Comcare v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 718 647)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Comcare v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 718 647) [2010] FCA 793

Citation: Comcare v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 718 647) [2010] FCA 793
Parties: COMCARE v LINFOX AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 004 718 647)
File number: WAD 215 of 2009
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 27 July 2010
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW - Occupational Health And Safety - civil penalty - failure to take reasonable steps to protect health and safety - declaration as to contravention - imposition of pecuniary penalty - principles to be applied
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA
Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (Cth) ss 5, 16(1), 77, subcll 5(1) and 2(1)(a) of Sch 2, Pt 1
Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) s 68
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute (WA) (1999) 95 FCR 114
Comcare v Commonwealth (2009) 184 IR 441
Comcare v Commonwealth of Australia (2007) 163 FCR 207
Comcare v John Holland Rail Pty Ltd (2009) 188 IR 415
Comcare v National Gallery of Australia (2007) 98 ALD 67
Comcare v Post Logistics Australasia Pty Ltd (2008) 107 ALD 578
Date of hearing: 27 May 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 47
Counsel for the Applicant: LB Black
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent: M Shume
Solicitor for the Respondent: Sparke Helmore

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 215 of 2009

BETWEEN:

COMCARE
Applicant

AND:

LINFOX AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 004 718 647)
Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 MAY 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Pursuant to subclause 2(1)(a) of Schedule 2, Part 1 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (“the OHS Act”), on 19 December 2007, the Respondent breached section 16(1) of the OHS Act in that it failed to take all reasonably practicable steps to protect the health and safety at work of the employee, Bradley Jacobs, by:

1.1failing to provide and maintain a working environment, including plant and systems of work, that were safe for the employee and without risk to his health; and

1.2failing to provide the employee with adequate supervision to enable him to operate the Clark Omega 54D Dedicated Container Handler Fork Truck in a manner that was safe and without risk to health.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT

2.Pursuant to clause 4 of Schedule 2, Part 1 of the OHS Act, that the Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty of $150,000 in respect of the breach of section 16(1) of the OHS Act.

3.The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceedings, fixed at $25,000.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Comcare v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 718 647) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 793
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Comcare v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd, Comcare brought proceedings against Linfox for breaches of occupational health and safety laws, specifically under section 16(1) of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (Cth). The dispute arose from a workplace incident where Mr Bradley Jacobs, an employee of Linfox, was severely injured when the fork truck he was operating overturned. Comcare sought a declaration of contravention, along with an order for a pecuniary penalty against Linfox for failing to take reasonable steps to protect Mr Jacobs' health and safety.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether Linfox breached its duty under section 16(1) of the OHS Act by failing to take reasonable steps to protect Mr Jacobs' health and safety, and if so, whether the proposed pecuniary penalty was appropriate. The court also needed to consider the principles governing the imposition of penalties and the appropriateness of the declaration of contravention.

The court examined the agreed facts and submissions from both parties to determine whether Linfox had indeed failed to take reasonable steps to protect Mr Jacobs' health and safety. The court noted that the incident was a result of the fork truck striking a stack of containers, which led to the truck overturning. It was established that Linfox did not have adequate risk management practices in place to prevent such incidents. The court concluded that Linfox had contravened section 16(1) of the OHS Act by failing to ensure the health and safety of its employees. Regarding the penalty, the court found that the agreed penalty of $200,000 was within the range of appropriate figures and took into account the public interest in deterring future breaches.

