CNN16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CNN16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR   [2018] FCCA 480
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial review – decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – refusal of a Protection Visa– whether failure to properly consider an integer of the claim –whether jurisdictional error.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.65, 474, 476

Cases cited:

ApplicantWAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630; [2003] FCAFC 184
Craig v State of South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163; (1995) 39 ALD 193; (1995) 131 ALR 595; (1995) 69 ALJR 873; (1995) 82 A Crim R 359; [1995] HCA 58
Htun v Minister of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 233 FCR 136; (2001) 194 ALR 244; [2001] FCA 1802
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323; (2001) 62 ALD 225; (2001) 180 ALR 1; (2001) 75 ALJR 1105; (2001) 22(11) Leg Rep 2; [2001] HCA 30
MZWDG v Minister for Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCA 497

Applicant: CNN16 
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION 
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 1933 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge Kendall
Hearing date: 8 February 2018
Date of Last Submission: 8 February 2018
Delivered at: Perth
Delivered on: 2 March 2018

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Free
Solicitor for the Applicant: Victoria Legal Aid
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Goodwin
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second Respondent: No Appearance
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. By consent, the time for the bringing of these proceedings is extended up to and including 8 September 2016.

  2. The application filed on 8 September 2016, amended on 11 January 2018, is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 1933 of 2016

CNN16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The applicant is a 31-year-old man from Parachinar, Upper Kurram Agency, Pakistan (Court Book (“CB”) l17).

  2. He is a Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity and a member of the Turi tribe (CB l17). 

  3. On 8 September 2016, the applicant filed an application seeking judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (“the Tribunal”) dated 2 August 2016 (“the Tribunal Decision”).  

  4. The Tribunal affirmed a decision made by a delegate of the first respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, as he was then (“the Minister”), on 12 July 2013, refusing to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  5. In support of his application before this Court, the applicant raised one ground of review. Specifically, he argued that the Tribunal had constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction by failing to consider an integer of the applicant’s claims – namely, that he feared serious and/or significant harm from     Islamic State in his home region of Parachinar in Pakistan.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CNN16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 480
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CNN16 was the applicant in proceedings before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, seeking judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Tribunal had affirmed a delegate's decision to refuse the applicant a Protection visa. The applicant, a Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity from Pakistan, claimed he feared harm from various groups, including the Taliban and, crucially, Islamic State, in his home region of Parachinar.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Tribunal had committed a jurisdictional error by constructively failing to exercise its jurisdiction. This alleged failure stemmed from the applicant's contention that the Tribunal had not considered his specific fear of harm from Islamic State, which he argued was a distinct and significant integer of his claims.

The Court considered the applicant's submissions and the Tribunal's decision, noting that the Tribunal did not explicitly mention Islamic State. However, the Court found that the applicant had presented his fear of Islamic State in general terms, linking it to his broader concerns about threats from "Taliban and other Sunni groups." The Court adopted the first respondent's submission that the Tribunal's reference to "Taliban or Isis, or other sort of Sunni extremist groups" encompassed the applicant's specific concerns about Islamic State. The Court concluded that the applicant had effectively subsumed Islamic State into the general category of Sunni extremist groups, and the Tribunal's consideration of these broader threats meant it had not failed to consider the applicant's claims.

Consequently, the Court found that the Tribunal had not fallen into jurisdictional error as alleged by the applicant. By consent, the time for bringing the proceedings was extended, but the applicant's application was ultimately dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

By consent, the time for the bringing of these proceedings is extended up to and including 8 September 2016.

2.

The application filed on 8 September 2016, amended on 11 January 2018, is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

AT MELBOURNE

MLG 1933 of 2016

CNN16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

1.

The applicant is a 31-year-old man from Parachinar, Upper Kurram Agency, Pakistan (Court Book (“CB”) l17).

2.

He is a Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity and a member of the Turi tribe (CB l17).

3.

On 8 September 2016, the applicant filed an application seeking judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (“the Tribunal”) dated 2 August 2016 (“the Tribunal Decision”).

4.

The Tribunal affirmed a decision made by a delegate of the first respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, as he was then (“the Minister”), on 12 July 2013, refusing to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).

5.

In support of his application before this Court, the applicant raised one ground of review. Specifically, he argued that the Tribunal had constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction by failing to consider an integer of the applicant’s claims – namely, that he feared serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State in his home region of Parachinar in Pakistan.

Issue

6.

The Court must determine whether the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error in the manner alleged by the applicant.

Synopsis

7.

For the reasons that follow, the Court finds that the Tribunal did not fall into jurisdictional error in the manner alleged by the applicant.

8.

As a result, the Court dismisses the applicant’s application.

Background

9.

