Commissioner of Taxation v Bogiatto

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Bogiatto [2020] FCA 1139

File number: NSD 1839 of 2018
Judge: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 7 August 2020
Catchwords: TAXATION – whether respondents engaged in conduct that resulted in them or another entity being a promoter of tax exploitation schemes in breach of s 290-50(1) of Sch 1 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – where over 20 alleged tax exploitation schemes involving 14 taxpayers – where taxpayers made research and development claims under Div 355 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) – whether respondents were promoters within the meaning of s 290-60(1) of Sch1 – whether there were tax exploitation schemes within the meaning of s 290-65(1) of Sch 1 – whether respondents received scheme benefits within the meaning of s 284-150(1) of Sch 1 – meaning of tax evasion in s 290-55(6) of Sch 1 – contraventions of s 290-50(1) of Sch 1 established in respect of schemes involving 13 taxpayers – applications regarding some contraventions statute barred
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 222C, 226K, 262A, 318

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 355-5, 355-25, 355-30, 355-35, 355-100, 355-705, 960-100, 995-1

Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) ss 27A, 27B, 27D, 27J, 28C

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 3AA, Sch 1 ss 255-1, 284-15, 284-150, 290-5, 290-50, 290-55, 290-60, 290-65

Tax Laws Amendment (Improvements to Self Assessment) Act (No. 1) 2005 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.34, 10.42, 10.43, 10.44, 10.49

Tax Laws Amendment (2005 Measure No. 6) Bill 2005 (Cth)

Tax Laws Amendment (2006 Measures No. 1) Bill 2006 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Allen v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2011) 195 FCR 416

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Maritime Union of Australia (2001) 114 FCR 472

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yellow Page Marketing BV [2010] FCA 1218

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Axis International Management Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1605

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Cameron Brae Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 161 FCR 468

Commercial Union Assurance Co of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Commissioner of Taxation v Arnold (No 2) (2015) 100 ATR 529

Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd (2012) 250 CLR 503

Commissioner of Taxation v Ludekens (2013) 92 ATR 301

Commissioner of Taxation v Ludekens (2013) 214 FCR 149

Denver Chemical Manufacturing Co v Commissioner of Taxation (NSW) (1949) 79 CLR 296

El-Kazzi v Kassoum [2009] NSWSC 99

Moreton Resources Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia (2019) 271 FCR 211

Pethybridge v Stedikas Holdings Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 154

R v Meares (1997) 37 ATR 321

Re Ozone Manufacturing Pty Ltd and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2013) 97 ATR 50

Ryledar Pty Ltd v Euphoric Pty Ltd (2007) 69 NSWLR 603

Walstern Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 138 FCR 1

Date of…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Bogiatto and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was a proceeding by the Commissioner of Taxation against Mr Bogiatto, Ryusei, Lambdachase Advisors and Lambdachase Services for contraventions of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) in relation to tax exploitation schemes. The court had to determine whether the respondents were promoters of tax exploitation schemes, whether the schemes constituted tax exploitation schemes, and whether the respondents received scheme benefits. The court also had to consider the meaning of tax evasion in the context of the relevant provisions.

The court found that the Commissioner had established contraventions in respect of thirteen of the fourteen taxpayers involved in the tax exploitation schemes. The court held that the respondents were promoters of tax exploitation schemes as they engaged in conduct that resulted in them or another entity being a promoter. The court also found that the schemes constituted tax exploitation schemes as they involved tax evasion. The court held that the respondents received scheme benefits as they received consideration for their services in facilitating the tax exploitation schemes. The court rejected the argument that receipt of consideration could not be conduct within the meaning of the relevant provisions.

The court held that the Commissioner had established the contraventions on the balance of probabilities. The court considered the nature of the cause of action, the nature of the subject-matter of the proceeding, and the gravity of the matters alleged in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The court found that the evidence established the contraventions to the required standard.

The court made orders that the applicant file within 14 days short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons for judgment and that the proceeding be listed for a case management hearing at 9 am on 27 August 2020. The court did not make any orders regarding the statute-barred applications concerning some of the contraventions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant file within 14 days short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons for judgment.

2. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing at 9 am on 27 August 2020.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Court is satisfied that the Commissioner has established various contraventions on the part of Mr Bogiatto, Ryusei, Lambdachase Advisors and Lambdachase Services with respect to tax exploitation schemes concerning thirteen of the fourteen taxpayers. Applications concerning some of the contraventions are statute barred.B FACTUAL BACKGROUND Mr Bogiatto was a director and shareholder of Ryusei and Lambdachase Advisors. Ryusei was incorporated in New South Wales on 19 October 2004. Lambdachase Advisors was incorporated in New South Wales on 17 January 2014. Ryusei traded as Lambda Chase Chartered Accountants and, on occasion, as “Hill & Bogiatto” or “Hill + Bogiatto”. Lambdachase Advisors also used the name “Lambda Chase Chartered Accountants” in some of its communications. Mr Bogiatto was also the sole director, secretary and shareholder of Lambdachase Services which was incorporated in New South Wales on 18 April 2013. Mr Bogiatto was the officer or employee with final responsibility for, and control over the work undertaken by, Ryusei, Lambdachase Advisors and Lambdachase Services. The conduct in relation to each of the alleged tax exploitation schemes is addressed in detail in Section F below. However, it is convenient to summarise now that it generally involved Mr Bogiatto or entities he controlled engaging in the following conduct:(1)The taxpayer would be contacted by telephone, either by Mr Bogiatto directly or by another person, for the purpose of arranging a meeting with Mr Bogiatto.(2)Mr Bogiatto would attend the prospective client’s premises, promoting himself as an R&D specialist, with considerable experience and expertise in assisting taxpayers with making R&D claims. Mr Bogiatto would discuss the possibility of the prospective client benefiting from R&D incentives, ask some questions about the operations of the business, advise that the taxpayer had a strong case for obtaining R&D incentives, and represent that he could assist.(3)Mr Bogiatto would send a letter of engagement, headed “Terms of Engagement”, to the prospective client. The “Terms of Engagement” provided for a fee calculated as a percentage of any R&D tax offset that the client might obtain, typically 30%.(4)Mr Bogiatto would then ask the client to send information about the operations and finances of the business, which he would use to prepare an “R&D Tax Incentive Application” for submitting to AusIndustry for registration of the entity’s R&D activities.(5)Once registration with AusIndustry was confirmed, Mr Bogiatto would inform the client of this outcome, and prepare an “R&D Tax Incentive Schedule” containing figures that Mr Bogiatto instructed or advised the client to incorporate in its tax return or, if the client had already lodged a tax return for a given year, an amended tax return.(6)By one of his companies, Mr Bogiatto would then send an invoice to the client, and pursue payment. During this process, if a client questioned Mr Bogiatto’s calculations or asked for an explanation as to how the figures produced by Mr Bogiatto were derived, Mr Bogiatto would typically respond by asserting that he would not disclose his methodology because it was his intellectual property, asserting that he was the expert, and stating that the client should not question him. On occasion, he would provide some reason to reassure the client that the figures had a sound basis.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 290-50(1) is a civil penalty provision. The Commissioner bears the onus of proof. In a civil proceeding, the court must find the case of a party proved if it is satisfied that the case has been proved on the balance of probabilities: s 140(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Section 140(2) of the Evidence Act then provides: Without limiting the matters that the court may take into account in deciding whether it is so satisfied, it is to take into account:(a) the nature of the cause of action or defence; and(b) the nature of the subject-matter of the proceeding; and(c) the gravity of the matters alleged. Section 140(2) applies according to its terms. Nevertheless, it is appropriate to observe that s 140(2)(c) reflects the common law position that the more serious the allegation, the less likely it might be expected, all other things being equal, that a respondent would have committed the relevant act: Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. D STATUTORY FRAMEWORK – RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT Division 355 of the ITAA 1997 entitles an eligible entity to a tax offset for eligible R&D expenditure. The object of Div 355 is set out in s 355-5:355-5 Object(1)The object of this Division is to encourage industry to conduct research and development activities that might otherwise not be conducted because of an uncertain return from the activities, in cases where the knowledge gained is likely to benefit the wider Australian economy.(2)This object is to be achieved by providing a tax incentive for industry to conduct, in a scientific way, experimental activities for the purpose of generating new knowledge or information in either a general or applied form (including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services). To be entitled to the tax offset, the entity needs to be eligible for one or more “notional” deductions identified in Div 355: s 355-100. The entity must be an R&D entity: s 355-100. Relevantly for present purposes, the definition of an R&D entity includes body corporates incorporated under an Australian law: s 355-35. The entity must be registered for R&D activities under Part III of the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) (IRD Act). Only R&D entities can register for R&D activities and claim the R&D tax offset. R&D activities include both “core R&D activities” and “supporting R&D activities”. Section 355-25 of the ITAA 1997 defines “core R&D activities”: 355-25 Core R&D activities (1) Core R&D activities are experimental activities: (a)whose outcome cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information or experience, but can only be determined by applying a systematic progression of work that: (i)is based on principles of established science; and (ii)proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation, and leads to logical conclusions; and (b)that are conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge (including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services).