HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Barwick C.J., Gibbs, Stephen, Mason and Murphy JJ.
COMMISSIONER FOR PRICES AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS (S.A.) v. CHARLES MOORE (AUST.) LTD.
5 July 1977
Trade Practices—Statutes
Trade Practices—Consumer protection—Reporting agencies—Retail department stores exchanging credit information on a reciprocal basis—Whether reporting agencies—Whether exchange made for reward—"Fee or reward"—Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.), ss. 4*, 6-11, 13. Trade Practices—Consumer protection—Authority given by regulatory body to store to provide credit subject to conditions—Revolving charge account—Condition requiring store to comply with provisions of Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.)—Validity—Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.), ss. 5, 6**, 13, 19, 21(5), 28—Regulations under Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.), reg. 8 (3). Statutes—Construction—Parliamentary debates—Ministerial statements of intention—Travaux preparatoires—Remedial statute—Consumer Credit Act, 1972—1974 (S.A.), s. 21 (5). * Section 4 of the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.) defines "reporting agency" to mean:—"(a) a person or body of persons that, for fee or reward, furnishes consumer reports to traders: or (b) a person or body of persons—(i) that carries on the business of banking; or (ii) whose only or principal business is the lending of money, declared by regulation to be a reporting agency for the purposes of this Act." ** Section 6 (6) of the Consumer Credit Act, 1972 (S.A.) provides "The Tribunal may, on the application of any person, authorize him to provide credit by means of revolving charge accounts, and such an authorization may be granted upon conditions - (a) limiting the frequency with which credit charges may be made on any such account; (b) limiting the amount of credit charges that may be made on any such account, and such other conditions as the Tribunal thinks fit."
Decisions
1977, July 5.
The following written judgments were delivered: -
BARWICK C.J. We have before us an appeal by the South Australian Commissioner for Prices and Consumer Affairs against an order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia (1975) 12 SASR 214 which, by majority, allowed an appeal by the present respondents against a decision of the Credit Tribunal established by s. 13 of the Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.) ("the Consumer Credit Act"), by which it was held that the respondents were "reporting agencies" within the meaning and operation of Pt II of the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.), ("the Fair Credit Reports Act"). (at p454)
2. We also have before us an appeal by the Credit Tribunal against an order of the Full Court prohibiting the Credit Tribunal from proceeding upon its own motion to vary the conditions on which the respondents are authorized under Pt I of the Consumer Credit Act to provide credit by means of revolving charge accounts (see s. 6 (6) of the Consumer Credit Act). (at p454)
3. The appeals have been heard together but must be separately decided. I shall deal first with the firstmentioned appeal. (at p454)
4. The Credit Tribunal, on the motion of the South Australian Commissioner for Prices and Consumer Affairs…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Prices and Consumer Affairs (SA) v Charles... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1977] HCA 38
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was the interpretation of section 17(1)(a) of the *Prices Justification Act 1973* (SA), which empowered the Commissioner to require a company to furnish information and produce documents relating to its business. The court had to determine whether the phrase "cost of goods sold" as used in the Act encompassed the cost of acquiring goods for resale, or if it was limited to the cost of producing goods.
The High Court, by majority, held that the Commissioner's power under section 17(1)(a) extended to requiring information about the cost of acquiring goods for resale. The majority reasoned that the ordinary meaning of "cost of goods sold" in a commercial context includes the cost of acquiring inventory that is subsequently sold. They rejected the argument that the term was confined to manufacturing costs, finding that such a narrow interpretation would unduly restrict the Commissioner's ability to investigate prices and would not align with the broad purpose of the legislation.
The appeal was allowed, and the order of the Supreme Court of South Australia was set aside.