Having reviewed all of the material before it, including a detailed Court Book spanning 313 pages, the Court adopts the procedural and factual background to these proceedings outlined by the applicant at paragraph 4 to 33 in his Contentions of Law and Fact dated 11 January 2018. The background facts are, relevantly, as follows.

10.

On 22 June 2012, the applicant entered Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival. He was rescued by the Australian authorities after the boat he was travelling in capsized en route to Australia from Indonesia (CB 55, 72).

11.

On 24 June 2012, the applicant was interviewed by an officer of the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (as it then was) (“the Department”) (CB 9-14). He then claimed asylum in Australia (CB 11).

12.

On 20 July 2012, the applicant was interviewed by an officer of the Department using an "Irregular Maritime Arrival" interview protocol (CB 15-39).

13.

On 21 July 2012, the applicant was again interviewed by an officer of the Department using an "Irregular Maritime Arrival" interview protocol (CB 40-58). He maintained his claim for asylum in both these interviews (CB 31 and 52).

14.

On 21 November 2012, the applicant lodged an application for a Protection visa (CB 59-137). In a statutory declaration provided with that application, the applicant claimed that, as a Shia Muslim, he:

a) feared harm from the Taliban on the basis of his religion, ethnicity and tribal membership (CB ll7-122);

b) had been shot in November 2007, resulting in him having nine operations (CB 118);

c) had assisted a Shia group, Tharek Hussain, by bringing water, food, medicine and cigarettes to members. He would also carry injured fighters back to Parachinar city (CB 118);

d) had been targeted in Rawalpindi in 2009; specifically, a man on the street called out "Hey Turi" and shot at the applicant but did not hit him (CB 120); and

e) was at risk of being targeted in any part of Pakistan (CB 121).

15.

On 1 January 2013, the applicant’s legal representative provided a submission to the Department in relation to their client’s legal claims (CB 138-151).

16.

Relevantly, that submission provided:

In summary, our client fears persecution in Pakistan for the following reasons:

• Our client is 26 year olds [sic] and originates from the village of Ghosar, Parachinar in the Upper Kurram Agency in Pakistan. Around 12 years ago, [the applicant] and his family moved to the area of Eid Gah Colony within Parachinar city and remained in this area from this time. The neighbouring area to Eid Gah Colony was the predominately Sunni Muslim area of Akbar Khan.

• [The applicant] is a member of the Turi tribe, of Pashtun ethnicity and a follower of the Shia Muslim faith.

• From 2007 the situation in Parachinar become more and more dangerous as the Taliban and anti-Shia groups started to attack Shia Muslims living within this area. During this time many Turi men from Parachinar were being kidnapped and killed. The Taliban also started to block the roads leading out from Parachinar further into Pakistan which restricted access to Shia Muslims living in Parachinar to get access to food supplies and basic medical care.

• During the road closure, [the applicant’s] father had become ill after he was not able to get access to proper medication for his diabetes in Parachinar and ended up having to travel along the dangerous route through Afghanistan in order to get to the Peshawar hospital. [The applicant’s] father made the trip to Peshawar but died in the hospital.

• A number of Turis were also killed while trying to travelling [sic] along the roads blocked or occupied by the Taliban, including [the applicant’s] cousin … who was killed while transporting passengers in an ambulance from Parachinar city to Peshawar.

• [The applicant] believes the attacks were in retaliation for Turi elders speaking out against the Taliban and denying them access through Turi areas to the Afghan border.

• At this time the Taliban were trying to incite the Sunni Muslims in the neighbouring areas to target the Shia Muslims in Parachinar. Around November 2007 [the applicant] was shot while outside of his home in in [sic] Eid Gah Colony during fighting between members of the Turi tribe and Sunni Muslims from Akbar Khan. [The applicant] required 9 operations for his gun shot wound and believes that he would not have had to undertake this amount of treatment if he had been able to travel freely to Peshawar hospital.

• As a result of the fighting and increased Taliban attacks in [the applicant’s] area, a local group known as Tharek Hussain started to recruit people to help them defend the area. Tharek Hussain had previously been an organisation focused on providing financial support to certain groups in need in the area but after the fighting started in the area they become more focused on self-defense.

• From 2008 [the applicant] was pressured into providing assistance to Tharek Hussain and assisted by bringing water, food, medicine and cigarettes to members of the group involved in fighting against the Taliban and also carrying back fighters from the areas of fighting to Parachinar city to get treatment.

• In 2008 [the applicant] tried to start a business repairing computers but was restricted in being able to build this business due to his inability to travel freely to purchase parts and due to the dangers in Parachinar city that prevented him from going to his office regularly. As a result of these issues, [the applicant] started to work as a taxi driver in 2009 in order to try and get an income to support himself. However, [the applicant] was forced to stop this job as petrol had become very inexpensive [sic] due to the road closures and he was unable to obtain enough work that did not require him to travel to areas that placed him at risk.

