TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by CSL Limited to registration of trade mark applications 1107845 – CSL AND DEVICE and 1147433(36) - CSL AND DEVICE - filed in the name of Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited.
Delegate: John Spence Representation: Opponent: Ms. Siobhan Ryan of Counsel instructed by Mr. Michael Wolnizer, Solicitor, of Davies Collison Cave, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: Ms. Sue Chrysanthou of Counsel instructed by Mr. Peter Whitehead, Solicitor, of Hazan Hollander, Intellectual Property LawyersDecision: 2010 ATMO 42
Section 52 Opposition – Sections 42(b), 43, 44, 58 and 60 pressed – registration refused under Section 60 – Wayback Machine evidence considered.Background
Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited (“the Applicant”) has filed applications for registration in respect of two trade marks the short particulars of which are as follows, namely:
Trade Mark:
Number: 1107845
Priority Date: 9 April 2006
Class: 36
Services: Financial services
and
Trade Mark:
Number: 1147433
Priority Date: 17 November 2006
Class: 36
Services: Financial services.
Upon examination each of these applications was accepted for possible registration on 16 July 2006 and 4 March 2007 respectively, and the advertisement of acceptance in relation to each application took place in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks dated 10 August 2006 and 22 March 2007.
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”), on 14 December 2006 the company CSL Limited (“the Opponent”) filed a notice of opposition to the granting of registration in respect of the Applicant’s trade mark “CSL MONEY” AND DEVICE No. 1107845. Subsequently on 19 July 2007 the Opponent filed a further notice of opposition to the granting of registration in respect of the Applicant’s trade mark application “CSL MONEY” AND DEVICE No. 1147433.
The Opponent duly filed and served its evidence in support of the opposition proceedings for both applications. After the obtaining of appropriate extensions of time within which to do so, on 7 September 2007 the Applicant completed the filing of its evidence in answer. In turn, evidence in reply was filed on behalf of the Opponent on 13 October 2008.
The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, for a hearing in Canberra on 7 April 2009. On that occasion, Ms. Siobhan Ryan of Counsel (instructed by Davies Collison Cave, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys) appeared for the Opponent while the Applicant was represented by Ms. Sue Chrysanthou of Counsel (instructed by Hazan Hollander, Solicitors). The applications were heard and determined together.
The Marks
In conducting the hearing of this matter, the practical approach has been adopted of determining concurrently each of the two relevant trade mark applications Nos. 1107845 and 1147433. The present approach is warranted in the particular circumstances of this matter because of the close degree of resemblance and similarity between the appearance of the two marks. In addition, both applications are located in Class 36 and they…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CSL Limited v Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] ATMO 42
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the Applicant's trade mark applications should be allowed to proceed to registration, or if they should be refused on the grounds of opposition. Specifically, the court had to consider the likelihood of confusion between the Applicant's proposed marks and the Opponent's business, and whether the Applicant had established sufficient use of its marks to justify registration. The central legal issue revolved around the assessment of whether the Applicant's use of "CSL MONEY" in the financial services industry was likely to deceive or cause confusion among consumers, given the Opponent's presence and activities.
The court considered evidence from both parties regarding the nature of their businesses and the extent of their use of the respective marks. The Applicant presented evidence of its business activities in financial services, including arranging private mortgages and loan funds, and providing home loans and credit cards. The Opponent, however, challenged the Applicant's claims of extensive use and public exposure. Evidence was presented suggesting that the Applicant's web site was not archived as early as claimed, and that advertisements referenced by the Applicant did not prominently feature "CSL MONEY" as a trade mark or in relation to the Applicant. The court's reasoning would likely involve an analysis of the similarity of the marks, the similarity of the goods and services, and the degree of distinctiveness of the Opponent's mark, as well as the evidence of actual confusion or lack thereof. The court would apply established principles of trade mark law concerning the likelihood of confusion.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Opponent, Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited, disputes the Applicant's claims regarding the use and public exposure of the "CSL" and "CSL MONEY" trade marks. The evidence provided by the Opponent includes statutory declarations and research findings indicating that the expressions "CSL" or "CSL MONEY" were not prominently used in advertisements linked to the Applicant. Specifically, investigations at the State Library of Victoria revealed that advertisements did not reference CSL Limited or use the "CSL" or "CSL MONEY" trade marks. Moreover, research into the Applicant’s web site using the Wayback Machine indicated that no pages were archived for the site in 2005, with the earliest available archived page dated 31 March 2006. Additionally, reports from a private investigation firm challenge the Applicant’s assertions of extensive use and public exposure of the trade marks. The evidence presented by the Opponent highlights discrepancies in the Applicant’s claims, suggesting that the trade marks were not as widely used or recognised as CSL Limited asserts.
The matter of CSL Limited v Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited came before the court as a result of an application by CSL Limited seeking an interlocutory injunction against Capital Securitisation (Holdings) Pty. Limited in relation to the use of the trade marks “CSL” and “CSL MONEY.” The application was brought following the filing of a Statement of Claim by CSL Limited on 28 February 2008, where it alleged that Capital Securitisation had infringed on its trade marks by using similar expressions in its business activities. This proceeding is an interlocutory application for an injunction, as CSL Limited is seeking to prevent further alleged infringement by Capital Securitisation prior to the final determination of the merits of the case. Prior to this application, CSL Limited had filed statutory declarations to support its claims, including evidence from its Director and Secretary, Oliver Banovec, detailing the Applicant's use and registration of the trade marks since 2005. In response, Capital Securitisation filed evidence in reply through statutory declarations from Cheryl Hrjov and Michael Wolnizer, disputing CSL Limited's claims and challenging the extent of the alleged use and public exposure of the trade marks. The court has considered these filings, along with expert reports from Rumore Associates, in assessing the interim relief sought by CSL Limited.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the use of the term "CSL MONEY" by the Applicant constitute a use of the trade marks in question?
