Commissioner of Taxation v Rowntree

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Commissioner of Taxation v Rowntree [2020] FCA 1322  

File number: NSD 655 of 2014
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 18 September 2020
Catchwords: TAXATION – Whether each respondent engaged in conduct that resulted in him or another entity being a promoter of a tax exploitation scheme in each of 4 tax years in contravention of s 290-50(1) of Sch 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – where scheme involved investor paying 15% non-refundable deposit for not presently existing carbon or REDD credits that vendor had no existing source for or obligation to supply in the future – where investor under scheme claimed tax deduction of full price in year of entry into purchase contract – whether each respondent promoter of tax exploitation scheme within meaning of ss 290-60(1) and 290-65 – whether entity had substantial role in respect of marketing or promotion of tax exploitation scheme within meaning of s 290-60(1)(c) – whether investor’s sole or dominant purpose for entering into scheme was to get a scheme benefit that was not reasonably arguably available at law within meaning of ss 284-15, 284-150 and 290-65 – whether schemes involved tax evasion within meaning of s 290-55(6) so that 4 year limitation period did not apply
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 50, 140

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) Pt IVA, ss 170, 177D, 177F, 318, 82KZL, 82KZM, 82KZMA

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth), ss 8-1, 960-100, 995-1

Partnership Act 1892 (NSW) s 50A

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Sch 1, ss 284-15, 284-150, 290-50, 290-55, 290-60, 290-65

Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme Bill 2009

Explanatory Memorandum for the Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme Bill 2009 [No 2]

Oxford English Dictionary, online

Macquarie Dictionary, online

Adjunct Professor Gordon S. Cooper AM: “Promoter Penalties” (2006) 4 Journal of Tax Research 117

Diplock K, “The Courts as Legislators” in B Harvey (ed), The Lawyer and Justice (Sweet & Maxwell, 1978)

Cases cited:

Academy Cleaning & Security Pty Limited  v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2017) 106 ATR 184

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar (2012) 247 CLR 345

Chamberlain v The Queen (No 2) (1984) 153 CLR 521

Commissioner of Taxation v Bogiatto [2020] FCA 1139

Denver Chemical Manufacturing Co v Commission of Taxation (NSW) (1949) 79 CLR 296

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hart (2004) 217 CLR 216

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v James Flood Pty Ltd (1953) 88 CLR 492

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Ludekens (2013) 214 FCR 149

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404

GlenfieldEstates Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 80 ALR 671

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Kajewski v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 52 ATR 455

Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361

MagnaAlloys and Research Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1980) 49 FLR 183

New Zealand Flax Investments Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1938) 61 CLR 179

Pridecraft…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Rowntree and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1322
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Commissioner of Taxation brought proceedings against Dr Rowntree, Mr Donkin, and Mr Manietta, alleging that each had engaged in conduct that resulted in them or another entity being a promoter of a tax exploitation scheme in each of the 2009, 2010, 2011, and 2012 tax years, in contravention of s 290-50(1) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). The court had to determine whether each respondent engaged in conduct that resulted in them or another entity being a promoter of a tax exploitation scheme, and whether each scheme involved tax evasion within the meaning of s 290-55(6) of the same Act, so that the 4-year limitation period did not apply.

The court found that the schemes involved the purchase of carbon or REDD credits that did not exist at the time of the purchase, and that the investors claimed tax deductions for the full price of the credits in the year of entry into the purchase contract. The court held that each respondent had a substantial role in marketing or promoting the tax exploitation scheme, and that the investors' sole or dominant purpose for entering into the scheme was to obtain a tax benefit that was not reasonably arguably available at law. The court also found that the schemes involved tax evasion, as the Commissioner did not bring the proceeding within the four-year period provided in s 290-55(4) of the Act. Therefore, the limitation period did not apply, and each respondent could be liable for a civil penalty under s 290-50 of the Act as a promoter of the tax exploitation scheme.

The court ordered that the proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on 16 October 2020, and that the parties file and serve their outlines of evidence of the lay witnesses and their experts' affidavits by a specified date. The court also ordered that the Commissioner serve his evidence and an amended statement of claim on Mr Manietta's trustee in bankruptcy and him at his residential address as recorded in the Commonwealth electoral roll. The court made findings of fact that affected Mr Manietta on the basis that it was satisfied of those facts on the balance of probabilities, having regard to the matters specified in s 140 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

2. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on 16 October 2020.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Introduction

[1]

The legislative context

[6]

Background

[10]

The contractual structure, context and implementation of the schemes

[19]

The 2009 tax year

[22]

The 2009 scheme documents

[33]

The 2009 year – summary

[38]

