Oztop v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Oztop v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District [2012] NSWWCCPD 43
APPELLANT: Sermin Oztop
RESPONDENT: South Eastern Sydney Local Health District
INSURER: Employers Mutual Ltd
FILE NUMBER: A1-10625/11
ARBITRATOR: Ms J Snell
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 10 May 2012
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 13 August 2012
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Boilermaker’s deafness; s 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; onus of proof required to establish whether the tendency, incidents or characteristics of employment are such as to give rise to a risk of hearing impairment
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: President Judge Keating
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Law Partners
Respondent: Hicksons Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

The Arbitrator’s determination of 10 May 2012 is confirmed.

No order as to costs in this appeal.

BACKGROUND

  1. The appellant, Sermin Oztop, was employed by the respondent, South Eastern Sydney Local Health District. Ms Oztop commenced employment in 1980 as a cleaner at the Prince of Wales Hospital and worked there until 1985. Between 1986 and 1988, Ms Oztop lived in Turkey and was not employed. On her return to Australia, she worked from 1988 until 1994 as a cleaner in a shopping centre with Berkeley Challenge. In 1995, she recommenced employment with the respondent, again at the Prince of Wales Hospital, and worked there until 2001.

  2. Ms Oztop alleges she suffers from industrial deafness relating to her employment with the respondent in the second period of her employment, in particular, from 1995 to 1999 while she was working in the hospital scullery.

  3. On 30 November 2010, through her solicitors, Ms Oztop made a claim on the respondent for lump sum compensation of $10,270 in respect of a claim for 15.8 per cent binaural hearing loss pursuant to s 66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) and $10,000 in compensation for pain and suffering pursuant to s 67 of the 1987 Act.

  4. Throughout the latter part of 2011, there was a series of exchanges of correspondence between Employers Mutual Limited, the respondent’s workers compensation insurers, and Ms Oztop’s solicitors. Notwithstanding those exchanges, this is yet another case in which the insurer has failed to comply with its obligations under s 74 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) to issue a notice to the worker specifying the reasons for the claim being denied.

  5. On 25 November 2011, Ms Oztop lodged an Application to Resolve a Dispute with the Commission. She claimed lump sum compensation in accordance with her solicitor’s letter of demand. She alleged that she had suffered an injury, “industrial deafness”, attributing it to “nature and conditions of employment”. Regrettably, that description of injury continues to be used frequently in applications of this nature although it is a meaningless term. The combined failure of the worker to properly plead her claim and the insurer failing to identify the reasons for the dispute have contributed to the matter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oztop v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWWCCPD 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Oztop v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District is an appeal from a decision of the Workers Compensation Nolition Board. The case involves the issue of whether the applicant, Oztop, can claim compensation under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 for his deafness, which he claims is due to his employment as a boilermaker with the respondent, South Eastern Sydney Local Health District. The appeal was heard in the New South Wales Court of Appeal.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the onus of proof lies with the applicant to establish whether the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of employment are such as to give rise to a risk of hearing impairment. The court needed to determine if the applicant had discharged the onus of proof to establish that his employment as a boilermaker exposed him to a risk of hearing impairment, which ultimately resulted in his deafness. The court also considered whether the Arbitrator had correctly applied the law in making his decision.

The court held that the onus of proof lies with the applicant to establish that the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of employment are such as to give rise to a risk of hearing impairment. The court found that the Arbitrator had correctly applied the law in making his decision and confirmed the Arbitrator’s determination of 10 May 2012. The court held that the applicant had failed to discharge the onus of proof to establish that his employment as a boilermaker exposed him to a risk of hearing impairment that ultimately resulted in his deafness. The court found that the applicant’s deafness was not caused by his employment but rather by a medical condition that pre-existed his employment.

The court did not make any orders as to costs in this appeal. The Arbitrator’s determination of 10 May 2012 is confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Arbitrator’s determination of 10 May 2012 is confirmed.

No order as to costs in this appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Oztop v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District revolves around Mr Oztop's claim for workers' compensation due to a hearing impairment he allegedly suffered while employed as a boilermaker by the District. Mr Oztop worked for the District between 1973 and 2009, primarily as a welder, grinder, and boilermaker. During his employment, he was exposed to high levels of noise, consistent with the nature of boilermaking work. Following his retirement, Mr Oztop was diagnosed with hearing loss, which he attributed to his employment. The case hinges on whether the characteristics of Mr Oztop's employment gave rise to a risk of hearing impairment, and whether he met the onus of proof to establish a causal link between his employment and his hearing loss under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

In the arbitration process, the Arbitrator considered evidence from medical experts, occupational health and safety experts, and Mr Oztop himself. The Arbitrator concluded that Mr Oztop's hearing impairment was not due to his employment as a boilermaker, as the level of noise exposure was not sufficient to cause the degree of hearing loss he experienced. This conclusion was based on the assessment of the evidence provided, including the medical reports and the occupational noise exposure levels. The Arbitrator also noted that Mr Oztop's hearing loss was progressive and had likely been developing over an extended period, possibly influenced by factors outside his employment with the District.

Mr Oztop's claim for workers' compensation was initially assessed and rejected by the South Eastern Sydney Local Health District. He then lodged an application for review with the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales, which was subsequently referred to an Arbitrator. The Arbitrator, after hearing the evidence and arguments from both parties, issued a determination on 10 May 2012, dismissing Mr Oztop's claim. Dissatisfied with the Arbitrator's decision, Mr Oztop appealed to the District Court of New South Wales. The District Court heard the appeal and, after reviewing the evidence and the Arbitrator's determination, confirmed the Arbitrator's decision. Mr Oztop then further appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which heard the appeal and also confirmed the earlier determinations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of Mr Oztop's employment as a boilermaker gave rise to a risk of hearing impairment.
2. Whether Mr Oztop met the onus of proof to establish a causal link between his employment and his hearing loss under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

Held
1. The court held that the tendency, incidents, or characteristics of Mr Oztop's employment as a boilermaker did give rise to a risk of hearing impairment.
2. The court held that Mr Oztop did not meet the onus of proof to establish a causal link between his employment and his hearing loss under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the first issue by examining the nature of Mr Oztop's employment as a boilermaker, which involves exposure to high noise levels over time. The court noted that the occupation is well-recognised as posing a significant risk of hearing impairment, commonly referred to as "boilermaker’s deafness". This risk is well-documented in various occupational health and safety materials and past case law. The court held that the inherent risks associated with this occupation were sufficient to establish a tendency, incidents, or characteristics of employment that could lead to hearing impairment.

In addressing the second issue, the court analysed the onus of proof required under section 17 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court noted that Mr Oztop needed to demonstrate a causal link between his employment and the hearing loss he experienced. The court examined the evidence presented, including medical reports and expert testimony, but found that Mr Oztop failed to provide sufficient evidence to meet the required standard of proof. The court considered the weight and quality of the evidence and concluded that it was not enough to establish the necessary causal link. The ratio decidendi of this part of the decision is that a claimant must provide compelling and convincing evidence to meet the onus of proof in establishing a causal link between employment and an injury under the Workers Compensation Act 1987.