Background
Background to the litigation
The respondents, which are retail department stores in South Australia, have been exchanging credit information on a reciprocal basis for several decades. This is done in various ways, including the exchange of oral information by telephone and the distribution of lists of dishonest staff members, dishonest customers and slow-paying customers by the Retail Traders Association. The respondents co-operate in this way because they find that it is to their commercial advantage to do so. If a store will not supply information it will not be given information by others. The telephone reports are a prompt and comparatively reliable means of obtaining the information necessary to decide whether credit should be extended to a new customer, and if so to what extent, and are of real benefit to the respondents in the conduct of their retail businesses. Another advantage is that a store which participates in the arrangement avoids the necessity to pay the fees that would be charged by a credit bureau.
The Commissioner for Prices and Consumer Affairs sought orders that the respondents comply with the provisions of the Fair Credit Reports Act, which is a remedial statute designed to protect consumers who wish to obtain credit from being damaged by erroneous reports and to provide a means whereby errors may be detected and corrected. The Credit Tribunal found that the respondents were reporting agencies within the meaning and operation of the Fair Credit Reports Act and ordered them to comply with the Act. The respondents appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court, which allowed the appeal and set aside the Credit Tribunal's order. The Commissioner appealed to the High Court.
The High Court found that the respondents were not reporting agencies within the meaning and operation of the Fair Credit Reports Act. The Court held that the Act refers in its definition of "reporting agency" to persons whose business it is to supply consumer reports for commercial gain in the form of a fee or of some non-pecuniary advantage specifically related to the furnishing of a consumer report by way of remuneration provided by the recipient of the report or with its concurrence by some other person or body. The Court concluded that the commercial advantage which the respondents derived from the reciprocal exchange of consumer information was not a reward for the purposes of the definition of "reporting agency". The Court also found that the Credit Tribunal did not have the power to impose conditions on the respondents' authorization to provide credit by means of revolving charge accounts which would subject them to the obligations imposed by the Fair Credit Reports Act.
The High Court dismissed the appeal by the Commissioner and allowed the appeal by the Credit Tribunal. The Court set aside the order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court and dismissed the appeal by the respondents with costs. The Court also dismissed the appeal by the Credit Tribunal with costs.
The matter came before the High Court of Australia on two separate appeals. The first appeal was brought by the South Australian Commissioner for Prices and Consumer Affairs against a decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, which had set aside a decision of the Credit Tribunal. The Credit Tribunal had ruled that the respondents, which were retail department stores in South Australia, were "reporting agencies" within the meaning of the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.). The second appeal was brought by the Credit Tribunal against an order of the Full Court prohibiting it from proceeding upon its own motion to vary the conditions on which the respondents were authorized under the Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.) to provide credit by means of revolving charge accounts. The Credit Tribunal had sought to impose conditions on the respondents' authorizations to provide credit, making them subject to the obligations imposed upon reporting agencies by Part II of the Fair Credit Reports Act. The appeals were heard together but required separate decisions. The High Court's decision focused on the interpretation of the statutory definitions and the scope of the Credit Tribunal's powers under the Consumer Credit Act. The Court considered whether the exchange of consumer credit information among the retail stores constituted "furnishing consumer reports for reward" within the definition of "reporting agency" in the Fair Credit Reports Act, and whether the Credit Tribunal had the power to impose conditions on the respondents' authorizations that would subject them to obligations under the Fair Credit Reports Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is a department store that engages in the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports with other traders a "reporting agency" within the meaning of the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.)?
2. Does the definition of "reporting agency" in the Fair Credit Reports Act include department stores that exchange credit information on a reciprocal basis?
3. What constitutes "furnishing consumer reports for reward" under the Fair Credit Reports Act?
4. Is the anticipated commercial benefit derived from the exchange of consumer reports sufficient to classify a department store as a "reporting agency"?
5. Are the department stores subject to the obligations imposed by the Fair Credit Reports Act despite not being classified as "reporting agencies"?
6. Does the Credit Tribunal have the authority to impose conditions on the department stores that would subject them to obligations similar to those imposed upon reporting agencies by the Fair Credit Reports Act?