The 2010, 2011 and 2012 scheme documents

[45]

Contracts for the supply of carbon credits

[50]

The expert evidence about the schemes

[57]

The 2010 tax year

[72]

Dr Robson’s 2010 tax year investment

[98]

The 2010 tax year – summary

[106]

The 2011 tax year

[117]

Dr Robson amends his tax returns

[124]

Mr Haralambidis decides to purchase the 2011 ERPAs

[134]

Mr Whitney decides to purchase the 2011 ERPAs

[140]

Other events in June 2011

[159]

The 2011 tax year – summary

[166]

The 2012 tax year

[173]

The 2012 tax year – summary

[204]

Later events

[211]

Summary of total receipts in the 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012 tax years

[230]

The conduct issue

[232]

Dr Rowntree’s conduct

[232]

Dr Donkin’s conduct

[246]

Was Mr Donkin a promoter in the 2011 and 2012 tax years? – Consideration

[268]

Mr Manietta’s conduct

[274]

The tax exploitation issue

[285]

Dr Rowntree’s and Mr Donkin’s submissions

[287]

Was each of the 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012 schemes a tax exploitation scheme?

[301]

Was the claim for a deduction in each tax year “reasonably arguable”?

[336]

Conclusion

[352]

The evasion issue

[353]

Conclusion

[367]

