Commercial Fitouts Australia Pty Ltd v Miracle Ceilings (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

COMMERCIAL FITOUTS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v MIRACLE CEILINGS (AUST) PTY LTD & ORS

[2020] SASC 11

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

4 February 2020

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - REMUNERATION - STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS - ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS

The plaintiff seeks declarations that a payment claim served by the first defendant was void for the purpose of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) (the Act) and that the adjudicator lacked jurisdiction such that the subsequent adjudication of the payment claim was void. The plaintiff also seeks an order that the adjudication decision and any certificate issued upon the adjudication be quashed and that the judgment entered upon the certificate be set aside.

At issue is whether the payment claim was void by reason that it was not served within the period of six months after the construction work to which the claim relates was last carried out as required by s 13(4) of the Act.

Held:

1.  The plaintiff is entitled to the declarations and orders it has sought.  The plaintiff is to bring into Court minutes of order that reflect these reasons.

Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) s 13, referred to.
APX Projects Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No. 64025 [2015] NSWSC 1250, applied.
Air Services Australia v Ferrier (1995-1996) 185 CLR 483, discussed.
Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd (2018) 264 CLR 1; Maxcon Constructions Pty Ltd v Vadasz (2018) 264 CLR 46; Southern Han Breakfast Point Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Lewence Construction Pty Ltd & Ors (2016) 260 CLR 340; Tagara Builders Pty Ltd v AP & L Services Pty Ltd (2015) 112 SASR 29; Canberra Drilling Rigs Pty Ltd v Haides Pty Ltd [2018] ACTSC 282; Canberra Drilling Rigs Pty Ltd v Haides Pty Ltd [2019] ACTCA 15; Estate Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd (2004) 61 NSWLR 515; Protectavale Pty Ltd v K2K Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1248; Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd v Luikens & Anor [2003] NSWSC 1140; Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Campbelltown Catholic Club Ltd [2003] NSWSC 1103; Minimax Fire Fighting Systems Pty Ltd v Bremore Engineering (WA) Pty Ltd [2007] QSC 333; Gantley Pty Ltd & Ors v Phoenix International Group Pty Ltd & Anor [2010] VSC 106, considered.

COMMERCIAL FITOUTS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v MIRACLE CEILINGS (AUST) PTY LTD & ORS
[2020] SASC 11

Civil

STANLEY J:

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff seeks declarations that the payment claim served by the first defendant on 22 March 2019 was void for the purpose of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) (the Act) and that the adjudicator lacked jurisdiction such that the subsequent adjudication of the payment claim was void. The plaintiff also seeks an order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commercial Fitouts Australia Pty Ltd v Miracle Ceilings (Aus... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Commercial Fitouts Australia Pty Ltd v Miracle Ceilings (Aust) Pty Ltd concerned a dispute over payment claims and adjudication of payment disputes under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (Cth). The plaintiff, Commercial Fitouts, claimed that the defendant, Miracle Ceilings, had not properly served a payment claim within the required six-month period, rendering an adjudication decision null and void. The central issue was whether the payment claim related to construction work completed within the preceding six months, as required by the Act.

