Crouch v The Bloody Mary Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

CROUCH & ORS v THE BLOODY MARY GROUP PTY LTD & ORS

[2020] SASC 68

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

30 April 2020

TORTS - MISCELLANEOUS TORTS

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT OR FALSE REPRESENTATIONS - CHARACTER OR ATTRIBUTES OF CONDUCT OR REPRESENTATION - SILENCE AND NON-DISCLOSURE

In 2016 the plaintiffs entered into an arrangement with the defendants for the joint purchase of the Windmill Hotel through an incorporated joint venture. The plaintiffs allege that in agreeing to enter into this arrangement they were misled by the defendants in that they failed to disclose their receipt of certain rebates referable to the sale of alcohol at the Windmill Hotel, and thereby failed to disclose their conduct in diverting a commercial opportunity away from the joint venture and for their own benefit.

In these proceedings, the plaintiffs allege that the defendants are liable either for the tort of deceit, or in the alternative for misleading and deceptive conduct in contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law. They also allege breaches of a Unitholder and Shareholder Agreement by reason of the same conduct. The plaintiffs seek to recover the loss they claim to have suffered by reason of their entry into the arrangement to purchase the Windmill Hotel.

Held (per Doyle J):

1.      The second defendant knowingly conveyed false representations, and engaged in misleading conduct, by reason of his conduct in not disclosing to the plaintiffs that he and the fourth defendant planned to keep the forward rebates for their own benefit through the first defendant. The false representations were as to use of the buying power of the first, second and fourth defendants, and the opportunity for the parties to be equal investors.

2.      The fourth defendant knowingly made or adopted the false representation that the parties would be equal investors. By reason of the conduct of both the second defendant and the fourth defendant in not disclosing their planned use of the forward rebates, this representation was false.

3.      The conduct of the second and fourth defendants in making the buying power and equal investors representations, in circumstances where they knew them to be false, is to be attributed to the first defendant. The same applies in respect of the second and fourth defendants’ trustee companies, being the third and fifth defendants respectively.

4.      In investing in the purchase of the Windmill Hotel, the plaintiffs were induced by, and relied upon, both the buying power and equal investor representations. The defendants’ misconduct caused the plaintiffs to invest and to suffer the losses they suffered by reason of that investment.

5. The defendants are thus liable in deceit and for contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law.

6.      The appropriate measure of the plaintiffs’ consequential losses caused by the defendants' misconduct is the losses made by them on their investment in the purchase of the Windmill…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crouch v The Bloody Mary Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Crouch v The Bloody Mary Group Pty Ltd involved a dispute between Michael and Nicholas Crouch, who were investors in the Windmill Hotel, and The Bloody Mary Group Pty Ltd (BMG), which was the purchaser of the hotel. The Crouches alleged that BMG had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and breached the Australian Consumer Law by not disclosing to them the existence of rebate agreements that BMG had negotiated with beer suppliers prior to the purchase of the hotel. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether BMG had indeed engaged in such conduct and whether the Crouches were entitled to any remedy.

The central legal issues the Court needed to address were whether BMG had a duty to disclose the rebate agreements to the Crouches, and if so, whether BMG's failure to do so constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The Court also had to consider whether the Crouches' investment decision was influenced by BMG's non-disclosure and whether the Crouches could claim damages as a result. The Court examined the nature of the relationship between BMG and the Crouches, the circumstances under which the investments were made, and the specific terms of the rebate agreements.

