CareerBuilder, LLC v Careerbuilders Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by CareerBuilder, LLC to application under section 92 of the Act by Careerbuilders Pty Ltd to remove trade mark registration number 838244(35) - MY CAREERBUILDER - in the name of CareerBuilder, LLC

Delegate: Michael Kirov
Representation: Opponent: No appearance and did not lodge written submissions
Removal Applicant: Christian Bova of Counsel, instructed by Mallesons Stephen Jaques, Lawyers
Decision: 2009 ATMO 31
s.92(4)(b) opposition: No relevant use shown and opposition not established. No reason for exercise of discretion in Opponent’s favour. Trade Mark to be removed. Costs awarded against Opponent.

Background

  1. CareerBuilder, LLC (“the Opponent”) is the registered owner of trade mark registration 838244, relevant details of which are as follows:

    Trade mark number:  838244
    Registered from:                   7 June 2000

    Services:Class: 35 Feature of on-line personnel recruitment information and job information services provided via the global computer network

    Trade Mark:  MY CAREERBUILDER

  2. Hereafter I refer to the MY CAREERBUILDER mark as “the Trade Mark” and to the services covered by registration 838244 as “the Services”.

  3. The Opponent is an American company which has provided recruitment services in the United States and elsewhere via various media including the Internet since 1995 and under its current name CareerBuilder since 1998

  4. On 10 March 2006, Careerbuilders Pty Ltd (“the Removal Applicant”) filed an application under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) for removal of the Trade Mark from the Register, alleging it was not used in good faith for the Services during the three year period ending on 10 February 2006 (“the Non-use Period”).

  5. The Removal Applicant is an Australian company which was incorporated in 2004.  Its evidence indicates that it has continuously used the name and trade mark CAREERBUILDERS since then in relation to the services in the recruitment, training and coaching fields covered by its own currently pending Australian trade mark application 1033764 for the CAREERBUILDERS mark.  The services covered by this application, which was filed on 17 March 2005, are on the face of it similar to the Services.  Not surprisingly, therefore, registration 838244 was cited as a significant obstacle to application 1033764 and this has apparently prompted the present removal application.

    The Opposition

  6. Section 100(1)(c) of the Act provides that the Opponent bears the onus of rebutting an allegation made against it under s.92(4)(b), by establishing that the Trade Mark (or the Trade Mark with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity) was used in good faith during the Non-use Period, or that there was an obstacle to use during that period. I proceed on the basis that the relevant standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities.

  7. On 5 July 2006 the Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition to the removal (“the Notice”), raising several grounds of opposition.  Of these, the principal ground relevant to the matter at issue at the hearing was that:

    The Opponent has used or authorized use of the Registered Trade…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CareerBuilder, LLC v Careerbuilders Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CareerBuilder, LLC (the Opponent) sought the removal of a trade mark registered by Careerbuilders Pty Ltd (the Removal Applicant) from the Register of Trade Marks. The dispute concerned whether the Removal Applicant had standing as a "person aggrieved" to seek removal and whether the Opponent had actually used its trade mark in Australia during the relevant non-use period. The matter was heard by Michael Kirov, acting as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were: firstly, whether the Removal Applicant possessed the requisite standing as a "person aggrieved" under the pre-amendment legislation applicable to the removal application; and secondly, whether the Opponent had demonstrated actual use of its trade mark in Australia during the claimed period of non-use.

The delegate found that the Removal Applicant was a "person aggrieved" because it had provided evidence of its own use of the "CAREERBUILDERS" mark for similar services since its incorporation in May 2004, and it had reasonable concerns about potential legal or practical disadvantage if the Opponent's mark remained on the Register. This satisfied the test established in *Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the Ritz Ltd*. Regarding actual use, the delegate noted that the Opponent's only evidence of use in Australia was through its website, which was maintained on a server in the United States. While the Opponent's evidence mentioned a partnership with "mycareer.com.au" in 2003, no further details were provided, and there was no indication that the trade mark was actually used by or on that website.

The delegate concluded that the Removal Applicant had standing. However, the delegate found that the Opponent had not established actual use of its trade mark in Australia during the relevant period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Opponent did not serve any evidence in reply to this further evidence and the matter was in due course heard before me as delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks in Sydney on 2 March 2009. Christian Bova of Counsel appeared for the Removal Applicant. The Opponent did not appear, nor was it represented, nor did it file any written submissions.The Evidence and SubmissionsStanding The application for removal of the Trade Mark was filed on 10 March 2006, prior to significant amendment to the relevant legislation which took effect from 23 October 2006, and thus the pre-amendment legislation is applicable. A removal applicant was then required to have the standing of “a person aggrieved”. The Opponent challenges the Removal Applicant’s status in this regard. I am nevertheless satisfied from the evidence that the Removal Applicant is indeed a person aggrieved within the meaning of s.92(4)(b). It has provided evidence of its use of the “word” CAREERBUILDERS, both as part of its corporate name and as a trade mark for services which I accept are similar to the Services, from its incorporation in May 2004 to 10 March 2006 (and beyond). It has used the CAREERBUILDERS mark on its business stationery, in its publicity brochures and leaflets, and on its website at and has given details of significant amounts spent on marketing the services in question prior to 10 March 2006. While one might wonder whether the Removal Applicant might not have made appropriate enquiries and discovered the existence of the Opponent and of the Trade Mark before itself adopting an apparently similar mark for similar services, this is not relevant to the issue of whether the Removal Applicant should be considered to be a person aggrieved at the time it filed the removal application.[1].[1] See for example Woolly Bull Enterprises Pty Ltd v Reynolds (2001) 51 IPR 149, at [11] to [12]. I accept that the Removal Applicant would have had reasonable concerns as at 10 March 2006 as to whether its use of the CAREERBUILDERS trade mark would be objectionable to the Opponent. I am thus satisfied the Removal Applicant meets the often quoted test of McLelland, J in Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the Ritz Ltd (1988) 12 IPR 417 (“the Ritz case”), at 454, that an applicant is aggrieved if there is a reasonable possibility of the applicant being appreciably disadvantaged in a legal or practical sense if the trade mark subject of the removal application were to remain on the Register.Actual Use The “use” of the Trade Mark in Australia during the Non-use Period claimed by the Opponent and shown in its evidence is entirely by means of the Opponent’s website at (“the Website”). That is to say, the Opponent has no physical presence in Australia other than the Website which, although accessible from Australia, is I understand maintained on a server in the United States[2].[2] Mr Yasin annexes a history of the Opponent downloaded from the Website on 10 May 2007 and does highlight that the Opponent apparently “created a new partnership in Australia with mycareer.com.au in 2003”. However, no further details of the nature of this relationship are given, no information concerning who or what entity is meant by the description “mycareer.com.au” is provided and there is no indication that the Trade Mark was ever actually used by, or on the website of, “mycareer.com.au”, or indeed if such a website existed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.