Cassimatis v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Cassimatis & Anor v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2016] QSC 281

PARTIES:

EMMANUEL GEORGE CASSIMATIS AND JULIE GLADYS CASSIMATIS

(plaintiffs/respondents)

v

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

(defendant/applicant)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 12787 of 2009

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application to dismiss proceeding

DELIVERED ON:

1 December 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 May 2016, further written submissions on 16 September and 23 September 2016

JUDGE:

Bond J

ORDER:

The order of the Court is that the plaintiffs’ proceeding is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – OVERRIDING PURPOSE OF AND OBLIGATIONS UNDER RULES OR ACTS REGULATING CIVIL PROCEDURES – where the evidence reveals the plaintiffs to be in breach of their implied undertaking under UCPR r 5 to prosecute the proceeding in an expeditious way – where the defendant applies to dismiss the proceeding – where plaintiffs presently involved in proceeding in the Federal Court – where the plaintiffs submit that unless they achieve an outcome in the Federal Court which avoids any substantial liability being imposed on them they would not be in a position to fund the prosecution of this proceeding – whether there is any evidentiary basis to conclude that the plaintiffs’ present inability or unwillingness to prosecute this proceeding is likely to change – whether, in the circumstances, it is an appropriate exercise of discretion for the Court to dismiss the proceeding

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 5, 280, r 371

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis (No 8) (2016) 336 ALR 209, considered
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541, followed
McIntosh v Maitland [2016] QSC 203, cited
Quinlan v Rothwell [2002] 1 Qd R 647, cited
Tyler v Custom Credit Corp Ltd [2000] QCA 178, cited

Ure v Robertson [2016] QSC 210, cited

COUNSEL:

P J Dunning QC, with P L Somers, for the plaintiffs/respondents

R S Hollo SC, with P K O’Higgins, for the defendant/applicant

SOLICITORS:

Russells for the plaintiffs/respondents

Clayton Utz for the defendant/applicant

  1. In this proceeding, the plaintiffs seek to recover damages in excess of $17 million from the defendant (the Bank), which they say they suffered consequent upon –

    (a)various breaches by the Bank of the terms of a margin loan agreement;

    (b)various breaches by the Bank of a duty of care alleged to have been owed by the Bank to the plaintiffs; and

    (c)misleading or deceptive and unconscionable conduct by the Bank.

  2. Part of the conduct by the Bank which the plaintiffs seek to impugn occurred on 30 September 2008 and consisted of an alleged failure by the Bank to provide accurate and appropriate data concerning the state of the plaintiffs’ margin loan accounts.  Amongst other things, the plaintiffs say that 3 identified members of the Bank’s staff were aware that the data was inaccurate but inadequate steps were taken to warn customers, including the plaintiffs, of the inaccuracies.  The plaintiffs say that if the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cassimatis v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 281
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cassimatis v Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the plaintiffs were involved in proceedings against the defendant bank. The dispute centred around the bank's application to dismiss the plaintiffs' proceeding due to their failure to prosecute the case expeditiously, as required by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The plaintiffs were also engaged in proceedings in the Federal Court, which had significant financial implications for them. They argued that unless they could avoid substantial liability in the Federal Court, they would not be able to fund the prosecution of the proceeding against the bank. The court had to determine whether there was any evidentiary basis to conclude that the plaintiffs' inability or unwillingness to prosecute the proceeding was likely to change and whether it was appropriate to exercise the discretion to dismiss the proceeding.

The court examined the plaintiffs' position and their prospects in the Federal Court. The plaintiffs maintained their wish to prosecute the proceeding but stated they would only be in a position to do so if they avoided substantial liability in the Federal Court. The court noted that the judgment in the ASIC proceeding did not provide an optimistic view regarding the plaintiffs' chances of completely avoiding a substantial pecuniary burden. The court had to consider whether the plaintiffs' current situation was likely to change and whether dismissing the proceeding was the appropriate exercise of discretion.

The court ultimately decided that the plaintiffs' proceeding should be dismissed. The court found that there was no evidentiary basis to conclude that the plaintiffs' current inability or unwillingness to prosecute the proceeding was likely to change. Given the plaintiffs' involvement in the Federal Court proceedings and the significant financial implications, the court exercised its discretion to dismiss the proceeding. The dismissal was considered an appropriate outcome in the circumstances.

The court ordered that the plaintiffs' proceeding against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The order of the Court is that the plaintiffs’ proceeding is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I had not determined the Bank’s application by the time judgment was obtained in the ASIC proceeding. That occurred on 26 August 2016: see Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis (No 8) (2016) 336 ALR 209 (the ASIC judgment). Amongst other things, Edelman J –(a)found that each of the plaintiffs had contravened s 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by exercising their powers in a way which caused or ‘permitted’ (by omission to prevent) inappropriate advice to be given to relevant investors by Storm Financial Limited;(b)concluded a reasonable director with the responsibilities of the plaintiffs would have known that the ‘Storm model’ was being applied to the relevant investors and that its application would lead to inappropriate advice and consequences catastrophic for Storm; and(c)dismissed the plaintiffs’ exoneration defence, concluding that their conduct involved a ‘high degree of departure’ from the requisite standard and that their role was so significant and the contraventions sufficiently serious that they ought not fairly be excused. The ASIC judgment dealt with liability only. All issues concerning the form of declarations to be made, whether a penalty ought to be imposed, whether any disqualification orders ought to be made, whether any banning orders ought to be made against the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs’ liability for ASIC’s costs of the proceeding were ultimately deferred to a hearing in in February 2017. On 31 August 2016, I invited submissions on whether I ought to have regard to the ASIC judgment and, if so, what that regard ought to be. I received written submissions from each side, and further affidavit evidence on behalf of the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs’ position was that unless they could achieve an outcome in the Federal Court which avoided any substantial liability being imposed on them (and, effectively, that meant no civil penalty orders and no adverse costs orders) they would not be in a position to fund the prosecution of the proceeding in this Court. Their solicitor deposed as follows:8. I am informed by [the plaintiffs] and I believe that:-(a)they maintain their earnest wish to prosecute these proceedings;(b) in the event that the proceedings in the Federal Court are concluded on the basis that there is no pecuniary penalty imposed, and no order for costs made against them, then they will be in a position to prosecute these proceedings (subject of course to any appeals);(c) if the proceedings are concluded on the basis that pecuniary penalty orders are made against them, and an order for costs which involves a substantial liability, then, subject again to the outcome of any appeals, they will not be in a position to prosecute these proceedings; and(d) they maintain their opposition to [the Bank’s] application. I note, however, that the plaintiffs do not put evidence before me which enables me to form a positive view of their prospects of achieving the favourable outcome they seek in the Federal Court. Certainly an examination of the nature of the ASIC judgment and the findings made by Edelman J does not provide any basis for forming an optimistic view on the prospect of the plaintiffs completely avoiding a judgment which imposes a substantial pecuniary burden on them, at the least in relation to ASIC’s costs of prosecuting the proceeding in the Federal Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established