Pavleski v ISS Property Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Pavleski v ISS Property Services Pty Ltd [2023] NSWPIC 263

APPLICANT: Slave Pavleski
RESPONDENT: ISS Property Services Pty Ltd
Member: Cameron Burge
DATE OF DECISION: 6 June 2023

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Hearing loss; claim for hearing aids; whether respondent was a noisy employer; Held – the respondent was the last employer by whom the worker was employed in an employment to the nature of which his binaural hearing loss was due; although much of the equipment which the applicant used did not expose him to noise above the relevant threshold, he nevertheless was repeatedly exposed to prolonged noise from a petrol powered leaf blower for up to two hours per day, which the evidence discloses had a noise level greater than 90 decibels; although the respondent’s lay witnesses provided evidence that the applicant did not have to use the leaf blower for as long as he stated he had to, they were not regular attendees in the workplace and were not familiar with his work routines; respondent ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to the applicant’s proposed hearing aids.

determinations made:

1.     The applicant suffered an injury in the nature of hearing loss caused by a gradual process as a result of his employment with the respondent which was the last employer by whom the worker was employed in an employment to the nature of which the injury was due, with deemed date of injury of 1 August 2021.

2.     As a result of the injury referred to in [1] above, the applicant requires the provision of hearing aids which are reasonably necessary.

3.     The respondent is to pay the costs of and incidental to the quotation for hearing aids of Susan Helfand dated 20 July 2022 set out at page 89 of the attachments to the Application to Resolve a Dispute.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Slave Pavleski (the applicant) was employed as a school cleaner by ISS Property Services (the respondent) for approximately 15 years up to approximately August 2021. While working for the respondent, the applicant carried out his duties at Woolooware Public School and Lilli Pilli Public School as cleaner.

  2. The applicant described his relevant duties which allegedly involved noisy employment as including the use of a petrol operated leaf blower at Lilli Pilli Public School between one to two hours per day, five days per week. He also used a leaf blower at Woolooware Public School.

  3. The applicant states that he used a number of items of noisy equipment during the course of his employment. However, much of the alleged noisiness is disputed by the respondent. The respondent disputes that it was the last noisy employer for whom the applicant worked and raises a dispute pursuant to s 16 of the Worker’s Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act).

  4. The applicant brings these proceedings seeking payment by the respondent for hearing aids said to be reasonably necessary as a result of by normal hearing loss suffered in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pavleski v ISS Property Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pavleski v ISS Property Services Pty Ltd involved a claim by the applicant, Pavleski, against the respondent, ISS Property Services Pty Ltd, for compensation related to hearing loss sustained during employment. The central issue before the court was whether the respondent, as the last employer, was responsible for the applicant's hearing impairment, which the applicant attributed to the prolonged exposure to noise from equipment used during his employment. The applicant specifically sought reimbursement for the cost of hearing aids.

The legal issues the court needed to address included determining whether the respondent was indeed the last employer in relation to the employment that caused the hearing loss, and if the equipment used by the applicant, particularly a petrol-powered leaf blower, exposed him to noise levels that could cause such impairment. The court also had to assess the credibility of the evidence provided by both parties regarding the extent of the applicant's exposure to the noise from the leaf blower.

In its reasoning, the court determined that the respondent was the last employer by whom the applicant was employed in the type of work that led to his binaural hearing loss. The court found that while much of the equipment used by the applicant did not exceed the noise threshold, the petrol-powered leaf blower did expose him to noise levels over 90 decibels for up to two hours daily. The court deemed the lay witnesses for the respondent, who suggested the applicant did not use the leaf blower as long as claimed, to be less credible due to their infrequent presence at the workplace and unfamiliarity with the applicant's routines. Consequently, the court ruled that the respondent was liable for the costs of the applicant's proposed hearing aids.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Pavleski v ISS Property Services Pty Ltd involves a claim for workers' compensation by the applicant, Pavleski, against the respondent, ISS Property Services Pty Ltd, for a binaural hearing loss. Pavleski was employed by ISS Property Services Pty Ltd as a cleaner. During his employment, Pavleski was exposed to noise from various cleaning equipment, including a petrol powered leaf blower. Pavleski alleged that the prolonged exposure to noise, particularly from the leaf blower, contributed to his hearing loss. Pavleski sought compensation for the hearing loss, including the costs of acquiring hearing aids. The central factual issue was the extent and duration of Pavleski's exposure to noise from the leaf blower and whether this exposure was sufficient to cause his hearing loss.

