Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG [2011] FCA 453

Citation: Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG [2011] FCA 453
Parties: ANN STREET MEZZANINE PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 102 848 866) (AND OTHERS ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE OF PARTIES) v KPMG (A FIRM) (AND OTHERS ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE OF PARTIES)
File number: VID 292 of 2010
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 6 May 2011
Catchwords:

COSTS – leave to discontinue sought – cross-claim for contribution– supervening event – whether discontinuance constitutes an “abandonment” of cross-claim –consideration of circumstances in which costs order is appropriate – leave to discontinue granted with no order as to costs.

EVIDENCE – affidavit material revealed contents of without prejudice communications – relevant to the issue of costs – s 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act provides exception where the communication is relevant to determine liability for costs

Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Cases cited: Bruinsma v Menczer (1995) 40 NSWLR 716
Marks v GIO Australian Holdings Ltd (1996) 137 ALR 579
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Limited (No 3) [2002] FCA 1294
Re the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia; ex parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622
Chapman v Luminis Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 162
Australian Securities Commission v Aust-Home Investments Ltd (1993) 44 FCR 194
Champagne View Pty Ltd v Shearwater Resort Management Pty Ltd [2000] VSC 214
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Kyriackou [2008] FCA 1860
Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Kyriackou (2010) 76 ACSR 428
Foundation for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Research Action Aboriginal Group v Minister for Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander Affairs [2002] FCA 9
Pilbara Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs (2000) 175 ALR 706
One.Tel Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2000) 101 FCR 548
Date of last submissions: 24 March 2011
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 42
Solicitor for the Respondent/Cross-Claimant: Allens Arthur Robinson
Counsel for the Fourth Cross-Respondent Mr E F Wheelahan
Solicitor for the Fourth Cross-Respondent: Consult Solicitors

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 292 of 2010

BETWEEN:

ANN STREET MEZZANINE PTY LTD ( IN LIQUIDATION)
(ACN 102 848 866) (AND OTHERS ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE OF PARTIES)
Plaintiffs

AND:

KPMG (A FIRM)
Respondent/Cross-Claimant

CEDRIC  RICHARD PALMER BECK
First Cross-Respondent

JOHN NORMAN DIXON
Second Cross-Respondent

GRAEME JOHN RUNDLE
Third Cross-Respondent

NORMAN PHILLIP CAREY
Fourth Cross-Respondent

LYNNETTE ROCHELLE SCHIFTAN
Fifth Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 MAY 2011

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The cross-claimant be given leave pursuant to Order 22 rule 2(1)(d) of the Federal Court Rules to discontinue its cross-claim against the fourth cross-respondent.

2.The fourth cross-respondent pay the cross-claimant’s costs of and incidental to this application.

3.There otherwise be no order as to the costs of the cross-claim.  

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 453
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v KPMG [2010] FCA 1253 involved a cross-claimant, KPMG, seeking to discontinue its cross-claim against a fourth cross-respondent. The matter originated from allegations of negligence and breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) against KPMG by the plaintiff companies. Following a settlement with the plaintiffs, KPMG applied for leave to discontinue its cross-claim. The Federal Court was required to determine whether KPMG’s application for discontinuance should be granted and whether any costs should be awarded.

The court considered the principles guiding the exercise of discretion to allow discontinuance, particularly in cases where events have occurred after the initiation of the proceeding. The court also had to address the implications of the affidavit material revealing the contents of without prejudice communications and their relevance to the issue of costs. The court found that section 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act provided an exception where the communication was relevant to determine liability for costs.

The court granted leave for discontinuance under Order 22 rule 2(1)(d) of the Federal Court Rules, considering the circumstances of the case and the absence of any significant prejudice to the parties. The court found that the discontinuance did not constitute an abandonment of the cross-claim and thus no costs order was appropriate. The court ordered that the fourth cross-respondent pay the cross-claimant’s costs of and incidental to the application, but otherwise made no order as to the costs of the cross-claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The cross-claimant be given leave pursuant to Order 22 rule 2(1)(d) of the Federal Court Rules to discontinue its cross-claim against the fourth cross-respondent.