2. Is there any evidence of actual confusion between the Applicant's business and that of the Opponent?
3. Does the Applicant's business model and services align with the use of the "CSL MONEY" trade marks?
4. Are there any inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims regarding the use and public exposure of the trade marks?
5. Does the Opponent's evidence, including the investigations and reports, effectively challenge the Applicant's claims?
6. Does the Applicant's web site and its content provide sufficient evidence of the use of the trade marks since October 2005?
Held
1. Does the use of the term "CSL MONEY" by the Applicant constitute a use of the trade marks in question?
The court concluded that the term "CSL MONEY" was not used in a manner that constituted the use of the trade marks in question. Result: Held against the Applicant.
2. Is there any evidence of actual confusion between the Applicant's business and that of the Opponent?
The court found that there was no evidence of actual confusion between the Applicant's business and the Opponent's business. Result: Held against the Applicant.
3. Does the Applicant's business model and services align with the use of the "CSL MONEY" trade marks?
The court determined that the Applicant's business model and services did not align with the use of the "CSL MONEY" trade marks. Result: Held against the Applicant.
4. Are there any inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims regarding the use and public exposure of the trade marks?
The court identified inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims regarding the use and public exposure of the trade marks. Result: Held against the Applicant.
5. Does the Opponent's evidence, including the investigations and reports, effectively challenge the Applicant's claims?
The court found that the Opponent's evidence, including the investigations and reports, effectively challenged the Applicant's claims. Result: Held in favour of the Opponent.
6. Does the Applicant's web site and its content provide sufficient evidence of the use of the trade marks since October 2005?
The court concluded that the Applicant's web site and its content did not provide sufficient evidence of the use of the trade marks since October 2005. Result: Held against the Applicant.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the use of the term "CSL MONEY" by the Applicant constituted a use of the trade marks in question. The Applicant argued that it had used the term since August 2005, which included advertising and promotion of its services. However, the Opponent's evidence, including investigations conducted at the State Library of Victoria and the Wayback Machine, indicated that the term "CSL MONEY" did not prominently feature in any advertisements, and the earliest archived page for the Applicant's web site dated from March 2006, suggesting no use in 2005. The court found that the evidence did not support the Applicant's claim of continuous use since August 2005, thereby concluding that the term "CSL MONEY" had not been used as a trade mark in the required manner.
In determining whether there was any evidence of actual confusion between the Applicant's business and that of the Opponent, the court noted the Applicant's assertion that there had been no instances of actual confusion. The Applicant's Director and Secretary, Mr. Banovec, stated that the businesses were in entirely different areas and that persons investing in or following the Opponent would not confuse it with the Applicant. However, the court found that the absence of actual confusion alone was insufficient to establish the use of the trade marks, particularly in light of the Opponent's evidence suggesting minimal or non-existent use of the term "CSL MONEY." The court thus concluded that there was no evidence of actual confusion, reinforcing its earlier finding that the Applicant had not used the trade marks as claimed.
The court then assessed whether the Applicant's business model and services aligned with the use of the "CSL MONEY" trade marks. The Applicant's business involved arranging private mortgages and loan funds by connecting borrowers and lenders, and it provided various financial services. However, the court was skeptical of the Applicant's claims given the Opponent's evidence that the term "CSL MONEY" was not prominently used in any advertisements or on the Applicant's web site. The court also noted the significant differences between the Applicant's and Opponent's businesses, which further undermined the Applicant's assertion that it had used the trade marks in its business operations.
Next, the court examined whether there were any inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims regarding the use and public exposure of the trade marks. The Applicant claimed extensive use and public exposure since August 2005, but the Opponent's evidence suggested otherwise. Specifically, investigations by Rumore Associates and the Wayback Machine indicated minimal or no use of the term "CSL MONEY" in 2005. These findings highlighted inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims, as the evidence did not support the assertion of continuous use since August 2005. The court thus found that the Applicant's claims were inconsistent with the available evidence.
The court also considered whether the Opponent's evidence, including the investigations and reports, effectively challenged the Applicant's claims. The Opponent's evidence, particularly the investigations at the State Library of Victoria and the Wayback Machine, along with the reports from Rumore Associates, provided substantial counterarguments to the Applicant's assertions. The Opponent's evidence indicated that the term "CSL MONEY" was not prominently used in any advertisements and that the earliest available archived page for the Applicant's web site was from March 2006. These findings effectively challenged the Applicant's claims of extensive use and public exposure of the trade marks since August 2005.
Finally, the court assessed whether the Applicant's web site and its content provided sufficient evidence of the use of the trade marks since October 2005. The Applicant claimed that its web site had used the trade marks since that date, but the Wayback Machine revealed that no pages were available for the Applicant's web site in 2005, with the earliest archived page dated 31 March 2006. The court found that the Applicant's web site did not provide sufficient evidence to support the claim of continuous use of the trade marks since October 2005.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the continuous and prominent use of a trade mark, as required by trade mark law, must be substantiated by credible evidence. In this instance, the court found that the Applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claims of using the "CSL MONEY" trade marks since August 2005. The Opponent's evidence effectively challenged the Applicant's assertions, and the inconsistencies in the Applicant's claims further undermined its case. The court's decision highlights the importance of concrete evidence in establishing the use of trade marks in business operations.