Ben Nevis Forestry v Cir

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 43/2007

[2008] NZSC 115

BETWEENBEN NEVIS FORESTRY VENTURES LTD, BRISTOL FORESTRY VENTURES LTD, CLIVE RICHARD BRADBURY, GREENMASS LTD, GREGORY ALAN PEEBLES AND ESTATE OF THE LATE KENNETH JOHN LAIRD


Appellants

ANDCOMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE


Respondent

SC 44/2007

AND BETWEEN             ACCENT MANAGEMENT LTD, LEXINGTON RESOURCES LTD AND REDCLIFFE FORESTRY VENTURES LTD


Appellants

ANDCOMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE


Respondent

Hearing:23 - 27 June 2008

Court:Elias  CJ, Tipping, McGrath, Gault and Anderson JJ

Counsel:C R Carruthers QC, R B Stewart QC and G J Harley for Appellants in SC 43/2007


C T Gudsell QC, M S Hinde and R J Southall for Appellants in SC 44/2007
D J White QC, R J Ellis and J H Coleman for Respondent

Judgment:19 December 2008 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeals are dismissed.

BThe appellants are ordered to pay costs to the respondent (for which the appellants will be jointly and severally liable) of $75,000 together with reasonable disbursements to be fixed if necessary by the Registrar.

REASONS

Para No

Elias CJ and Anderson J  [1]
Tipping, McGrath and Gault JJ  [11]

ELIAS CJ AND ANDERSON J

[1]       We have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons of Tipping, McGrath and Gault JJ.  We agree with their conclusion that the Trinity scheme is a tax avoidance arrangement.  It is void as against the Commissioner for income tax purposes under s BG 1 of the Income Tax Act 1994.[1]  The Commissioner was therefore entitled to counteract the tax advantage obtained by the appellants even when they were not parties to the arrangement entered into by their loss attributing qualifying companies.  They are “persons affected by that arrangement” within the meaning of s GB 1 of the Income Tax Act.[2]  We also agree that in acting on the arrangements the taxpayers have adopted an abusive tax position within the meaning of s 141D of the Tax Administration Act 1994.  It follows that the penalties provided by that Act, as adjusted where applicable by s 141FC to prevent doubling up of the penalties through their application to both the investors and their loss attributing qualifying companies, properly attach to the taxpayer appellants.

[1]Section BG 1(1) makes a “tax avoidance arrangement” void as against the Commissioner for income tax purposes.  The definitions contained in s OB 1 must be read with it.   They define “arrangement” as “any contract, agreement, plan or understanding (whether enforceable or unenforceable), including all steps and transactions by which it is carried into effect”.  “Tax avoidance” is defined as including “directly or indirectly altering the incidence of any income tax”, “directly or indirectly relieving any person from liability to pay income tax” and “directly or indirectly avoiding, reducing or postponing any liability to income tax”.  “Tax avoidance arrangement” is defined as one:

whether entered into by the person affected by the arrangement or by another person, that directly or indirectly -

(a)     Has tax avoidance as its purpose or effect; or

(b)    Has tax avoidance as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ben Nevis Forestry v Cir and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZSC 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New Zealand heard appeals from nine appellants, who were investors or loss attributing qualifying companies (LAQCs) of investors in a syndicate involved in the development of a Douglas Fir forest project known as the Trinity scheme. The central issue was whether the arrangements entered into by the syndicate, including the payment of a licence premium and insurance premiums, constituted tax avoidance and, if so, whether the deductions claimed for these expenses were allowable under the specific provisions of the Income Tax Act 1994. The Court was also required to decide whether the Commissioner of Inland Revenue correctly imposed civil penalties for taking an abusive tax position. The Court held that the Trinity scheme was a tax avoidance arrangement void under the general anti-avoidance provision. The deductions claimed for the licence premium and insurance premiums were not allowable because they were part of a wider tax avoidance arrangement. The Court also concluded that the appellants had taken an abusive tax position, resulting in a tax shortfall, and were liable for penalties. The appeals were dismissed, with the appellants ordered to pay costs to the Commissioner of Inland Revenue.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a tax avoidance scheme known as the Trinity scheme, which was established to develop a Douglas Fir forest in Southland, New Zealand. The scheme was structured such that investors did not acquire ownership of the land or the trees but instead paid various premiums and fees to a syndicate. The syndicate, in turn, paid premiums to an insurance company and was responsible for establishing, managing, and harvesting the forest. The scheme included a licence fee for the use of the land and insurance premiums to cover the risk that the forest would not yield a specified return. The investors claimed deductions for these expenses in their tax returns. The Commissioner of Inland Revenue determined that the scheme constituted a tax avoidance arrangement and imposed penalties on the appellants for taking an abusive tax position.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New Zealand as an appeal from decisions of the High Court and the Court of Appeal. The appellants, who were investors or loss attributing qualifying companies (LAQCs) in the Trinity scheme, challenged the Commissioner's assessment and the imposition of penalties. The Court of Appeal upheld the Commissioner's decision, and the appellants sought further review by the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Commissioner was entitled to counteract the tax advantage obtained by the appellants under the general anti-avoidance provision in the Income Tax Act 1994.
2. Whether the licence premium and insurance premiums claimed by the appellants were deductible under the specific provisions of the Income Tax Act.
3. Whether the insurance premiums claimed by the appellants had to be spread over the period from 1997 to 2047 as accrual expenditure.
4. Whether the appellants took an abusive tax position resulting in a tax shortfall, warranting the imposition of penalties under the Tax Administration Act 1994.

Held
1. The Commissioner was entitled to counteract the tax advantage obtained by the appellants under the general anti-avoidance provision in the Income Tax Act 1994.
2. The licence premium and insurance premiums claimed by the appellants were not deductible under the specific provisions of the Income Tax Act.
3. The insurance premiums claimed by the appellants did not have to be spread over the period from 1997 to 2047 as accrual expenditure.
4. The appellants took an abusive tax position resulting in a tax shortfall, warranting the imposition of penalties under the Tax Administration Act 1994.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court held that the Trinity scheme, including the licence fee component and the insurance premium, constituted tax avoidance and was void as against the Commissioner under section BG 1 of the Income Tax Act 1994. The Court agreed with the Court of Appeal that the scheme had the purpose or effect of altering the incidence of tax, and thus was a tax avoidance arrangement. The specific tax provisions and the general anti-avoidance provision were not in potential conflict and should be purposively and contextually interpreted. The specific tax provisions did not immunise all arrangements involving their use against being categorised as tax avoidance arrangements. The Court found that the licence premium and insurance premiums did not fall within the scope of the relevant specific statutory provisions, properly construed. The general anti-avoidance provision was concerned with arrangements having the purpose or effect of altering the incidence of tax. The insurance premiums were not accrual expenditure and did not need to be spread over the period from 1997 to 2047. The appellants had taken an abusive tax position resulting in a tax shortfall, warranting the imposition of penalties under the Tax Administration Act 1994. The appellants' tax position involved an unacceptable interpretation of a tax law and was taken with a dominant purpose of avoiding tax. The Court rejected the appellants' arguments that their tax position met the standard of being "about as likely as not to be correct" and that the penalty provisions were not applicable to their situation.