Daly and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Daly and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2020] AATA 1516 (27 May 2020)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/7614

Re:Peter Daly

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

File Number(s):      2019/7640

Re:Ian Williams

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investment Commission

RESPONDENT

File Number(s):      2019/7740

Re:Paul Raftery

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investment Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Date:27 May 2020

Place:Sydney

The applications for stay and confidentiality orders are refused. As of 4:00pm on Thursday 28 May 2020, the respondent is released from the undertakings given while the interlocutory application was on foot. The interim orders made under s 35 are also discharged at that time.

...............................[sgd]....................................

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – STAY APPLICATION – application for stay of publication of banning order by the Respondent – where applicants were banned for 5 years for mismanagement of funds – where publication of ban may impact sale of a business to compensate investors hurt by Applicant’s conduct – whether publication may hurt identifiable group of investors – objectives of the regulators in making a decision – where objective of legislation evince concern for consumer protection – objective of transparency – where there may be reputational damage – impact on family and business interests – where granting stay may subvert fundamental logic of legislative regime – stay application refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 35, 41

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 s 1

Corporations Act 2001 s 760A

CASES

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185; (2009) 181 FCR 130

Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Joseph Heller, Catch-22 (1961)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

27 May 2020

  1. The applicants were all involved in the provision of financial services. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) banned each of them from providing financial services for a term. The applicants have asked the Tribunal to review those decisions. In the interim, while the review proceeds, the applicants have each asked the Tribunal to make orders under ss 35 and 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) that will have the effect of suppressing information about ASIC’s decisions.

  2. The applicants are not asking for the underlying decision in each case to be stayed. They say they merely want to prevent ASIC from publicising news of the banning orders. The applicants argue any announcement by ASIC would derail negotiations for the sale of a business with which the applicants are or were involved. The twist here is that a successful sale of that business might provide the funds to compensate investors who were said to be hurt by the very conduct which brought the applicants to ASIC’s attention in the first place.

  3. While the applicants have not conceded they engaged in the misconduct that prompted ASIC’s regulatory action against them, they say they are trying to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daly and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1516
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceeding involved an application by Mr Peter Daly and others for a stay of the publication of a banning order made by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). ASIC had banned the applicants for five years due to alleged mismanagement of funds. The applicants sought to prevent the publication of this ban, arguing it could negatively impact the sale of a business intended to compensate investors who had suffered losses due to their conduct. The application was heard by Deputy President Bernard J McCabe.

The central legal issue before the court was whether to grant a stay of ASIC's banning order publication under section 41(2) of the relevant legislation. The applicants contended that publication of the ban before the settlement of a business sale agreement would cause significant and irrecoverable losses, potentially jeopardising the sale and reducing the funds available to compensate investors. They argued that the purchaser might withdraw from the agreement, or the business's value would diminish due to the potential departure of its network of representatives, who were sensitive to reputational damage.

The court refused the application for a stay. It reasoned that the legislative regime governing ASIC's decisions prioritised consumer protection and transparency. Granting a stay would subvert the fundamental logic of this regime by delaying the public notification of regulatory action. While acknowledging the potential reputational and financial impacts on the applicants and the business sale, the court found that these concerns did not outweigh the public interest in the timely and unredacted publication of ASIC's decisions. The court emphasised that the Tribunal's processes, including the publication of reasoned decisions, served to establish norms and provide guidance, thereby yielding significant savings in better-quality executive decision-making and avoiding future disputes.

The application for a stay was refused, and ASIC was released from undertakings given during the interlocutory application. The interim orders were discharged, and the reasons for the decision were to be published without redaction in the ordinary course.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

