Dhi22 v Qatar Airways Q.C.S.C (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DHI22 v Qatar Airways Q.C.S.C (No 3) [2024] FCA 351

File number(s): NSD 837 of 2022
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 10 April 2024
Catchwords:

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW – where second respondent asserts immunity under s 9 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) (FSI Act) – whether second respondent is a separate entity within the meaning of s 3(1) of the FSI Act – whether second respondent is an agency or instrumentality of the State of Qatar – whether second respondent is not a separate entity entitled to immunity because it was not exercising inherently governmental or sovereign functions – second respondent is a separate entity entitled to immunity under the FSI Act

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW – whether the commercial transactions exception to foreign State immunity in s 11 of the FSI Act is made out – whether proceeding “concerns” a commercial transaction – where necessary to consider substance of case pleaded and conduct giving rise to claims – whether conduct can be properly characterised as a commercial, trading, business, professional or industrial or like transaction – exception to foreign State immunity not made out.

TORTS – originating application advancing claims in negligence, assault, battery and false imprisonment – interlocutory application by second respondent to set aside service and the originating application and the further amended statement of claim in so far as they advance claims against second respondent on the basis of foreign State immunity – service and originating documents set aside

Legislation:

Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) s 3, Pt II, ss 9, 11, 13, 22, Pt IV, ss 32, 38

Human Rights Act 1998 (UK)

Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, done at Rome 4 November 1950, 213 UNTS 222, art 6

Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, done at Montreal on 28 May 1999, 2242 UNTS 309

Cases cited:

Alcom Ltd v Republic of Colombia [1984] AC 580

Benkharbouche v Embassy of the Republic of Sudan [2019] AC 777

CCDM Holdings, LLC v Republic of India (No 3) [2023] FCA 1266

DHI22 v Qatar Airways Q.C.S.C (No 2) [2024] FCA 348

DSG Holdings Australia Pty Ltd v Helenic Pty Ltd (2014) 86 NSWLR 293; [2014] NSWCA 96

Firebird Global Master Fund II Ltd v Republic of Nauru (2015) 258 CLR 31; [2015] HCA 43

Greylag Goose Leasing 1410 Designated Activity Company v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd (2023) 111 NSWLR 550; [2023] NSWCA 134

I Congreso del Partido [1978] QB 500

Playa Larga v I Congreso del Partido [1983] 1 AC 244

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2012) 247 CLR 240; [2012] HCA 33

PT Garuda International Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2011) 192 FCR 393; [2011] FCAFC 52

Wells Fargo Bank Northwest National Association v Victoria Aircraft Leasing Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dhi22 v Qatar Airways Q.C.S.C (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 351
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dhi22 v Qatar Airways Q.C.S.C (No 3) involves the applicants seeking to serve legal documents on Qatar Airways, represented by the Qatar Civil Aviation Authority (QCAA), following an incident on a flight from Doha to Sydney. The QCAA has applied to set aside the service of the originating application and amended statements of claim on the basis of foreign State immunity under the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth). The applicants' claims include negligence, assault, battery, and false imprisonment. The court had to decide whether the QCAA is a separate entity within the meaning of the Act and whether the commercial transactions exception to foreign State immunity applied.

The court examined the nature of the QCAA as a public entity of Qatar, established to regulate civil aviation and perform inherently governmental functions. It considered the statutory provisions and legal principles regarding foreign State immunity, including the customary international law principle that immunity is granted for inherently governmental or sovereign acts. The court found that the QCAA was exercising governmental functions during the incident, thus qualifying as a separate entity under the Act. Furthermore, the court held that the commercial transactions exception did not apply as the proceeding did not concern a commercial transaction but rather involved inherently governmental acts.

Consequently, the court set aside the service of the originating application and amended statements of claim against the QCAA. It ordered the applicants to pay the QCAA's costs. The decision underscores the importance of distinguishing between inherently governmental and commercial activities when determining foreign State immunity under the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The order made on 6 October 2022 granting leave to the applicants to serve the originating application and the statement of claim on the second respondent be set aside pursuant to s 38 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth).

2. The further amended originating application filed on 23 May 2023 and the further amended statement of claim filed on 23 May 2023, in so far as they make claims against the second respondent, be set aside pursuant to s 38 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth).

