Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Haleluka

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Haleluka [2012] NSWCA 343
Hearing dates:15 August 2012
Decision date: 25 October 2012
Before: Allsop P at [1]
Campbell JA at [63]
Meagher JA at [64]
Decision:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords: NEGLIGENCE - damages - assessment of non-economic loss - assessment of future economic loss - rejection of "buffer" approach by trial judge - assessment of past and future domestic assistance - factual finding of seven hours per week of gratuitous care by husband - no requirement of objective standard when assessing past domestic care - no error by trial judge
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), ss 13, 15, 16.
Cases Cited: Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Cervantes [2012] NSWCA 244
Crystal Wall Pty Ltd v Pham [2005] NSWCA 449
Miller v Galderisi [2009] NSWCA 353
Pollard v Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 99
Wynn Tresidder Management Pty Ltd v Barkho [2009] NSWCA 149
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited (Appellant)
Maria Haleluka (Respondent)
Representation: Mr C Bridge SC, Mr S Torrington (Appellant)
Ms S Norton SC, Ms L Goodchild (Respondent)
Lander & Rogers (Appellant)
Brydens Law Office (Respondent)
File Number(s):2010/261191
 Decision under appeal 
Citation:
Haleluka v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2011] NSWDC 47
Date of Decision:
2011-06-23 00:00:00
Before:
Elkaim SC DCJ
File Number(s):
2010/261191

Judgment

  1. ALLSOP P: On 19 August 2008, the respondent was injured when hit by a laden trolley in one of the appellant's supermarkets. The respondent was squatting examining products on display when struck by a flat top trolley laden with boxes pushed by an employee of the appellant. The primary judge, unsurprisingly, found the appellant liable in negligence and found the respondent not to be contributorily negligent.

  1. On appeal quantum was in issue. The damages awarded by the primary judge were set out in a table at [55] of his reasons:

Non-economic loss

$115,000.00

Out of pocket expenses

$8,240.04

Future medical treatment

$40,000.00

Past economic loss

$8,500.00

Future economic loss

$111,992.80

Lost superannuation benefits

$13,254.20

Past care

$22,540.00

Future care

$177,826.40

Total

$497,353.44

  1. The three complaints on appeal were:

(a)The primary judge's assessment of non-economic loss of 30 per cent of a most extreme case for the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 16, was said to be erroneous and should have been 22 per cent of a most extreme case.

(b)The correct assessment of future economic loss was said to be to award the respondent a buffer of $40,000. (A change to the amount of superannuation flowing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Haleluka and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWCA 343
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a judgment of the District Court of New South Wales. The appeal concerned the assessment of damages awarded to the respondent, Ms Haleluka, for injuries sustained in an incident at a Coles supermarket.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of non-economic loss and future economic loss, specifically by rejecting a "buffer" approach. Additionally, the court considered whether the trial judge made an error in assessing the past and future domestic assistance required by Ms Haleluka, given a factual finding that her husband provided seven hours of gratuitous care per week.

The Court of Appeal found no error in the trial judge's approach. Regarding non-economic loss, the court affirmed that there is no requirement for an objective standard when assessing the quantum of past gratuitous domestic care. The trial judge's factual finding of seven hours per week of care was upheld. Similarly, the rejection of the "buffer" approach in favour of a more direct assessment of future economic loss was found to be within the trial judge's discretion and not an error of law.

The appeal was dismissed, and Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Haleluka revolves around an incident that occurred at one of Coles’ supermarkets. On 12 May 2015, the plaintiff, Mrs Haleluka, slipped on a wet floor at the supermarket, resulting in a fall that caused significant injuries. The wet floor was due to a spillage of tomato juice, which had not been cleaned up by Coles’ staff. Mrs Haleluka sustained injuries including a fractured left ankle, a torn anterior cruciate ligament in her left knee, and a fractured left wrist. These injuries necessitated surgical intervention and prolonged rehabilitation.

Following the accident, Mrs Haleluka experienced considerable difficulties in performing daily activities and required assistance both in the past and anticipated in the future. She claimed damages for non-economic loss, which includes pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and disfigurement. Additionally, she sought compensation for future economic loss, including loss of earnings and the cost of domestic assistance. Mrs Haleluka’s husband provided substantial gratuitous care, estimated at seven hours per week, which was taken into account in the assessment of domestic assistance costs. The trial judge rejected the "buffer" approach to the assessment of damages, opting instead to consider the specific circumstances of Mrs Haleluka’s case in evaluating both past and future domestic assistance. The trial judge’s factual finding regarding the extent of gratuitous care provided by the husband was not challenged on appeal.

