Commissioner of State Revenue v Harrison

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Commissioner of State Revenue v Harrison [2019] QCA 50

PARTIES:

COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE
(applicant)
v
FRANCIS LISTER HARRISON
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 6980 of 2018
QCATA No 72 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – [2018] QCATA 75

DELIVERED ON:

26 March 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 October 2018

JUDGES:

Morrison and Philippides JJA and Davis J

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal is refused.

2.   The parties have leave to deliver written submissions within fourteen days on the question of whether the Chorley exception applies to enable the respondent to claim professional costs.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – OTHER CASES – where the applicant applies for leave to the Court of Appeal to appeal a decision of the QCAT Appeal Tribunal – where the identification of an error of law is not sufficient, of itself, to warrant a grant of leave – where leave will be granted where a substantial injustice has been sustained or an important principle arises – where the applicant applies on the sole basis that the appeal raises issues of public importance – whether leave to appeal ought to be granted

TAXES AND DUTIES – LAND TAX – LIABILITY FOR LAND TAX – where the respondent and his wife have three adult children – where the respondent was the registered owner of three residential properties other than his own residence – where he was assessed as liable for land tax in each of the 2014 and 2015 years calculated on the aggregate value of the three properties – where the QCAT Appeal Tribunal found the value of the properties should not be aggregated for the purposes of land tax calculation – whether the Appeal Tribunal erred

EQUITY – TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – DISCRETIONARY TRUSTS – CREATION AND EFFECT GENERALLY – where the respondent contended that each property was held by him as trustee for one of his children – where the QCAT Appeal Tribunal found that each child had agreed to rent each property from their father on the basis that their parents would make mutual wills leaving each property to the relevant child – whether the Appeal Tribunal erred

Land Tax Act 2010 (Qld), s 8, s 10, s 19, s 20
Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld), s 63, s 67, s 68, s 69
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 9, s 10, s 25, s 26, s 27, s 142, s 150

Barns v Barns (2003) 214 CLR 169; [2003] HCA 9, followed
Bown v Lee[2018] QCA 13, cited
Cachia v Hanes (1994) 179 CLR 101; [1994] HCA 14, cited
Giumelli v Giumelli (1999) 196 CLR 101; [1999] HCA 10, cited
Hartford Holdings Pty Ltd v CP (Adelaide) Pty Ltd [2004] SASC 161,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of State Revenue v Harrison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of State Revenue applied to the Queensland Court of Appeal for leave to appeal a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Appeal Tribunal (QCAT Appeal Tribunal) in the case of Harrison v Commissioner of State Revenue. The appeal was concerned with the liability for land tax on three residential properties held by the respondent, Mr Harrison. Mr Harrison argued that the properties were held by him as trustee for his three adult children, and thus should not be aggregated for land tax assessment purposes. The QCAT Appeal Tribunal found in favour of Mr Harrison, determining that the properties should not be aggregated for land tax purposes. The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the QCAT Appeal Tribunal erred in its determination that the properties should not be aggregated for land tax purposes, and whether the trusts claimed by Mr Harrison were validly established.

The Court of Appeal held that the QCAT Appeal Tribunal's decision on the aggregation of the properties for land tax purposes was not an error of law, in itself, warranting leave to appeal. However, the Court recognised that the case involved issues of public importance, which could justify the grant of leave. The Court found that the QCAT Appeal Tribunal had correctly identified the existence of a representation by Mr Harrison to his children that the properties would be left to them if they participated in the arrangements to occupy and pay rent. The Tribunal also correctly found that there was sufficient detriment to establish a constructive trust based upon the arrangements in place between Mr Harrison and his children. Therefore, at the time of the relevant assessments, Mr Harrison held each of the three properties on trust individually for each of his children.

The Court of Appeal refused the application for leave to appeal, but granted leave for the parties to deliver written submissions within fourteen days on the question of whether the Chorley exception applies to enable Mr Harrison to claim professional costs. The Court of Appeal's decision underscores the importance of establishing trusts and the need for evidence of detriment to support such claims. It also highlights the Court's discretion in granting leave to appeal, particularly in cases involving issues of public importance.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is refused.

2. The parties have leave to deliver written submissions within fourteen days on the question of whether the Chorley exception applies to enable the respondent to claim professional costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The application by the Commissioner for leave to appeal is made under s 150(2). This Court then only has jurisdiction to hear an appeal on a question on law. Exercise of the jurisdiction is at the discretion of the Court; the Commissioner must obtain leave.The decision of the Appeal Tribunal Before the Appeal Tribunal, Mr Harrison argued that the three trusts arose in one of four ways:(i)estoppel by representation;(ii)common intention constructive trust;(iii)trust arising from promises to leave property by will; and(iv)trust sub modo.Estoppel by representation The Appeal Tribunal found that there was a representation by Mr Harrison to his children that the property would be left to them if they participated in the arrangements to take up occupation and paid rent. The appeal tribunal held:“[46] The evidence here demonstrates that the agreement was one to leave the property to the children, and was not merely a promise to make a will in a particular form to do so at some other time.[47]We accept that the present case involved the giving of specific consideration on the part of the children, not only their promises under the agreement but in one case selling an existing property to take up occupation. Furthermore, it was accepted that each of the children had performed the part of the agreement by paying the so-called “rent” on the property.[48]In our view, the learned Member erred in failing to conclude that there was evidence of sufficient detriment to establish a constructive trust based upon the arrangements in place between the parties. The result is that at the time of the relevant assessments, the appellant held each of the three relevant properties on trust individually for each of those adult children.”[44][44]Harrison v Commissioner of State Revenue [2018] QCATA 75 at [46]–[48].Common intention constructive trust It was argued by Mr Harrison that even if there was no relevant and operative representation by him to his children, he and his children held a common intention that would give rise to a trust. The Appeal Tribunal proceeded on the basis that for such a trust to arise, detriment would have to be demonstrated. The Appeal Tribunal concluded, on this point:“[52] In our view, in any event, there was sufficient detriment to enable a conclusion to be reached that the appellant held each of the properties on constructive trust based on the common intention of the parties.”[45][45]At [52].Trust arising from promises to leave property by will The Appeal Tribunal analysed the decision of the High Court in Barns vBarns,[46] and then concluded:“[65] It follows from Barns that the mere execution of the wills, even containing a promise to leave specific property, did not involve a transfer of the beneficial ownership of the assets, and would require something more to create a present declaration of trust.”[47][46](2003) 214 CLR 169.[47]Harrison v Commissioner of State Revenue [2018] QCATA 75 at [65].Trusts sub modo Mr Harrison’s argument to the Appeal Tribunal was that a trust arose from the promise to convey an interest in land. That submission was rejected by the Appeal Tribunal.[48][48]At [76]–[77].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established