3. The applicants are to pay the costs of the second respondent, as taxed or agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants rely on the following evidence:(a)affidavits of Damian Sturzaker, solicitor for the applicants, affirmed on 20 March 2023 and 27 October 2023;(b)an affidavit of Dr Wolfgang Peter Babeck, a solicitor who was a passenger on board Qatar Airways flight QR908 to Sydney on 2 October 2023, affirmed on 17 March 2023; (c)affidavit of Ioannis Metsovitis, Senior Vice-President of Operations at MATAR, affirmed on 19 July 2023; and (d)affidavits of each of the applicants variously affirmed on 15 March 2023 and 16 March 2023. D. BACKGROUND The QCAA is a public entity of the State of Qatar. It was established in 2001 by the Decree-Law No 16 of 2001 (since repealed) to carry out functions that had previously been performed by the Civil Aviation Department in the Ministry of Transport and Communications. Its staff members are public employees. The operations, responsibilities and functions of the QCAA are now governed by Law No 15 of 2002 on Civil Aviation as Amended, and Amiri Decision 66 of 2018 on the Reorganization of the Civil Aviation Authority, which is itself a public law. Article 3 of Amiri Decision 66 provides that the QCAA has its own legal personality and is “affiliated to the Ministry of Transport and Communications”. The QCAA comprises the various administrative units created by Art 9. It is managed by a President, appointed by an Amiri Decision: Art 7 of Amiri Decision 66. Pursuant to Art 2 bis of Law No 15, the QCAA is relevantly required to act “in coordination with the competent authorities” in the State of Qatar to:develop and implement the required regulations, bylaws, measures to protect civil aviation from unlawful interference … in ways that ensure the safety of passengers … and visitors of civil aviation facilities … and shall develop and implement a system to respond immediately to any security threats. The QCAA’s responsibilities also include:(a)the “organization of the civil aviation and civil aerodromes” of the State of Qatar;(b)ensuring the “enforcement of the effective provisions of the Chicago Convention and its Annexes”;(c)supervision and oversight of air navigation services and airports;(d)developing and implementing the “State Safety Program that aims to achieve an acceptable level of safety”; and(e)preparing a “National Civil Aviation Security Program” to meet the State of Qatar’s “obligations under the Chicago Convention and its Annexes”. The administrative units of the QCAA created by Art 9 of Amiri Decision 66 are also given specific duties and responsibilities. Article 6 of Amiri Decision 66 provides that the Minister of Transport and Communications (Minister) is responsible for the QCAA’s overall performance. The Minister is required to propose the QCAA’s annual estimated budget and provide an annual report to the Council of Ministers about the status of the QCAA. The financial resources of the QCAA consists of funds allocated to it by the State of Qatar, and other resources approved by the Council of Ministers, based on the Minister’s proposal. The QCAA’s budget is affiliated to the Ministry of Transport and Communications. E. SEPARATE ENTITYE.1. Statutory provisions and legal principles

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the absence of such material facts and particulars, it is difficult to see how the claims for assault, battery and false imprisonment against the QCAA could succeed. For present purposes, however, it is not necessary to resolve any the deficiencies in the pleading of these causes of action. The critical issue for present purposes is that all of the claims advanced against the QCAA in the FASOC, including the intentional torts, are with respect to the Incident. C. EVIDENCE The QCAA relies on the following evidence in support of its application:(a)an affidavit of Saad Abdullah AL-Mahmoud affirmed on 26 January 2023, the Ambassador of the State of Qatar to Australia. He gives evidence that the QCAA is an organ or instrumentality of the government of Qatar that regulates civil aviation in Qatar, and that the State of Qatar claims foreign State immunity in these proceedings on the QCAA’s behalf;(b)an affidavit of Mohamed Faleh Al Hajri affirmed on 26 January 2023, the Acting President of the QCAA. He describes the QCAA’s structure, and governance and its public funding arrangements and functions;(c)an affidavit of Dr Islam Chiha affirmed on 26 January 2023, and an expert report prepared by Dr Chiha, an Assistant Professor of Public Law at Qatar University College of Law, Doha, Qatar. He gives expert evidence concerning aspects of Qatari law that are relevant to the interlocutory application, including the nature of public laws and how they are made in Qatar, and the legal status, governing laws and functions of the QCAA; (d)an affidavit of Amr Hossam El-Din sworn on 7 August 2023, and an expert report prepared by Mr Hossam El-Din, a Legal Consultant and Head of the Arbitration Department at Al Sulaiti Law Firm in Doha, Qatar. His areas of expertise include aviation law, and he has advised and conducted litigation concerning the operation of Qatari public utility projects. He gives expert evidence concerning additional aspects of Qatari law relevant to the status and powers of the QCAA, including the laws providing for the status of the Doha Airport and the financing laws governing the QCAA; and (e)an affidavit of Thomas Riddell, solicitors for the first and third respondents, affirmed on 8 November 2023. The applicants rely on the following evidence:(a)affidavits of Damian Sturzaker, solicitor for the applicants, affirmed on 20 March 2023 and 27 October 2023;(b)an affidavit of Dr Wolfgang Peter Babeck, a solicitor who was a passenger on board Qatar Airways flight QR908 to Sydney on 2 October 2023, affirmed on 17 March 2023; (c)affidavit of Ioannis Metsovitis, Senior Vice-President of Operations at MATAR, affirmed on 19 July 2023; and (d)affidavits of each of the applicants variously affirmed on 15 March 2023 and 16 March 2023. D. BACKGROUND The QCAA is a public entity of the State of Qatar. It was established in 2001 by the Decree-Law No 16 of 2001 (since repealed) to carry out functions that had previously been performed by the Civil Aviation Department in the Ministry of Transport and Communications. Its staff members are public employees.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the second respondent (QCAA) is a separate entity within the meaning of s 3(1) of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) and entitled to immunity.
2. Whether the second respondent is an agency or instrumentality of the State of Qatar.
3. Whether the second respondent was not exercising inherently governmental or sovereign functions and therefore not a separate entity entitled to immunity.
4. Whether the commercial transactions exception to foreign State immunity in s 11 of the FSI Act is made out.

