Di Marco v Brisbane City Council & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Di Marco v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2006] QPEC 035

PARTIES:

ADRIAN DI MARCO
Applicant
v
BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
Respondent

and
FELICITY COYNE
First Co-Respondent

and
HUGHES BUILT ENVIRONMENTS
Second Co-Respondent

FILE NO/S:

No 564 of 2006

DIVISION:

Planning & Environment

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 April 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20, 21 April 2006

JUDGE:

Skoien SJDC

ORDER:

Application dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

Jurisdictional error; Wednesbury principle; House Code and Character Code of City Plan 2000

COUNSEL:

Mr S Keliher for the applicant
Mr T Trotter for the respondent
Mr W Everson for the first co-respondent
(No appearance for the second co-respondent)

SOLICITORS:

McCullough Robertson for the applicant
Brisbane City Legal Practice for the respondent

Nicol Robertson Hallett for the first co-respondent

  1. In this Originating Application, Di Marco alleges that the Council made a jurisdictional error when it approved a code assessable development application by Coyne to add a storey to a house at 76 Windermere Road, Hamilton.  Alternatively he alleges that no reasonable Council could have decided to approve the application.

The Locality

  1. Windermere Road runs roughly east/west and can fairly be described as one of Brisbane’s premier residential streets.  Its houses are, almost without exception, and in varying architectural styles, grand and of high money value.  The Di Marco house site is on or about a crest in the road, the Coyne site (immediately to its east) being slightly lower by about two metres.  Both of these sites have (ignoring any man-made structures) extensive views, especially to the north and east.

The Coyne Site

  1. The Coyne site has a narrow frontage to Windermere Road, which widens as it progresses to the rear.  About 30m in from the road stands the house, a single storied traditional “Queenslander”, certainly of the pre-1946 vintage and I would say decades older than the 40’s.  At present it is somewhat dilapidated but it is obviously a house of potentially great beauty in its size, shape, proportions and conception and it is not surprising that Coyne wants to re-furbish and to enlarge it.  Standing in one of Brisbane’s premier residential streets it is without doubt a property of great value in all senses of the word.

  1. The Coyne site is unusually long, about 90 m.  Behind the house is a tennis court and in front of it is, at present, an unkempt garden.  Over this front section is an air and light easement in favour of the property to the west, the Di Marco land.

The Di Marco Site

  1. This site is immediately to the west of the Coyne site and its ground level, as it presently stands, is a couple of metres higher than the Coyne land.  Di Marco has built on it a very large and grand brick house.  Rectangular in shape, two stories high, with generous balconies and set in most impressively grand surrounds, it is probably the residence which stands out most prominently in Windermere Road.

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Di Marco v Brisbane City Council & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QPEC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Di Marco v Brisbane City Council & Ors, the plaintiff sought judicial review of a decision by the Brisbane City Council to approve a development application. The plaintiff argued that the Council had failed to properly consider the impact of the proposed development on the plaintiff's property, specifically the loss of views and outlook. The case was heard and determined in the Queensland Court of Appeal.

The primary legal issue in the case was whether the Brisbane City Council had made a jurisdictional error in approving the development application by failing to properly consider the effect of the proposed dwelling on the plaintiff's loss of views or outlook. The plaintiff argued that the Council had misapplied the relevant codes and had failed to consider the impact of the development on the plaintiff's property.

The Court of Appeal held that the Council had not made a jurisdictional error in approving the development application. The Court found that the Council had properly considered the impact of the proposed development on the plaintiff's property, and that the plaintiff's argument that the Council had misapplied the relevant codes was without merit. The Court held that the Council's decision to approve the development application was not unreasonable, and that the plaintiff's application for judicial review should be dismissed.

In light of the above, the Court dismissed the plaintiff's application for judicial review and made no orders. The decision of the Brisbane City Council to approve the development application was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I was also referred to s.2.6 of Chapter 3 of City Plan 2000 which is –“For code assessment the Code is the Purpose, Performance Criteria and Acceptable Solutions. The Acceptable Solutions represent the preferred way of complying with the Performance Criteria. There may be other ways to comply that meet the Code’s Purpose. It is up to the applicant to demonstrate how alternative solutions achieve this. A proposal that fails to comply (except in insignificant details) and cannot be conditioned to mitigate impacts will be refused.”and to s.3.5.13 of IPA which is (relevantly) –“3.5.13 Decision if application requires code assessment(1)This section applies to any part of the application requiring code assessment.(2)The assessment manager must approve the application if the assessment manager is satisfied the application complies with all applicable codes whether or not conditions are required for the development to comply with the codes.(3)Subject to subsection (2), the assessment manager’s decision may conflict with an applicable code only if there are enough grounds to justify the decision, having regard to –(a) the purpose of the code; …” The principal jurisdictional error submitted on behalf of Di Marco was a failure to properly consider Performance Criterion P3 of the House Code, which required consideration of the effect of the proposed dwelling on loss of views or outlook, materially from the Di Marco house. Ms Freeman’s Report to the Coordination Panel states:“The revised roof proposal drops the roofline at the centre of the site and reduces the roof mass at the western elevation, allowing views over the reduced ridge line” (my emphasis) That statement was repeated in Ms Freeman’s September 2005 submission to the Council’s delegate. Further statements in her submission along similar lines to the above were made that:“The applicants have also proposed that the north-south ridge line be dropped from the original proposal of 11.8m above NGL to 10m at the centre of the building in order to preserve existing views of the adjacent property to the west,” (my emphasis)and specifically in relation to the quoted portion of Performance criterion P3:“The issues of view retention for the property to the west have been addressed above.” In cross-examination Ms Freeman accepted that the emphasised statements were incorrect. So they were, in that it would have been more accurate to say that the Di Marco views to the east were, because of the reduction of the Coyne roof height “less affected” or “partly preserved”. On the debated question whether ability to see sky and cloud is a view (what I would have thought to be self-evidently true) she might more accurately have qualified her statement to reflect that fact. But this particularised alleged jurisdictional error relates, at best, to a mis-statement of a relevant fact, or an error on a relevant fact, by Ms Freeman. It is not (see para [20]) the identification of a wrong issue, the asking of a wrong question, the ignoring of relevant material or the reliance on irrelevant material. The passage from Craig v South Australia accepts that there can be a jurisdictional mistake of fact or finding, and as I understood the Di Marco argument it was that such a mistake had been made because, contrary to Performance Criterion P3 of the House Code, the Coyne proposal involves “impacts on (the Di Marco dwelling) in terms of loss of views or outlook.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established