Wiest, EA v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
.’ C ’

LIMITED DISTRIBUTION ONLY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) No. G982 of 1988
GENERAL DIVISION 1
On appeal from Davies J. of the
Federal Court of Australia. . ” I .
BETWEEN:  EUGEN ALEXANDER WIEST

Appellant

AND :  THE DIRECTOR OF

PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

First Respondent

AND :  THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC
OF GERMANY
Second Respondent
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY No. 1148 of 1988

..

GENERAL DIVISION 1 I .

On appeal from Pincus J. of the

Federal Court of Australia. :-. , .
BETWEEN:  EUGEN ALEXANDER WIEST

Appellant

AND :  THE DIRECTOR OF

PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

First Respondent

AND :  RICHARD PETER MISZALSKI
t.

Second Respondent

CORAM: GUMMOW J .
PLACE :  SYDNEY
DATE :  5 SEPTEMBER 1988
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (EX TEMPORE) I .
I -
HIS HONOUR: There are before the Court two applications f o r
g . .

security for costs instituted by notices of motion both filed

on 26 August 1988, in matters Nos. 982 of 1988 and 1148 of

1988. The proceedings in respect of which security is sought

are two appeals set down for hearing before the Full Court to

start on 14 September 1988. The respondents to the appeals
are the applicants on the motion. The appeals arise from
litigation concerning attempts to extradite the appellant (who
is the respondent to these motions) to the Federal Republic of

Germany pursuant to the provisions of the Extradition (Foreign

States) Act 1966, which I shall call "the Act". A

substantially interested party in opposition to the appellant
in each proceeding would appear to be the Federal Republic of
Germany although that country is a party, as it happens, only

in matter No. G982 of 1988.

Serious questions would appear to arise on the

appeals. First, as to questions of issue estoppel and res

judicata in the area of public law, and secondly, as to the
construction of various provisions of the Act.
The first field of debate is presented by the decision
of Mr. Justice Davies in matter No. G982 of 1988 and the second
by the judgment of Mr. Justice Pincus in the other matter.
The position is that the judgment of Mr. Justice Davies is
under appeal pursuant to a Notice of AppeaL filed on 27 May
1988. The draft index for the appeal book was filed on 7 July
1988 and, as I have said, the present application for security .
z was filed on 26 August 1988.
The other judgment, that of Mr. Justice Pincus, is

I.

under appeal pursuant to a Notice of Appeal filed on 2 August
1988. The draft index in that matter was flled on 10 August

1988, and again the application for security was filed on 26 August 1988. The allocation of dates for hearing by the Full Court in September was foreshadowed in the course of hearing

before a Full Court of which I was a member, of a…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wiest, EA v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1988] FCA 568
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wiest, EA v Director of Public Prosecutions involves two applications for security for costs brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Federal Republic of Germany against the appellant, Eugen Alexander Wiest. The appeals in question concern the extradition of the appellant to the Federal Republic of Germany under the Extradition (Foreign States) Act 1966. The legal issues at hand involve questions of issue estoppel and res judicata in public law, as well as the construction of various provisions of the Act.

The Federal Court of Australia considered the applications for security for costs in light of the circumstances of the case. The court noted that the respondents to the appeal had judgments in their favor and that the appellant was ordinarily resident outside Australia. Additionally, the court observed that the appellant had limited assets in Australia and substantial assets in Germany that were currently frozen. The court also took into account the potential penal consequences of the appeals and the importance of the issues involved.

Ultimately, the court found that there had not been a satisfactory explanation for the delay in bringing the applications for security for costs. As a result, the motions were dismissed, and the costs of the motions were to be paid by the respondents to the respective appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two appeals against decisions related to the extradition of Eugen Alexander Wiest to the Federal Republic of Germany under the Extradition (Foreign States) Act 1966. The appeals are against judgments made by Mr. Justice Davies in matter No. G982 of 1988 and Mr. Justice Pincus in matter No. 1148 of 1988. The Federal Republic of Germany is a party in matter No. G982 of 1988, and Richard Peter Miszalski is a second respondent in matter No. 1148 of 1988. The appeals raise issues of issue estoppel, res judicata, and the construction of various provisions of the Act. The applications for security for costs were filed on 26 August 1988, and the appeals are set down for hearing on 14 September 1988.

The matter came before the court as two applications for security for costs filed on 26 August 1988. These applications were made in relation to two appeals against judgments from the Federal Court of Australia. The first appeal, concerning matter No. G982 of 1988, was filed on 27 May 1988, with a draft index filed on 7 July 1988. The second appeal, concerning matter No. 1148 of 1988, was filed on 2 August 1988, with a draft index filed on 10 August 1988. The applications for security for costs were heard on 2 and 5 September 1988, and the judgment was delivered on 5 September 1988.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should order security for costs in matter No. G982 of 1988.
2. Whether the court should order security for costs in matter No. 1148 of 1988.
3. Whether there has been a satisfactory explanation for the delay by the respondents to the appeals in bringing the applications for security for costs.

Held
1. The court dismissed the application for security for costs in matter No. G982 of 1988.
2. The court dismissed the application for security for costs in matter No. 1148 of 1988.
3. The court found there was no satisfactory explanation for the delay by the respondents to the appeals in bringing the applications for security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the applications for security for costs in two separate appeals, brought under section 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. The court examined the circumstances of the appellant, Eugen Alexander Wiest, and the respondents, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Federal Republic of Germany. The court found that Wiest was ordinarily resident outside Australia and had limited assets available in Australia, while the respondents had significant assets in Germany that were not readily accessible. The court also noted the serious and public importance of the appeals, which had penal consequences for the appellant's liberty. Despite these factors, the court emphasised the significant delay by the respondents in bringing the applications for security for costs, for which no satisfactory explanation was provided. Considering all these factors, the court decided that the applications should be dismissed, and the costs of the motions should be paid by the respondents.

The court relied on previous cases such as Lucas v Yorke (1983) 58 ALJR 20, where it was established that the discretion to order security for costs is entirely dependent on the circumstances of each case. The court also considered the decision in Smail v Burton [1975] VR 776, which highlighted the importance of the delay in bringing the applications. The court applied the principle that the discretion must be exercised judicially, meaning that the court had to inquire how, on the whole, justice would be best served in each case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court may dismiss an application for security for costs if there is no satisfactory explanation for the delay in bringing the application, even if other factors may favour the applicant.