The court examined whether the payment claim related to construction work carried out within the six months prior to the claim being made. The court considered the specific invoices and payments made between the parties. It found that the payment claim did not relate to the construction work in question, as it pertained to invoices that had already been fully or partially paid. Moreover, the circumstances of the payments implied an appropriation of payments made in respect of specific invoices. The court concluded that the payment claim was not made within the statutory period, and therefore the adjudicator's decision lacked jurisdiction.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff and ordered that Commercial Fitouts was entitled to the declarations and orders it sought. The plaintiff was directed to bring into Court minutes of order that reflected the court's reasons. This decision highlights the importance of timely and specific payment claims under the Security of Payment Act and the consequences of failing to adhere to the statutory requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff is entitled to the declarations and orders it has sought. The plaintiff is to bring into Court minutes of order that reflect these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This implication is reinforced not just by the circumstances in which the payments were made, and in particular the payment of invoice 79 was made, but by the requirements of s 13(2) of the Act which I have explained above. I do not accept the first defendant’s submission based on a running account. While it is apparent that payments were made from time to time by the plaintiff that represented part payment of certain invoices, namely, a payment of $18,720.90 on 16 August 2018 representing payment of invoice 73 and part payment of invoice 67, and a payment of $17,548.30 on 31 August 2018 representing payment of invoice 75 and part payment of invoice 74, that does not detract from the fact that invoice 79 had been specifically paid by the plaintiff on 27 September 2018. Neither does it detract from the fact that the payment claim on its face relates to a claim for payment for invoice 67 and part payment of invoices 70, 72 and 74. Accordingly, it follows that the construction work to which invoice 79 relates was not the subject of the payment claim served on 22 March 2019. As a result, the payment claim was not made within the six months prescribed by s 13(4)(b). That conclusion dictates that the adjudication decision was made in want of jurisdiction.Conclusion The plaintiff is entitled to the declarations and orders it has sought. I direct that the plaintiff is to bring into Court minutes of order that reflect these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At issue is whether specific payments were made by the plaintiff to the first defendant in payment of a specific invoice. That gives rise to consideration of whether there has been appropriation of payments. I will come back to this question. Consideration For jurisdictional purposes the critical question in this matter is not whether the plaintiff was dealing with the first defendant on a running account basis but rather whether progress payments were made in respect of specific invoices which related to specific work pursuant to the construction contract between the parties. This requires identification of the relevant jurisdictional fact, namely, whether the payment claim served on 22 March 2019 related in any way to construction work which was last carried out in the preceding six months. The only construction work that answered that description was the work that related to invoice 79. That invoice was dated 25 September 2018. It was an invoice in the amount of $3,784. That amount was paid on 27 September 2018. The terms of the payment claim itself issued by the first defendant identified the payment claim as relating to the unpaid invoice 67 and the part-paid invoices 70, 72 and 74. It is the case that the payment claim identifies 13 separate invoices, nine of which are indicated as having been fully paid, but those nine invoices cannot reflect a claim for a progress payment in respect of the construction work to which those invoices relate because of the fact that they have been paid. Reference to those invoices in the payment claim cannot make the work to which those invoices relate, and in particular, the work done in respect of invoice 79, a claim for payment for the particular construction work to which these nine invoices relate. This conclusion is founded on two propositions. First, pursuant to s 13(2) the payment claim must identify with reasonable specificity the work which is the subject of the payment claim to enable a respondent to a payment claim to consider and respond to it, either by accepting the claim in full or in part, or rejecting the claim totally, and to define the issues in dispute between the parties which the adjudicator is to resolve, and to enable an adjudicator, if appointed, to determine the adjudication application.[13] Second, the circumstances of the payments made in this case implies an appropriation of payments made by the plaintiff to the first defendant. The circumstances of the payments imply that the payments have been made by the plaintiff in respect of specific invoices. Most importantly, the circumstances by which the plaintiff paid the sum of $3,784 on 27 September 2018 implies that this payment was made in respect of invoice 79. [13] Gantley Pty Ltd & Ors v Phoenix International Group Pty Ltd & Anor [2010] VSC 106 at [41]. In APX Projects Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No. 64025[14] Slattery J explained the principles for ascertaining to which debt a payment will be appropriated as follows:[15][14] [2015] NSWSC 1250.