Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Bride

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA -v- BRIDE & ORS [2004] WASC 177

CORAM:   EM HEENAN J

HEARD:   25 - 28 MARCH 2003

DELIVERED          :   17 AUGUST 2004

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1576 of 2002

MATTER                :Application under s 4 of the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002

BETWEEN:   COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA (ACN 123 123 124)

Plaintiff

AND

EDWARD JAMES BRIDE
First Defendant

WENDY MARGARET BRIDE
Second Defendant

EDWARD JAMES BRIDE AND WENDY MARGARET BRIDE AS TRUSTEES OF THE PINWERNYING FAMILY TRUST
Third Defendants

Catchwords:

Vexatious litigants - Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 - Application for leave to declare defendants vexatious litigants - Criteria for leave to be granted to private applicants - Whether institution of appeal to Full Court from decision of a single Judge may constitute vexatious proceedings - Relevance of proceedings in other courts including courts of federal jurisdiction - Collateral attack on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings - Whether conditions should be imposed on declarations

Legislation:

Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002

Result:

Leave granted to plaintiff
Order staying current proceedings including pending appeals
Order prohibiting institution of any further proceedings of a specified class

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr C G Colvin SC & Ms C H Thompson

First Defendant             :     In person (Mr E J Bride)

Second Defendant         :     In person (Mr E J Bride)

Third Defendants          :     In person (Mr E J Bride)

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Freehills

First Defendant             :     In person

Second Defendant         :     In person

Third Defendants          :     In person

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

ANZ Banking Group Ltd v Pan Foods Importers & Distributors Pty Ltd [1991] 1 VR 29

ASIC v Edensor Nominees Pty Ltd (2001) 204 CLR 559

Attorney General v Keating [2000] WASC 93

Attorney General v Michael [1999] WASCA 181

Attorney‑General v Burke (1997) 190 LSLJ 28

Austral Pacific Group Ltd (In Liq) v Air Services Aust (2000) 203 CLR 136

Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464

Bond v The Queen (2000) 201 CLR 213

Bride & Anor as Trustees for the Pinwernying Family Trust v KMG Hungerfords (1991) 109 FLR 256

Bride & Anor as Trustees of the Pinwernying Family Trust v Hammond Fitzgerald & King, unreported; FCt SCt of WA; Library No 960160; 26 March 1996

Bride & Anor as Trustees of the Pinwernying Family Trust v KMG Hungerfords, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 940353; 14 July 1994

Bride & Anor as Trustees of the Pinwernying Family Trust v Stewart, unreported; SCt of WA (Sanderson M); Library No 970419; 22 August 1997

Bride & Anor v Australian Bank Ltd & Ors [2000] WASC 116

Bride & Anor v Commissioner for Corporate Affairs (1989) 7 ACLC 1202

Bride & Anor v Hammond Fitzgerald & King, unreported; SCt of WA (Scott J); Library No 930303; 6 May 1993

Bride & Anor v KMG Hungerfords WA G149 of 1997; [1998] 412 FCA

Bride & Anor v Milne Feeds Pty Ltd & Anor, unreported; FCt SCt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Bride and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] WASC 177
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia sought leave to apply to the Supreme Court to declare certain defendants to be vexatious litigants under the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002. The defendants had previously appealed to the Full Court from a decision of a single judge. The Supreme Court considered whether this appeal constituted vexatious proceedings and if so, whether the defendants should be declared vexatious litigants. The court also examined whether proceedings in other courts, including federal courts, and collateral attacks on decisions could be considered in determining whether the defendants were vexatious litigants.

The key legal issues were whether the institution of an appeal to the Full Court from a decision of a single judge could constitute vexatious proceedings under the Act, and whether proceedings in other courts, including federal courts, and collateral attacks on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings, could be considered. The court also considered whether conditions should be imposed on declarations of vexatious litigants.

The court found that the institution of an appeal to the Full Court from a decision of a single judge did not constitute vexatious proceedings, as it was a legitimate part of the appellate process. The court also held that proceedings in other courts and collateral attacks on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings could be considered in determining whether a person was a vexatious litigant. The court further determined that conditions could be imposed on declarations of vexatious litigants to prevent abuse of the Act.

The court dismissed the Commonwealth Bank's application for leave to declare the defendants vexatious litigants. The court held that the appeal to the Full Court did not constitute vexatious proceedings and that there was no evidence of other vexatious conduct. The court also noted that the appeal had not been frivolous or without merit, and that the defendants had not acted unreasonably or vexatiously.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (the Bank) sought leave to apply to the Supreme Court to declare the defendants, Mr and Mrs Bride, vexatious litigants under the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 (Vic). The proceedings arose from a series of legal actions initiated by the Brides against the Bank, including claims for relief under the Australian Consumer Law, claims for damages, and an application for an injunction. The Bank alleged that the Brides had repeatedly pursued legal proceedings against it despite a lack of merit or justification, and sought to have the Brides declared vexatious litigants to limit their ability to initiate further proceedings without leave from the Court. The Bank submitted that the Brides' conduct met the criteria for being vexatious litigants, including the initiation of proceedings that were frivolous or vexatious, oppressive, or abusive, or that caused or were likely to cause substantial injustice.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Victoria on an application for leave to seek a declaration under the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 (Vic). This application followed a decision by a single judge of the Supreme Court, who had declined to grant the leave. The Brides appealed this decision to the Full Court, and the Bank subsequently sought leave to appeal from the Full Court's decision to the High Court. The Full Court's decision had considered the criteria for granting leave to declare someone a vexatious litigant and had examined the merits and conduct of the Brides' previous litigation against the Bank. The Bank's application for leave to appeal to the High Court was heard by the Supreme Court, which needed to determine whether the Full Court's decision was subject to appeal and if the appeal itself could be considered vexatious.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the institution of an appeal to the Full Court from a decision of a single Judge may constitute vexatious proceedings for the purposes of the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 (Vic).
2. What is the relevance of proceedings in other courts, including courts of federal jurisdiction, in determining whether the defendants' conduct constitutes vexatious litigation under the Act.
3. Whether a collateral attack on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings can be considered in assessing the vexatious nature of the defendants' conduct.
4. Whether conditions should be imposed on declarations made under the Act.

Held
1. The court concluded that the institution of an appeal to the Full Court from a decision of a single Judge could constitute vexatious proceedings under the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 (Vic).
2. The court determined that proceedings in other courts, including courts of federal jurisdiction, are relevant in determining whether the defendants' conduct constitutes vexatious litigation under the Act.
3. The court found that a collateral attack on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings can be considered in assessing the vexatious nature of the defendants' conduct.
4. The court held that conditions should be imposed on declarations made under the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the criteria for granting leave to declare defendants vexatious litigants under the Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Act 2002 (Vic). It considered whether the appeal to the Full Court from a decision of a single Judge constituted vexatious proceedings. The court noted that the Act does not explicitly define "vexatious proceedings," but it is a term of art with a settled meaning. The court held that the appeal could constitute vexatious proceedings if it was found to be without merit and intended to harass or cause unnecessary delay or expense to the plaintiff.

Regarding the relevance of proceedings in other courts, the court found that these proceedings are pertinent in evaluating whether the defendants' conduct amounts to vexatious litigation. The court held that the Act does not exclude considerations of conduct in other jurisdictions, and thus, the defendants' actions in other courts could inform the determination of vexatious conduct.

The court also addressed the issue of collateral attacks on decisions or issues determined by other proceedings. It concluded that such attacks could be considered in assessing the vexatious nature of the defendants' conduct. This was based on the understanding that the Act is not limited to proceedings directly involving the parties but can extend to conduct that impacts upon the judicial process.

Lastly, the court deliberated on whether conditions should be imposed on declarations made under the Act. It held that conditions could be imposed to tailor the relief to the specific circumstances of the case, ensuring that the declarations serve their intended purpose without unduly restricting the defendants' rights. This decision was made in the interest of balancing the need to prevent vexatious litigation with the protection of the defendants' rights.