2. The fourth cross-respondent pay the cross-claimant’s costs of and incidental to this application.

3. There otherwise be no order as to the costs of the cross-claim.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Order 22 of the Rules makes provision for discontinuance. In the present case, as noted, the cross-claimant seeks to discontinue with the leave of the court pursuant to O 22 r 2(1)(d). If such leave is given, there is power to order costs by virtue of s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia 1976 (Cth). The power, though discretionary, must be exercised judicially. In a case such as this, where a plaintiff wishes to discontinue because of events that have occurred after the institution of the proceeding, the courts have propounded some principles to guide the exercise of the discretion. Of course, these principles offer no more than guidance; and in each case the discretion must be exercised having regard to the circumstances of the particular case. BACKGROUND The circumstances in which the application is made can be briefly stated. In this proceeding (VID 292 of 2010) a claim was made against the cross-claimant, KPMG, which was the former auditor of various companies in the Westpoint Group. Put simply, it was alleged that KPMG acted negligently and in breach of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) in auditing them. KPMG cross-claimed against the directors of the plaintiff companies (including Mr Carey) for contribution. As against Mr Carey, KPMG alleged breach of duties to the plaintiffs. Mr Carey denied KPMG’s claims against him. KPMG entered into a settlement with the plaintiffs earlier this year. The Court has since made orders:(a)dismissing proceeding VID 292 of 2010 commenced by the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (‘ASIC’) in the name of eight plaintiff companies (‘the Mezzanine Companies’) against KPMG (‘the main proceeding’), with no order as to costs;(b)dismissing four of the five cross-claims commenced by KPMG in the main proceeding, being the cross-claims against four of the five named cross-respondents (Mr Cedric Richard Palmer Beck, Mr John Norman Dixon, Mr Graeme John Rundle, and Ms Lynette Rochelle Schiftan), such orders being made with no order as to costs; and (c)dismissing proceeding VID 920 of 2010 commenced by the Mezzanine Companies against KPMG, with no order as to costs. Further, with the exception of the claims against Palentia Pty Ltd, the Mezzanine Companies’ claims in other related proceedings have also been wholly discontinued or dismissed, with no orders as to costs (although Mr Carey’s cross-claims are still alive). These proceedings are (i) York Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 484 of 2008; (ii) Market Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 607 of 2008; (iii) Bayshore Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 608 of 2008; (iv) Mount Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 609 of 2008; (v) Bayview Heritage Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 611 of 2008; (vi) Market Street Mezzanine No 2 Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 613 of 2008; (vii) Cinema City Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 614 of 2008; and (viii) North Sydney Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) – VID 259 of 2009. Hereafter, I refer to these proceedings collectively as the ‘Directors Actions’.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the discontinuance of the cross-claim constitutes an "abandonment" of the cross-claim.
2. In what circumstances is a costs order appropriate in this case.
3. Whether the affidavit material revealing the contents of without prejudice communications is relevant to determining liability for costs under s 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act.

Held
1. The court concluded that the discontinuance of the cross-claim does not constitute an "abandonment" of the cross-claim.
2. The court found that a costs order is not appropriate in this case.
3. The court held that the affidavit material revealing the contents of without prejudice communications is relevant to determining liability for costs under s 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting that the cross-claimant, KPMG, sought leave to discontinue its cross-claim against the fourth cross-respondent under Order 22 rule 2(1)(d) of the Federal Court Rules. The court recognised that the circumstances in which leave to discontinue is sought can guide the exercise of the court’s discretion, although these principles offer no more than guidance and must be exercised with regard to the particular circumstances of the case. In this instance, the court considered that the cross-claimant's entry into a settlement with the plaintiffs and the dismissal of the main proceeding and related claims were significant events that justified the discontinuance of the cross-claim against the fourth cross-respondent. As such, the court granted leave to discontinue the cross-claim.

Regarding the appropriateness of a costs order, the court acknowledged that the power to order costs is discretionary and must be exercised judicially. The court weighed various factors, including the timing of the discontinuance, the stage of the proceeding, and the overall conduct of the parties. It concluded that a costs order was not warranted in this case, particularly in light of the supervening events and the nature of the proceeding.

Finally, the court addressed the relevance of the affidavit material that disclosed the contents of without prejudice communications. Under s 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act, an exception allows the communication to be admitted if it is relevant to determine liability for costs. The court found that the material in question was relevant for the purpose of assessing costs, thereby permitting its consideration in determining the appropriate costs order.

In summary, the court applied the principles guiding the exercise of discretion in discontinuance applications and the factors relevant to determining a costs order. The binding principle established in this case is that the discontinuance of a cross-claim does not necessarily constitute an abandonment, and the relevance of without prejudice communications in determining costs under s 131(2)(h) of the Evidence Act.