Background

Background to the litigation

Thus, the issue is whether, at the time of the marketing or encouraging, it may reasonably be concluded that one entity entered into or carried out the scheme with the sole or dominant purpose that that entity or another entity (who or which is not relevantly a promoter but can be an investor in the scheme) would get a tax benefit. Background Dr Rowntree holds a doctorate of juridical science, wrote his thesis in international taxation, and holds degrees of bachelor of laws and master of taxation as well as a diploma of financial planning. His associates within the meaning of s 318(2)(f) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (ITAA 1936) in the schemes were a Malaysian corporation, Voluntary Credits Ltd (which was called BR Redd Ltd prior to 17 January 2010), Voluntary Credits Pty Ltd (VCPL), Bonnell Rowntree Pty Ltd (BRPL) and Bonnell Rowntree Taxation Advisers Pty Ltd (BRTAPL). By force of s 318(2)(f) of the ITAA 1936, each of those entities was an associate of each of the others. Dr Rowntree’s colleague in the latter two law practices was David Bonnell. Mr Donkin’s accounting practice entity, Strategic Accounting Advisers Pty Ltd, as trustee of the Strategic Accounting Advisers Trust, was his associate. Both Dr Rowntree and Mr Manietta are undischarged bankrupts. On 27 October 2014, Mr Manietta’s solicitor filed a notice of acting in this proceeding. On 8 May 2017, Mr Manietta’s debtor’s petition was accepted and he became bankrupt. On 17 November 2017, I ordered that the Commissioner serve outlines of evidence of the lay witnesses and his expert’s affidavit by 29 March 2018, the respondents file and serve their defences by 27 April 2018 and that service on Mr Manietta be effected by serving his trustee in bankruptcy and him at his residential address as recorded as at 17 November 2017 in the Commonwealth electoral roll. The last order was in anticipation of Mr Manietta’s solicitor filing (as he did on 28 November 2017) a notice of ceasing to act. The Commissioner attempted to serve his evidence and an amended statement of claim on Mr Manietta at the apartment recorded on his electoral roll address in Paddington, a suburb of Sydney, on 29 March 2018, but was unsuccessful in obtaining access to the property. The Commissioner served Mr Manietta’s trustee with that evidence on that day and subsequently, the Commissioner’s solicitors have sent emails to both Mr Manietta and his trustee, although only the trustee responded to acknowledge receipt. On 16 July 2018, my associate emailed the parties, including Mr Manietta with the entered orders I had made at a case management hearing on 6 July 2018 which included the order fixing the hearing to commence on 8 April 2019. Mr Manietta did not appear at the hearing, including after being called outside the courtroom at the beginning of the trial. In those circumstances, Mr Manietta has not filed any defence and I have made the findings of fact that affect him on the basis (as with all my other findings of fact) that I am satisfied of those facts on the balance of probabilities, having regard to the matters specified in s 140 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Thus, if Carbon Strategic were able to get either of the two proposed projects to the point where it could trade carbon credits, it could have been in a position to sell those carbon credits to BR Redd / Voluntary Credits. But, there was no evidence of any contract for this to occur at all, let alone within a timeframe to enable Voluntary Credits to be in a position to serve a delivery notice on an investor under the 2009 or any later ERPA.The expert evidence about the schemes Robert Fowler gave expert evidence for the Commissioner. He was highly experienced in carbon markets and their commercial operation. He began working in the carbon and greenhouse gas industry in 2002 and was a member of committees of Standards Australia during most of the period between 2003 and 2010. He worked as a methodology expert for bodies within the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change during 2004 to 2009, including on a registration and issuance, accreditation, appraisals and reviews of projects. He also worked as an international carbon broker acting on transactions during 2006 to 2008 that covered approximately 100 million tonnes of emissions reductions under various forms of ERPAs. He advised the Australian Government’s National Greenhouse & Energy Reporting System during 2008 to 2009 on developing best practices for regulatory and compliance frameworks. He led the preparation of a report for the Australian Government in 2008 on the international carbon markets, including the development of consensus volume and price forecasts, market drivers and modelling of supply and demand in the Clean Development Mechanism. He also did work during 2010 to 2012 for the Latin American Development Bank, Morgan Stanley Australia, the Australian and Japanese Governments and the Verified Carbon Standard Committee on streamlined approaches for setting baselines and assessing additionality. He was the representative for Australia and New Zealand to the International Emissions Trading Association during 2011 to 2014. I found Mr Fowler to be a cogent and reliable witness. Mr Fowler reviewed each of the ERPAs and options that Smart Dental had entered in each of the 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012 tax years. He noted, correctly, that the 2009 ERPA and 2009 option contained several typographical errors. Mr Fowler explained that they were not documents of the sophistication, detail or clarity that professional traders in those markets at the time would have regarded as usual and necessary. While some of the minor errors were corrected in the corresponding ERPAs and options for the 2010, 2011 and 2012 tax years, the substantive deficiencies or problems in the documentation remained throughout. For example, the 2010, 2011 and 2012 ERPAs provided that on completion, the investor would pay the second instalment in exchange for Voluntary Credits’ promise after the funds cleared to post (from Malaysia) documentation enabling the investor to be “in effective possession and control” of the contract lot(s) acquired.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I am satisfied that it was not reasonably arguable that the tax benefit would be available at law. That is because, even if I were wrong in my findings that no part of the deposit or purchase price was deductible under s 8-1 of the ITAA 1997, the Commissioner would have exercised his power under s 177F(1)(b) of the ITAA 1936 not to allow any part of a deduction claimed in respect of any payment to enter into any of the ERPAs.Conclusion For these reasons, I am satisfied that each of the schemes was a tax exploitation scheme. The evasion issue Dr Rowntree and Mr Manietta can only be liable to a civil penalty under s 290-50 in Sch 1 of the TAA as a promoter of the 2009 scheme if it involved tax evasion within the meaning of s 290-50: see too Bogiatto [2020] FCA 1139 at [79]–[82]. That is because the Commissioner did not bring this proceeding within the four year period provided in s 290-55(4). Relevantly, s 290-55(4) and (6) in Sch 1 of the TAA provided:Time limitation(4) The Commissioner must not make an application under section 290-50 in relation to an entity's involvement in a *tax exploitation scheme more than 4 years after the entity last engaged in conduct that resulted in the entity or another entity being a *promoter of the tax exploitation scheme.