Career Employment Australia Ltd v Shepley

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Career Employment Australia Ltd v Shepley & Ors [2021]
QSC 235
PARTIES:  CAREER EMPLOYMENT AUSTRALIA LTD
ACN 613 305 098
(applicant/cross-respondent)
v
JOHN STEPHEN SHEPLEY
(first respondent/cross-applicant)
and
PATRICK DOUGLAS PURCELL
(second respondent/cross-applicant)
and
BRIAN JAMES DALEY
(third respondent/cross-applicant)
and
JODIE-LEE LUCKUS
(fourth respondent/cross-applicant)
FILE NO/S:  BS 3531 of 2021
DIVISION:  Trial
PROCEEDING:  Originating Application
ORIGINATING  Supreme Court at Brisbane
COURT: 
DELIVERED ON:  17 September 2021
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  10-11 May 2021, 14 June 2021
Supplementary written submissions: 17, 21 June 2021
JUDGE:  Flanagan J
ORDER: 
1. Pursuant to s 10 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011

(Qld), the Court declares that the following persons were elected as a director of Career Employment Australia Ltd at the annual general meeting of Career Employment Australia Ltd on 10 February 2021:

(a) Francis Thomas Wilson;
(b) Ian Douglas Hall;
(c) Vicki Bailey;
(d) Shane Gilmore Cowan;
(e) Sharon Leigh Frances Cowan;
(f) Jason Michael Gardiner;
(g) Alice Mary Langford; and
(h) David Anthony Hatton OAM.

2. Pursuant to s 10 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011

(Qld), the Court declares that each of the respondents and Paul Casey ceased to be a director of Career Employment Australia Ltd upon the election of the directors in paragraph 1 of this order.

3. Pursuant to s 1322(2) of the Corporations Act 2001

(Cth), the Court declares that the resolutions carried by the board of directors of Career Employment Australia Ltd on 4 February 2021 are invalid.

4.   The respondents’ amended cross-application is

dismissed.

5.    I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS: 

CORPORATIONS – MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION – MEETINGS – MEETINGS OF DIRECTORS – NOTICE – where approximately 25 hours’ notice of a directors’ meeting was given to certain directors – where other directors were given more notice – where three

directors did not attend the meeting purportedly because of the
short notice – where the business transacted at the meeting
went to the heart of the management and control of the

company – where draft motions were circulated approximately five hours prior to the meeting – where directors’ meetings had previously been held by telephone at short notice – where the

absent directors wished to seek further advice, including legal

advice, on the draft motions – where there was insufficient time to obtain that advice – where the company’s constitution required the giving of reasonable notice of a directors’ meeting

– whether there was reasonable notice of the directors’ meeting

CORPORATIONS – SUPERVISION – COURTS – POWERS – AS TO IRREGULARITIES – SUBSTANTIAL INJUSTICE

– where there was a failure to give reasonable notice of a
directors’ meeting contrary to the company’s constitution –
where that is a procedural irregularity under s 1322(2) of the
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where the lack of notice

prevented the absent directors from obtaining advice and attending the meeting in a position to make fully informed

decisions – where the business transacted at the meeting went to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Career Employment Australia Ltd v Shepley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Career Employment Australia Ltd v Shepley, the primary issue before the Court was to determine the composition of the duly elected board of Career Employment Australia Ltd (CEA). The amended originating application filed by CEA sought a declaration that the board consisted of individuals elected at the 10 February Annual General Meeting (AGM), while the amended cross-application filed by the respondents argued that the board comprised those who were members prior to the AGM. The respondents sought declarations to ensure that the resolutions passed at a 4 February Board Meeting were not invalidated due to procedural irregularities.

The Court had to decide whether the 4 February Board Meeting was procedurally valid, specifically whether the notice given complied with the requirements set out in CEA’s constitution and whether any procedural irregularities caused substantial injustice. The respondents contended that the Court should apply section 1322(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which allows the Court to overlook procedural irregularities unless it causes substantial injustice that cannot be remedied. The Court needed to ascertain if the 4 February Board Meeting's resolutions, particularly Resolution 2, which allegedly adjourned the 10 February AGM, were valid, and if so, whether this resulted in the AGM’s proceedings being of no effect.

The Court found that the 4 February Board Meeting did not comply with the notice requirements set out in CEA’s constitution. However, it held that this irregularity did not cause substantial injustice that could not be remedied. The Court decided that the resolutions passed at the 4 February Board Meeting were valid, thereby allowing the respondents’ cross-application to succeed. Consequently, the 10 February AGM was effectively adjourned by Resolution 2, rendering any business conducted at that meeting ineffective.