(2) However, none of the following activities are core R&D activities:(a)market research, market testing or market development, or sales promotion (including consumer surveys);(b)prospecting, exploring or drilling for minerals or *petroleum for the purposes of one or more of the following:(i) discovering deposits;(ii) determining more precisely the location of deposits;(iii) determining the size or quality of deposits;(c)management studies or efficiency surveys;(d)research in social sciences, arts or humanities;(e)commercial, legal and administrative aspects of patenting, licensing or other activities;(f)activities associated with complying with statutory requirements or standards, including one or more of the following:(i)maintaining national standards;(ii)calibrating secondary standards;(iii)routine testing and analysis of materials, components, products, processes, soils, atmospheres and other things;(g)any activity related to the reproduction of a commercial product or process:(i)by a physical examination of an existing system; or(ii)from plans, blueprints, detailed specifications or publically available information;(h)developing, modifying or customising computer software for the dominant purpose of use by any of the following entities for their internal administration (including the internal administration of their business functions):(i)the entity (the developer) for which the software is developed, modified or customised;(ii)an entity *connected with the developer;(iii)an *affiliate of the developer, or an entity of which the developer is an affiliate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner did not point to any conduct or “involvement” (see s 290-55(4)) on the part of Lambdachase Advisors, within four years of commencement of the relevant proceeding, which resulted in it or another entity being a promoter. Accordingly, in so far as the proceeding concerned Lambdachase Advisors’ involvement in the 2013 tax exploitation scheme, the proceeding is statute barred. As mentioned earlier, that scheme was not one involving evasion.I CONCLUSION The Commissioner is directed to bring in short minutes of order to give effect to these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The reference to Walstern (said in Allen to be more strict than the test in Cameron Brae) is a reference to what Hill J had said in Walstern Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 138 FCR 1 at [108] in relation to former s 226K of the ITAA 1936:1.The test to be applied is objective, not subjective. This is clear from the use of the words “it would be concluded” in para (1)(b) of the section;2.The decision-maker considering the penalty must first determine what the argument is which supports the taxpayer’s claim;3.That person will already have formed the view that the claim is wrong, otherwise the issue of penalty could not have arisen. Hence the decision-maker at this point will need to compare the taxpayer’s argument with the argument which is considered to be the correct argument;4.The decision maker must then determine whether the taxpayer’s argument, although considered wrong, is about as likely as not correct, when regard is had to “the authorities”;5.It is not necessary that the decision-maker form the view that the taxpayer’s argument in an objective sense is more likely to be right than wrong. That this is so follows from the fact that tax has already been short paid, that is to say the premise against which the question is raised for decision is that the taxpayer’s argument has already been found to be wrong. Nor can it be necessary that the decision-maker form the view that it is just as likely that the taxpayer’s argument is correct as the argument which the decision-maker considers to be the correct argument for the decision-maker has already formed the view that the taxpayer’s argument is wrong. The standard is not as high as that. The word “about” indicates the need for balancing the two arguments, with the consequence that there must be room for it to be argued which of the two positions is correct so that on balance the taxpayer’s argument can objectively be said to be one that while wrong could be argued on rational grounds to be right;6.An argument could not be as likely as not correct if there is a failure on the part of the taxpayer to take reasonable care. Hence the argument must clearly be one where, in making it, the taxpayer has exercised reasonable care. However, mere reasonable care will not be enough for the argument of the taxpayer must be such as, objectively, to be “about as likely as not correct” when regard is to be had to the material constituting “the authorities”; and7.Subject to what has been said the view advanced by the taxpayer must be one where objectively it would be concluded that having regard to the material included within the definition of “authority” a reasoned argument can be made which argument when contrasted with the argument which is accepted as correct is about as likely as not correct. That is to say the two arguments, namely, that which is advanced by the taxpayer and that which reflects the correct view will be finely balanced. The case must thus be one where reasonable minds could differ as to which view, that of the taxpayer or that ultimately adopted by the Commissioner was correct. There must, in other words, be room for a real and rational difference of opinion between the two views such that while the taxpayer’s view is ultimately seen to be wrong it is nevertheless “about” as likely to be correct as the correct view. A question of judgment is involved.C.4 Can receipt of consideration be conduct within s 290-50(1)?