Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2012] QPEC 32

PARTIES:

HOLCIM (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
(ACN 009 732 297)
(first applicant)

and

LIDA AMBROSELLI
(second applicant)

and

DESIREE CORONEO
(third applicant)

and

ROSS JAMES JOHNSTON
(fourth applicant)

and

NICHOLAS KARALOUKAS
(fifth applicant)

and

MARK TREVOR WARNOCK
(sixth applicant)

v

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(first respondent)

and

ARDEN MANAGEMENT GROUP PTY LTD
(ACN 056 870 770)

(second respondent)

FILE NO:

2571/2011

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court

DELIVERED ON:

27/04/2012

DELIVERED AT:

BRISBANE

HEARING DATE:

07/11/2011 – 9/11/2011 and 12/03/12 - 16/03/12

JUDGE:

Searles DCJ

ORDER:

1.     Declaration that the Council’s Decision of 15 March 2011 to approve a development application for a material change of use (multi-dwelling unit) and for a preliminary approval to carry out building work is invalid, of no legal effect, and

2.     Order Council’s Decision be set aside; and

3.     Declaration that the Council’s Negotiated Decision of 14 June 2011 which changed the Decision (the Negotiated Decision) is invalid, of no legal effect, and

4.     Order Councils Negotiated Decision be set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

Application for Declaration of invalidity of Council’s approval decision - Sustainable Planning Act 2009- Integrated Planning Act1997- Amenity - Meaning of Amenity - Incorrect consideration of Amenity amounting to Jurisdictional Error – Approval invalid.

COUNSEL:

Applicant:  J.E Gallagher QC with M.F Johnston

First Respondent:  M. Hinson SC with J. Lyons

Second Respondent: J.D Houston

SOLICITORS:

Applicant: Minter Ellison

First Respondent: BCC Legal Practice

Second Respondent: Herbert Geer Lawyers

INDEX

APPLICATION

NATURE OF APPLICATION

APPLICANTS’ GROUNDS

AMENITY GROUND

HEIGHT GROUND

ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION

AMENDMENT TO DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION

COUNCIL DECISION ON DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION

NEGOTIATED DECISION NOTICE 14 JUNE 2011

COUNCIL’S REASONS FOR DECISION

PRESENT APPLICATION

STATUTORY SCHEME

PLANNING SCHEME

COUNCIL DOCUMENTS RELEVANT TO ITS DECISIONS

A.ORIGINAL DEVELOPER’S COMPLAINT TO COUNCIL ABOUT HOLCIM OPERATIONS – 21 APRIL 2008

B. PRE-LODGEMENT MEETING WITH COUNCIL – JUNE 2008

C..... LODGEMENT OF ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION – 15 SEPTEMBER 2008

D. AUGUST 2008 – NOISE REPORT

E. TRAFFIC

F. THE CODE RESPONSES

G. COUNCIL’S VARIOUS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT NOTICES

H. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY 14 OCTOBER 2008

I. COUNCIL ESTABLISHMENT AND CO-ORDINATION (PLANNING GUIDANCE) COMMITTEE PRESENTATION

J. COUNCIL 2008 INFORMATION REQUEST

K. COUNCIL FILE NOTE 1 DECEMBER 2008

L. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY DATED 3 SEPTEMBER 2009

M. COUNCIL LETTER TO CONCRETE BATCHING PLANT – 20 NOVEMBER 2009

N. NCO’S RESPONSE TO COUNCIL’S 2008 INFORMATION REQUEST – NOVEMBER 2009

O..... COUNCIL’S FURTHER ASSESSMENT BASED ON NCO’S NOVEMBER 2009 RESPONSE

P. HOLCIM’S OBJECTION 23 DECEMBER 2009

Q. COUNCIL MEMO 4 JANUARY 2010

R. FURTHER NOTE OF COUNCIL’S PRINCIPAL POLLUTION OFFICER – 20 JANUARY 2010

S. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY 1 FEBRUARY 2010

T. ASSESSMENT NOTES OF COUNCIL’S SENIOR URBAN PLANNER, MS ADRIANA BRAMLEY, 3 FEBRUARY 2010 USEFULLY SUMMARISES EVENTS TO THAT DATE.

