Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1334

APPEALS – security for costs – impecunious appellant – self represented – extensive notice of appeal – wide ranging factual challenges – lengthy and expensive hearing – costs unlikely to be recovered – costs of trial at first instance unlikely to be recovered in any event – principles governing discretion – security for costs ordered

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 56

Federal Court Rules O 28, O 52

Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 853 cited
March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506 cited
KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189 cited
Cowell v Taylor [1885] 31 Ch D 34 cited
Bethune v Porteous [1892] 18 VLR 493 cited
Wiest, EA v Director of Public Prosecutions [1988] FCA 568 cited
Paton, S v Campbell Capital  Ltd [1993] FCA 449 cited
J & M O’Brien Enterprises Pty Ltd v The Shell  Company of Australia Limited (No 2) (1983) 70 FLR 261 cited
Lucas v Yorke (1983) 50 ALR 228 cited
Cummings, JB  v Lewis, MT & Ors [1991] FCA 772 cited
Endormer Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Australian Guarantee Corporation Ltd [2001] FCA 510 cited

KAREN CAREY-HAZELL v GETZ BROS & CO (AUST) PTY LIMITED, PETER THOMPSON and TREVOR NICHOLLS
W176 OF 2004

FRENCH J
15 OCTOBER 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W176 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

KAREN CAREY- HAZELL
APPELLANT

AND:

GETZ BROS & CO (AUST) PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

PETER THOMPSON
SECOND RESPONDENT

TREVOR NICHOLLS
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 OCTOBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

On the First Respondent’s amended motion filed in Court 28 September 2004 and the Second and Third Respondents’ motion filed 26 August 2004:

1.The appellant is to provide security for the first respondent’s costs of the appeal in the  amount of $75,000 and for the second and third respondents’ costs of the appeal in the further amount of $75,000 by way of bank guarantees on the terms set out in the attached schedule or such other terms as may be agreed to respectively by the first respondent and by the second and third respondents.

2.The appeal be stayed until such security has been provided or until further order.

3.The respondents have liberty to apply for further security for their costs of the appeal on 7 days’ notice.

4.The appellant have liberty to apply to reduce the security for costs of the appeal on 7 days’ notice.

5.The appellant is to pay:

(a)the first respondent’s costs of its motion;

(b)the second and third respondents’ costs of their motion.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

SCHEDULE

At the request of Karen Carey-Hazell, [name of bank] (‘the Bank’) guarantees…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd involved Karen Carey-Hazell, who had undergone heart surgery that resulted in the implantation of a mechanical valve. Post-surgery, she experienced various complications, including blood clots and strokes, leading her to seek damages against Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd, the distributor of the valve, and two medical professionals involved in her surgery. The primary issues before the court were whether Ms Carey-Hazell was required to provide security for costs of the appeal, and if so, the appropriate amount.

The court considered the relevant factors for granting security for costs, including the strength of the appeal, the applicant's financial situation, and the potential oppression of the respondent if security was not required. The court noted that while appeals generally do not require security for costs, exceptions could be made if the appeal lacked merit or if the potential costs to the respondent were significant. The decision highlighted that an appeal signifies the appellant has already had their day in court and the initial ruling may be presumed correct. The court observed that a significant proportion of appeals succeed, but the discretion to require security for costs remains when the appeal lacks substantial merit or the issues are not of significant importance to the appellant.

The court ultimately decided that Ms Carey-Hazell must provide security for the costs of the appeal. It ordered her to furnish bank guarantees totalling $150,000, which would be held until the appeal was resolved. The appeal was to be stayed until the security was provided. Ms Carey-Hazell was also granted the liberty to apply to reduce the amount of security if the grounds of appeal were narrowed, thereby reducing the anticipated costs and duration of the appeal. The respondents were permitted to apply for further security if necessary, and Ms Carey-Hazell was required to pay the costs of the motion filed by the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the First Respondent’s amended motion filed in Court 28 September 2004 and the Second and Third Respondents’ motion filed 26 August 2004:

1. The appellant is to provide security for the first respondent’s costs of the appeal in the amount of $75,000 and for the second and third respondents’ costs of the appeal in the further amount of $75,000 by way of bank guarantees on the terms set out in the attached schedule or such other terms as may be agreed to respectively by the first respondent and by the second and third respondents.

