Clarey Builders v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Clarey Builders v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2021] QCAT 289

PARTIES:

PETER SELWYN CLAREY TRADING AS CLAREY BUILDERS
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION
(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

GAR370-19

MATTER TYPE:

Building matter

DELIVERED ON:

20 August 2021

HEARING DATES:

9 February 2021 and 10 February 2021

HEARD AT:

Townsville

DECISION OF:

Member Pennell

ORDER:

The decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 6 September 2019 to issue Peter Selwyn Clarey trading as Clarey Builders with a Direction to Rectify No. 0105154 to rectify building work said to be defective or incomplete is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – STATUTORY POWER TO REQUIRE RECTIFICATION OF DEFECTIVE OR INCOMPLETE BUILDING WORK – construction of a new house – the applicant was a licenced building contractor – the home owner commissioned his own design plans – the design plans were certified – the house was constructed in accordance with the certified plans – the house consisted of a deck adjacent to the living area – the applicant was aware the certified plans for the construction of the deck were non-compliant with the regulations – the home owner was aware of the defect in the certified plans for the deck – the home owner instructed the applicant to build the deck as per the certified plans – the applicant built the deck as per the certified plans – the deck was built without the mandatory drop off or fall away from the house – the home owner discovered a defect in the deck which caused water ingress – the home owner undertook rectification himself without advising the applicant – the home owner’s rectification of the defect was insufficient – the home owner sold the house without informing the new owners of the defect – the new owners discovered the water ingress defect – Category 1 defect – QBCC notified – the applicant is now retired and his construction business is no longer operating – direction to rectify issued – unfairness principle – the responsibility lies with a building contractor to ensure building work is undertaken according to the relevant regulations – by simply following certified plans does not relieve the building contractor of that responsibility

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 3, s 3(a)(ii), s 3(b), s 72, s 72(3), s 72(5), s 87, Schedule 2,

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 18, s 19, s 20(2), s 24(1), s 28(2), s 28(3)(a).

Dixon Projects Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority [2009] QCCTB 2

Don Mackay Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority [2009] QCCTB 259

Doolan v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2017] QCAT 58

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577

Duke Building Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Ors [2015] QCAT 397

Fenfox Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2014] QCAT 664

Fontain v Queensland Building Services Authority [2004] QCCTB 163

Harold…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarey Builders v Queensland Building and Construction Commi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Clarey Builders v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, the primary dispute revolves around the construction of a house, specifically the quality and compliance of the building work, particularly the deck, which led to water ingress and consequential damage. The matter was brought before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which was tasked with reviewing the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission to issue a notice to the applicant, Clarey Builders, to rectify the defective building work.

The central legal issues in this case included whether the applicant's adherence to the approved plans and specifications could excuse non-compliance with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards, and whether it would be unfair to direct the applicant to rectify the defective work. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider whether the applicant's actions were in line with their obligations as a licensed contractor.

The Tribunal carefully examined the evidence and concluded that following the approved plans did not absolve the applicant of their duty to ensure compliance with relevant regulations. As a licensed contractor, the applicant was responsible for ensuring that the building work met the required standards, regardless of the plans' approval. The Tribunal found that there was no tangible evidence or extenuating circumstances to suggest that issuing a notice to rectify would be unfair. Consequently, the Tribunal upheld the Commission's decision to direct the applicant to rectify the defective building work, confirming that it would not be unfair for the applicant to be required to address the issues.

