SYRL and Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SYRL and Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2024] AATA 2636 (23 July 2024)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2024/3220      

Re:SYRL  

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities & Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION     

Tribunal:Senior Member D Benk 

Date:23 July 2024

Place:Sydney

The application for a confidentiality order pursuant to s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) is refused.

...............[SGD].........................................................

Senior Member D Benk 

Catchwords

CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER – application for confidentiality order –– section 35 Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – consideration given to openness, open justice, maintaining public confidence – application refused

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 35, 41

Cases

Daly and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2020] AATA 1516

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeal Tribunal

(2009) 181 FCR 130

Devasahayam and Comcare [2010] AATA 784

Flood & Secretary, Department of Social Security (1994) 33 ALD 182

Re Lawrance and CRS Australia (2004) 85 ALD 238

Modini and Tax Agents’ Board of Queensland [2005] AATA 1200

Modini v Tax Agents Board of Queensland [2005] FCA 570

Re Pochi and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1979] AATA 64

Re Pochi and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 33

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D Benk 

23 July 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. The matter has history before the Tribunal. On 3 June 2024, the Tribunal made interim conditional stay orders pertaining to a decision made by the Respondent which sought to disqualify the Applicant from managing corporations for a period of 18 months. Reasons were published under a pseudonym.[1]

    [1] SYRL and ASIC [2024] AATA 1370

  2. The matter was again listed on 19 June 2024 to determine the issue of stay and confidentiality orders. In the interim, the respondent refrained from issuing its standard media release and agreed not to do so until the Tribunal determined the application for confidentiality orders sought by the Applicant.

  3. On 19 June 2024, the parties came to an agreement with regards to the continuance of the Stay subject to conditions pursuant to s 41 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act (the Act).  Orders in accordance with that agreement have been made separately.  Despite being by consent, the terms are in my view appropriate given the history of this matter, which has been previously recorded and which in the interests of brevity will not be repeated here.

  4. Both parties made further submissions with regards to the issue of confidentiality, the last being received on 10 July 2024.

  5. The only issue that I am required to determine is whether it is appropriate to grant confidentiality orders with reference to s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The orders sought are opposed by the respondent. Multiple affidavits are amongst the exhibits and were considered along with the oral submissions.

    RELIEF SOUGHT

  6. Relief sought includes:

    (a)That the applicant be described by a pseudonym ”for the purposes of protecting her identity”;

    (b)That the hearing take place in private (a closed hearing);

    (c)That the publication…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SYRL and Australian Securities & Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2636
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by a party, SYRL, for a confidentiality order against the Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC) before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). SYRL sought to restrict the publication or disclosure of information that could reveal its identity or other information concerning it within the proceeding.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant SYRL's application for a confidentiality order, which would involve directing that the hearing or part of it take place in private, or prohibiting or restricting the publication or disclosure of information concerning SYRL. This required the Tribunal to consider the principles of openness and open justice, as enshrined in section 35 of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (AAT Act), against the reasons put forward by SYRL for confidentiality.