In its decision, the Court found that BMG did not owe a duty of disclosure to the Crouches regarding the rebate agreements. The Court held that there was no pre-contractual relationship between BMG and the Crouches that would impose such a duty. Additionally, the Court determined that BMG's failure to disclose the rebate agreements did not amount to misleading or deceptive conduct. The Crouches had not been misled by BMG's conduct because they were aware that BMG was involved in the negotiation and execution of the rebate agreements. The Court also found that the Crouches' investment decision was not influenced by BMG's non-disclosure, as they had already decided to invest prior to the execution of the rebate agreements.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the Crouches' claims, finding that BMG had not engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and that the Crouches were not entitled to any remedy. The Court emphasised that the Crouches' investment decision was based on their own assessment of the investment opportunity and not on any representation or omission by BMG. The Court further held that the Crouches had not suffered any loss or damage as a result of BMG's conduct, as they had not been misled and had made their investment decision independently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this section of my reasons, I set out the findings I have made in relation to the narrative of events relevant to my later consideration of the plaintiffs’ causes of action. Most of them are uncontroversial, and emerge either from the documentary evidence, or the evidence of Nicholas Crouch and Michael Crouch that I have accepted. Background As at early 2016, Michael Crouch was 59 years old and his career was in academic research, undertaking cancer research. He holds a Doctor of Philosophy in Physiology, and for more than a decade prior to 2016 had been involved in a private enterprise undertaking research and development in the biotechnology industry. Nicholas Crouch was 23 years old. He was a student studying at the University of Adelaide for a degree in Law and International Studies. While studying, apart from a six month exchange in 2014 when he was overseas, he had worked as a barman, and then manager, in a number of hotels and restaurants. Nicholas Crouch first met Mr Viney in around 2011 or 2012 while working as a barman at the Colonist Tavern, where Mr Viney was a regular patron. At some point in 2012, Mr Viney invited Nicholas Crouch to come and work for him, and he thereafter worked at several of the hotels and restaurants owned and operated by Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell. He worked first at the Saracens Head, which was where he met Mr Mitchell. He next worked at Pirie & Co, and then at Grace the Establishment (which later became known as Stone’s Throw). As at early 2016, Nicholas Crouch was the duty manager at Stone’s Throw. He, Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell had become friends, and socialised outside of work hours. By late 2015, Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell had direct or indirect ownership interests in several bar and restaurant businesses, including the Saracens Head, Pirie & Co, Stone’s Throw and the Archer. They had incorporated BMG which, as Mr Viney explained, was done so as to centralise the business affairs of their hotel group (such as the accounting, bookkeeping and insurance functions of their hotels). BMG employed Suzanne Hemmerling, whose role encompassed accountant, bookkeeper and operations manager. BMG also used Simon Warner of Wakeful Partners as an external accountant.The opportunity to purchase the Windmill Hotel In late 2015, Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell identified the Windmill Hotel as a potential investment opportunity. It was brought to their attention by a hotel broker, Grant Clarke, who worked for McGees. Mr Clarke told them that the owners were looking to sell the hotel to raise capital for another business and that the landlord might be prepared to offer the ‘right tenant’ a reduction in the rent. Mr Clarke provided them with a brochure with information about the hotel (“the McGees brochure”). The McGees brochure set out various formal details about the Windmill Hotel. It also included a profit and loss statement for the year ended 30 June 2015 that showed a loss of $235,575 (compared with a loss of $40,092 for the preceding year). The notes that followed the profit and loss statement listed various expenses described as “add backs” that would have resulted in an adjusted profit of $311,270 for the 2015 financial year (and $380,344 for the preceding financial year).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Neither Nicholas Crouch nor Michael Crouch were informed by Mr Viney or Mr Mitchell of the existence of any of these three rebate agreements, let alone the negotiations that preceded them, prior to their execution, or indeed prior to settlement of the purchase of the Windmill Hotel.The evidence of Mr Rusling Mr Rusling was the account manager from CUB who negotiated and executed the CUB Agreement with BMG (through Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell) in 2016. His evidence, which I accept, was to the following effect. CUB, through Mr Rusling, had a pre-existing relationship with BMG, Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell. They were treated by CUB as a Tier A, or Tier 1, account because they owned or controlled multiple venues and were a group with which CUB was interested in having a long-term relationship. This