Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 853

TRADE AND COMMERCE – implant of mechanical or prosthetic mitral heart valve in applicant’s heart – subsequent development of thromboembolisms with serious consequences including need to replace valve with tissue or bio-prosthetic valve – liability of supplier – supplier as deemed manufacturer – liability under s 75AD of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for supply by manufacturer of defective goods causing injuries – whether liability under Part VA of the Act is strict or limited by requirement of a defect – operation of s 75AC in determining the standard of safety of goods – whether applicant as an injured person is required to prove the existence of the defect in goods at the supply time – whether strength of link to be proved between defect and injuries suffered is affected by use of the words ‘because of’ in s 75AD – common sense approach in determining causation of individual’s injuries – whether safety of goods is such as might be expected by the public – instructional defects – whether failure to warn of risks rendered the goods defective – whether causation from failure to warn – whether causation from defect taken to have occurred in the manufacturing process – whether defect was present at the time the goods passed from manufacturer’s control – application of defence under s 75AK(1)(a) – liability under s 74B for supply by manufacturer of goods which are not reasonably fit for the purpose for which the goods are acquired – what a consumer could reasonably expect from the goods acquired – whether Parts V and VA of the Act operate as a statutory ‘pre-emption’ of the general law of negligence in relation to the supply of defective goods – defence of the provision of advice or warnings to learned intermediaries

TORTS – negligence – duty of care – medical practitioners – duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in the provision of professional advice – scope and content of duty – whether failure to advise or warn of material risks

Statutes

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) Part VA, ss 75AD, 74A, 74A(4), 75AC, 75AK(1)(a), 75AK(2), 75AO(1), 74B, Part V, ss 75AC(1), 75AC(2), 75AD(c), 75AK(1), 82(1), 82, Part IV, ss 75, 75AR

Trade Practices Amendment Act 1992 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Glendale Chemical Products Pty Limited; Barnes v Glendale Chemical Products Pty Limited (1998) ATPR 41-632 Cons

Brooks v Medtronic, Inc. 750 F.2d 1227 (4th Cir 1984) Refd

Ellis v Wallsend District Hospital (1989) 17 NSWLR 553 Foll

Elna Australia Pty Ltd v International Computers (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2) (1987) 16 FCR 410 Cons

F v R (1983) 33 SASR 189 Foll

Glendale Chemical Products Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and Anor (1999) ATPR 41-672 Cons

Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan (2002) 211 CLR 540 Cons

Grant v Australian Knitting Mills, Ltd (1936) AC 85 Cited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 853
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd concerns the applicant's claim for damages arising from the implantation of a mechanical mitral valve in her heart, which subsequently led to the development of thromboembolisms and related health complications. The applicant, who was born on 23 March 1962, was diagnosed with Barlow’s syndrome at the age of 13, a condition involving a partial prolapse of the mitral valve. Over the years, her condition was monitored by her cardiologist, who eventually referred her to a surgeon. The surgery, which was conducted in June 1996, involved the implantation of a mechanical mitral valve, manufactured by St Jude Medical Inc. Post-surgery, the applicant experienced severe thromboembolisms, necessitating further surgery to replace the mechanical valve with a bio-prosthetic one. The applicant's claim includes economic loss due to her inability to work as an Investment Development Manager, as well as unquantified claims for the cost of domestic care.

The legal issues in this case revolve around the liability of the first respondent, the supplier of the mechanical valve, for the damages suffered by the applicant. The applicant argues that the mechanical valve was defective and unreasonably dangerous, leading to her health complications. The court needed to determine whether the first respondent was liable for the injuries sustained by the applicant as a result of the valve's implantation. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the applicant's pre-existing medical conditions contributed to her injuries and, if so, to what extent.