The court made a declaration that Linfox contravened section 16(1) of the OHS Act and ordered Linfox to pay a pecuniary penalty of $200,000 to the Commonwealth. The decision underscored the importance of employers implementing adequate risk management practices to protect their employees' health and safety.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the orders appearing below were made in open court at that hearing. BACKGROUND Comcare is established pursuant to s 68 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act). It is authorised pursuant to s 77 and subcl 5(1) of Sch 2, Pt 1 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (Cth) (the OHS Act) to apply for relief in the circumstances affected by this proceeding. Linfox is and was an employer within the meaning of s 5 of the OHS Act. At relevant times it was a body corporate holding a licence under Pt VIII of the SRC Act and a non-commonwealth licensee within the meaning of s 5 of the OHS Act. On 31 August 2006, Linfox acquired a container yard located in Welshpool in Western Australia (the Site) as part of its corporate acquisition of FCL Interstate Transport Services Pty Ltd (FCL). The acquisition of FCL included the Site and employees at the Site amongst other assets and business. The Site is used for loading, storage and handling of freight containers as part of the Linfox Linehaul operations. Those operations relevant to the Site involve the transportation and storage of rail and truck freight containers. In addition, the Site is used as a transfer point for stock that is being moved between rail and road transport. Freight containers that are moved around the Site are moved with the use of large Dedicated Container Handler (DCH) fork trucks.THE ACCIDENT On 19 December 2007, Mr Bradley Jacobs (Mr Jacobs) who was employed by Linfox was operating a Clark Omega 54D DCH fork truck at the Site when the fork truck overturned pinning Mr Jacobs in its cab. Mr Jacobs sustained very serious and extensive crush injuries to his left arm and both legs (the incident). On the same day, he had commenced work on a late shift at 8.11 am. At about 1.00 pm, Mr Jacobs started operating the fork truck and conducted between 40 and 60 container lifts. By about 5.00 pm, the only remaining tasks were to tidy the Site yard in preparation for the next day. Mr Jacobs was operating the fork truck to undertake this task and was aware that there was minimal traffic in the Site yard at the time. Tidying the Site yard involved clearing the front packing line which required moving loaded containers from the area where containers are loaded. Mr Jacobs was moving a container, loaded with steel casts from the front packing line to an old trailer at the rear of the yard. The container weighed approximately 32,000 kilograms and was 12.1 metres long, 2.5 metres wide and 2.6 metres high. Mr Jacobs was carrying the container at a height of about 8 metres along the south-eastern side of the dry shed which was located on the left side of the fork truck. The dry shed in turn is 55 metres long, along its south-eastern edge. A stack of containers was stacked four high on the right hand side of the carriageway. After passing the rear corner of the dry shed, the bottom, right hand side corner of the container struck the top stationary container of the nearby stack. The top of the stationary container was 8.2 metres above the ground. The collision caused the fork truck to flip forward onto its roof, trapping Mr Jacobs inside the cabin. Mr Jacobs’ left arm sustained severe crush injuries and his right leg was pinned to the floor of the cab of the fort truck by a large steel beam. He suffered severe crush injuries to both of his legs. He received initial first aid at the scene of the incident before being transported by ambulance to the Royal Perth Hospital for emergency treatment. He remained in hospital until approximately April 2008, over four months. INTERNAL RISK IDENTIFICATION AND MANAGEMENT

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 2 of the Sch 2 to the OHS Act provides:2 Declarations of contravention(1)If a court considers that a person has breached one of the following provisions, or was involved in such a breach, it must make a declaration that the person has contravened this subclause:(a)subsection 16(1) (duties of employers in relation to their employees etc.);… The parties have submitted that it is appropriate for the Court to inform itself of the facts necessary for the granting of declaratory relief by reference to the statement of agreed facts, the agreed statement of claim and the consent of the parties to the granting of the declaratory relief (see Comcare v Post Logistics Australasia Pty Ltd (2008) 107 ALD 578 (at [24]). Where a declaration is made under subcl 2(1), the Court may also order the person to pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty which must not exceed the amount stated in the table to the maximum penalty to be the maximum penalty in relation to the provisions concerned. The maximum penalty prescribed for a contravention of s 16(1) (in cl 2) is 2,200 penalty units. At the relevant time, a penalty unit was defined by s 4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) as being $110. It follows that the maximum penalty for a breach of s 16(1) of the OHS Act is $242,000. The view taken by Gyles J in Comcare v National Gallery of Australia (2007) 98 ALD 67 was that the approach to be taken for the Court when parties have reached agreement as to the quantum of a pecuniary penalty was not so much a matter of the Court deciding what figure should be proposed. His Honour said (at [8]) ‘a commonsense approach is to take the agreed figure and give consideration to whether it is within the range of appropriate figures …’ But the role of the Court is, by no means, one of mere rubber stamping. As French J said in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute (WA) (1999) 95 FCR 114 (at [37]-[39]:[37]As I observed in the reasons for judgment in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79 there is a general principle of judicial restraint in the scrutiny of proposed settlements which was enunciated early in the history of the Trade Practices Act. It is not the function of the Court to impede settlements between parties legally represented and able to understand and evaluate the desirability of agreeing to a settlement nor to refuse to give effect to terms of settlement by refusing to make orders or accept undertakings where they are within the Court's jurisdiction and are otherwise unobjectionable. The Court will not substitute its own view of the orders or undertakings which it would have made if those proffered fall within the range of an appropriate disposition in the case. [38]Nevertheless, in the making of consent orders and the acceptance of undertakings the Court must not exceed its power. The limitations affecting jurisdiction or power to grant the relief sought must be observed. The Court cannot put itself in the position of enforcing conduct which it has no capacity to command or compel. Parties cannot by consent confer power on the Court to make orders which the Court lacks power to make. Moreover the power of the Court to make orders is an exercise of power defined and conferred by public law. The Court, in exercising that power, does not merely give effect to the wishes of the parties. It exercises a public function and must have regard to the public interest in doing so. In consideration of the public interest, however, it must also weigh the desirability of non-litigious resolution of enforcement proceedings. [39]I respectfully accept, as I did previously, the observations of Merkel J in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Z-Tek Computer Pty Ltd (1997) 78 FCR 197 at 202; 148 ALR 339 at 343 that there must be a nexus between the conduct alleged or found to constitute the relevant contraventions and the injunctions granted. See also Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Office Link (Aust) Pty Ltd (1997) 19 ATPR 41-598. Whether there is a sufficient nexus between the orders sought and the contravention alleged involves an evaluative judgment.