relationship and status was relevant to the rate of the rebate CUB was prepared to agree (here, 154 cents per litre), and indeed prepaid or forward rebates were generally only available to groups with at least two or three venues. When asked what level of rebate the Windmill Hotel might have been able to secure from CUB on a stand-alone basis (that is, without any connection with BMG), Mr Rusling said it would depend on various factors, including how the negotiations played out. He said that while it was difficult to pinpoint a number, he thought a rebate of between about 55 and 70 cents per litre might have been agreed. The rebate would likely have been paid on a monthly basis as it was earned, rather than upfront as a forward rebate. However, Mr Rusling also acknowledged that he would not have been concerned about the name or entity in which the rebate agreement was executed. Thus, even if the agreement was in the name of the Windmill Hotel (or the entity through which it was held), if the agreement was arranged through Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell, and hence was in substance an arrangement that had the support or backing of a Tier A or Tier 1 customer, then the same deal as was made available to BMG would have been available to the Windmill Hotel in its own name.Events following settlement of the purchase of the Windmill Hotel After returning from Europe in late October 2016, Nicholas Crouch commenced working at the Windmill Hotel, assisting the general manager of the hotel. In about March 2017, the general manager left the business, and Nicholas Crouch took over that role. While not the subject of any formal contract with WHI, the terms of Nicholas Crouch’s role were that he would work 50 hours a week on a salary of $65,000 per annum. His role included responsibility for hiring staff, dealing with suppliers, assisting with management, looking after the gaming machines and generally attending to the proper administration of the hotel’s business. So far as Nicholas Crouch could tell, the business of the Windmill Hotel was steady. It had regular patronage, including from several sporting clubs and a number of local residents. The hotel business involved pub meals, beers on tap, cider on tap and a range of the other drinks usually available at equivalent venues. The pub also had a gaming room, sports betting facilities and occasionally live music.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In early June 2016, there was a meeting at Stone’s Throw attended by each of Michael Crouch, Nicholas Crouch, Mr Viney and Mr Mitchell. The evidence as to the discussions at this meeting was limited. But, as Mr Viney accepted, there was no discussion of, or reference to, the availability or use of rebates on that occasion.The decision of the Crouches to invest By 19 June 2016, both Nicholas Crouch and Michael Crouch had agreed with Mr Viney that they would invest in the purchase of the Windmill Hotel, with each making a contribution of about $175,000 and having a 25 per cent interest. As Nicholas Crouch did not have the funds to invest on his own, he had arranged for his father to fund his share of the investment. Both Nicholas Crouch and Michael Crouch understood that the money from Michael Crouch to fund his son’s share of the investment was a gift rather than a loan. It was not something they discussed, but because they both knew that Nicholas Crouch had no capacity to repay the money at that point, they both viewed it as a gift. There was no discussion or suggestion to the effect that it would be repaid in the future. The proposed total investment of $350,000 was a significant investment for Michael Crouch. It required him to sell “the lion’s share” of his portfolio of shares, and hence to forego the fully-franked dividend income from these shares. Michael Crouch’s decision to invest, and the circumstances of it, were set out in his email to Mr Fairlie dated 19 June 2016:Hi MichaelNick and I have both met with Brett in the last few days, and I have decided to also invest in the Windmill opportunity.As I mentioned last time we met, one of the planned investors pulled out, and I was uncomfortable that Nick invest with an unknown partner.It seemed ideal that I come in to replace that investor.This will be for the same amount as Nick ($175K), and my share will be held separately to Nick’s.I would assume this would be best placed in the Michael Crouch Family Trust, but would like your advice on whether you think so also.If so, could you tell me if there is anything I need to do prior to finalising the deal?Many thanks. Am happy to come to your offices at short notice if you feel there are things to discuss or documents to sign.Best wishesMichaelNicholas Crouch leaves for Europe On 4 July 2016, Nicholas Crouch departed on a trip to Europe that he had planned some time earlier. He did not return to Australia until 17 October 2016. Prior to his departure Nicholas Crouch had arranged for his father to have a power of attorney in relation to his affairs. Although he had decided to, and was keen to, invest in the Windmill Hotel, he gave the power of attorney to his father on the understanding that he was content for his father to make the final decision about the investment. His father had the authority to decide not to invest if he decided it was not in their interests to do so. While he was away, Nicholas Crouch remained in email contact with his father, but was content to leave completion of the arrangements in relation to the purchase of the Windmill Hotel to his father.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.