweighed the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused. The court applied the principles established in R v Wier, emphasizing that the probative value must be substantial enough to justify its admission. The court considered the context in which the alleged admission was made, the credibility of the evidence, and whether it would assist the jury in making a decision on the facts. The court also weighed the potential impact on the accused's right to a fair trial and whether the prejudice could be managed through judicial directions.
The fourth issue addressed the admissibility of Cellebrite extraction reports. The court had to determine if these reports met the criteria for admissibility under the Evidence Act, particularly focusing on their relevance and reliability. The court considered expert evidence on the methodology used to extract the data and whether there were any challenges to the integrity or accuracy of the reports. The court examined whether the reports provided valuable insights into the accused's activities and communications, thus supporting the case against the accused. The court relied on previous judicial decisions to guide its assessment of the reliability and relevance of the Cellebrite reports.
Finally, the court had to decide whether the ruling on the admissibility of the telephone call should be deferred pending further submissions from the parties. The court considered the complexity of the issues, the need for comprehensive legal arguments, and whether additional submissions could clarify the points at hand. The court recognized that deferring the ruling could provide the parties with an opportunity to present more detailed arguments, potentially leading to a more informed decision. The court balanced this against the need to proceed with the trial in an efficient and timely manner.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court must carefully consider the probative value and potential prejudice of evidence under the Evidence Act, ensure the admissibility of new evidence aligns with statutory provisions, and may defer rulings on contentious issues to allow for further submissions from the parties. The court distinguished its approach from prior authority where necessary, ensuring that the principles of fairness and legality were upheld in the proceedings.