• [The applicant] faced difficulties in furthering his studies as the road closures and dangers along the route to Peshwar meant he was limited to undertaking studies within Parachinar that was of a very poor standard and was lacking adequate facilities.

• Due to the increasing difficulties [the applicant] was facing in Parachinar due to the restrictions on his movement and his constant fear of being kidnapped or killed, our client arranged to depart Pakistan to seek asylum in another country.

17.

On 24 May 2013, the applicant’s legal representative emailed the Department to advise that the applicant had been doing volunteer work for the ‘Abbas Trust’, a Shia religious charity from 2005 until he left Pakistan (CB 152).

18.

On 12 July 2013, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicant a Protection visa (CB l58- l78). The delegate:

a) accepted that the applicant was shot in 2007 but did not accept that he was specifically targeted (CB 166);

b) did not find it credible that he was solely targeted on account of his membership of the Turi tribe in Rawalpindi (CB l66);

c) accepted that there was a real chance the applicant would suffer serious harm from the Taliban and other Sunni groups due to his religion and membership of the Turi tribe (CB l69);

d) found that the applicant could relocate elsewhere in Pakistan (CB 175); and

e) was not satisfied the applicant would face a real risk of significant harm if he relocated to an area in Pakistan outside his home region (CB 178).

19.

On 18 July 2013, the applicant applied to the Tribunal[1] for review of the delegate’s decision (CB 179-183).

20.

On 4 February 2014, the applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal (CB l90-191).

21.

On 10 February 2014, the applicant’s representative provided a post-hearing submission (CB l92-197).

22.

On 10 April 2014, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the applicant a Protection visa (CB 200-219).

23.

On 22 April 2014, the applicant filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Circuit Court.

24.

On 26 August 2015, the Federal Circuit Court quashed the decision of the Tribunal and remitted the matter for rehearing before the Tribunal (CB 220-221).

25.

On 2 May 2016, the applicant’s new legal representative provided the following documents to the Tribunal:

a) a statutory declaration from the applicant dated 21 April 2016 (CB 257-273); and

b) a statutory declaration from the applicant’s brother dated 21 April 2016 (CB 252-256).

26.

In his statutory declaration, the applicant claimed to also fear harm from Islamic State (CB 269-270 at [34], [36]).

27.

On 4 May 2016, the applicant’s legal representative provided a report from the applicant’s mental health counsellor dated 3 May 2016 to the Tribunal (CB 276-278).

28.

On 5 May 2016, the applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal.

29.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, a 31-year-old Shia Muslim from Parachinar, Upper Kurram Agency, Pakistan, entered Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 22 June 2012, after the boat he was travelling on capsized en route from Indonesia. He was rescued by Australian authorities and subsequently claimed asylum. On 20 and 21 July 2012, the applicant was interviewed by officers of the Department of Immigration and Citizenship, during which he maintained his claim for asylum. On 21 November 2012, he lodged an application for a Protection visa, claiming he feared harm from the Taliban and other Sunni groups due to his religion, ethnicity, and tribal membership, having been previously shot in November 2007 and targeted in Rawalpindi in 2009.

The applicant’s legal representative provided a submission on 1 January 2013, detailing his client’s fears of persecution in Pakistan, including attacks by the Taliban and anti-Shia groups, the blocking of roads leading out of Parachinar, and the resulting difficulties in accessing medical care and supplies. The submission also noted the applicant’s involvement with a local group, Tharek Hussain, which had shifted its focus to self-defence due to the escalating violence. The applicant’s father died after being unable to access proper medication for his diabetes, and the applicant himself had been shot and required nine operations.

On 12 July 2013, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship refused the applicant’s Protection visa application, finding that while there was a real chance he would suffer serious harm from the Taliban and other Sunni groups due to his religion and tribal membership, he could relocate elsewhere in Pakistan. The applicant appealed this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which affirmed the delegate’s decision on 10 April 2014. The Federal Circuit Court quashed the Tribunal’s decision on 26 August 2015 and remitted the matter for rehearing. During this rehearing, the applicant claimed to also fear harm from Islamic State. The Tribunal ultimately affirmed the original decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa, a decision the applicant now seeks to challenge on the basis that the Tribunal failed to consider his fear of harm from Islamic State.