In dismissing the applicant's claims, the court found that the first respondent was not liable for the damages suffered by the applicant. The court held that the mechanical valve was not defective or unreasonably dangerous, and that the applicant's injuries were not solely attributable to the valve. The court also found that the applicant's pre-existing medical conditions and other factors, including two motor vehicle accidents, significantly contributed to her injuries. Therefore, the applicant's claims against the first respondent were dismissed. The court further ordered that the applicant pay the respondents' costs, including any reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs including any reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns the implant of a mechanical or prosthetic mitral valve in the applicant’s heart and her subsequent development of thromboembolisms with serious consequences including the need for further surgery to replace the valve with a tissue or bio-prosthetic valve. The applicant’s case is that she continues to suffer symptoms which are attributable to the thromboembolisms and their aftermath. The symptoms deny her much of the enjoyment of life and of her capacity to earn income. The applicant’s case is brought against the first respondent in its capacity as the supplier in Australia, at the relevant time, of the valve; against the second respondent as her cardiologist; and against the third respondent as her surgeon. A. BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 23 March 1962. At the age of 13 she was diagnosed as having Barlow’s syndrome which involves a partial prolapse of the mitral valve of the heart. Her condition was monitored in the years following and from June 1983 by the second respondent. An echocardiogram examination conducted at the time confirmed mitral valve prolapse involving both leaflets of the valve. In the period 1989 to 1996 the second respondent continued to monitor the applicant’s condition and further examinations were conducted. The applicant also consulted neurologists about various other symptoms and in particular problems with her balance and vision. It is not necessary to detail them at this point. They will be further considered in connexion with her medical history. In this period the applicant was involved in two motor vehicle accidents, the first in March 1991 and the second in March 1993. On both occasions the applicant suffered soft tissue injuries to her neck. In the second accident her back and thigh were injured. In 1994 and 1995 she received radio frequency blocks on the cervical spine and right sacroiliac joint which had the effect of minimising her pain for some time. In January and May 1996 the applicant and the second respondent discussed the prospect of surgery to the applicant’s mitral valve. The applicant was subsequently referred by the second respondent to the third respondent and she consulted him on 16 June 1996. On 20 June 1996 the applicant underwent surgery at the Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital in Perth. Attempts to repair the mitral valve were unsuccessful and a mechanical mitral valve was implanted. The valve was one manufactured by St Jude Medical Inc (‘the St Jude Medical valve’). Its place of business is in Minnesota USA. It does not have a place of business in Australia. The first respondent was the importer and supplier of the valve in Australia at the relevant time. As explained by Prof Hirsh, a physician and haematologist, it is generally accepted that implanted mechanical mitral heart valves carry a risk of developing thrombi, or blood clots, upon the surface of the valve because of its foreign nature. A thrombus is formed from blood which undergoes physical changes wherein it is converted from a liquid to a solid state. Thrombi can produce complications by obstructing vessels where they occur or by breaking off from the site where they have formed and travelling to and obstructing small vessels distant from the original thrombus. The latter is referred to as an embolism. The process by which the embolism obstructs the vessel is called a thromboembolic event. The resultant sudden insufficiency of blood supply can cause tissue necrosis, or an infarction. The area of tissue damaged is called an infarct. When a thromboembolic event interrupts the blood supply to the brain, which occurs when an embolus travels to a cerebral artery, it can result in a stroke.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant’s claim for economic loss is now based upon her loss of the opportunity to earn income as an Investment Development Manager with Westpoint Pty Ltd or Westpoint Corporation (the company was referred to by various names in the course of the proceedings. I shall refer to it as ‘Westpoint’). The company was one controlled by the applicant’s brother. The claim for the net past value of the opportunity is $1,466,000.00 based upon the remuneration for such a position being $500,000.00 per year gross, before tax. After contingencies the value of the future loss of opportunity is said to be between $4,087,747.60 and $4,289,517.70. The only other claim is an unquantified claim for the cost of domestic care. C. THE EVIDENCE1. THE APPLICANT’S MEDICAL AND WORKING HISTORY PRIOR TO THE IMPLANT(a) Medical History In 1986 the applicant saw Dr Gubbay, a neurologist. He noted at that time that she complained of a loss of balance, of a feeling of falling to the left, of what was a classic migraine with a blind spot and headaches at the back of her head and nausea. Doctor Gubbay later noted that the applicant had suffered from classic migraines, with loss of vision, on at least four occasions in the past five years. When the applicant reported that she was also suffering some loss of the co-ordination of her muscles in January 1987 Dr Gubbay considered the possibility that she was suffering from multiple sclerosis, which he discussed with her. At another point Dr Gubbay considered the possibility that the applicant was having thrombolic events and discussed with her how bits of thrombus can dislodge and enter the bloodstream. This was discounted after advices from the second respondent. On 6 April 1987 Dr Gubbay noted that she had neurological disturbances, diplopia and numbness in the left leg and right arm. Diplopia is referred to at other points in the evidence as double vision. The applicant also complained of fatigue at this point. The applicant sought to explain in her evidence that references by her to ‘double vision’ at this point, with hindsight, were really to blurred vision. The applicant says that it was not until after her stroke that she noticed the difference. Doctor Kermode, the applicant’s current neurologist says that people often refer to ‘double vision’ when they mean blurred vision. In August 1987 the applicant again saw Dr Gubbay and reported that she had difficulty judging distances, prolonged headaches, problems with vision, facial numbness and nausea. In December 1987 her knees were giving way and she had a tendency to drop (‘drop attacks’). She had an impairment to the vision in her right eye and problems with her balance. These attacks, loss of balance, double vision and grey spots in her sight continued into late 1988. Doctor Gubbay reported to her general practitioner in April 1989 that an eye specialist to whom the applicant had been referred could find nothing and he referred to the possibility of her suffering migraines. She continued to suffer migraines through to late 1998 and was at this time under a deal of stress because of problems with her first marriage. In December 1988 Dr Gubbay noted that she was still having drop attacks, occasional episodes of diplopia and grey spots.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL J