Commissioner of Taxation v Starr

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Starr [2007] FCAFC 204

TAXATION – penalty tax – s 224 and s 226L of Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – whether “purpose” for which a scheme is entered into or carried out is to be assessed by reference to the subjective purpose of the parties to the scheme

WORDS AND PHRASES – “purpose”

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 51, 177A, 177D, 222A, 224, 226, 226AA, 226H, 226J, 226L, 227, 260
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4D, 4F

Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 1984 (Cth), Explanatory Memorandum

Vincent v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2002] FCA 656
Vincent v Commissioner of Taxation (2002) 124 FCR 350
News Ltd v South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club Ltd (2003) 215 CLR 563
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Lutovi Investments Pty Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 434
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Students World (Australia) Pty Ltd (1978) 138 CLR 251

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA v DONALD ST CLAIR STARR AND GARY KEVIN HOPKINS
WAD 28 OF 2007

SPENDER, SIOPIS and GILMOUR JJ
21 DECEMBER 2007
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 28 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Appellant

AND:

DONALD ST CLAIR STARR
First Respondent

GARY KEVIN HOPKINS
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

SPENDER, SIOPIS and GILMOUR JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

21 DECEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1The appeal is dismissed.

2No order as to costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 28 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Appellant

AND:

DONALD ST CLAIR STARR
First Respondent

GARY KEVIN HOPKINS
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

SPENDER, SIOPIS and GILMOUR JJ

DATE:

21 DECEMBER 2007

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. In June 1996, each of Mr Starr and Mr Hopkins invested in a cattle breeding project known as the Active Cattle Management Project (ACM Project).  It was operated in Tamworth in New South Wales, and comprised the breeding and managing of stud cattle for third party investors.  The breeding programme involved the creation of cattle embryo by artificial insemination and the transfer of the embryos to recipient cows.  Each investor was required to pay an annual fee in respect of expenses incurred in carrying out the breeding programme.  These expenses included the lease of the recipient cow, embryo costs, agistment costs and management fees.  For the income year 1996, Mr Starr lodged an income tax return in which he claimed a deduction in respect of “primary production losses” of $35,832 arising from his investment in the project.  Mr Hopkins lodged an income tax return for the same period in which he claimed a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Starr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCAFC 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in the case of Commissioner of Taxation v Starr involved the Commissioner of Taxation as the appellant and Starr as the respondent. The central issue before the court was the interpretation of section 226L of the Act, specifically whether the "purpose" for which a tax avoidance scheme was entered into or carried out should be determined based on the actual or subjective intentions of the parties involved, or if it could be attributed to them based on objective criteria. This issue arose from the application of section 226L, which imposes a penalty tax on taxpayers who have a shortfall in their tax obligations due to a tax avoidance scheme, as defined in section 224.

The court was tasked with determining the correct approach to interpreting the term "tax avoidance scheme" as defined in section 224. This required an examination of the language used in sections 226L and 224, including the definition of "scheme" in section 177A. The court needed to decide whether the purpose of the scheme should be assessed based on the actual intentions of the parties or if objective factors could be used to attribute a purpose to them. The court considered whether the subjective intent of the parties or objective criteria should prevail in determining whether a scheme was indeed a tax avoidance scheme under section 224(2). The decision hinged on the precise wording of the statutes and how they should be interpreted in light of established legal principles.

The court concluded that the purpose for which a scheme was entered into or carried out should be determined by reference to objective criteria rather than the actual or subjective purpose of the parties. This interpretation was based on the broad definition of "scheme" in section 177A and the language of section 224(2). The court held that the purpose of the scheme could be attributed to the parties based on observable actions and outcomes, rather than their unexpressed intentions. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and no order was made as to costs. This decision clarified that tax avoidance schemes could be identified based on objective evidence, irrespective of the parties' subjective motivations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1 The appeal is dismissed.

2 No order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The major issue which arises on this appeal is, whether on the proper construction of s 226L, the determination of the “purpose” for which a scheme was “entered into or carried out”, is to be made by reference to the actual or subjective purpose of the parties to the scheme; or whether that purpose can be attributed to the parties on the basis of objective criteria.Statutory background Section 226L of the Act provides:Subject to this Part, if:(a)a taxpayer has a tax shortfall for a year; and(b)the shortfall or part of it was caused by the taxpayer in a taxation statement treating an income tax law as applying in relation to a scheme in a particular way; and(c)the scheme was a tax avoidance scheme within the meaning of subsection 224(1); and(d)none of the scheme sections applies in relation to the scheme;the taxpayer is liable to pay, by way of penalty, additional tax equal to:(e)if, when the statement was made, it was reasonably arguable that the way in which the application of the law was treated was correct – 25% of the amount of the shortfall or part; or(f)in any other case – 50% of the amount of the shortfall or part. There are terms used in s 226L which are defined in s 222A(1) of the Act:“income tax law” means a law under which the extent of liability for income tax is worked out;“scheme section” means sections 224, 225, 226 or 226AA;“tax shortfall”, in relation to a taxpayer and a year, means the amount, if any, by which the taxpayer’s statement tax for that year at the time at which it was lowest is less than the taxpayer’s proper tax for that year;“statement tax”, in relation to a taxpayer, a year and a time, means the tax that would have been payable by the taxpayer in respect of that year if it were assessed at that time on the basis of taxation statements by the taxpayer after allowing the credits claimed by the taxpayer. It was common ground that each of the income tax returns lodged by Mr Starr and Mr Hopkins for the year ended 30 June 1996 comprised the “taxation statement” referred to in s 226L(b), and that the conditions referred to in s 226L(a), (b) and (d) applied in this case. It was only the construction of s 226L(c) that was in issue. That subsection referred to “a tax avoidance scheme” within the meaning of s 224(1) of the Act, which applied the following definition in s 224(2):In subsection (1), “tax avoidance scheme” means a scheme within the meaning of Part IVA that was entered into or carried out for the sole or dominant purpose of enabling a person to pay no tax or less tax. It was also common ground that the reference in s 224(2) to “scheme within the meaning of Part IVA” is a reference to the following definition of scheme in s 177A ‑ the opening interpretation section in Pt IVA:“scheme” means:(a)any agreement, arrangement, understanding, promise or undertaking, whether express or implied and whether or not enforceable, or intended to be enforceable, by legal proceedings; and(b)any scheme, plan, proposal, action, course of action or course of conduct.