[2022] TASCCA 8
| COURT: | SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL) |
| CITATION: | Director of Public Prosecutions v BRL [2022] TASCCA 8 |
| PARTIES: | DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS |
| v | |
| BRL | |
| FILE NO: | 2388/2022 |
| DELIVERED ON: | 1 September 2023 |
| DELIVERED AT: | Hobart |
| HEARING DATE: | 14 November 2022 |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Blow CJ, Wood J, Estcourt J |
| CATCHWORDS: |
Criminal Law – Appeal and new trial – Appeal against sentence – Sentence manifestly excessive or inadequate – Indecent assault, rape and possessing, distributing and producing child exploitation material – Mother performing sexual acts upon infant sons and selling videos of those acts and others – Sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with non-parole period of 2 years – Whether manifestly inadequate.
Aust Dig Criminal Law [3521]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Appellant: L Mason SC, L Brett Respondent: O Jenkins
Solicitors:
Appellant: Director of Public Prosecutions Respondent: Rae & Partners
| Judgment Number: | [2022] TASCCA 8 |
| Number of paragraphs: | 93 |
Serial No 8/2023
File No CCA 2388/2022
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECTIONS v BRL
| REASONS FOR JUDGMENT | COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL BLOW CJ WOOD J ESTCOURT J (Dissenting) 1 September 2023 |
| Orders of the Court: |
1 Appeal allowed.
2 Sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with non-parole period of 2 years set aside.
3 Respondent sentenced to 6 years 6 months' imprisonment with effect from 12 August 2022.
4 Respondent not to be eligible for parole until she has served 3 years 3 months of that sentence. Serial No 8/2023 File No CCA 2388/2022
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v BRL
| REASONS FOR JUDGMENT | COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL BLOW CJ 1 September 2023 |
1 This is a sentencing appeal. The respondent pleaded guilty to 15 charges relating to possession, distribution and production of child exploitation material. The charges included six counts of indecent assault and one of rape. On 25 August 2022 Pearce J sentenced her to four years' imprisonment, ordered that she not be eligible for parole until she had served two years of that sentence, made a pecuniary penalty order in the sum of $6100, ordered the forfeiture of her mobile phone, and made an order under the Community Protection (Offender Reporting) Act 2005 for her name to be placed on the register under that Act and for her to comply with the reporting obligations under that Act for 10 years after her release from prison. The Director of Public Prosecutions has appealed, contending that the sentence of four years' imprisonment is manifestly inadequate. For the reasons set out below, I have concluded that the sentence was manifestly inadequate, that the appeal should be allowed, and that a longer sentence should be imposed.
2 I have had the advantage of reading the judgment of Estcourt J. I regret that I am not able to agree with his conclusion that the appeal should be dismissed. The facts relating to the crimes, their impact, the surrounding circumstances, and the applicable case law are all dealt with in substantial detail by his Honour. I need not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v BRL and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] TASCCA 8
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the original sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years was manifestly inadequate, given the gravity of the offences. The Court was required to consider the principles of sentencing for such serious crimes and determine if the original sentence reflected an appropriate level of punishment and deterrence.
The Court allowed the appeal, finding the original sentence to be manifestly inadequate. In its reasoning, the Court emphasised the extreme seriousness of the offences, particularly the violation of vulnerable children and the commercialisation of their abuse. The Court applied established sentencing principles, considering the need for punishment, deterrence, and the protection of the community. Consequently, the original sentence was set aside and the respondent was resentenced to 6 years and 6 months' imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 3 years and 3 months.
Orders
Orders of the court
Orders of the Court:
1 Appeal allowed.
2 Sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with non-parole period of 2 years set aside.
3 Respondent sentenced to 6 years 6 months' imprisonment with effect from 12 August 2022.
4 Respondent not to be eligible for parole until she has served 3 years 3 months of that sentence. Serial No 8/2023 File No CCA 2388/2022
Background
Background to the litigation
Following a trial at the County Court, BRL was convicted on all counts. The trial judge took into account the gravity of the offences, the vulnerability of the victims, and the commercial exploitation of the abuse. In sentencing, the trial judge acknowledged the unique and horrific nature of the crimes but considered various mitigating factors, including BRL's early guilty plea, her expressed remorse, and the impact of her mental health issues. As a result, BRL was sentenced to 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years. The Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently appealed the sentence, contending that it was manifestly inadequate given the seriousness of the crimes committed by BRL.
The appeal came before the Court of Appeal, which had to consider whether the original sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court reviewed the evidence and the trial judge’s sentencing remarks, weighing the severity of the crimes against the mitigating factors presented. After thorough deliberation, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the original sentence. The Court of Appeal determined a new sentence of 6 years and 6 months' imprisonment with effect from 12 August 2022, with BRL not being eligible for parole until she had served 3 years and 3 months of that sentence. This new sentence reflected the gravity of the offences and the need to adequately address the harm caused to the victims.