Held
1. The court held that the second respondent (QCAA) is a separate entity within the meaning of s 3(1) of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) and is entitled to immunity.
2. The court held that the second respondent is an agency or instrumentality of the State of Qatar.
3. The court held that the second respondent was exercising inherently governmental or sovereign functions and is therefore a separate entity entitled to immunity.
4. The court held that the commercial transactions exception to foreign State immunity in s 11 of the FSI Act is not made out.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, and in any event, the principle proffered by the applicants is not an accepted part of customary international law. E.3. ConsiderationE.3.1. The applicants’ exercise of governmental function requirement As a general proposition, it is entirely unexceptional that a Court would consider whether an entity was exercising governmental functions on behalf of a foreign State, for the purpose of determining whether that entity was an agency or instrumentality within the meaning of “separate entity” for the purposes of the FSI Act. So much is clear from the ALRC Report and the rule of customary international law, that a foreign State is entitled to immunity only in respect of its inherently governmental or sovereign acts: Benkharbouche at [37] and [52]-[53] (Lord Sumption giving the judgment of the United Kingdom Supreme Court). Further, it is well settled that the FSI Act ought, so far as its language permits, to be construed in conformity with this rule of customary international law, particularly where the FSI Act implements or codifies Australia’s obligations under international law: Firebird at [44] (French CJ and Kiefel J) and [134] (Gageler J). The applicants’ contention, however, that the QCAA was not a separate entity for the purposes of s 9 and s 22 of the FSI Act because it was not relevantly “exercising inherently governmental or sovereign functions” in relation to the Incident, is untenable for the following reasons. First, the conduct of which the applicants complain occurred in the course of a police operation conducted by the MOI. That was on any view conduct that had the character of an “inherently governmental or sovereign act”. A police operation seeking to locate a person who had committed an apparent crime under Qatari law of abandoning a newborn baby in a toilet cubicle necessarily involved a range of different activities, including interviewing potential witnesses and suspects. Those interviews could be pursued in a variety of ways, some relatively unobstructive and others more so. It is also readily apparent that the manner in which interviews of potential witnesses and suspects are conducted may involve breaches of relevant regulations or laws and give rise to criminal offences or breach fundamental human rights. Second, and in any event, any contention that an entity cannot be a separate entity of a foreign State to the extent that it engages in conduct that is unlawful or in breach of human rights is contrary to the statutory text and intrinsic materials. The ALRC Report recommended at [65], in the context of the underlying principles of foreign state immunity identified in Chapter 3 of the report:Accordingly the proposed Australian legislation should provide that a foreign state is immune except as provided in the legislation. The exceptions should be designed so as to reflect not a single governmental/commercial dichotomy but rather the full range of considerations outlined in Chapter 3. The form of “restrictive immunity” recommended in the ALRC Report, and adopted by the Parliament, was one pursuant to which s 9 of the FSI Act granted an absolute immunity “[e]xcept as provided by or under this Act”. Specific exceptions to the absolute immunity from jurisdiction are then set forth in s 10 to s 20 of the FSI Act. None of these exceptions stipulates that an entity cannot be a “separate entity” for the purposes of the immunity in s 9, read together with s 22 of the FSI Act, if it engages in unlawful conduct or the conduct is in breach of human rights.