2. The appeal be stayed until such security has been provided or until further order.

3. The respondents have liberty to apply for further security for their costs of the appeal on 7 days’ notice.

4. The appellant have liberty to apply to reduce the security for costs of the appeal on 7 days’ notice.

5. The appellant is to pay:

(a) the first respondent’s costs of its motion;

(b) the second and third respondents’ costs of their motion.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that given the nature of the appeal that she has lodged it is appropriate that she provide some security for the costs of the appeal. In the event that the grounds of appeal are narrowed and the likely costs and duration of the appeal reduced, she will have liberty to apply to vary the orders which are now made. Factual Background Karen Carey-Hazell, who is 42 years of age, has suffered, since aged 13, with Barlow’s Syndrome which involved a partial prolapse of the mitral valve of her heart. On 20 June 1996 she underwent surgery at Sir Charles Gardiner Hospital in Perth. Her mitral valve could not be repaired and a mechanical valve manufactured by St Jude Medical Inc, a United States based company, was implanted. Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd (Getz) distributes the St Jude medical valve in Australia. Ms Carey-Hazel’s cardiologist was Dr Peter Thompson. The surgeon who carried out the operation was Dr Trevor Nicholls. Post-operatively, Ms Carey-Hazell suffered some blood clotting and infarcts to the spleen and left kidney. In March 1997 she suffered a mid brain stroke. Following a review of her case by a conference of specialists the mechanical valve was removed and a porcine tissue value was implanted. On 13 March 2001, Ms Carey-Hazell commenced proceedings in this Court against Getz and Drs Thompson and Nicholls. She asserted causes of action: 1.Against Getz as deemed manufacturer pursuant to s 74A(4) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) asserting – its liability for defective goods pursuant to s 75AD of the Trade Practices Act, breach of the requirement that the goods be reasonably fit for their purpose and for common law negligence. 2.Against Dr Thompson – claiming he was negligent in failing to warn her of material risks associated with the operation. 3.Against Dr Nicholls – claiming he was negligent for failing to warn her of material risks associated with the operation. Ms Carey-Hazel said she had suffered a range of injuries as a result of the implantation of the mechanical valve. These included splinter haemorrhages, kidney and spleen infarcts, stroke, occluded left vertebral artery and partially occluded right vertebral artery, loss of life expectancy, scarring to the heart, permanent visual injury and pericarditis. She claimed damages for pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life and loss of her expectation of life. She also claimed economic loss based upon the loss of her opportunity to earn income as an Investment Development Manager with her brother’s company, Westpoint Pty Ltd (Westpoint). She said the net past value of her lost opportunity was $1,466,000 based upon an annual pre-tax remuneration of $500,000. Her future loss after contingencies was said to be between $4,087,747.60 and $4,289,517.70. The trial of the action proceeded before Kiefel J. It occupied 13 hearing days in February 2004. On 6 July 2004, Kiefel J delivered judgment – Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 853. She dismissed the application and ordered that Ms Carey-Hazell pay the respondents’ costs, including costs reserved. The reasons for judgment were comprehensive and lengthy, occupying some 78 pages.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Order 52 r 20, relating specifically to appeals, provides: ‘Unless the Court or a Judge otherwise directs no security for costs of an appeal to the Court shall be required.’Relevant Considerations in the Discretion to Award Security for Costs The general principles relevant to the exercise of the discretion to order security for costs were conveniently set out by Beazley J in KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189. They are: 1.Whether the application for security has been brought promptly.2.The strength and bona fides of the applicant’s case. 3.Whether the applicant’s impecuniosity was caused by the respondent’s conduct the subject of the claim. 4.Whether the respondent’s application for security is oppressive in the sense that it is being used merely to deny an impecunious applicant a right to litigate. 5.Whether there are any persons standing behind the applicant who are likely to benefit from the litigation and who are willing to provide the necessary security. 6.Whether the persons standing behind the applicant have offered any personal undertaking to be liable for the costs and, if so, the form of any such undertaking. 7.Whether the applicant is in substance a plaintiff or the proceedings are defensive in the sense of directly resisting proceedings already brought or seeking to halt the respondent’s self-help procedures. As a general rule impecuniosity and even insolvency does not mandate an order for security for costs – Cowell v Taylor [1885] 31 Ch D 34 at 38. However that case did recognise an exception in the case of appeals: ‘... the appellant has had the benefit of a decision by one of Her Majesty’s courts, and so an insolvent party is not excluded from the courts, but only prevented, if he cannot find security, from dragging his opponent from one court to another.’See also Bethune v Porteous [1892] 18 VLR 493 at 494 referred to in Wiest, EA v Director of Public Prosecutions [1988] FCA 568 (Gummow J). The tendency in Cowell in favour of security for costs in the case of appeals is not reflected in O 52 r 20. Burchett J said of that rule in Paton v Campbell Ltd [1993] FCA 449: ‘It is plain from the manner in which that rule is expressed that there is a discretion, but that there is something of an onus resting upon one who says that an appellant must be required to provide security. A feature of an appeal, which marks it out from litigation at first instance from this point of view, is that there has already been a decision given by the judge who heard the matter at first instance, and that the appellant has, in other words, had a day in court, has had an opportunity to present his case and has had a ruling which may be presumed to be correct.’His Honour went on to observe that it is unreal to ignore the reality that a significant proportion of appeals succeed. He referred to decisions of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales illustrating the proposition that there is a discretion to require the giving of security where the Court is of the view either that the appeal is without real merit or substance or that the issues sought to be litigated in the appeal is not one of great importance to the appellant while the prospect of the respondent being left without remedy in respect of a costs order is significant.