Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] FCA 662

CORRIGENDUM

COMCARE v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
ACD 38 OF 2005

MADGWICK J
4 MAY 2007 (CORRIGENDUM 8 MAY 2007)
SYDNEY (HEARD AT CANBERRA)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

ACD 38 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

COMCARE
Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 MAY 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD AT CANBERRA)

CORRIGENDUM

  1. On page 7, paragraph 29, delete “Bornholdt” and replace with “Bornholt”.

  2. On page 30, paragraph 115, third-final dot point, delete both instances of “Bornholdt” and replace with “Bornholt”.

  3. On page 34, paragraph 128, delete “Bornholdt” and replace with “Bornholt”.

I certify that the preceding three (3) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Madgwick.

Associate:

Dated:       8 May 2007


FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] FCA 662

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Industrial safety, health and welfare – The Commonwealth – Penalties for breach of Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Act 1991 (Cth) – appropriate considerations – inadequacy of available sanctions as against Commonwealth

Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Act 1991 (Cth), s 16(1), Sch 2, cll 2 and 4

Coochey v Commonwealth (2005) 149 FCR 312, cited

COMCARE v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
ACD 38 OF 2005

MADGWICK J
4 MAY 2007
SYDNEY (HEARD AT CANBERRA)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

ACD 38 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

COMCARE
Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 MAY 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD AT CANBERRA)

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Between on or about 4 November 2004 and on or about 12 November 2004 at the Mount Bundey Training Area in the Northern Territory the respondent, acting through the Chief of the Defence Force as the employing authority in relation to members of the Australian Defence Force, contravened cl 2(1) of Sch 2 of the Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Act 1991 (Cth) by  reason of its having breached s 16(1) of the said Act in that in the course of conducting the Subject 1 Corporals Course it:

(a)failed to conduct the field phase of the Corporals Course during the wet season at a training area outside of the Northern Territory;

and then having decided not to conduct the course outside of the Northern Territory:

(b)failed to promulgate its own policies and procedures contained in the Defence Safety Manual (SAFETYMAN) and train relevant personnel about those procedures.

(c)failed to provide a structured system of acclimatisation prior to the field phase of the Corporals Course.

(d)did not effectively monitor the heat conditions and suspend the field phase of the course in accordance with the policies and procedures contained in SAFETYMAN according to the Wet Bulb Globe Thermometer readings or when participants began to experience symptoms of heat injury.

(e)failed to introduce rest/work cycles as required by SAFETYMAN.

(f)failed to provide rest periods…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 662
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia involved the Commonwealth, represented by Comcare, as the applicant, and the Commonwealth of Australia, represented by the Minister for Defence, as the respondent. The dispute centred on the appropriate level of financial penalty to impose on the Commonwealth for breaches of the Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Act 1991 (Cth) (OHS Act), which led to the death of Trooper Lawrence. Trooper Lawrence, a member of the Australian Defence Force (ADF), died in November 1994 due to heat stress sustained during a training course. The Commonwealth admitted to breaching its obligations under s 16(1) of the OHS Act, which requires employers to take all reasonably practicable steps to protect the health and safety of their employees.

The legal issues before the court included determining the appropriate financial penalty for the Commonwealth's admitted breaches of the OHS Act and the factors to consider in setting the penalty. The court was required to weigh the Commonwealth's admissions of fault, its subsequent actions to address the issues, and the impact of Trooper Lawrence's death on his family. The court considered several mitigating factors, such as the Army's immediate review and improvement of its approach to heat injury, the establishment of the Heat Injury Remediation Project, and the Army's cooperation with investigations and acceptance of responsibility.

The court reasoned that while the Commonwealth had taken significant steps to address the issues following Trooper Lawrence's death, the breaches were serious and had led to a tragic outcome. The court acknowledged the Commonwealth's efforts to improve its policies and practices but emphasised the importance of holding the employer accountable for its failures. After considering all the relevant factors, the court determined that the appropriate penalty was 1,800 penalty units. Additionally, the court ordered the respondent to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to cl 4 of Sch 2 of the said Act the respondent pay a penalty of 1,800 penalty units.

2. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns what level of financial “penalty”, up to a relatively low limit, it is appropriate for the Court to impose on the Commonwealth for admitted breaches of the Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Act 1991 (Cth) (“OHS Act”) by the Commonwealth as the deemed employer of a soldier, Trooper Lawrence, who died at the age of 25 in November 1994 in the Northern Territory as a result of heat stress sustained while on an Army promotional training course.Background Between 4 and 10 November 2004, members of the Australian Defence Force (“ADF”), including Trooper Lawrence, participating in the field phase of a leaders training course known as the Subject 1 for Corporal Course (“Corporal Course”), being conducted at the Mount Bundey Training Area (“Mount Bundey”) in the Northern Territory, experienced environmental circumstances giving rise to a risk of heat injury, including heat stroke. By virtue of s 9(2)(b) of the OHS Act, a member of the ADF is, for the purposes of the OHS Act, taken to be employed by the Commonwealth. Regulation 4 of the Occupational Health and Safety (Commonwealth Employment) Regulations 1991 makes the Chief of the Defence Force the employing authority in relation to a member of the Defence Force for the purposes of the Act (see, in particular, s 10). At all material times, therefore, the respondent is taken to have been the employer of members of the ADF for the purposes of the OHS Act. The applicant seeks a declaration of contravention and the imposition of a pecuniary penalty pursuant to the provisions of Sch 2 of the OHS Act. Subsections 11(1) and (3) provide that the OHS Act binds the Crown in right of the Commonwealth and that the Commonwealth is subject to proceedings for a contravention of cl 2(1) of Sch 2 and liable to pay a pecuniary penalty under cl 4(l) of that Schedule. Clause 2(1) of Sch 2 provides:(1) If a court considers that a person has breached one of the following provisions, or was involved in such a breach, it must make a declaration that the person has contravened this subclause: (a) subsection 16(1) (duties of employers in relation to their employees etc.) The applicant alleges that the Commonwealth has breached its obligations under s 16(1) of the OHS Act which provides that: “An employer must take all reasonably practicable steps to protect the health and safety at work of the employer’s employees.” The respondent concedes that the circumstances leading up to the death of Trooper Lawrence involved contravention by it of its duty under s 16(1) of the OHS Act.The ADF’s Regional Training Centre in the Northern Territory In 1992 the ADF directed the Army to locate a Brigade in the Darwin area. This resulted in approximately 1,200 Army personnel moving there. Mount Bundey was set up to provide training facilities to serve this Brigade. Use of Mount Bundey is managed by the Defence Corporate Support and Information Group, while Training Command - Army provides training services to “client” units of other commands. Training is undertaken by arrangement with client units according to an Army-wide program by instructors from the Regular Army and Army Reserve.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MADGWICK J
The principal factors argued in mitigation are:·Following Trooper Lawrence’s death, the Army discontinued using Mount Bundey for wet season training courses incorporating a field phase, pending review of its approach to heat injury. Mount Bundey has not since been used in the wet season for such courses.·The Army immediately conducted an initial review of its approach to heat injury, resulting in the promulgation of Brigadier Anstey’s new and greatly improved directive: Prevention of Heat-Related Illness and Injuries, dated 8 December 2004.·The Army continued its review of its approach to heat injury and on 8 April 2005 Brigadier Anstey issued a further revised directive, Prevention of Heat-Related Illness and Injuries.·As a direct consequence of Trooper Lawrence’s death and the other severe heat stroke case referred to, the Chief of Army established the Heat Injury Remediation (“HIR”) Project, which is ongoing.·The Army co-operated fully with the Comcare investigator (Mr Wray). The improvement notices issued were promptly complied with by the Army. ·The Army initiated its own inquiry into the circumstances of Trooper Lawrence’s death. The results are contained in three reports prepared by Colonel Charles. The first two pre-dated the Northern Territory coronial inquiry and were tendered to the Coroner. Colonel Charles’ investigations were thorough and far-ranging, and all of the main criticisms of the Army’s approach to heat injury prior to Trooper Lawrence’s death were identified in Colonel Charles’ first report. All of the recommendations made in that report were implemented. There can be no suggestion that by initiating and publishing Colonel Charles’ reports the Army has attempted to minimize or gloss over its failings regarding the circumstances of Trooper Lawrence’s death. The reports are highly embarrassing to the Army.·To make itself further accountable for Trooper Lawrence’s death, the Army submitted to the Northern Territory Coroner’s jurisdiction when it was not legally obliged to do so, a fact remarked upon by the Coroner. ·The Army has admitted responsibility for Trooper Lawrence’s death and apologised publicly and privately to his family and friends. At the coronial inquiry, Brigadier Bornholdt, on behalf of the Army, accepted responsibility for the soldier’s death, acknowledged his service to his country and, in the presence of his family, apologised to them for the Army’s failures. The Coroner, who witnessed Brigadier Bornholdt’s apology, said the Army had “been accountable in my view and have accepted fault and have made an abject and genuine apology.”·The Coroner remarked, with justification, that “[i]n all my years as a Coroner I do not think that I’ve seen a better or more commendable institutional response to fault discovered within the institution that has lead to death”.·Since Trooper Lawrence’s death the Army has provided support and comfort to his family and his fiancée. Conclusions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MADGWICK J

Full text does not contain this section.