[15] [2015] NSWSC 1250 at [30]-[35].The principles for ascertaining to which debt a payment will be appropriated work in the following stages. Firstly, a debtor has the right, in the first instance, to declare in respect of which debt he pays money: Mills v Fowkes. However as noted by the authors in E Tyler, P Young and C Croft, Fisher & Lightwood's Law of Mortgage (3rd ed 2013, LexisNexis) at 32.52, the debtor’s direction must be in clear terms: Colonial Bank of Australasia v Kerr; Healey v Commonwealth Bank of Australia. For example, entries made by the debtor in his or her own books are not sufficient evidence of a particular appropriation of money paid on a general account: Wrout v Dawes.Equally, it is possible that in circumstances where a debtor fails expressly to communicate to the creditor the appropriation of a debt, the circumstances of payment may be such that the proper appropriation of the debt is implied. This may be the case, for example, where two debts of different amounts are owing and the amount paid equates to one of them.Secondly, where the debtor does not appropriate his or her payment to a particular debt, the creditor enjoys the right of choosing the debt to which the payment is appropriated. As Lord McNaughten in Cory Brothers & Company v Owners of Turkish Steamship ‘Mecca’:“When a debtor is making a payment to his creditor he may appropriate the money as he pleases, and the creditor must apply it accordingly. If the debtor does not make any appropriation at the time when he makes the payment the right of application devolves on the creditor.”Thirdly, where neither the debtor nor the creditor acts upon their successive entitlements to choose how the debt will be appropriated, the default position is that the payment will be applied to the oldest debts first: Devaynes v Noble (‘Clayton’s Case’); Sibbles v Highfern Pty Ltd. In Re Walsh; Ex parte DCT, Lockhart J explained the application of these three rules governing the appropriation of payments in the following way:“A debtor who owes two debts to a creditor is entitled to appropriate a payment which he makes to his creditor to one debt rather than to the other. If he omits to do so, the creditor may make the appropriation. If neither makes any appropriation, the law appropriates the payment to the earlier debt. If there is specific appropriation by the debtor cadit quaestio. In the absence of a specific appropriation it is a question of fact whether there was any appropriation by the debtor. To constitute an appropriation there must be more than an intention to appropriate by the debtor. I respectfully adopt the following passage from the judgment of Greene LJ in I:‘When, however, he does not notify the creditor of his intention, and when the circumstances are such that the creditor receives the payment merely in satisfaction of the debts and the payment is not more appropriate to the payment of the one debt than to that of the other the creditor is entitled to make the appropriation. When it is said that there need not be an express appropriation of a payment, but that the appropriation can be inferred, that does not mean that appropriation of a payment can be inferred from some undisclosed intention in the mind of the debtor. It is to be inferred from the circumstances of the case as known to both parties. Any other view might lead to injustice, as the creditor's right to appropriate a payment would be defeated. When the matter is examined upon principle it will be found that an undisclosed intention in the mind of the debtor is not sufficient to support an appropriation. If authority is needed for that proposition it can be found in the judgment of Lush J in Parker v Guinness where he said: ‘What is to be considered is this. Is the true inference to be drawn from all the circumstances of the case that the debtor paid the moneys generally on account, leaving the creditor to apply them as he thought fit, or is the true inference that he paid them on account of special portions of the debt for the purpose and with a view to wipe these out of the account? His undisclosed intention so to do would, of course, not benefit him. It is what he did in fact, and not what he meant to do that is to be regarded.’ A debtor's undisclosed intention to appropriate a payment to one of two debts owed by him to a creditor cannot benefit him.’”As noted in Caltabiano v Electoral Commission Of Queensland (‘Caltabiano’), the above quotation from Parker v Guiness regarding when an appropriation of a payment to a particular debt will be inferred continues, as follows:“It is what he did in fact, and not what he meant to do that is to be regarded. But if the inference to be drawn from the circumstances is that the payment was in fact appropriated by the debtor at the time of payment, the fact that he made no express statement at the time is immaterial. Now an appropriation by the debtor may be inferred from a variety of circumstances. Each case must, in my opinion, be considered on its own peculiar facts.”Muir JA in Caltabiano held that the inference as to appropriation to be drawn from the circumstances “is the inference which would have been drawn by a reasonable person who had regard to those circumstances. The circumstances include ‘the purpose and object’ of the application.”[Citations omitted].