Dean v Central Highlands Region Water Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2024 0038
STEPHEN JAMES DEAN Applicant
v
CENTRAL HIGHLANDS REGION WATER CORPORATION Respondent

---

JUDGES: MACAULAY JA, GORTON and J FORREST AJJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 16 October 2024
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 12 December 2024
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2024] VSCA 315
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: Dean v Central Highlands Region Water Corporation (County Court of Victoria, Judge K Bourke, 8 March 2024)

---

NEGLIGENCE – Application for leave to appeal judgment entered on jury verdict – Applicant severely injured in dog attack while working as water meter reader – Applicant sought damages from respondent employer, alleging negligent failure to provide dog safety training and/or animal repellent spray – Applicant claimed training and/or spray would have avoided attack, or alternatively, caused injuries to be less severe – Judge directed jury not to consider alternative ‘less severe injury’ case – Majority verdict for respondent on primary ‘no injury’ case – Judge erred in directing jury not to consider ‘less severe injury’ case – Victoria v Bryar (1970) 44 ALJR 174; Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361, applied.

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Misdirection by trial judge – Whether judgment should be set aside – Whether misdirection occasioned substantial wrong or miscarriage in trial – Respondent failed to establish that proper direction could not have made difference to outcome of trial – Substantial miscarriage – Power to set aside judgment and order retrial enlivened – When error occasions no substantial wrong or miscarriage, difference between residual discretion to refuse leave to appeal notwithstanding real prospect of success and prohibition against ordering new trial – Supreme Court Act 1986, s 14C, Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015, rr 64.37(1)–(2); Civil Procedure Act 2010, ss 7–8 – Balenzuela v De Gail (1959) 101 CLR 226; Weiss v The Queen (2005) 224 CLR 300; Nobarani v Mariconte (2018) 265 CLR 236; Tory v Megna [2007] NSWCA 13; Kennedy v Shire of Campaspe [2015] VSCA 47, considered.

CIVIL PROCEDURE – New trial – Material misdirection by trial judge – Applicant sought new trial in County Court on all issues – Respondent sought determination by Court of Appeal of ‘less severe injury’ case only with retention of jury verdict on ‘no injury’ case – Whether Court of Appeal empowered to set aside judgment but retain jury verdict – Clear power under Supreme Court Act 1986, s 14(1) – Whether Court of Appeal should determine ‘less severe injury’ case alone, or remit proceeding for new trial on all issues – Discretionary considerations relevant to choosing between ordering a new trial and Court of Appeal giving judgment – Leave to appeal granted – Appeal allowed – Judgment set aside, proceeding remitted for new trial on all issues – Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015, r 64.37; Supreme Court Act 1986, s 14; Civil Procedure Act 2010, ss 7–8 – Pateman v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dean v Central Highlands Region Water Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSCA 315
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in this case was severely injured in a dog attack while working as a water meter reader for the respondent, the Central Highlands Region Water Corporation. The applicant sought damages from the respondent, alleging that it was negligent in failing to provide dog safety training and/or animal repellent spray, which the applicant claimed would have either avoided the attack or caused the injuries to be less severe. The case was heard in the County Court of Victoria, where the jury found in favour of the respondent on the primary claim that the respondent's negligence did not cause the applicant's injuries. The judge directed the jury not to consider the alternative 'less severe injury' case, a direction which the applicant now seeks to challenge on appeal.

The central legal issue in this appeal was whether the trial judge's direction to the jury not to consider the 'less severe injury' case constituted a misdirection that occasioned a substantial wrong or miscarriage in the trial. The Court of Appeal found that the misdirection was material, as it led the jury to consider only one of the two possible cases presented by the applicant. The Court held that the misdirection could not be considered a minor error because it deprived the jury of the opportunity to weigh the evidence on the alternative theory of liability. This finding was based on the precedents set in Victoria v Bryar and Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd, which emphasised that where there is a misdirection of the jury, the error must be assessed in the context of the entire case and not in isolation.

