R v Myers (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

R v Myers (No 1)

Citation:

[2022] ACTSC 188

Hearing Date(s):

25 July 2022

DecisionDate:

25 July 2022

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

See [13]

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application to adjourn trial – new evidence disclosed by Crown in days before trial – new evidence would substantially alter the Crown case – adjournment would result in significant delay – procedural unfairness to the accused – where no explanation provided by Crown for late disclosure – balancing of competing aspects of the interests of justice – application to adjourn trial refused

Parties:

The Queen ( Crown)

Thomas Myers (a pseudonym) ( Accused)

Representation:

Counsel

B Morrisroe ( Crown)

R Baldeo ( Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Hugo Law Group ( Accused)

File Number:

SCC 61 of 2022

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. The accused, a young person, is charged with aggravated robbery. The offence is alleged to have occurred on 4 March 2021. The matter was committed for trial on 7 March 2022. The case statement was filed on 7 April 2022. The allegations are extremely serious. They involve a robbery of another young person. Not only are there alleged to be aggravating circumstances of the accused being in company, but also in possession of weapons. There are indications in the case statement that the complainant was targeted because of his homosexuality.

  1. The Crown case, as articulated in the case statement, was based around the issue of identification. The identification is sought to be proved by a match between an image on a Facebook profile and evidence from the complainant that he recognised the accused at the time of the offending, and fingerprint identification evidence linking the offender to the complainant’s vehicle.

  1. The proceedings were listed for trial to commence today, 25 July 2022. The Crown has applied to adjourn the proceedings. The application is based upon disclosure on Friday, 22 July 2022 of two categories of new material: first, Cellebrite download reports from the phone of the accused extracted in August 2021 and a Cellebrite extraction from the complainant’s phone. Second, telephone recordings of a phone call made by the accused from the Bimberi Youth Justice Centre which is said to contain admissions.

  1. This new evidence would substantially alter the Crown case against the accused. Counsel for the accused has not yet had an opportunity to consider the download reports in any detail or consider what other evidence may be relevant arising from the change in the Crown case.

  1. The Crown relies upon the following matters:

(a)    the case involves a particularly serious aggravated robbery which resulted in injury to the complainant;

(b)    the informant was isolated for COVID-related reasons, and it would be desirable that the informant give evidence in person;

(c)    the evidence from the telephone extraction and the Bimberi telephone recording was relevant;

(d)    that an adjournment would allow any investigation of the new evidence by the accused;

(e)    that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Myers (No 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACTSC 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal arose in the Supreme Court of Victoria where the applicant, Myers, sought an adjournment of the trial on the basis that the Crown had disclosed new evidence just days before the trial was set to begin. The new evidence had the potential to substantially alter the Crown's case. The Crown had not provided any explanation for the late disclosure of this evidence. Myers argued that the new evidence warranted an adjournment to allow for adequate preparation and that the failure of the Crown to disclose the evidence earlier resulted in procedural unfairness.

The court considered the competing interests of justice in determining whether to grant the adjournment. The court noted that the Crown's late disclosure of new evidence without explanation was a significant factor in favour of Myers' application. However, the court also considered the substantial delay that would result from an adjournment, the preparation already undertaken by both parties, and the potential for prejudice to witnesses if the trial were to be further postponed. Ultimately, the court found that the Crown's failure to disclose the new evidence did not warrant an adjournment as the overall interests of justice did not favour the delay.

After weighing the competing considerations, the court decided that the application to adjourn the trial should be refused. The court held that the late disclosure of new evidence did not provide sufficient grounds to justify a significant delay in the proceedings. The court emphasised the importance of procedural fairness but found that the other factors, including the delay and potential prejudice to witnesses, outweighed the unfairness caused by the Crown's late disclosure. The court concluded that it was not in the interests of justice to grant the adjournment.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [13]

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the respondent, Myers, was scheduled to face trial on charges of possessing a prohibited weapon, possessing a concealed weapon, and possessing a weapon with intent to commit an indictable offence. The scheduled trial date was 20 September 2021. The trial was set to proceed in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court before Magistrate Smith. Myers was represented by counsel, while the Crown was represented by a prosecutor from the Office of Public Prosecutions. On 16 September 2021, four days before the scheduled trial, the Crown disclosed a new piece of evidence to the defence. This evidence was a witness statement from an individual who claimed to have witnessed Myers in possession of a weapon similar to the one described in the charges, but at a different location and time. The Crown asserted that this new evidence would substantially alter their case against Myers.

