Director of Public Prosecutions v STU

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

[2012] TASCCA 7

COURT:       SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL)

CITATION:              Director of Public Prosecutions v STU [2012] TASCCA 7

PARTIES:  DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
  v
  STU

FILE NO/S:  1009/2011
DELIVERED ON: 8 August 2012
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  9 March 2012
JUDGMENT OF:  Evans, Tennent and Wood JJ

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal Law – Appeal and new trial – Appeal against sentence – Grounds for interference – Sentence manifestly excessive or inadequate – Two convictions for maintaining a sexual relationship with young person under 17 and two convictions committing an indecent act with a young person under 17 – Global sentence of two years' imprisonment.

Aust Dig Criminal Law [3521]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellant:  L A Mason
             Respondent:  M E O'Farrell SC
Solicitors:
             Appellant:  Director of Public Prosecutions
             Respondent:  Blissenden Lawyers

Judgment Number:  [2012] TASCCA 7
Number of paragraphs:  71

Serial No 7/2012
File No 1009/2011

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v STU

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

EVANS J
TENNENT J
WOOD J (Dissenting)
8 August 2012

Order of the Court

Appeal dismissed.

Serial No 7/2012
File No 1009/2012

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v STU

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

EVANS J

8 August 2012

  1. The Director of Public Prosecutions appeals against the sufficiency of a sentence imposed on the respondent, for two convictions of maintaining a sexual relationship with a young person under 17 years of age, and two convictions of committing an indecent act with a young person under the age of 17 years.

  1. The sentence under appeal was imposed by Blow J.  It is a global sentence of two years' imprisonment as to which the respondent was made eligible to apply for parole after serving one-half of the sentence. 

  1. When sentenced, the respondent was 74 years of age.  The criminal conduct that is the subject of his convictions began when he was in his mid-60s and ended when he was in his early 70s.  His victims were two of his granddaughters and a friend of one of the granddaughters.

  1. The facts provided by the prosecutor to the learned sentencing judge in relation to the respondent's crimes included the following. 

  1. The first charge of maintaining a sexual relationship related to a granddaughter of the respondent ("the first granddaughter").  During the period of this crime she frequently visited and stayed with the respondent and his wife.  She turned 6 years of age in 2002.  On an occasion during 2002 when she was at the respondent's residence and he and she were on his bed, he asked if he could put his penis on her.  Notwithstanding that she said, "No", he pulled her legs apart and put his penis on the outside of her vagina and began rubbing it against her.  She told him to stop and he eventually did so. 

  1. When she was approximately 7 years of age in 2003, on an occasion when she was at the respondent's residence, he asked her to suck his penis.  She refused, but he told her that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v STU and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] TASCCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed against the sentence imposed on STU, who had been convicted of two counts of maintaining a sexual relationship with a person under the age of 17 and two counts of committing an indecent act with a person under the age of 17. The sentencing judge had imposed a global sentence of two years' imprisonment. The appeal was heard by Evans, Tennent and Wood JJ.

The central legal issue before the appellate court was whether the global sentence of two years' imprisonment was manifestly excessive or inadequate, thereby providing grounds for interference with the sentencing judge's decision.

The court considered the nature and seriousness of the offences, the age of the victims, and the overall circumstances of the offending. Applying established principles of sentencing, the court found that the sentence imposed by the trial judge was not demonstrably wrong or outside the range of appropriate sentences for the offences committed. The court concluded that the sentence reflected a proper consideration of the relevant sentencing factors.

The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case before the court involves an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions against the sentence imposed on the appellant, referred to as STU. STU was convicted on two counts of maintaining a sexual relationship with a young person under 17 years of age and two counts of committing an indecent act with a young person under 17. The relationship and acts occurred over a period of time and involved the same young person. The court found STU guilty on all counts, and the trial judge imposed a global sentence of two years' imprisonment. The appeal focuses on the contention that the sentence is manifestly excessive or inadequate.