U. COUNCIL APPLICATION SUMMARY – 11 MARCH 2010

V. LETTER – COUNCIL TO NCO – 16 MARCH 2010

W. E&C PLANNING GUIDANCE COMMITTEE PRESENTATION – 22 MARCH 2010

X. COUNCIL’S APPLICATION SUMMARY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QPEC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Holcim (Australia) PL v Brisbane City Council involved a challenge by Holcim to the Brisbane City Council's approval of a residential development application on a site in Albion. The dispute centred around the Council's decision to approve a change of use for the site from a concrete batching plant to a residential development, and the subsequent negotiated changes to the approval conditions. Holcim argued that the Council's decision was invalid due to jurisdictional error, primarily concerning the incorrect consideration of the amenity and height restrictions outlined in the Albion Neighbourhood Plan and the Residential Design – Medium Density Code.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Council's approval of the development application was valid and whether the subsequent negotiated decision altering the conditions of approval was also valid. Holcim contended that the Council had made a jurisdictional error by not correctly applying the neighbourhood plan and development codes, specifically regarding the height and amenity of the proposed development. The court needed to determine whether the Council's failure to adhere to the prescribed height limit and amenity considerations rendered its decisions legally flawed.

The court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties, focusing on whether the Council had correctly applied the Albion Neighbourhood Plan and the Residential Design – Medium Density Code. The court concluded that the Council had indeed made a jurisdictional error in approving the development application and subsequently the negotiated decision. The Council had incorrectly considered the amenity and height restrictions, resulting in decisions that were invalid. The court found that the Council's failure to adhere to the prescribed height limit and amenity considerations amounted to jurisdictional error, leading to the invalidity of both the initial approval decision and the negotiated decision.

Consequently, the court granted the declarations and orders sought by Holcim. The Council’s decision of 15 March 2011 to approve the development application and the subsequent negotiated decision of 14 June 2011 were declared invalid, of no legal effect, and set aside. This ruling underscores the importance of strictly adhering to planning codes and neighbourhood plans when approving development applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Declaration that the Council’s Decision of 15 March 2011 to approve a development application for a material change of use (multi-dwelling unit) and for a preliminary approval to carry out building work is invalid, of no legal effect, and

2. Order Council’s Decision be set aside; and

3. Declaration that the Council’s Negotiated Decision of 14 June 2011 which changed the Decision (the Negotiated Decision) is invalid, of no legal effect, and

4. Order Councils Negotiated Decision be set aside.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicants rely on two grounds to challenge the Council’s Decision of 15 March 2011 (Decision) and its Negotiated Decision of 14 July 2011 (Negotiated Decision) which may be conveniently called the P16 Amenity Ground (Amenity Ground) and the A4.1 Height Ground (Height Ground). As to the amenity ground the Applicants say that the Council fell into jurisdictional error, in the language of administrative law, in five material respects in arriving at its decision to approve the development namely:- The Applicants assert that the proposal as approved will necessarily exceed the maximum height limit of RL33AHD mandated in acceptable solution A4.1 in the Albion Neighbourhood Plan Code, in which event the parties all agree, the proposal would be impact assessable and not code assessable as it was. The original Development Application was lodged with the Council on 15 September 2008 proposing a new residential development consisting of 277 units across three buildings (160 two bedroom units, 18 three bedroom units and 99 dual-key units across three buildings, with each building of six storeys in height). It is common ground that the proposal was subject to the provisions of IPA and subject to assessment against the Albion Neighbourhood Plan and the Residential Design – Medium Density Code. The site of the proposal (site) is located in the North Precinct of the Albion Neighbourhood Plan. The site at 35 Burdett Street, Albion is opposite the first applicant’s concrete batching plant which has frontages to Burdett Street and Crosby Road. The Burdett Street frontage has entry and exit points for concrete mixing trucks and other heavy vehicles but there are no entry or exit points onto Crosby Road. On or about 20 October 2010 Norris Clarke & O’Brien Pty Ltd (NCO) the town planners who prepared the Development Application, amended the DA pursuant to IPA s 3.2.9 to, amongst other things, remove lot 3 (being 9 Burdett Street) from the DA and to provide for 280 units across three residential unit buildings to be developed in three stages with stage 1 consisting of 59 units, stage 2, 149 units and stage 3, 72 units. On 15 March 2011 the Council approved the application subject to conditions and on 17 March 2011 issued a Decision Notice pursuant to IPA s 3.5.15 notifying the second respondent (Arden) of its decision. In response to a request from Holcim of 24 March 2011 seeking reasons for the Council’s decision pursuant to IPA s 5.9.5(2) and s 32(2)(b) the Judicial Review Act 1991, the Council under cover of its letter of 13 April 2011, provided those reasons and the development approval package.[4][4]Exhibit 20, Vol 6, Tab 81, p 2423. Pursuant to a request by Arden, through NCO, on 15 April 2011[5], pursuant to IPA s 3.5.17, seeking changes to the conditions and other matters in the Development Approval, the Council issued a Negotiated Decision Notice approving some changes on 14 June 2011.[6] This replaced the Decision Notice of 17 March 2011.[5]Ibid, p 2532.[6]Ibid, p 2545.