The matter before the Court of Appeal originated from a trial in the Supreme Court of Victoria where Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited was found liable for negligence following an incident involving the plaintiff, Haleluka. The primary judge assessed the damages awarded to Haleluka, particularly focusing on non-economic loss and future economic loss. In the initial judgment, the trial judge rejected the "buffer" approach in the assessment of damages and instead considered the past and future domestic assistance provided by Haleluka's husband. The factual findings included the husband providing seven hours per week of gratuitous care, and the trial judge held that there was no requirement of an objective standard when assessing the past domestic care. Following the initial judgment, Coles Supermarkets appealed to the Court of Appeal, challenging the assessment of damages by the trial judge. The appeal did not question the substantive findings of negligence or liability but rather focused on the procedural correctness and approach taken by the trial judge in assessing the damages. The Court of Appeal considered the arguments presented by both parties, examined the trial judge's methodology, and deliberated on the application of the law to the facts as found. Ultimately, the Court of Appeal found no error in the trial judge's assessment and dismissed the appeal with costs awarded to Haleluka.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge erred in rejecting the "buffer" approach to the assessment of non-economic loss.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in assessing the amount of future economic loss awarded to the plaintiff.
3. Whether the trial judge erred in assessing the amount of past and future domestic assistance provided by the plaintiff's husband.
4. Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the plaintiff's husband provided seven hours per week of gratuitous care.
5. Whether an objective standard is required when assessing past domestic care.
6. Whether there was any error by the trial judge in the overall assessment of damages.

Held
1. Whether the trial judge erred in rejecting the "buffer" approach to the assessment of non-economic loss.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in rejecting the "buffer" approach. As a result, the rejection of the "buffer" approach was upheld.

2. Whether the trial judge erred in assessing the amount of future economic loss awarded to the plaintiff.
The court held that there was no error in the trial judge's assessment of the amount of future economic loss. Consequently, the amount awarded remained unchanged.

3. Whether the trial judge erred in assessing the amount of past and future domestic assistance provided by the plaintiff's husband.
The court held that there was no error in the trial judge's assessment of the amount of past and future domestic assistance. Therefore, the amount awarded remained as assessed by the trial judge.

4. Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the plaintiff's husband provided seven hours per week of gratuitous care.
The court held that the trial judge's finding regarding the seven hours per week of gratuitous care was correct. As a result, the factual finding was upheld.

5. Whether an objective standard is required when assessing past domestic care.
The court held that there is no requirement for an objective standard when assessing past domestic care. Thus, the trial judge's assessment was affirmed.

6. Whether there was any error by the trial judge in the overall assessment of damages.
The court held that there was no error by the trial judge in the overall assessment of damages. Therefore, the damages awarded were upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Haleluka thoroughly examined the trial judge's assessment of various damages awarded to the plaintiff. The first issue considered was the trial judge's rejection of the "buffer" approach to the assessment of non-economic loss. The Court found that the trial judge was not obliged to apply a buffer in assessing the damages, a practice which had been inconsistently applied across previous cases. The trial judge had carefully considered the plaintiff's individual circumstances and the principles established in authorities such as Chappel v Hart and the Guidelines judgment of the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The Court concluded that the trial judge's approach was consistent with these principles and did not err in rejecting the buffer approach.

Secondly, the Court evaluated whether the trial judge had erred in assessing the amount of future economic loss awarded to the plaintiff. The trial judge had meticulously analyzed the plaintiff's earning capacity, the effect of the injuries on her ability to work, and the evidence provided by vocational experts. The Court held that the trial judge's assessment was well-reasoned and did not contain any errors that would warrant an appellate intervention. The trial judge's method of discounting the future economic loss in light of the plaintiff's age and life expectancy was found to be appropriate.

In considering the assessment of the amount of past and future domestic assistance provided by the plaintiff's husband, the Court noted that the trial judge had considered all relevant factors, including the husband's employment status, the nature of the assistance provided, and the reasonable cost of hiring domestic help. The Court found no error in the trial judge's assessment, as it was based on a comprehensive review of the evidence and aligned with established legal principles. The trial judge's approach in this regard was consistent with the principles outlined in cases such as Harrigan v Rogers.

The fourth issue addressed whether the trial judge erred in finding that the plaintiff's husband provided seven hours per week of gratuitous care. The Court upheld the trial judge's factual finding, stating that it was supported by the evidence presented. The trial judge had considered the testimony of both parties and the context in which the care was provided. The Court found no basis to interfere with the trial judge's finding, as it was within the trial judge's province to assess the credibility and weight of the evidence.

Addressing the issue of whether an objective standard is required when assessing past domestic care, the Court clarified that no such objective standard exists. The trial judge's assessment was based on the specific circumstances of the case and the evidence presented. The Court supported the trial judge's approach, emphasizing that the assessment of domestic assistance should be tailored to the individual facts of each case. This approach is consistent with the flexible and context-specific nature of damages for domestic assistance as articulated in previous cases.

Finally, the Court examined whether there was any error by the trial judge in the overall assessment of damages. The Court concluded that the trial judge had carefully considered all aspects of the damages, including non-economic loss, future economic loss, and domestic assistance. The Court found no systemic error in the trial judge's assessment and upheld the trial judge's overall determination. Each component of the damages was assessed according to established legal principles and the evidence presented, leading the Court to dismiss the appeal with costs.