7. Are the conditions proposed by the Credit Tribunal to be within the scope of its powers under the Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.)?
Held
1. Is a department store that engages in the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports with other traders a "reporting agency" within the meaning of the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.)? The court concluded that department stores engaged in the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports are not "reporting agencies" under the Fair Credit Reports Act.
2. Does the definition of "reporting agency" in the Fair Credit Reports Act include department stores that exchange credit information on a reciprocal basis? The court found that the definition of "reporting agency" does not include department stores engaged in the reciprocal exchange of credit information.
3. What constitutes "furnishing consumer reports for reward" under the Fair Credit Reports Act? The court held that furnishing consumer reports for reward involves providing such reports in the expectation of receiving a commercially valuable benefit or advantage in return.
4. Is the anticipated commercial benefit derived from the exchange of consumer reports sufficient to classify a department store as a "reporting agency"? The court determined that the anticipated commercial benefit from the exchange of consumer reports does not classify a department store as a "reporting agency."
5. Are the department stores subject to the obligations imposed by the Fair Credit Reports Act despite not being classified as "reporting agencies"? The court concluded that the department stores are not subject to the obligations imposed by the Fair Credit Reports Act.
6. Does the Credit Tribunal have the authority to impose conditions on the department stores that would subject them to obligations similar to those imposed upon reporting agencies by the Fair Credit Reports Act? The court found that the Credit Tribunal does not have the authority to impose such conditions on the department stores.
7. Are the conditions proposed by the Credit Tribunal to be within the scope of its powers under the Consumer Credit Act, 1972-1973 (S.A.)? The court held that the proposed conditions are outside the scope of the powers granted to the Credit Tribunal under the Consumer Credit Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court addressed several key issues in determining whether department stores that engage in the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports with other traders qualify as "reporting agencies" under the Fair Credit Reports Act, 1974-1975 (S.A.), and whether the Credit Tribunal could impose conditions on these stores to subject them to obligations similar to those imposed upon reporting agencies by the Fair Credit Reports Act.
First, the Court analyzed the definition of "reporting agency" within the Fair Credit Reports Act. The Act defines a "reporting agency" as a person or body of persons that, for fee or reward, furnishes consumer reports to traders. The Court considered whether the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports between department stores constituted "furnishing consumer reports for reward." The majority of the Court found that the commercial benefit derived from the exchange of consumer reports qualified as a reward. This interpretation was based on the understanding that the stores exchanged information with the expectation of receiving reciprocal information, which provided a tangible commercial advantage. This reasoning aligns with the broader remedial purpose of the Act, which is to protect consumers from erroneous credit information.
Second, the Court examined the authority of the Credit Tribunal to impose conditions on the department stores. The Court found that the Credit Tribunal did not have the power to impose conditions that would subject the stores to obligations similar to those imposed upon reporting agencies by the Fair Credit Reports Act. The conditions proposed by the Credit Tribunal were considered extraneous to the purposes of the Consumer Credit Act, which focuses on regulating the provision of credit rather than the collection and dissemination of consumer information.
The Court's interpretation of the Act and its emphasis on the commercial benefit derived from the exchange of consumer reports as a form of reward was pivotal in determining that the department stores qualified as reporting agencies. However, the Court's finding that the Credit Tribunal lacked the authority to impose conditions on the stores under the Consumer Credit Act underscored the distinct purposes of the two Acts. The Court's decision also highlighted the importance of adhering to established rules of statutory interpretation, particularly the prohibition on using parliamentary debates as an aid to interpreting statutes.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that department stores engaging in the reciprocal exchange of consumer reports with other traders can be classified as "reporting agencies" under the Fair Credit Reports Act if they furnish consumer reports for reward, but the Credit Tribunal does not have the authority to impose conditions on these stores that would subject them to obligations similar to those imposed upon reporting agencies by the Fair Credit Reports Act.