The matter initially arose from Pavleski's claim for workers' compensation lodged with the respondent. Following the initial claim, the matter proceeded to a hearing before a tribunal, where Pavleski argued that his hearing loss was due to his employment with ISS Property Services Pty Ltd. The tribunal had to determine whether ISS Property Services Pty Ltd was the last employer responsible for Pavleski's hearing loss, and if so, whether Pavleski was entitled to compensation. The tribunal also considered the evidence provided by Pavleski and the respondent, including expert opinions on noise exposure and the impact on hearing. The tribunal made a determination on whether Pavleski's hearing loss was work-related and if the respondent was liable for compensation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was ISS Property Services Pty Ltd the last employer by whom Pavleski was employed in an employment to the nature of which his binaural hearing loss was due?
2. Was Pavleski exposed to noise levels from the petrol powered leaf blower that could have caused his hearing loss?
3. If Pavleski's hearing loss was work-related, is the respondent liable for the costs of Pavleski’s proposed hearing aids?

Held
1. The court concluded that ISS Property Services Pty Ltd was the last employer by whom Pavleski was employed in an employment to the nature of which his binaural hearing loss was due.
2. The court found that Pavleski was exposed to noise levels from the petrol powered leaf blower that could have caused his hearing loss, despite the majority of the equipment he used not exposing him to noise above the relevant threshold.
3. The court held that if Pavleski's hearing loss was work-related, the respondent is liable for the costs of Pavleski’s proposed hearing aids.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether ISS Property Services Pty Ltd was the last employer by whom Pavleski was employed in an employment to the nature of which his binaural hearing loss was due, the court examined the nature of Pavleski's employment and the specific activities that led to his exposure to noise. The court noted that Pavleski's duties involved using various tools and equipment, including a petrol powered leaf blower which exposed him to prolonged noise exceeding 90 decibels. The court considered the testimonies of Pavleski and the respondent’s lay witnesses, finding that Pavleski’s evidence was more credible due to his direct involvement and familiarity with his work routines. Therefore, the court concluded that ISS Property Services Pty Ltd was indeed the last employer responsible for Pavleski's exposure to the conditions that caused his hearing loss.

Regarding the second issue, the court assessed the noise levels Pavleski was exposed to while using the petrol powered leaf blower. It was established that this equipment had a noise level greater than 90 decibels, which could potentially cause hearing loss. The testimonies from Pavleski and the lay witnesses were closely examined. While the lay witnesses argued that Pavleski did not use the leaf blower for as long as he claimed, their infrequent presence in the workplace and lack of familiarity with Pavleski's routines made their testimony less reliable. Consequently, the court accepted Pavleski's account, determining that his exposure to the leaf blower's noise was a significant factor in his hearing loss.

Lastly, the court addressed the liability of ISS Property Services Pty Ltd for the costs of Pavleski’s proposed hearing aids. Given the findings that Pavleski’s hearing loss was work-related and that the respondent was the last employer responsible for his exposure to hazardous noise levels, the court ruled that the respondent is liable for the costs. The decision is based on the principle that employers are responsible for providing a safe working environment and compensating employees for injuries sustained as a result of their employment. The court ordered ISS Property Services Pty Ltd to pay the costs of and incidental to Pavleski’s proposed hearing aids, establishing a binding legal principle in this regard.