But it turns out the dilemma is not insoluble, and the outcome is not perverse when one understands the logic of the regulatory regime. The application for orders under ss 35 and 41 is refused, for reasons I will explain. As of 4:00pm on Thursday 28 May 2020, ASIC is released from the undertakings it gave while the interlocutory application was on foot. The interim orders made under s 35 are also discharged at that time. In the absence of further orders, these reasons will thereafter be published without redaction in the ordinary course. Background to the reviewable decisions The applicants were all involved in the management of a group of companies that conducted a range of financial services businesses. The group included the holding company, Linchpin Capital Group Ltd (in liq), and Beacon Financial Group Pty Ltd, a group company that controls a number of other companies that I will refer to as the Beacon group. The Beacon group is a discrete group of companies within the Linchpin group. The companies in the Beacon group conduct a financial services business that manages funds, provides financial advice and offers mortgage broking services. The success of the business depends on the work of a network of independent authorised representatives and credit representatives. The representatives channel work or funds towards the companies in the group. While each of the representatives have an established relationship with the group, they are not beholden to the group companies and could break off their individual relationship at any time and direct their business elsewhere. If representatives quit the Beacon group network, the Beacon group’s business will diminish in value. The companies in the Beacon group are not the source of the applicants’ present difficulties. Those difficulties arise out of the activities of Linchpin and other group companies involved in the Investport Income Opportunity Fund (the IIOF). The IIOF was essentially comprised of registered and unregistered managed investment schemes. Linchpin was the trustee of the unregistered scheme while a subsidiary company was the responsible entity for the registered scheme. ASIC claimed in Federal Court proceedings against Lynchpin that the funds were mismanaged in a variety of ways that I do not need to particularise here. (The allegations were summarised in a concise statement that ASIC provided to the Federal Court). The investors in the IIOF are likely to suffer a substantial loss. Importantly, ASIC says the three applicants in these proceedings were involved in the mismanagement of IIOF in various respects. The first applicant, Mr Peter Daly, was the key executive in the Beacon group companies and a director of Linchpin and the subsidiary involved in IIOF. He was also a member of the lending committee of the unregistered scheme and the investment committee of the registered scheme. The committees effectively operated the schemes as a single fund and mismanaged them in a variety of ways – including appointing unauthorised transfers between the funds and approving loans to related parties that did not comply with the conflict policy and other internal procedures. ASIC’s delegate decided Mr Daly should be banned from providing financial services for a period of five years after:(a)making adverse findings about his failure to comply with financial services laws and involvement in the contraventions of others; and(b)concluding it had reason to believe Mr Daly would contravene financial services laws (or become involved in the contraventions of others) in the future.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is true the Tribunal’s processes in the General and Other Divisions are relatively costly precisely because they include forensic fact-finding processes, judicial-style hearings with a contradictor and carefully reasoned decisions which are published for all to read. But there is a bigger picture. The Tribunal’s decision in each case establishes a norm that can be adopted and applied in the bureaucracy at low cost when decision-makers come across similar cases in the future. Decision-makers and the public can avoid disputes because the Tribunal has already told them where they are likely to stand. The cost of the Tribunal is therefore an investment that yields much larger savings in the form of better-quality executive decision-making. Should the Tribunal issue a stay under s 41(2) that restrains ASIC from publicising the reviewable decision? I have already explained the power in s 41(2) must be exercised for the requisite purpose – namely, securing the effectiveness of the hearing and the review. The applicants in this case say they and many others will experience significant losses that cannot be recovered even if the applicants (or any of them) are successful at the hearing. They have each provided affidavits which claim the proposed sale of the Beacon group companies will be threatened if the news of ASIC’s banning orders were to come out now. Mr Daly explained the Beacon group companies depended on the loyalty and support of the network of representatives who steered business their way. The representatives were easily spooked, I was told, because they had their own reputations to protect. They would be nervous about remaining associated with companies that had an ongoing relationship with Mr Daly if news of his banning were to be announced. Mr Daly said the network of advisers had already shrunk in response to news of the litigation against Linchpin and its subsidiary and the commencement of winding up proceedings. He expected a more stringent reaction in the absence of a stay order. The reaction of the representatives was particularly problematic because the Beacon group companies had negotiated a Share and Business Sale Agreement that would see the sale of the Beacon group to a third party. A copy of the agreement was annexed to an affidavit of Mr Williams. Mr Daly and Mr Williams said the purchaser might pull out of the agreement if it got wind of the regulatory action before the settlement date. At a minimum, the business would be less valuable if the network of representatives were to shrink in response to an announcement by ASIC. I was told the contract provided for the final sale price to be calculated with reference to certain performance measures. If those measures were impacted because the representatives reacted adversely to ASIC’s news about the applicants, the final sale price would be lower – which meant less money would be available to the investors in IIOF who had sustained a loss. The applicants say there is unlikely to be any controversy if ASIC made an announcement after settlement day. If settlement occurred, the Beacon group companies would be under new management. On the other hand, if the sale did not proceed and the network of representatives were to dissipate in response to bad news, the worst case scenario included the failure of the Beacon group companies as the business was compromised.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established