The Tribunal reasoned that section 35 of the AAT Act mandates that hearings are generally to be held in public, and evidence and documents should be made available to the public and parties, as this promotes public confidence in the administration of justice. While the Tribunal has the power to make confidentiality orders, it must take openness as the basis of its consideration and only depart from this principle if there are proper and cogent reasons. The Tribunal found that SYRL's submissions did not displace the paramount consideration of open justice, nor did they establish that such orders were necessary for the proper administration of justice. The Tribunal noted that embarrassing or inconvenient facts are an unavoidable consequence of open justice and that the respondent's reviewable decision, being that of a public regulator, is ordinarily published openly.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the relief sought by SYRL should be granted, finding that the applicant's submissions failed to establish compelling grounds to bypass the foundational principle of open justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On balance, the Tribunal is not satisfied the relief sought in paragraph 6 above should be granted as I find the submissions and contentions of the applicant do not displace the factors set out in subsection 35(5) of the AAT Act; the Tribunal’s objectives in section 2A of the AAT Act and established authorities discussed above because:i.Such orders would hinder ‘open justice’ which is the paramount consideration in assessing whether such orders are to be made and which is an indispensable feature of our legal system. The reason for the principle of open justice is that, if the proceedings are fully exposed to public and professional scrutiny and criticism, and interested observers are able to follow and comprehend the evidence, submissions and reasons for judgment, then public administration of justice will be enhanced and confidence in the integrity and independence of the Tribunal will be maintained. Not only does the conduct of proceedings publicly and in open view assist in removing doubts and misapprehensions about the operation of the system, but it also limits the opportunity for abuse and injustice by those involved in the process, by making them publicly accountable.ii.Departure from the principle of open justice is only justified where observance of the principle would in fact frustrate the administration of justice. To that end, an order restricting the public availability of information will only be made if it is really necessary to secure the proper administration of justice. Such an order must be clear in its terms and do no more than is necessary to achieve the due administration of justice. Furthermore, there must be some material before the Tribunal upon which it can reasonably reach the conclusion that it is actually necessary to make an order of that type. In these circumstances, the submissions fall short in establishing the confidentiality orders and relief sought generally would secure the proper administration of justice. I acknowledge the argument that legal representation may be curtailed or impeded by virtue of Mr Baker’s threats, but this can be mitigated through an approach on the police service. iii.It is a trite statement that one of the consequences of the principle of open justice is that embarrassing, damaging and inconvenient facts may occasionally come to light. There is much authority supporting the proposition that those grounds have rarely if ever been regarded as a reason of itself for the suppression of evidence or the use of a pseudonym. Equally, it is common for sensitive issues to be litigated and for information that is extremely personal or confidential to be disclosed. This is sometimes an unavoidable by-product, and a necessary consequence, of the application of the principle of open justice. iv.Furthermore, there must be some material before the Tribunal upon which it can reasonably reach the conclusion that it is actually necessary to make an order of that type. Whilst there have been submissions made, none were compelling to bypass the foundation of open justice for the reasons discussed above. v.Finally, it is relevant to mention here that there is nothing inherently confidential about the respondent’s reviewable decision. It is the decision of a public regulator and in the ordinary course of events is published openly. The applicant has not referred to any other reason as to why this should not take place apart from those above which I have already determined to be not persuasive nor proper grounds to grant the relief sought. DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 35 of the AAT Act relevantly provides that:Public hearing(1)Subject to this section, the hearing of a proceeding before the Tribunal must be in public.Private hearing(2)The Tribunal may, by order:(a) direct that a hearing or part of a hearing is to take place in private; and(b) give directions in relation to the persons who may be present.Orders for non-publication or non-disclosure(3)The Tribunal may, by order, give directions prohibiting or restricting the publication or other disclosure of:(a) information tending to reveal the identity of:(i)a party to or witness in a proceeding before the Tribunal; or(ii)any person related to or otherwise associated with any party to or witness in a proceeding before the Tribunal; or(b) information otherwise concerning a person referred to in paragraph (a).(4)The Tribunal may, by order, give directions prohibiting or restricting the publication or other disclosure, including to some or all of the parties, of information that:(a) relates to a proceeding; and(b) is any of the following:(i)information that comprises evidence or information about evidence;(ii)information lodged with or otherwise given to the Tribunal.(5)In considering whether to give directions under subsection (2), (3) or (4), the Tribunal is to take as the basis of its consideration the principle that it is desirable:(a) that hearings of proceedings before the Tribunal should be held in public; and(b) that evidence given before the Tribunal and the contents of documents received in evidence by the Tribunal should be made available to the public and to all the parties; and(c) that the contents of documents lodged with the Tribunal should be made available to all the parties.However (and without being required to seek the views of the parties), the Tribunal is to pay due regard to any reasons in favour of giving such a direction, including, for the purposes of subsection (3) or (4), the confidential nature (if applicable) of the information.CONSIDERATION As indicated above, subsection 35(3) of the AAT Act gives the Tribunal power to make directions prohibiting or restricting the publication or other disclosure of information tending to reveal the identity of a party or witness in a proceeding. To this end, the Tribunal may allocate a pseudonym to a party or witness and use this instead of their name. Further, subsection 35(5) of the AAT Act makes plain that in considering whether to grant a confidentiality order under subsection 35(3) the Tribunal is to take as the basis of its consideration that ‘it is desirable’ that hearings of proceedings before the Tribunal be held in public and that evidence given before the Tribunal and the contents of documents received in evidence should be made available to the public. It is clear from the terms of section 35 of the AAT Act that the Tribunal must generally conduct a proceeding on the basis of openness, in the interests of maintaining public confidence in the fairness and integrity of that proceeding, and that the Tribunal should only depart from this approach if it is satisfied that there are proper and cogent reasons for doing so. This has been the subject of much authority as outlined below.