Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2012] FCA 611

Citation: Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2012] FCA 611
Appeal from: Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2011] FMCA 288
Parties: RECEP CETINKAYA and BAHAR CETINKAYA v OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF RECEP CETINKAYA AND BAHAR CETINKAYA and METIN UNAL
File number: VID 528 of 2011
Judge: BROMBERG J
Date of judgment: 13 June 2012
Catchwords: COSTS – appeal – where continuance of proceedings futile – where proceeding discontinued – whether
r 36.73(4) of the Federal Court Rules is determinative on the question of costs where notice of discontinuance is filed – whether adverse costs order is justified because of unreasonable conduct of a party
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 58, 77C, 121, 178
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43
Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 26.12, 36.73
Cases cited: Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy  [2011] FMCA 288
Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) (2011) 115 FCR 229
Mineralogy Pty Ltd v National Native Title Tribunal & Ors [1998] FCA 1700
Christodoulou v Disney Enterprises Inc [2006] FCA 902
Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex Parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622
Akiba and Another v Queensland (2010) 184 FCR 406
Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG [2011] FCA 453
Rickus v Motor Trades Association of Australia Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (2010) 265 ALR 112
Date of hearing: 9 November 2011 and 3 May 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 38
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr T Sowden
Solicitor for the Appellants: Law 554
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms C Gobbo (9 November 2011)
Mr T Connard (3 May 2012)
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Piper Alderman Lawyers (9 November 2011)
Australian Government Solicitor (3 May 2012)
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr T Elder
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Tony Hargreaves & Partners

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 528 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

RECEP CETINKAYA
First Appellant

BAHAR CETINKAYA
Second Appellant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF RECEP CETINKAYA AND BAHAR CETINKAYA
First Respondent

METIN UNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BROMBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.There be no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 528 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

RECEP CETINKAYA
First Appellant

BAHAR CETINKAYA
Second Appellant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF RECEP CETINKAYA AND BAHAR CETINKAYA
First Respondent

METIN UNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BROMBERG J

DATE:

13 JUNE 2012

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. There is only one issue that remains in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 611
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the question of who should bear the costs, given that the continuation of the appeal has become futile and has therefore been discontinued. The case is an appeal from a decision of the Federal Magistrates Court in Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2011] FMCA 288. The Cetinkayas, who were bankrupts, sought to challenge the conduct of the Official Trustee, who was the trustee of their bankrupt estates, in relation to a proceeding they had commenced against Unal in the County Court of Victoria. The appeal was ultimately discontinued due to the futility of continuing it.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether rule 36.73(4) of the Federal Court Rules should determine the costs in this case, given that notice of discontinuance was filed. Additionally, the court had to decide if an adverse costs order was justified due to the unreasonable conduct of a party. The court examined whether the Cetinkayas' appeal was unreasonably commenced or whether any party acted unreasonably in the conduct of the appeal.

The court held that no order as to costs should be made. The strict application of rule 36.73(4) would result in injustice, as the consent orders impliedly granted the Cetinkayas leave to withdraw and reserved the question of costs if they did. Despite the terms of the rule, the question of costs falls to be considered in accordance with the court's discretion. The court found that the appeal had become futile and that no party sought its continuance. Furthermore, there was no basis for an order that the Cetinkayas pay the costs of the appeal to either Unal or the Official Trustee. The court was not satisfied that the appeal was unreasonably commenced, and there was no allegation of unreasonable conduct by the Cetinkayas.