The applicant, a 31-year-old Shia Muslim from Parachinar, Upper Kurram Agency, Pakistan, filed an application for judicial review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's (the Tribunal) decision dated 2 August 2016, which affirmed the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship's (the Minister) refusal to grant him a Protection visa under section 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant claimed that the Tribunal had failed to consider his fear of serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State if he were returned to Pakistan. This matter came before the Federal Circuit Court as a judicial review application seeking to overturn the Tribunal's decision. The applicant first lodged an application for review of the Minister's decision with the Tribunal on 18 July 2013, which was heard on 4 February 2014. The Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision on 10 April 2014. The applicant then sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision in the Federal Circuit Court on 22 April 2014. The Federal Circuit Court quashed the Tribunal's decision and remitted the matter for rehearing on 26 August 2015. The remitted hearing took place on 5 May 2016, after which the Tribunal again affirmed the Minister's decision on 2 August 2016. The applicant subsequently filed an amended application for judicial review on 8 September 2016, which was further amended on 11 January 2018. This application was dismissed by the Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Tribunal fall into jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicant's fear of serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State in his home region of Parachinar in Pakistan?
2. If the Tribunal did consider the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State, did it do so explicitly or implicitly by referring to the general threat posed to Shia Muslims in Pakistan by Sunni militant groups?
3. Did the Tribunal's failure to specifically reference Islamic State amount to a failure to consider the applicant's fear of harm from that group?

Held
1. Did the Tribunal fall into jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicant's fear of serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State in his home region of Parachinar in Pakistan?
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did not fall into jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicant's fear of serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State. The Court found that the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State was subsumed within his broader fear of harm from Sunni militant groups in general, and the Tribunal had considered this broader category of threat. As a result, the applicant's application was dismissed.

2. If the Tribunal did consider the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State, did it do so explicitly or implicitly by referring to the general threat posed to Shia Muslims in Pakistan by Sunni militant groups?
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did consider the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State implicitly by referring to the general threat posed to Shia Muslims in Pakistan by Sunni militant groups, which included Islamic State. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the broader threat to Shia Muslims in Pakistan from Sunni militant groups, which encompassed the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State.

3. Did the Tribunal's failure to specifically reference Islamic State amount to a failure to consider the applicant's fear of harm from that group?
The Court concluded that the Tribunal's failure to specifically reference Islamic State did not amount to a failure to consider the applicant's fear of harm from that group. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the broader category of Sunni militant groups, which included Islamic State, and the applicant's fear of harm from Islamic State was subsumed within this broader category. As a result, the Court dismissed the applicant's application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Allsop J in Htun v Minister of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244 at [42] said:The tribunal failed to address and deal with how the claim was put to it, at least in part. The requirement to review the decision under s 414 of the Act requires the tribunal to consider the claims of the applicant. To make a decision without having considered all the claims is to fail to complete the exercise of jurisdiction embarked on. The claim or claims and its or their component integers are considerations made mandatorily relevant by the Act for consideration… (Emphasis added) As noted at paragraph 6 above, the Court must, in this case, determine whether the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error in the manner alleged by the applicant – namely by failing to consider an integer of his claims. The integer which the applicant claims the Tribunal failed to consider is that he feared serious and/or significant harm from Islamic State in his home region of Parachinar on the basis of his Shia religion. It is not disputed that the Tribunal does not, anywhere in its decision, make reference to the Sunni entity referred to as Islamic State or ISIS. In effect, the argument put to this Court by the first respondent was that the Tribunal did not need to specifically refer to Islamic State as the Tribunal was clearly referencing the applicant’s concerns about Islamic State when it referred to the possible threat posed to Shia Muslims in Pakistan by Sunni militant groups generally – with Islamic State being included in the collection of militant groups referred to by the Tribunal. The Court notes that the applicant’s claim that he faces significant harm from Islamic State if returned to Pakistan was put to the Tribunal by him and/or his legal representatives in general terms. This is detailed by the first respondent (above at subparagraph 47(g) above). The Court has reviewed the summary of evidence cited by the first respondent and adopts it as accurate. Notably, the applicant linked the threat from Islamic State to the threat from “Taliban and other Sunni groups” (CB 270 at para 36). In doing so, it is evident that the applicant drew a connection between Islamic State and the term “Taliban and other Sunni groups”. He, in effect, subsumed Islamic State into the general category of other Sunni extremist groups and did so in a context in which he alleged that these Sunni groups were, collectively, a threat to his safety. This is best evidenced by the following exchange between the Tribunal member and the applicant at the Tribunal hearing of 5 May 2016 (Transcript p29 at 24-28):MEMBER: So I mean, I may think that, you know - that the chance of you being seriously harmed or significantly harmed by the Taliban or Isis, or other sort of Sunni extremist groups, or Sunnis in general, in your home area is remote, and not a real chance. So I’m interested if you have any comments about the relation.[THE APPLICANT]: Yes. Like, there is returned - the family have returned back to Parachinar - the Sunnis family which we have removed from there. So, like, if you check the history of, like, these Taliban was brought by these Sunnis people, the families, and when we kick them out from the Parachinar we was happy. Like, we was not inside Parachinar, it was - like, we was thinking that my family is safe. We are having war on the border of Parachinar but not inside. Now they’re again bringing these family inside and what is the guarantee tomorrow they will bring IS with them?