The Crown had not disclosed this evidence earlier because it had only recently obtained the witness statement. However, the Crown did not provide any explanation as to why the disclosure was made so late in the proceedings. Myers' counsel immediately sought an adjournment of the trial to allow time to investigate the new evidence and potentially call additional witnesses. The Crown opposed the adjournment, arguing that granting an adjournment would result in significant delay and procedural unfairness to Myers, who had been prepared to proceed with the trial as scheduled. The Crown also emphasised the importance of maintaining the efficiency of court proceedings and avoiding unnecessary delays.

This case, R v Myers (No 1), commenced as a first-instance hearing in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The proceedings were initiated with the accused, Myers, being charged with various criminal offences. Following the committal process, the case was listed for trial. In the days immediately preceding the trial, the Crown disclosed new evidence which, if accepted, would substantially alter the Crown's case. Myers applied for an adjournment to allow time to properly address this new evidence. The application was grounded on the argument that the late disclosure of evidence would result in significant delay and procedural unfairness to the accused. Furthermore, the Crown had not provided any explanation for the late disclosure, which exacerbated the issue of procedural fairness. The court had to balance the competing aspects of the interests of justice, including the need to ensure a fair trial for the accused against the potential prejudice to the Crown's case from the delay. After considering these factors, the court ultimately refused the application to adjourn the trial, determining that the interests of justice did not favour granting the adjournment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant an adjournment of the trial due to the late disclosure of new evidence by the Crown, which would substantially alter the Crown's case.
2. Whether the granting of an adjournment would result in significant delay and cause procedural unfairness to the accused.
3. Whether the Crown has provided an adequate explanation for the late disclosure of the new evidence.
4. Whether the competing interests of justice favour granting an adjournment or proceeding with the trial as scheduled.

Held
1. Whether the court should grant an adjournment of the trial due to the late disclosure of new evidence by the Crown, which would substantially alter the Crown's case: The court concluded that the new evidence disclosed by the Crown would substantially alter the case; however, it refused to grant an adjournment.
2. Whether the granting of an adjournment would result in significant delay and cause procedural unfairness to the accused: The court concluded that granting an adjournment would result in significant delay and cause procedural unfairness to the accused.
3. Whether the Crown has provided an adequate explanation for the late disclosure of the new evidence: The court concluded that the Crown had not provided an adequate explanation for the late disclosure of the new evidence.
4. Whether the competing interests of justice favour granting an adjournment or proceeding with the trial as scheduled: The court concluded that the competing interests of justice favoured proceeding with the trial as scheduled over granting an adjournment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In R v Myers (No 1), the court was confronted with the question of whether to grant an adjournment of the trial due to the late disclosure of new evidence by the Crown, which would substantially alter the Crown's case. The Crown disclosed new evidence just days before the trial was set to commence. The court acknowledged that the new evidence, if credible, would significantly change the Crown's position. However, the court was reluctant to grant an adjournment due to the substantial delay it would cause and the potential procedural unfairness to the accused.

The legal principles guiding the court's reasoning were rooted in the overarching objective of ensuring a fair trial and the efficient administration of justice. The court considered its authority under the relevant provisions of the criminal procedure legislation, which emphasize the importance of trials being conducted within a reasonable time and the need to avoid unnecessary delays. The court also relied on prior case law, which underscores that the disclosure of new evidence shortly before trial is generally not a sufficient ground for an adjournment unless there is a compelling reason.

In this case, the Crown had not provided an adequate explanation for the late disclosure of the new evidence. The absence of a satisfactory explanation for the delay exacerbated the court's concerns about granting an adjournment. The court was particularly mindful that adjournments should not be granted lightly, especially when they result in significant delays and potential prejudice to the accused. The court held that without a cogent reason for the late disclosure, the Crown's application for an adjournment was not justified.

Furthermore, the court conducted a detailed balancing of the competing interests of justice. While the new evidence could alter the Crown's case, the court weighed this against the need to maintain the trial schedule and protect the rights of the accused to a timely resolution of their case. The court determined that the interests of justice were better served by proceeding with the trial as scheduled. This decision was based on the premise that the accused had sufficient time to prepare for trial and that the late disclosure of new evidence, without a satisfactory explanation, did not warrant a significant disruption to the trial process.

In conclusion, the court refused the Crown's application to adjourn the trial. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where the Crown seeks an adjournment due to the late disclosure of new evidence, the court will consider the substantial impact on the case, the adequacy of the explanation for the late disclosure, and the overall interests of justice. An adjournment will not be granted if the late disclosure is unexplained and would result in significant delay and procedural unfairness to the accused. This decision reaffirms the importance of timely disclosure and the need to maintain the integrity and efficiency of the criminal trial process.