…(6) However, the limitation in subsection (4) or (5) does not apply to a *scheme involving tax evasion. The expression “tax evasion” is not defined. The object of Div 290 in s 290-(5)(a) is “to deter the promotion of tax avoidance schemes and tax evasion schemes”. The Parliament intended to distinguish between avoidance and evasion of tax. Item 5 of s 170(1) of the ITAA 1936 confers an exceptional power on the Commissioner to amend a notice of assessment at any time if he is “of the opinion that there has been fraud or evasion”. In Denver Chemical Manufacturing Co v Commission of Taxation (NSW) (1949) 79 CLR 296 at 313 Dixon J (with whose reasoning McTiernan and Webb JJ agreed; and see too per Williams J at 317-318) said that “evasion”:means more than avoid and also more than a mere withholding of information or the mere furnishing of misleading information. It is probably safe to say that some blameworthy act or omission on the part of the taxpayer or those for whom he is responsible is contemplated. An intention to withhold information lest the commissioner should consider the taxpayer liable to a greater extent than the taxpayer is prepared to concede, is conduct which if the result is to avoid tax would justify finding evasion.In the present case the Board concluded that the appellant intentionally omitted the income from the return and that there was no credible explanation before them why he did so. They thought that the conduct of the taxpayer answered the description of an avoidance of tax by evasion.(emphasis added) In Bogiatto [2020] FCA 1139 at [80], Thawley J cited what Gleeson CJ (with whom Sully and Bruce JJ agreed) in R v Meares (1997) 37 ATR 321 at 323 to emphasise the distinction between tax avoidance and tax evasion. Gleeson CJ said there:Although on occasion, it suits people for argumentative purposes, to blur the difference, or pretend that there is no difference, between tax avoidance and tax evasion, the difference between the two is simple and clear. Tax avoidance involves using, or attempting to use, lawful means to reduce tax obligations. Tax evasion involves using unlawful means to escape payment of tax. Tax avoidance is lawful and tax evasion is unlawful. Although some people may feel entitled to disregard that difference, no lawyer can treat it as unimportant or irrelevant. It is sometimes said that the difference is difficult to recognise in practice. I would suggest that in most cases there is a simple test that can be applied. If the parties to a scheme believe that its possibility of success is entirely dependent upon the authorities never finding out the true facts, it is likely to be a scheme of tax evasion, not tax avoidance.(emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Rowntree responded to Mr Le later on 26 June 2009 saying that he had read Mr Wenderoth’s concerns and did not think that there was any point in calling him. The Flowers Group appears to have comprised, at least, based on the sources of funds identified in the s 50 summary of documents relating to consideration received by the respondents and their associates (the consideration summary) Flowers Accounting Solutions Pty Ltd, Flowers Financial Management Pty Ltd, Flowers Financial Group Pty Ltd and SVPMA Pty Ltd. Dr Rowntree wrote that Mr Wenderoth could wait until the final version was “settled by our barristers in July/August”. Next, on 24 August 2009, Paul Miller of Deutsch Miller, solicitors, emailed Dr Rowntree and Mr Bonnell with drafts of, among others, a revised version of the 2009 ERPA. Mr Miller pointed out that the draft ERPA did:not specify which Projects need to be completed before BR Redd is obliged to send to the Buyer a Delivery Notice. This clause acts as a condition precedent to the Buyer receiving a Delivery Notice, which is out of its control. Please consider being more specific in relation to which Projects need to be completed as I am concerned that this clause could make the agreement void for uncertainty.(emphasis added) Despite, or perhaps because of, Mr Miller’s warning, the 2010, 2011 and 2012 ERPAs had no reference to any projects by reference to which Voluntary Credits (or as it was called in 2009, BR Redd) could serve a delivery notice on the purchaser. Next, on 25 August 2009, Mr Manietta (on Ti Amo Strategies letterhead) wrote to an investor, The Mark Colin Co Pty Ltd, which had purchased two contract lots in the 2009 year, advising it that the “Green Frog” carbon credit logo was now available. He advised his client that by September 2009, the BR Redd website would have a downloadable marketing and media pack including a draft press release and a suggested tendering clause. This was similar to Dr Rowntree’s 9 July 2009 letter to Dr Robson (see [31] above). In August 2009, Dr Rowntree and Mr Bonnell participated in a workshop with IMPACT Communications Australia Pty Ltd to develop key messages for a media campaign to be conducted on behalf of BR Redd up to 31 January 2010. The campaign was to promote BR Redd in the lead up to the United Nations Climate Summit that was to take place in Copenhagen between 6 to 18 December 2009. In a letter to Dr Rowntree dated 1 September 2009, IMPACT set out the activities that it would undertake in that campaign for a fee of $58,075. These activities included media training for Dr Rowntree and Mr Bonnell, the preparation of drafts of a “green kit” for clients, a media kit, interviews with Mr Flood (of Carbon Strategic, a media release, pitch/case studies and a poll to survey clients as well as weekly and monthly reporting. IMPACT prepared a key messages report soon after its engagement that referred to the “Voluntary Credits Pty Ltd Communications Campaign” (even though BR Redd only changed its name on 17 January 2010). The key messages report identified that the initial “direct targets” of the campaign were “owners and managers of small to medium enterprises”. The campaign would focus on Voluntary Credits’ market for carbon credits and “enable [it] to utilise media coverage gained to generate more business, test the media’s reaction to the REDD market and build the confidence of David Bonnell and Bruce Rowntree as media spokespeople” (emphasis added). The key messages report stated:Key MessagesA 'key message' is a claim supported by a fact or example. The key messages below were developed during a workshop between IMPACT and Voluntary Credits Pty Ltd (Bruce Rowntree and David Bonnell) in August 2009. They are divided into two categories; company/ Voluntary Credits Pty Ltd messages and general REDD messages. Spokespeople should use key messages appropriate to the media wherever possible.Note, all media materials should refer to Voluntary Credits Pty Ltd as a distinct business that sits separately from the parent company, BR Advisers. This will allow spokespeople to distance themselves from the 'tax reduction' component of the REDD product.(emphasis in original)