Ultimately, the Tribunal confirmed the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission to issue a notice to rectify the defective building work. The Tribunal found that the applicant's adherence to the approved plans did not excuse non-compliance with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. Additionally, the Tribunal determined that there were no compelling circumstances to consider the direction unfair. This decision ensures that the applicant, as a licensed contractor, is held to the standards expected in their profession.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In arriving at a conclusion of what is the correct and preferable decision, there is a discretionary authority for the Tribunal to either confirm or amend the respondent’s decision; or set aside the respondent’s decision and substitute that decision with its own decision; or set aside the respondent’s decision and return the matter for consideration to the respondent with directions the Tribunal considers appropriate.[11] [11]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 24(1).Background In August 2013, the applicant contracted with Alan Gunders to build a split level masonry block four-bedroom house in the Townsville suburb of Douglas. The house was to be constructed as per the plans and specifications supplied by Inspire Planning and Design. The principal of Inspire Planning and Design is Ian Darnell. He is related to Alan Gunders and the plans and specifications he drafted were as per the instructions given to him from Alan Gunders. With respect to all work embarked on for the installation of the plumbing and electricals, that work was undertaken by contractors who were personally acquainted with Alan Gunders. Although the house was completed in July 2014, Alan Gunders never lived in it. He sold the house sometime in early 2015 through a local real estate agent. At some point prior to the sale of the property, the real estate agent notified him of a water stain on the ceiling of the garage, which is immediately below a timber deck. Alan Gunders did not notify the applicant about this defect. Instead, he carried out his own inspection and repairs. He found that the quad moulding on the outside of the corner of the deck had no sealant behind it. He injected sealant into the gap behind the quad mould and removed grout from the line in the floor tiles above the join in the timber deck. This grout was replaced with sealant. He then painted over the water stain on the garage ceiling. He declined to tell the applicant about the defect; and nor did he inform the real estate agent or the subsequent buyer why the water stain existed on the garage ceiling. Regardless of the repairs undertaken by Alan Gunders, the problems with the defect resurfaced later on. In April 2019, the current owners of the house became aware of water damage to the roof and walls below the decking. A complaint was made to the respondent about that defect. An inspection was undertaken of the defect by the respondent’s building inspector[12] and an initial inspection report was compiled setting out a finding that the building work of the deck was defective. In part, the defects identified the floor from the living room to the decking did not have the required step down onto the deck of at least 50mm, and nor was there a minimum 1mm:100mm ratio fall away from the living area. This resulted in ponding of water on the deck. The deck had not been constructed in accordance with the manufacture’s installation guide and the tiling was defective. Overall, the assessment of the inspection was that the building work of the deck had failed, and consequential damage was caused by water ingress. [12]Inspection undertaken by Mr Kevin Cameron on 12/07/2019.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A distinguishing feature between Luscombe and the applicant’s case is that in Luscombe, the Tribunal was satisfied that although the deck was built as per the express wishes of the owner, and although the set down did not comply with the approved drawings, and the fall did not comply with the Australian Standards or the manufacturer’s recommendation, the Tribunal did not regard the deck flooring as faulty or unsatisfactory.[35] That is not the findings in this matter involving the applicant as it has been established the applicant’s building work was defective and consequential damage resulted from water ingress. [35]Luscombe v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 13, [57].Conclusion Ultimately the assessment for the Tribunal is whether by Alan Gunders wanting the deck built as per the certified plans exonerates or excuses the applicant from his obligation to comply with the Building Code of Australia and the Australian Standards and would it be unfair for a direction to rectify to be issued to him. For the Tribunal to reach a conclusion that a notice to rectify a defect should be issued, it has to be satisfied that the giving of that notice is not unfair to the applicant.[36] Before arriving at that point, there must be some tangible evidence or some other compelling or otherwise extenuating circumstances which would allow the Tribunal to conclude that it should exercise its discretion to find that it would be unfair to direct the applicant to rectify the defect. There is no such evidence or circumstances which exists in this matter. [36]Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 72(5). At the time the applicant constructed the house, he was a licensed contractor. As a licensed contractor, he was responsible for ensuring the building work was carried out in accordance with the relevant regulations and simply following approved building plans does not in itself relieve him of that responsibility. Therefore, the Tribunal is satisfied that it would not be unfair for the applicant to be directed to rectify the defective work. The Tribunal’s correct and preferable decision is to confirm the respondent’s decision made on 6 September 2019 to issue the applicant with a notice to rectify the defective building work at the house he constructed for Alan Gunders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.