Combined Civil Pty Ltd v Rikaloski

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Combined Civil Pty Ltd v Rikaloski [2007] NSWWCCPD 181

APPELLANT:  Combined Civil Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT:  Stanko Rikaloski

INSURER:CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd

FILE NUMBER:  WCC783-07

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          7 May 2007

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  20 August 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Boilermakers deafness; expert evidence; application of Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; right of Arbitrator to rely on his own experience in the absence of expert evidence

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Deputy President Bill Roche

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      TurksLegal

Respondent:   IDC Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The Arbitrator’s determination dated 7 May 2007 is revoked and the following order made:

“1.Award for the Respondent Employer.

2.No order as to costs.”

No order as to costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Stanko Rikaloski (‘the Respondent Worker/Mr Rikaloski’) worked for Combined Civil Pty Ltd (‘the Appellant Employer/Combined’) from 1994 until 13 September 2001 as a traffic controller for four hours per day seven days per week.  His duties were to change line posts on the road.  In the course of his work he was exposed to “noise of truck engines and traffic movements” (Mr Rikaloski’s statutory declaration 2 February 2007, paragraph six).  As a result of that noise he was “not able to communicate with co-workers at a normal conversational level” but had to “shout in order to be heard” (Mr Rikaloski’s statutory declaration 2 February 2007, paragraph seven).

  1. He has not worked since ceasing employment with Combined in September 2001.  On 13 January 2003 he went onto the disability pension.

  1. He completed an “Industrial Deafness - Notice of Injury Form” on 22 January 2005.  On 9 June 2005 Dr Lucchese assessed him to have a 9.2% binaural hearing loss, after adjustment for his age.  By letter dated 23 June 2005 Mr Rikaloski claimed the sum of $5,980.00 in respect of 9.2% binaural hearing loss.

  1. His claim was denied by letter dated 9 March 2006 from CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘CGU’) on the basis of evidence from Dr Carroll in his report of 24 November 2005.

  1. An Application to Resolve a Dispute (‘the Application’) was registered in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) on 8 February 2007 claiming lump sum compensation as particularised in the letter of 23 June 2005.

  1. By its Reply filed on 23 March 2007 Combined disputed liability on the grounds that Mr Rikaloski had not been employed by it in employment to the nature of which hearing loss was due, he suffered no hearing loss and it was not the last entity to employ Mr Rikaloski in employment to the nature of which hearing loss was due.

  1. The matter was listed for conciliation and arbitration before a Commission Arbitrator on 4 May 2007 when it proceeded to arbitration.  In an ex tempore decision the Arbitrator found in favour of Mr Rikaloski. 

  1. In an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Combined Civil Pty Ltd v Rikaloski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Combined Civil Pty Ltd (Appellant) appealed against a decision of an arbitrator (Arbitrator) in favour of Stanko Rikaloski (Respondent) in respect of a claim for compensation for a hearing loss allegedly caused by noise exposure during his employment as a traffic controller. The appeal was heard on the papers by Deputy President Bill Roche. The primary issue before the Deputy President was whether the Arbitrator erred in his determination that Combined Civil Pty Ltd was the Respondent’s last noisy employer. The Deputy President found that there was no evidence to support the Arbitrator’s findings that the Respondent’s employment involved a real risk of hearing loss. The Deputy President held that the Arbitrator’s determination contained an error of law in that it failed to require expert evidence of the level of noise to which the Respondent was exposed, the period of exposure and whether those two factors were sufficient to result in the employment being employment to the nature of which boilermaker’s deafness was due. The Deputy President found that in the absence of appropriate expert evidence, the Respondent’s claim must fail. Accordingly, the Arbitrator’s determination was revoked and an award for the Respondent Employer was dismissed. No order as to costs was made.

Background

Background to the litigation

Stanko Rikaloski worked for Combined Civil Pty Ltd as a traffic controller from 1994 until September 2001, where he was exposed to noise from truck engines and traffic movements. He was unable to communicate with co-workers at a normal conversational level and had to shout in order to be heard. Rikaloski did not work after leaving employment with Combined and went on the disability pension in January 2003. In June 2005, Dr Lucchese assessed him to have a 9.2% binaural hearing loss, after age adjustment. Rikaloski claimed compensation for his hearing loss, which was denied by CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited based on a report from Dr Carroll. An Application to Resolve a Dispute was registered in the Workers Compensation Commission on 8 February 2007. The matter proceeded to arbitration before a Commission Arbitrator on 4 May 2007, who found in favour of Rikaloski. Combined Civil Pty Ltd appealed the Arbitrator's decision on 29 May 2007.