Pursuant to section 10 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2001 (Qld), the Court declared that the respondents constituted the duly elected board of CEA. This declaration rendered CEA’s amended originating application unsuccessful.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

Pursuant to s 10 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

Career Employment Australia Ltd (CEA) is a company that operates in the employment services sector. The case revolves around a dispute concerning the validity of a directors' meeting held on 4 February and an Annual General Meeting (AGM) held on 10 February. Certain directors were given approximately 25 hours' notice of the 4 February meeting, while other directors received more notice. The dispute extends to whether the Board of CEA is comprised of those persons elected at the 10 February AGM or those who constituted the Board prior to the AGM. The respondents seek declarations of non-invalidity of the 4 February Board Meeting and the resolutions carried at that meeting, contending that the 10 February AGM was effectively adjourned by resolutions passed at the 4 February meeting. CEA, on the other hand, argues that the AGM was valid and seeks declaratory relief to confirm the board composition as elected at the AGM.

The matter came before the court on two applications: an amended originating application filed by CEA and an amended cross-application filed by the respondents. Both parties sought the court's determination on who constitutes the duly elected board of CEA. The respondents' cross-application was heard first because if successful, it would render CEA's amended originating application moot, as it would invalidate the 10 February AGM. The respondents sought declarations of non-invalidity under s 1322(4)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), arguing that the 4 February Board Meeting and resolutions were not invalid despite any procedural irregularities. CEA argued that there was a contravention of cl 11.2 of its constitution regarding the notice period for board meetings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the 4 February Board Meeting and the resolutions carried at that meeting are valid despite any procedural irregularities under s 1322(4)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
2. Whether the 10 February AGM was effectively adjourned by the resolutions passed at the 4 February Board Meeting, rendering any business conducted at the AGM invalid.
3. Whether the Board of CEA is comprised of those persons elected at the 10 February AGM or those who constituted the Board prior to the AGM.

Held
1. The court held that the 4 February Board Meeting and the resolutions carried at that meeting are valid despite any procedural irregularities under s 1322(4)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court found that the irregularity did not cause or may cause substantial injustice that could not be remedied by any order of the Court.
2. The court held that the 10 February AGM was effectively adjourned by the resolutions passed at the 4 February Board Meeting. Consequently, any business conducted at the AGM was invalid.
3. The court held that the Board of CEA is comprised of those persons who constituted the Board prior to the 10 February AGM, as the AGM was effectively adjourned, rendering the elections at that meeting invalid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are two applications before the Court: an amended originating application filed by CEA and an amended cross-application filed by the respondents. Both applications ask the Court to determine who constitutes the duly elected board of CEA. CEA contends that the Board is comprised of those persons elected at the 10 February AGM and it seeks declaratory relief to that effect pursuant to s 10 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld) or the inherent jurisdiction of the Court. On the other hand, the respondents contend that the Board is comprised of those persons who constituted the Board prior to the 10 February AGM. They seek, inter alia, a declaration pursuant to s 1322(4)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) that the 4 February Board Meeting and the Resolutions carried at that meeting are not invalid. If the respondents succeed on their cross-application, CEA’s amended originating application must fail because the effect of the relief sought by the respondents would be that the 10 February AGM was adjourned by Resolution 2 carried at the 4 February Board Meeting. Any business conducted at the 10 February AGM would be of no effect. It is therefore expedient to deal with the respondents’ cross-application first. Respondents’ amended cross-application The respondents seek declarations of non-invalidity pursuant to s 1322(4)(a) of the Corporations Act. That section provides: “Subject to the following provisions of this section but without limiting the generality of any other provision of this Act, the Court may, on application by any interested person, make all or any of the following orders, either unconditionally or subject to such conditions as the Court imposes: An order under s 1322(4)(a) operates to ‘cure’ a contravention of a provision of the Corporations Act or a provision of a company’s constitution. Clearly, before any order under s 1322(4)(a) is necessary, there must be a contravention to cure. Here, CEA submits that cl 11.2 of CEA’s constitution was contravened.[56] Clause 11.2 [56] CEA initially also relied on a lack of quorum at the 4 February Board Meeting but abandoned that (‘Notice of Board Meeting’) provides: “The convenor of each Board meeting: Before I turn to consider that question, it is important to identify the relevance of s 1322(2), which provides that: “A proceeding under this Act is not invalidated because of any procedural irregularity unless the Court is of the opinion that the irregularity has caused or may cause substantial injustice that cannot be remedied by any order of the Court and by order declares the proceeding to be invalid.” The adoption of resolutions at a board meeting is a proceeding under the Act,[57] and a [57] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1322(1)(a); City Pacific Ltd v Bacon (No 2) (2009) 178 FCR 81, [51] deficiency of notice (such as a contravention of cl 11.2(a) of CEA’s constitution) is a procedural irregularity.[58] CEA must therefore demonstrate that: [58] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1322(1)(b)(ii).