ORDERS:
1. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

There is only one issue that remains in this appeal and that is the question of who should pay its costs, in circumstances where the continuance of the appeal has become futile and has therefore been discontinued. For the following reasons, I have determined that no order as to costs should be made. BACKGROUND This proceeding is an appeal from the judgment of a Federal Magistrate published as Cetinkaya v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2011] FMCA 288. Each of the appellants (“the Cetinkayas”) became bankrupt on 14 October 1997 on their own petition. The Cetinkayas made an application pursuant to s 178 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Bankruptcy Act”) for the Federal Magistrates Court to review the conduct of the first respondent (“the Official Trustee”) who is the trustee of their bankrupt estates. Relevantly, s 178 empowers a bankrupt “affected by an act, omission or decision of the trustee” to apply for “such order as the court thinks just and equitable”. By their application in the Federal Magistrates Court, the Cetinkayas contested what they alleged was the Official Trustee’s refusal to determine whether a proceeding commenced by them on 11 December 2008 against the second respondent (“Unal”) in the County Court of Victoria (“the County Court claim”), should be assigned by the Official Trustee to the Cetinkayas. Recognising that s 58 of the Bankruptcy Act had the effect of vesting the chose in action arising from the County Court claim in the Official Trustee and desiring to proceed with that claim, the Cetinkayas had sought that the Official Trustee assign the County Court claim to them. By their application to the Federal Magistrates Court, the Cetinkayas also sought an order that the Official Trustee be restrained from assigning the County Court claim to Unal. Those orders were sought in the context of the Official Trustee having decided that it was prepared to assign the County Court claim and was entertaining offers from both the Cetinkayas and Unal. The Federal Magistrate dismissed the Cetinkayas’ application. Firstly, on the basis that it was out of time, and secondly, that there had been no refusal by the Official Trustee to determine whether or not to assign the County Court claim to the Cetinkayas. When the appeal came on for hearing, it became apparent that the real controversy between the parties (at that time) was whether the County Court claim ought be assigned by the Official Trustee to the Cetinkayas, or instead, to Unal and the terms of any such assignment. It also became apparent that the Official Trustee was willing to consider afresh and determine any competing proposals for an assignment and make a decision as to whether or not to assign the County Court claim to either the Cetinkayas or to Unal. In light of the Official Trustee’s position that the conduct of the proceeding below, and of the appeal, had contributed to the Official Trustee not making a decision as to an assignment, and with the general consensus of the parties, I adjourned the appeal in order to allow the Trustee to consider any further offers and determine to whom it would assign the County Court claim. That seemed to me (at that time and on the limited understanding I then had about the nature of the County Court claim) to be a course which held out some prospect of a resolution of the real issue then in controversy. If no resolution was achieved, that course was also intended to facilitate any review which may have been sought by either the Cetinkayas or Unal of the anticipated decision of the Official Trustee. I regarded such a review a preferable course, to the course in which the parties were then engaged of devoting time and expense, through the further conduct of the appeal, to the far less useful question of whether or not the Official Trustee had earlier refused to make a decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The second category relates to cases where one of the parties has acted “so unreasonably” that the other party should obtain the costs of the action. The unreasonableness of the conduct of a party may be examined by reference to the commencement of, and the conduct of, the proceeding.CONSIDERATION In this case, the consent orders made on 20 March 2012 impliedly granted to the Cetinkayas leave to withdraw should they choose to do so by 23 March 2011 and effectively reserved the question of costs if they did. In that context, the strict application of r 36.73(4) would result in injustice. If it had been necessary, I would have utilised r 1.34 to dispense with the requirement imposed by that sub-rule. However, as I have earlier observed, despite the terms of r 36.73(4), the question of costs falls to be considered in accordance with the Court’s discretion. Turning then to the question of how the Court’s discretion should be exercised, it is apparent that this is a case where the prosecution of the proceeding has become futile. No party seeks the continuance of this appeal. It is clear that, in the context of the Official Trustee’s position that it will not assign the County Court claim, the continuance of the appeal has been rendered futile. No party suggested a different conclusion and each may be taken to have agreed that discontinuance was the only sensible course. This is not a case of the Cetinkayas surrendering their claim for relief. Nor am I able to confidently say that their appeal would have failed. In those circumstances, I should next consider whether a costs order may be supported by reason of the unreasonable conduct of one or more of the parties. Unal’s claim for Cetinkaya to pay its costs is based upon the operation of r 36.73(4). For reasons already explained, I do not consider that the question of costs should be resolved by the operation of that rule. No criticism is made by Unal of the conduct of the Cetinkayas in commencing the proceeding or in its conduct. The Official Trustee has criticised the Cetinkayas for the commencement of both the proceeding below and the appeal. No basis is given for the contention that the proceeding lacks legal foundation and was incompetent and no such basis is apparent. I am not satisfied that the appeal was unreasonably commenced, and there is no allegation that the Cetinkayas have acted unreasonably in the conduct of the appeal, including by affecting its discontinuance. There is therefore no basis for an order that the Cetinkayas pay the costs of the appeal incurred by either Unal or the Official Trustee. The basis for the application of both the Cetinkayas and Unal, that the Official Trustee pay their costs, is the Official Trustee’s change of position. They say that they were induced to commence and/or participate in the proceeding by the initial course embarked upon by the Official Trustee, that it would consider an assignment to one or other of them and, by inference, that the Official Trustee did not intend to pursue proceedings pursuant to s 121 of the Bankruptcy Act in relation to the Brunswick property.