The matter originated as an Application to Resolve a Dispute registered in the Workers Compensation Commission on 8 February 2007. Combined Civil Pty Ltd disputed liability in its Reply filed on 23 March 2007. The case was listed for conciliation and arbitration on 4 May 2007 before a Commission Arbitrator, who found in favour of Rikaloski. Combined Civil Pty Ltd filed an 'Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator' on 29 May 2007, seeking leave to appeal the Arbitrator's decision. The appeal was heard by Deputy President Bill Roche on the papers and determined on 20 August 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that Combined was contracted to construct roads.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that Mr Rikaloski's work site would have included various pieces of road construction machinery.
3. Whether the Arbitrator erred in assuming that Mr Rikaloski was exposed to noise from road construction machinery.
4. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that employment in the road construction industry was employment to the nature of which hearing loss was due.
5. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that employment in the road construction industry would average out at around 85 decibels per working day.
6. Whether the Arbitrator erred in relying on his own experience to conclude that employment in the road construction industry would have averaged out at around 85 decibels per working day.
7. Whether the Arbitrator misunderstood and incorrectly applied the law in relation to the test for noisy employment.
8. Whether the Arbitrator erred in giving no reasons for preferring the history taken by Dr Lucchese over that taken by Dr Carroll.
9. Whether the Arbitrator erred in making his decision without any reference to the evidence.

Held
1. The appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator is allowed.
2. The Arbitrator's finding that Combined was contracted to construct roads is incorrect as it was not supported by the evidence.
3. The Arbitrator's finding that Mr Rikaloski's work site would have included various pieces of road construction machinery is incorrect as it was not supported by the evidence.
4. The Arbitrator's assumption that Mr Rikaloski was exposed to noise from road construction machinery is incorrect as it was not supported by the evidence.
5. The Arbitrator's finding that employment in the road construction industry was employment to the nature of which hearing loss was due is incorrect as it was not supported by the evidence.
6. The Arbitrator's finding that employment in the road construction industry would average out at around 85 decibels per working day is incorrect as it was not supported by the evidence.
7. The Arbitrator's reliance on his own experience to conclude that employment in the road construction industry would have averaged out at around 85 decibels per working day is incorrect.
8. The Arbitrator misunderstood and incorrectly applied the law in relation to the test for noisy employment as stated in Callaby v State Transit Authority (NSW) & another and in Blayney Shire Council v Lobley & another.
9. The Arbitrator did not give any reasons for preferring the history taken by Dr Lucchese over that taken by Dr Carroll.
10. The Arbitrator made his decision without any reference to the evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator was allowed because the Arbitrator erred in several respects. Firstly, the Arbitrator erred in finding that Combined was contracted to construct roads as there was no evidence to support this finding. Secondly, the Arbitrator erred in finding that Mr Rikaloski's work site would have included various pieces of road construction machinery as there was no evidence to support this finding. Thirdly, the Arbitrator erred in assuming that Mr Rikaloski was exposed to noise from road construction machinery as there was no evidence to support this assumption. Fourthly, the Arbitrator erred in finding that employment in the road construction industry was employment to the nature of which hearing loss was due as there was no evidence to support this finding. Fifthly, the Arbitrator erred in finding that employment in the road construction industry would average out at around 85 decibels per working day as there was no evidence to support this finding. Sixthly, the Arbitrator erred in relying on his own experience to conclude that employment in the road construction industry would have averaged out at around 85 decibels per working day. Seventhly, the Arbitrator misunderstood and incorrectly applied the law in relation to the test for noisy employment as stated in Callaby v State Transit Authority (NSW) & another and in Blayney Shire Council v Lobley & another. The Arbitrator failed to consider the requirements of Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles in evaluating the expert evidence. Eighthly, the Arbitrator did not give any reasons for preferring the history taken by Dr Lucchese over that taken by Dr Carroll. Finally, the Arbitrator made his decision without any reference to the evidence. The absence of appropriate expert evidence on the matters in issue meant that Mr Rikaloski's claim must fail. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Commission is not an expert tribunal in matters of injury and causation, and requires appropriate expert evidence to make findings in these areas.