The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal, setting aside the judgment and remitting the proceeding for a new trial on all issues. The Court concluded that the misdirection had occasioned a substantial wrong or miscarriage in the trial, as the respondent could not establish that the proper direction could not have made a difference to the outcome. The Court considered the relevant statutory provisions and case law, including Balenzuela v De Gail, Weiss v The Queen, Nobarani v Mariconte, Tory v Megna, and Kennedy v Shire of Campaspe, in making its decision. The Court also noted that it had the clear power under the Supreme Court Act 1986, s 14(1), to set aside the judgment and remit the proceeding for a new trial. In exercising its discretion, the Court determined that the appropriate course of action was to order a new trial on all issues, rather than giving judgment on the 'less severe injury' case alone. The Court referred to the precedents in Pateman v Higgin, Murphy v Mark, David Syme & Co Ltd v Mather, Vandeloo v Waltons Ltd, and Coroneo v Kurri Kurri and South Maitland Amusement Co Ltd in reaching its decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Dean, was employed by the respondent, Central Highlands Region Water Corporation, as a water meter reader. During the course of his employment, Dean was severely injured in an attack by a dog while performing his duties. He brought a claim for damages against his employer, alleging that they were negligent in failing to provide adequate dog safety training and animal repellent spray. Dean argued that such measures would have either prevented the attack or, at the very least, resulted in less severe injuries. The case proceeded to trial before a jury, where the judge directed the jury not to consider the alternative scenario of less severe injuries. The jury returned a verdict in favour of the respondent on the primary issue of no injury. Dean subsequently applied for leave to appeal against the judgment.

The matter first came before the County Court where Dean sought damages from the Central Highlands Region Water Corporation for the injuries sustained during the dog attack. The case was heard by a jury, and the trial judge directed the jury to consider only the primary issue of no injury, excluding the alternative scenario of less severe injuries. Following the jury's verdict in favour of the respondent, Dean applied to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal against the judgment. The Court of Appeal was asked to determine whether the trial judge's direction to the jury constituted a misdirection that occasioned a substantial wrong or miscarriage in the trial. The Court of Appeal considered the relevant statutory provisions and legal precedents in deciding whether to grant leave to appeal and, if so, whether to set aside the judgment and order a new trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the trial judge's direction to the jury, which excluded consideration of the alternative scenario of less severe injuries, constitute a misdirection?
2. If the direction was a misdirection, did it occasion a substantial wrong or miscarriage in the trial?
3. If a substantial wrong or miscarriage occurred, was the appropriate remedy to set aside the judgment and order a new trial on all issues or to remit the proceeding for a new trial?
4. Does the Court of Appeal have the power to set aside the judgment but retain the jury verdict on the issue of no injury, and if so, should it exercise that power?

Held
1. The trial judge's direction to the jury, which excluded consideration of the alternative scenario of less severe injuries, constituted a misdirection.
2. The misdirection occasioned a substantial wrong or miscarriage in the trial.
3. The appropriate remedy was to set aside the judgment and order a new trial on all issues.
4. The Court of Appeal did not exercise its power to set aside the judgment but retain the jury verdict on the issue of no injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal held that the trial judge's direction to the jury to not consider the scenario of less severe injuries amounted to a misdirection. The court applied the principles established in Victoria v Bryar and Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd, which require a jury to consider all available scenarios in a negligence case, including alternative scenarios of less severe injuries. The Court found that the respondent employer failed to demonstrate that the proper direction could not have made a difference to the outcome of the trial, thus establishing a substantial miscarriage. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions under the Supreme Court Act 1986, Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015, and Civil Procedure Act 2010, as well as the precedents in Balenzuela v De Gail, Weiss v The Queen, Nobarani v Mariconte, Tory v Megna, and Kennedy v Shire of Campaspe. The court's decision to set aside the judgment and remit the proceeding for a new trial on all issues was grounded in the established legal principle that when a misdirection occasions a substantial wrong or miscarriage, the power to set aside the judgment and order a retrial is enlivened. The Court of Appeal's decision not to exercise its power to set aside the judgment but retain the jury verdict on the issue of no injury was influenced by the discretionary considerations relevant to choosing between ordering a new trial and the Court of Appeal giving judgment on the 'less severe injury' case alone. The court referred to Pateman v Higgin, Murphy v Mark, David Syme & Co Ltd v Mather, Vandeloo v Waltons Ltd, and Coroneo v Kurri Kurri and South Maitland Amusement Co Ltd in reaching its conclusion.