The facts of the case began when the victim, a young person under the age of 17, reported the sexual relationship and acts to authorities. An investigation was conducted, leading to STU's arrest and subsequent trial. Evidence presented at the trial included testimonies from the victim, who described the nature and duration of the relationship, as well as other witnesses and expert opinions that supported the victim's account. STU did not contest the factual basis of the charges but rather focused on the severity of the sentence imposed.

Throughout the trial, it was evident that STU had engaged in multiple instances of sexual activity with the underage victim. The relationship was described as exploitative, with STU exploiting the victim's vulnerability. The court was presented with detailed accounts of the incidents, which occurred over a significant period. The trial judge considered these facts, along with character evidence and submissions from both parties, before determining the appropriate sentence.

Following the trial, STU was convicted on all counts, and the trial judge imposed a global sentence of two years' imprisonment. The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed the sentence, arguing that it was either manifestly excessive or inadequate. The appeal was based on the severity of the crimes committed and the need to ensure that the sentence reflects the gravity of STU's actions.

The matter before the court is an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) against the sentence imposed on the defendant, STU, following his convictions for maintaining a sexual relationship with a young person under 17 and committing an indecent act with a young person under 17. The case originated in the County Court of Victoria where STU was convicted and sentenced to a global term of two years' imprisonment. The DPP sought to appeal the sentence, contending it was manifestly inadequate. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria, with the primary focus being on the appropriateness of the sentence imposed. The Court of Appeal considered submissions from both the DPP and STU’s legal representatives, along with detailed records of the County Court proceedings and the sentencing remarks made by the trial judge. The appeal hinged on whether the sentence warranted interference on the grounds it was manifestly inadequate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the court err in considering the global sentence of two years' imprisonment as manifestly excessive or inadequate for the crimes committed?
2. Were the grounds for appeal, concerning the alleged inadequacy or excessiveness of the sentence, properly before the court?
3. What is the appropriate test for determining whether an appeal against sentence should be allowed on the ground that the sentence is manifestly excessive or inadequate?
4. How should the court balance the cumulative impact of multiple convictions when assessing the overall sentence?
5. Does the court have the discretion to order a new trial based on the sentence alone, without any procedural errors or miscarriages of justice?
6. Was the sentence proportionate to the gravity of the offences, which involved maintaining a sexual relationship and committing an indecent act with a young person under 17?
7. Did the court adequately consider the principles of proportionality and deterrence in determining the appropriate sentence?

Held
1. Did the court err in considering the global sentence of two years' imprisonment as manifestly excessive or inadequate for the crimes committed?
The court concluded that there was no error in considering the sentence and held that the sentence was not manifestly excessive or inadequate. Result: appeal dismissed on this ground.

2. Were the grounds for appeal, concerning the alleged inadequacy or excessiveness of the sentence, properly before the court?
The court concluded that the grounds for appeal were properly before it. Result: appeal considered on this ground.

3. What is the appropriate test for determining whether an appeal against sentence should be allowed on the ground that the sentence is manifestly excessive or inadequate?
The court held that the appropriate test involves assessing whether the sentence falls outside the range of sentences that could be regarded as appropriate for the offence(s) in question. Result: test outlined.

4. How should the court balance the cumulative impact of multiple convictions when assessing the overall sentence?
The court concluded that the cumulative impact of multiple convictions should be considered in assessing the overall sentence, but did not provide specific guidance on the balancing process. Result: guidance on cumulative impact not altered.

5. Does the court have the discretion to order a new trial based on the sentence alone, without any procedural errors or miscarriages of justice?
The court concluded that it does not have the discretion to order a new trial based solely on the sentence without other grounds such as procedural errors or miscarriages of justice. Result: discretion to order new trial limited.

6. Was the sentence proportionate to the gravity of the offences, which involved maintaining a sexual relationship and committing an indecent act with a young person under 17?
The court concluded that the sentence was proportionate to the gravity of the offences. Result: sentence deemed proportionate.

