PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2012] QPEC 32
PARTIES:
HOLCIM (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
(ACN 009 732 297)
(first applicant)and
LIDA AMBROSELLI
(second applicant)and
DESIREE CORONEO
(third applicant)and
ROSS JAMES JOHNSTON
(fourth applicant)and
NICHOLAS KARALOUKAS
(fifth applicant)and
MARK TREVOR WARNOCK
(sixth applicant)v
BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(first respondent)and
ARDEN MANAGEMENT GROUP PTY LTD
(ACN 056 870 770)
(second respondent)FILE NO:
2571/2011
DIVISION:
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Planning and Environment Court
DELIVERED ON:
27/04/2012
DELIVERED AT:
BRISBANE
HEARING DATE:
07/11/2011 – 9/11/2011 and 12/03/12 - 16/03/12
JUDGE:
Searles DCJ
ORDER:
1. Declaration that the Council’s Decision of 15 March 2011 to approve a development application for a material change of use (multi-dwelling unit) and for a preliminary approval to carry out building work is invalid, of no legal effect, and
2. Order Council’s Decision be set aside; and
3. Declaration that the Council’s Negotiated Decision of 14 June 2011 which changed the Decision (the Negotiated Decision) is invalid, of no legal effect, and
4. Order Councils Negotiated Decision be set aside.
CATCHWORDS:
Application for Declaration of invalidity of Council’s approval decision - Sustainable Planning Act 2009- Integrated Planning Act1997- Amenity - Meaning of Amenity - Incorrect consideration of Amenity amounting to Jurisdictional Error – Approval invalid.
COUNSEL:
Applicant: J.E Gallagher QC with M.F Johnston
First Respondent: M. Hinson SC with J. Lyons
Second Respondent: J.D Houston
SOLICITORS:
Applicant: Minter Ellison
First Respondent: BCC Legal Practice
Second Respondent: Herbert Geer Lawyers
INDEX
APPLICATION
NATURE OF APPLICATION
APPLICANTS’ GROUNDS
AMENITY GROUND
HEIGHT GROUND
ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION
AMENDMENT TO DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION
COUNCIL DECISION ON DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION
NEGOTIATED DECISION NOTICE 14 JUNE 2011
COUNCIL’S REASONS FOR DECISION
PRESENT APPLICATION
STATUTORY SCHEME
PLANNING SCHEME
COUNCIL DOCUMENTS RELEVANT TO ITS DECISIONS
A.ORIGINAL DEVELOPER’S COMPLAINT TO COUNCIL ABOUT HOLCIM OPERATIONS – 21 APRIL 2008
B. PRE-LODGEMENT MEETING WITH COUNCIL – JUNE 2008
C..... LODGEMENT OF ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION – 15 SEPTEMBER 2008
D. AUGUST 2008 – NOISE REPORT
E. TRAFFIC
F. THE CODE RESPONSES
G. COUNCIL’S VARIOUS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT NOTICES
H. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY 14 OCTOBER 2008
I. COUNCIL ESTABLISHMENT AND CO-ORDINATION (PLANNING GUIDANCE) COMMITTEE PRESENTATION
J. COUNCIL 2008 INFORMATION REQUEST
K. COUNCIL FILE NOTE 1 DECEMBER 2008
L. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY DATED 3 SEPTEMBER 2009
M. COUNCIL LETTER TO CONCRETE BATCHING PLANT – 20 NOVEMBER 2009
N. NCO’S RESPONSE TO COUNCIL’S 2008 INFORMATION REQUEST – NOVEMBER 2009
O..... COUNCIL’S FURTHER ASSESSMENT BASED ON NCO’S NOVEMBER 2009 RESPONSE
P. HOLCIM’S OBJECTION 23 DECEMBER 2009
Q. COUNCIL MEMO 4 JANUARY 2010
R. FURTHER NOTE OF COUNCIL’S PRINCIPAL POLLUTION OFFICER – 20 JANUARY 2010
S. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY 1 FEBRUARY 2010
T. ASSESSMENT NOTES OF COUNCIL’S SENIOR URBAN PLANNER, MS ADRIANA BRAMLEY, 3 FEBRUARY 2010 USEFULLY SUMMARISES EVENTS TO THAT DATE.
U. COUNCIL APPLICATION SUMMARY – 11 MARCH 2010
V. LETTER – COUNCIL TO NCO – 16 MARCH 2010
W. E&C PLANNING GUIDANCE COMMITTEE PRESENTATION – 22 MARCH 2010
X. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] QPEC 32
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Council's approval of the development application was valid and whether the subsequent negotiated decision altering the conditions of approval was also valid. Holcim contended that the Council had made a jurisdictional error by not correctly applying the neighbourhood plan and development codes, specifically regarding the height and amenity of the proposed development. The court needed to determine whether the Council's failure to adhere to the prescribed height limit and amenity considerations rendered its decisions legally flawed.
The court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties, focusing on whether the Council had correctly applied the Albion Neighbourhood Plan and the Residential Design – Medium Density Code. The court concluded that the Council had indeed made a jurisdictional error in approving the development application and subsequently the negotiated decision. The Council had incorrectly considered the amenity and height restrictions, resulting in decisions that were invalid. The court found that the Council's failure to adhere to the prescribed height limit and amenity considerations amounted to jurisdictional error, leading to the invalidity of both the initial approval decision and the negotiated decision.
Consequently, the court granted the declarations and orders sought by Holcim. The Council’s decision of 15 March 2011 to approve the development application and the subsequent negotiated decision of 14 June 2011 were declared invalid, of no legal effect, and set aside. This ruling underscores the importance of strictly adhering to planning codes and neighbourhood plans when approving development applications.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Declaration that the Council’s Decision of 15 March 2011 to approve a development application for a material change of use (multi-dwelling unit) and for a preliminary approval to carry out building work is invalid, of no legal effect, and
2. Order Council’s Decision be set aside; and
3. Declaration that the Council’s Negotiated Decision of 14 June 2011 which changed the Decision (the Negotiated Decision) is invalid, of no legal effect, and
4. Order Councils Negotiated Decision be set aside.
Decision