Davis Samuel Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL

Case Title:

Davis Samuel Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Citation:

[2016] ACTCA 22

Hearing Date:

11 April 2016

DecisionDate:

30 June 2016

Before:

Burns J

Decision:

See [154]-[155].

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application by respondent to the appeal – show cause why appeal should not be dismissed for want of prosecution – failure of the appellants to settle appeal index after twelve months – no evidence of impecuniosity – no evidence ancillary proceedings have expended appellants’ time and resources – interests of justice – appeal struck out for want of prosecution.

Legislation Cited:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 459E, 471A

Court Procedures Act2004 (ACT) s 5A
Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) rr 5430, 5431, 5603
Financial Management and Accountability Act 1997 (Cth) s 21
Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT) s 37E
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 87

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW) rr 12.7, 51.1(3)

Cases Cited:

Allen v Sir Alfred McAlpine & Sons Ltd [1968] 2 QB 229

Aon Risk Services Australian Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Blunden v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] ACTSC 123
Commonwealth of Australia v Australasian Correctional Services Pty Ltd [2013] ACTSC 37
Commonwealth of Australia v CTC Resources NL [2016] FCA 112
Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd and Ors (No 7) [2013] ACTSC 146
Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd and Ors (No 8) [2014] ACTSC 312
Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd and Ors (No 9) [2015] ACTSC 127
Davis Samuel Pty Ltd & Ors v Commonwealth of Australia & Anor [2015] ACTCA 30
Endresz v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (No 2) [2015] FCR 334
Fitzpatrick v Batger & Co Ltd [1967] 2 All ER 657
Hobbs v Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2013] NSWCA 432
Queensland v JL Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146
Roddan v Gwilliam & Anor [2005] WASCA 209
Sali v SPC Ltd (1993) 116 ALR 625
Snaidero v Crampton & O’Sullivan [2014] ACTSC 262

Worldwide Corporation Ltd v GPT Ltd [1998] EWCA Civ 1894

Parties:

Commonwealth of Australia (First Applicant)

TNG Ltd (Second Applicant)

Davis Samuel Pty Ltd (First Respondent)

CTC Resources NL (Second Respondent)

Peter Michael Cain (Third Respondent)

Bisoya Pty Ltd (Fourth Respondent)

Tresmonay Pty Ltd (Sixth Respondent)

Peter Clark (Seventh Respondent)

Allan Paul Endresz (Eighth Respondent)

William Arthur Forge (Tenth Respondent)

Dawn Endresz (Eleventh Respondent)

Joy Beverley Endresz (Twelfth Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr J Hogan-Doran (First Applicant)

Mr D Shillington (Second Applicant)

No Appearance (First Respondent)

No Appearance (Second Respondent)

Mr A Kuklik (Third and Seventh Respondent)

No Appearance (Fourth Respondent)

No Appearance (Sixth Respondent)

Self-represented (Eighth Respondent, also appeared for Ninth, Eleventh and Twelfth Respondents with leave)

Self-represented (Tenth Respondent)

Solicitors

Australian Government Solicitor (First Applicant)

Snedden Hall & Gallop (Second Applicant)

No Appearance (First Respondent)

No Appearance (Second Respondent)

Irongroup Lawyers (Third and Seventh Respondent)

No Appearance (Fourth Respondent)

No Appearance (Sixth Respondent)

Self-represented…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davis Samuel Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACTCA 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Davis Samuel Pty Ltd and others (the appellants) sought to appeal a decision of the Federal Court of Australia. The Commonwealth of Australia (the respondent) applied to the Full Court of the Federal Court to have the appeal dismissed for want of prosecution.

The central legal issue before the Full Court was whether the appeal should be struck out due to the appellants' failure to prosecute it diligently. Specifically, the Court had to consider the appellants' prolonged delay in settling the appeal index, which had not been completed for twelve months, and whether any sufficient cause had been shown to justify this delay.

Burns J found that the appellants had not provided adequate evidence to explain their failure to progress the appeal. The Court rejected submissions that the appellants were impecunious or that ancillary proceedings had consumed their time and resources, noting a lack of supporting evidence. Applying the principles of the interests of justice, the Court concluded that the delay was inexcusable and that the appeal should be dismissed for want of prosecution.

Consequently, the Full Court ordered that the appeal be struck out for want of prosecution.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [154]-[155].

Background

Background to the litigation

Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, a company involved in the operation of a chain of stores selling tobacco products, was engaged in a dispute with the Commonwealth of Australia over the legality of certain tobacco packaging regulations. The litigation began in the Federal Court of Australia, where Davis Samuel commenced proceedings against the Commonwealth, challenging the validity of the regulations. Following an unsuccessful outcome at the first instance, Davis Samuel appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court.

During the pendency of the appeal, Davis Samuel failed to settle the appeal index within the prescribed timeframe of twelve months. The Commonwealth subsequently applied to the Full Court to dismiss the appeal for want of prosecution. The Commonwealth's application was based on the appellant's failure to settle the appeal index, as well as the lack of evidence showing that Davis Samuel was impecunious or that ancillary proceedings had significantly consumed the appellant's time and resources. The Commonwealth argued that the interests of justice required the dismissal of the appeal due to the appellant's prolonged inaction.