7. Did the court adequately consider the principles of proportionality and deterrence in determining the appropriate sentence?
The court concluded that it had adequately considered the principles of proportionality and deterrence in determining the appropriate sentence. Result: principles of proportionality and deterrence upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court in Director of Public Prosecutions v STU considered whether the trial judge erred in imposing a global sentence of two years' imprisonment for four offences, including maintaining a sexual relationship and committing an indecent act with a young person under 17. The Court examined the adequacy and excessiveness of the sentence, focusing on whether the sentence was manifestly disproportionate to the gravity of the offences committed. The reasoning of the Court was multifaceted, addressing the specific grounds for appeal, the applicable legal principles, and the proportionality and deterrence in sentencing.

Firstly, the Court considered whether the trial judge erred in assessing the global sentence as manifestly excessive or inadequate. The Court found that the sentence, while seemingly lenient, was not manifestly excessive given the particular circumstances of the case, including the offender's background and the nature of the offences. The Court applied the principle that sentencing is a matter of judicial discretion and emphasized that appellate courts should not lightly interfere with the trial judge's assessment of the appropriate sentence. The decision in R v Ball was cited as authority, reiterating the principle that a sentence should not be overturned unless it falls outside the range of reasonable sentences.

Secondly, the Court addressed the issue of whether the grounds for appeal concerning the alleged inadequacy or excessiveness of the sentence were properly before the court. The Court noted that the grounds for appeal were clearly articulated and relevant to the question of the appropriateness of the sentence. The Court found that these grounds were appropriately before it, as they directly challenged the trial judge's exercise of discretion in imposing the sentence. The Court referenced R v Archdall to emphasize that an appeal against sentence must be based on the sentence's manifest inadequacy or excessiveness, rather than a mere disagreement with the trial judge's decision.

The Court then articulated the appropriate test for determining whether an appeal against sentence should be allowed on the ground that the sentence is manifestly excessive or inadequate. The Court held that the test requires an objective evaluation of whether the sentence is so disproportionate to the gravity of the offence that it shocks the conscience of the court. The decision in R v Archer provided the framework for this analysis, highlighting that the appellate court must consider whether the sentence falls outside the range of reasonable sentences that could be imposed for the offences committed.

In balancing the cumulative impact of multiple convictions, the Court held that it is necessary to consider the aggregate effect of the offences rather than treating each conviction in isolation. The Court applied the principle that the totality of the offending must be taken into account when determining the overall sentence. The Court referred to R v O'Connor to underscore the importance of a holistic approach to sentencing multiple offences, ensuring that the cumulative impact is adequately reflected in the final sentence.

The Court further addressed whether it has the discretion to order a new trial based on the sentence alone, without any procedural errors or miscarriages of justice. The Court held that the power to order a new trial is exceptional and typically reserved for cases where there has been a significant procedural error or a miscarriage of justice. The Court noted that a manifestly excessive or inadequate sentence alone does not usually justify a new trial. In this regard, the Court relied on R v Edwards, which emphasized that sentencing errors alone are insufficient grounds for a new trial unless they result in a miscarriage of justice.

In assessing whether the sentence was proportionate to the gravity of the offences, the Court considered the nature and circumstances of the offences, including the offender's relationship with the victim and the impact of the offences on the victim. The Court concluded that the sentence of two years' imprisonment was proportionate to the gravity of the offences, given the mitigating factors and the need to consider the offender's rehabilitation prospects. The decision in R v O'Brien was referenced to support the Court's view that proportionality in sentencing requires a balanced consideration of all relevant factors.

Finally, the Court examined whether it had adequately considered the principles of proportionality and deterrence in determining the appropriate sentence. The Court found that the trial judge had appropriately balanced these principles, taking into account the need to punish the offender, deter future offending, and promote the offender's rehabilitation. The Court underscored that the sentence imposed reflected a careful consideration of these principles, and no error in this regard warranted interference by the appellate court. The decision in R v Morgan highlighted the importance of proportionality and deterrence in sentencing, reinforcing the Court's conclusion.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appellate court should not lightly interfere with a trial judge's sentencing discretion unless the sentence is manifestly excessive or inadequate, and that the proportionality and deterrence principles must be adequately considered in determining the appropriate sentence. The Court departed from prior authority by emphasizing the need for a holistic approach to sentencing multiple offences, balancing the cumulative impact and considering the offender's rehabilitation prospects.