Hartford Holdings Pty Ltd v CP (Adelaide) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

HARTFORD HOLDINGS PTY LTD v CP (ADELAIDE) PTY LTD & ORS AND COLLIERS JARDINE PTY LTD

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Besanko)

8 June 2004

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT - CHARACTER AND ATTRIBUTES OF CONDUCT

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - CONDUCT OF PARTIES

PROCEDURE - COSTS - TAXATION - PRINCIPLES OF TAXATION - IN GENERAL

Appeal and cross-appeal from a Judge of the District Court - first respondents entered into indentures with appellants to lease shops and run businesses - second respondent acted as agent for appellant in the course of the transaction - both businesses ran at a loss - the first respondents were awarded damages for misleading and deceptive conduct by the appellants - whether in relation to misleading and deceptive conduct the trial Judge had made a finding of inducement or reliance - whether the trial Judge erred in finding that there was inducement or reliance - whether the trial Judge erred in finding that the appellant acted imprudently with regard to Calderbank offer made by the second respondent - whether the trial Judge's order in relation to costs will result in an injustice to first respondents - whether plaintiff in person is entitled to costs payable to counsel - whether plaintiff in person is entitled to compensation by way of lost earnings for work of counsel - whether interest awarded by trial Judge inadequate - appeal dismissed - cross-appeal allowed in part.

Trade Practices Act (1974) Cth s 51A, s 51A(2), s 52, s 52(1), s 82, s 82(1), s 87; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40(1); District Court Act 1991 (SA) s 42(1); Supreme Court Rules (SA) R 101, R 101.07(2)(b), referred to.
Henville v Walker (2001) 206 CLR 459; Cachia v Hanes (1993) 179 CLR 403, applied.
Khan v Lord Chancellor [2003] 2 All ER 367; Malkinson v Trim [2003] 2 All ER 356, not followed.
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215; CP (Adelaide) & Ors v Hartford (Holdings) & Anor (No.10) [2002] SADC 102; Burford v Allan [1998] SASC 6693, discussed.
CP (Adelaide) v Hartford (Holdings) [2002] SASC 304; I & L Securities Pty Limited v HTW Valuers (Brisbane)Pty Limited (2002) 210 CLR 109; Walton v McBride (1995) 36 NSWLR 440; Kowal v Zaccoli (2002) 4 VR 399; Bickford v Bickford [1923] SASR 148, considered.

HARTFORD HOLDINGS PTY LTD v CP (ADELAIDE) PTY LTD & ORS AND COLLIERS JARDINE PTY LTD
[2004] SASC 161

Full Court:   Doyle CJ, Gray and Besanko JJ

DOYLE CJ  

Introduction

  1. On about 28 July 2000 CP (Adelaide) Pty Ltd (“CP”) executed two indentures between CP and Hartford (Holdings) Ltd (“Hartford”), the effect of which was that CP would fit out two shops in a food court to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hartford Holdings Pty Ltd v CP (Adelaide) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hartford Holdings Pty Ltd v CP (Adelaide) Pty Ltd, the respondents entered into agreements with the appellants to lease shops and operate businesses, but both businesses operated at a loss. The respondents were awarded damages for misleading and deceptive conduct by the appellants. The central legal issues were whether the trial judge had correctly found that the respondents had relied on or been induced by the appellants' conduct, whether the trial judge had erred in finding that the appellants acted imprudently regarding a Calderbank offer made by the second respondent, and whether the trial judge's costs order would result in an injustice to the respondents. Additionally, there were issues regarding the entitlement of a plaintiff in person to costs payable to counsel and compensation for lost earnings of counsel, as well as the adequacy of interest awarded by the trial judge. The appeal was dismissed, and the cross-appeal was allowed in part.

The Court examined whether the trial judge had made a finding on the crucial matter of reliance or inducement. The appellants argued that there was no basis for a finding of inducement or reliance, or alternatively, that there should be an order for a retrial. The Court compared the present case with the High Court decision in Henville, where the plaintiffs had successfully claimed damages for losses incurred due to misleading representations. Gleeson CJ held that for there to be a causal relationship between a contravention of s 52 and loss or damage, it was not essential for the contravention to be the sole cause of the loss or damage. The Court held that the decision in Henville was relevant and found that the trial judge had made a finding of inducement or reliance, which was sufficient.

In relation to the imprudency of the appellants' conduct, the Court found that the trial judge's finding that the appellants acted imprudently regarding the Calderbank offer was not erroneous. The Court also determined that the trial judge's costs order would not result in an injustice to the respondents. The Court held that the plaintiff in person was not entitled to costs payable to counsel, but was entitled to compensation by way of lost earnings for work of counsel. Finally, the Court found that the interest awarded by the trial judge was inadequate and increased it to 8% per annum.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J BESANKO J
In the end the submission is that there is either no finding on the crucial matter of reliance or inducement, or that there is a finding in general terms that cannot be sustained. Mr Whitington submits that this Court should find that there is no basis for a finding of inducement or reliance, or, in the alternative, there should be an order for a retrial on the basis that the trial Judge has not made a finding as to a critical matter.The High Court decision in Henville In Henville the plaintiffs bought land and built a small block of home units. The project was undertaken with a view to making a profit on the sale of the units. When considering whether to buy the land they relied on advice from the defendant about the likely selling prices for the units, and about market demand for the units. They relied also on their own estimates for construction and other costs. The defendant overestimated demand and price, and the plaintiffs underestimated the project costs. The plaintiffs lost on the project, and sued the defendant, claiming damages assessed by reference to the loss they made. The statements by the defendant about selling prices and demand were found to be in breach of s 51 of the TPA. On appeal, the High Court restored the trial Judge’s finding that the defendant’s contravention of s 52 was one of two concurrent causes of the plaintiffs’ loss, and held that that sufficed to entitled the plaintiffs to damages under s 82(1) of the TPA. On appeal there was also an issue as to the quantification of damages. In particular, should the damages be reduced because of the part played by the plaintiffs’ own carelessness in estimating construction and other costs, or could it be said that some part of the loss suffered was attributable to the plaintiffs’ own conduct and thus not recoverable from the defendant? On this matter the Court divided, but in view of the submissions on appeal this aspect of the case can be put to one side. Does the decision in Henville state a principle that is relevant to the present case? In my opinion it does. Gleeson CJ proceeded on the basis of the trial Judge’s findings that the defendant’s representations were “a substantial inducement” to the plaintiffs in deciding to undertake the project: at [10] and [21]. He also accepted the trial Judge’s finding that the plaintiffs relied as well on their own erroneous estimates at [10]. He rejected a Full Court finding on appeal that the plaintiffs’ erroneous estimates were “the sole cause of the decision to undertake the project”: at [13]. In that context, and before coming to the question of quantification of the damages (on which point he was in dissent), he said at [14]:“For there to be the necessary causal relationship between a contravention of s 52, and loss or damage, so as to satisfy the requirements of s 82(1), it is not essential that the contravention be the sole cause of the loss or damage. As Brennan J pointed out in Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL , where the making of a false representation induces a person to act in a certain manner, loss or damage may flow directly from the act and only indirectly from the making of the representation; but in such a case the act “is a link – not a break- in the chain of causation”. In the present case there were two concurrent causes of the imprudent decision to buy the land and undertake the development project. The conduct of the respondents was one of those causes. That is enough.” (Footnote omitted)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J, BESANKO J