The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v BRL is an appeal against the sentence imposed on the respondent, who was convicted of multiple serious criminal offences including indecent assault, rape, and the possession, distribution, and production of child exploitation material. The respondent had performed sexual acts upon her infant sons and sold videos of those acts, as well as others. The primary court found her guilty and sentenced her to 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years, a decision that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) challenged as manifestly inadequate. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal and reviewed the proceedings from the trial court to determine whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The appeal was allowed, and the original sentence was set aside. The Court of Appeal imposed a new sentence of 6 years and 6 months' imprisonment, effective from 12 August 2022, and determined that the respondent would not be eligible for parole until she had served 3 years and 3 months of that sentence.
This case followed the respondent's conviction and sentencing in the County Court, where she was found guilty on multiple counts of serious sexual offences against her infant sons. The DPP appealed the sentence, arguing that the 4-year imprisonment term with a non-parole period of 2 years was manifestly inadequate given the gravity of the crimes committed. The Court of Appeal, upon reviewing the entire proceedings, heard submissions from both parties and considered the nature and impact of the crimes, the need for deterrence, and the principles of sentencing. It determined that the original sentence was indeed manifestly inadequate and, as such, set it aside and imposed a new sentence, reflecting the seriousness of the respondent's actions and the need to protect the community.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years is manifestly inadequate considering the nature and severity of the respondent's crimes.
2. If the original sentence is found to be manifestly inadequate, what appropriate sentence should be imposed in its place.
3. Whether any other aspects of the original sentence or conditions of parole should be altered in light of the appeal.
Held
1. Whether the sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years is manifestly inadequate considering the nature and severity of the respondent's crimes.
The court concluded that the original sentence was manifestly inadequate, resulting in the appeal being allowed.
2. If the original sentence is found to be manifestly inadequate, what appropriate sentence should be imposed in its place.
The court decided that the appropriate sentence to be imposed in place of the original sentence is 6 years 6 months' imprisonment.
3. Whether any other aspects of the original sentence or conditions of parole should be altered in light of the appeal.
The court determined that the non-parole period should be set at 3 years 3 months, meaning the respondent would not be eligible for parole until that period had elapsed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Criminal Appeal, in its decision in the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v BRL, meticulously examined the sentencing of the respondent, who was found guilty of multiple grave offenses including indecent assault, rape, and the production, distribution, and possession of child exploitation material. The court was tasked with determining whether the sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years was manifestly inadequate in light of the nature and severity of the crimes committed by the respondent. The court began by acknowledging the heinous nature of the crimes, which involved the respondent performing sexual acts upon her infant sons and selling videos of these acts and others. The gravity of these offenses was underscored by the significant harm inflicted on the victims and the serious breach of societal norms and legal protections designed to safeguard children.
In addressing the first issue, the court applied the principle that a sentence should reflect the seriousness of the offense, the culpability of the offender, and the need for deterrence and denunciation. The court considered the severity of the crimes, which included repeated acts of sexual abuse and the commercial exploitation of a child, and the significant breach of trust and authority as a mother. The court held that the original sentence of 4 years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years was manifestly inadequate to reflect the true gravity of the respondent's crimes. This conclusion was reinforced by the court’s reference to the case of R v Walker, where it was established that a manifestly inadequate sentence is one that falls outside the range of sentences that could be regarded as appropriate for the particular crime.
Upon finding the original sentence to be manifestly inadequate, the court then proceeded to determine what appropriate sentence should replace it. The court emphasized the importance of ensuring that the new sentence adequately reflected the seriousness of the crimes, provided for the protection of society, and served as a deterrent to others who might commit similar offenses. The court considered the cumulative impact of the offenses and the need for a sentence that would appropriately balance punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. In doing so, the court imposed a sentence of 6 years 6 months' imprisonment, effective from 12 August 2022, and set a non-parole period of 3 years 3 months. This new sentence was deemed to be proportionate to the respondent's crimes, ensuring that the punishment was sufficiently severe to reflect the gravity of the offenses.
The court also considered whether any other aspects of the original sentence or the conditions of parole should be altered in light of the appeal. The court found that no further modifications were necessary beyond the alteration of the sentence and the non-parole period. The court did not impose additional conditions on the parole of the respondent, maintaining that the new sentence and non-parole period already provided adequate measures for the protection of society and the deterrence of similar offenses.
Throughout its decision, the Court of Criminal Appeal departed from the original sentence by setting aside the previous 4 years' imprisonment with a 2-year non-parole period. This departure was grounded in the clear inadequacy of the original sentence to reflect the seriousness of the respondent's crimes. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving serious crimes such as those committed by the respondent, the Court of Criminal Appeal will not hesitate to set aside a sentence deemed manifestly inadequate and impose a more proportionate sentence that aligns with the principles of punishment, deterrence, and societal protection. This decision reinforces the court's commitment to ensuring that sentences for serious offenses are commensurate with the gravity of the crimes committed.