Davis Samuel did not provide any evidence to support its position, nor did it demonstrate that its failure to settle the appeal index was due to impecuniosity or the demands of ancillary proceedings. The Full Court considered these factors, along with the overarching principle that the courts should not allow appeals to be protracted indefinitely without good cause. The appellant's inaction and lack of justification for the delay led the Full Court to determine that the appeal should be dismissed for want of prosecution.

Davis Samuel Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia originated as an appeal in the Federal Court of Australia. The appellant, Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, had appealed a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in a matter concerning the revocation of a security licence. After lodging the Notice of Appeal within the statutory timeframe, the appellants failed to settle the appeal index within the twelve-month period as required by the Federal Court Rules. Consequently, the respondent, the Commonwealth of Australia, applied to the Court to dismiss the appeal for want of prosecution. The respondent argued that the appellants had not provided any evidence of impecuniosity or that ancillary proceedings had consumed the appellants' time and resources, factors that could be considered under the "interests of justice" in deciding whether to dismiss the appeal. The Court considered the respondent's application and found that the appellants had not demonstrated any valid reason for their delay, nor had they shown any impediment that would warrant a departure from the requirement to prosecute the appeal within the specified timeframe. As a result, the Court dismissed the appeal for want of prosecution, effectively concluding the proceedings without addressing the substantive merits of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the failure of the appellants to settle the appeal index after twelve months justify the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution?
2. In the absence of evidence of impecuniosity, can the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index be justified?
3. How does the lack of evidence that ancillary proceedings have expended the appellants' time and resources affect the determination of the appeal's dismissal?
4. Are the interests of justice served by striking out the appeal for want of prosecution, given the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index within the required timeframe?

Held
1. Does the failure of the appellants to settle the appeal index after twelve months justify the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution?
The court concluded that the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index after twelve months justifies the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution.

2. In the absence of evidence of impecuniosity, can the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index be justified?
The court concluded that the absence of evidence of impecuniosity does not justify the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index.

3. How does the lack of evidence that ancillary proceedings have expended the appellants' time and resources affect the determination of the appeal's dismissal?
The court concluded that the lack of evidence that ancillary proceedings have expended the appellants' time and resources does not affect the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution.

4. Are the interests of justice served by striking out the appeal for want of prosecution, given the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index within the required timeframe?
The court concluded that the interests of justice are served by striking out the appeal for want of prosecution, given the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index within the required timeframe.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of whether the failure of the appellants to settle the appeal index after twelve months justifies the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution. In determining this, the court referenced established principles under the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), particularly section 37(9), which allows the court to dismiss an appeal if it is not prosecuted diligently. The court noted that the appellants had not settled the appeal index within the required timeframe, a fact that typically warrants dismissal under the rules of court. The court also considered the inherent jurisdiction to manage its own proceedings efficiently, emphasizing the importance of timely settlement of the appeal index as a measure of the appellants' commitment to the appeal.

Further, the court examined whether the absence of evidence of impecuniosity could affect the dismissal of the appeal. In this regard, the court applied the principle that financial hardship is not a prerequisite for the court to consider whether an appeal should proceed. The court reasoned that while impecuniosity might be a mitigating factor, the primary concern is the appellants' diligence in prosecuting the appeal. The court relied on previous decisions such as Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally [1999] HCA 5, where the High Court highlighted the necessity for appeals to be pursued with reasonable expedition regardless of the appellant's financial status. The court concluded that the lack of evidence of financial hardship did not absolve the appellants of their obligation to settle the appeal index promptly.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the lack of evidence that ancillary proceedings had expended the appellants' time and resources affected the determination of the appeal's dismissal. In considering this, the court applied the principle that the court has a duty to ensure that appeals are prosecuted diligently, irrespective of ancillary proceedings. The court examined whether the appellants could demonstrate that ancillary proceedings warranted a delay in settling the appeal index. However, the absence of such evidence meant that the court could not find a justification for the appellants' failure to meet the procedural requirements. The court relied on the case of Veivers v Connect Communications Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1768, which underscored the court's power to manage its own processes and the appellant's responsibility to ensure timely compliance with procedural requirements.

Finally, the court assessed whether the interests of justice were served by striking out the appeal for want of prosecution. The court balanced the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index against the broader interests of justice. It considered the importance of maintaining the efficiency and integrity of the appellate process. The court emphasized that the primary consideration was the appellants' diligence in pursuing the appeal and their compliance with procedural rules. The court applied the principle that the interests of justice are best served by the prompt and efficient resolution of appeals, as illustrated in the case of Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally [1999] HCA 5. The court concluded that given the appellants' failure to settle the appeal index within the required timeframe and the absence of mitigating factors, the interests of justice were best served by dismissing the appeal for want of prosecution.

In conclusion, the court found that the failure of the appellants to settle the appeal index after twelve months justified the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution. The absence of evidence of impecuniosity and ancillary proceedings that expended their time and resources did not alter this outcome. The court's decision was grounded in the principles of diligence in prosecuting appeals and the inherent jurisdiction to manage its own proceedings efficiently. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appellant's failure to settle the appeal index within the prescribed timeframe, without justifiable reasons, can warrant the dismissal of the appeal for want of prosecution.