Bentley Capital Limited v Keybridge Capital Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bentley Capital Limited v Keybridge Capital Limited [2019] FCA 1675

File number: WAD 475 of 2019
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 11 October 2019
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS - deadlock - urgent hearing - meetings of directors - public company - practice of directors as to conduct of meetings - where plan to remove chairperson who holds casting vote - where resolutions proposed at first meeting without notice - where purpose of first meeting otherwise disclosed - whether notice of proposed resolutions was required - whether resolutions of first meeting valid - where second meeting convened for stated separate purpose - where resolutions proposed at second meeting to reverse resolutions of first meeting and to remove alternate director - no prior notice of proposed resolutions - whether resolutions of second meeting valid - declarations made

CORPORATIONS - alternate director - where removal of alternate director mid-meeting without notice - whether resolution valid - declarations made

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 201K, 203E, 1322
Cases cited:

Australian Hydrocarbons NL v Green (1985) 10 ACLR 72

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich [2003] NSWSC 85; (2003) 174 FLR 128

Aveo Group Limited v State Street Australia Ltd in its capacity as custodian for the Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Limited as trustee of the Retail Employees Superannuation Trust [2015] FCA 1019

Barron v Potter [1914] 1 Ch 895

Bell v Burton (1993) 12 ACSR 325

Colorado Constructions Pty Ltd v Platus [1966] 2 NSWR 598

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (NSW) v Mutton (1988) 12 NSWLR 104

Dhami v Martin [2010] NSWSC 770; (2010) 241 FLR 165

Efstathis v Greek Orthodox Community of St George [1989] 1 Qd R 146

Geelong School Supplies Pty Ltd v Dean [2006] FCA 1404

Gibb v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1966) 118 CLR 628

Goodwin v Phillips (1908) 7 CLR 1

In the matter of Warwick Keneally as administrator of Australian Blue Mountain International Cultural & Tourist Group Pty Ltd (admin apptd) [2015] NSWSC 937

Kelly v Wolstenholme (1991) 4 ACSR 709

La Compagnie De Mayville v Whitley [1896] 1 Ch 788

Markwell Bros Pty Ltd v CPN Diesels (Qld) Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 508

McLure v Mitchell (1974) 24 FLR 115

Mercanti v Mercanti [2016] WASCA 206; (2016) 50 WAR 495

Molopo Energy Limited 03R, 04R & 05R [2017] ATP 12

National Dwelling Society v Sykes [1894] 3 Ch 159

NRMA Ltd v Gould (1995) 13 ACLC 1518

Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Buffier [2005] NSWSC 839; (2005) 54 ACSR 767

Poliwka v Heven Holdings (1992) 7 ACSR 85

Re Chevron Furnishers Pty Ltd (In liq) [1994] 2 Qd R 475

Re East Norfolk Tramways Co [1877] 5 Ch D 963

Re Homer District Consolidated Gold Mines; Ex parte Smith (1888) 39 Ch D 546

Re Ryde Ex-Services Memorial and Community Club Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2015] NSWSC 226

Swiss Screens (Australia) Pty Ltd v Burgess (1987) 11 ACLR 756

Toole v Flexihire Pty Ltd (1991) 6…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bentley Capital Limited v Keybridge Capital Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1675
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bentley Capital Limited and William Johnson have brought proceedings against Keybridge Capital Limited, John Patton, and Jeremy Kriewaldt. The plaintiffs seek declarations as to the validity of certain resolutions passed by the board of Keybridge, as well as other ancillary relief. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The central issue before the Court was whether certain resolutions passed by the board of directors of Keybridge were valid. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether the resolutions passed on 10 July 2019 and 16 July 2019 were valid, considering the manner in which the meetings were convened, the notice given, and the process followed. Another issue was the validity of the removal of an alternate director during a meeting without proper notice.

The Court found that the meeting held on 10 July 2019 was indeed a meeting of directors and that the resolutions passed during this meeting were invalid because they were not passed by all four directors as required by the company's constitution. The Court held that while the constitution did not require notice of the business to be transacted at the meeting, it was prudent to provide such notice, especially in cases where resolutions were proposed. The Court also found that the removal of the alternate director during the meeting on 16 July 2019 was invalid because proper notice was not given. Furthermore, the resolutions passed during the reconvened meeting on 16 July 2019 were deemed valid as they were passed by all four directors.

The Court declined to make orders restraining Mr Patton from acting as chairperson at the general meetings or to declare him as the validly appointed chairperson of Keybridge. The claim and counterclaim were dismissed, and the matter was reserved for costs. The Court found that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of Keybridge on 10 July 2019 were invalid and of no force and effect, while the resolutions purportedly passed on 16 July 2019 were valid and of full force and effect.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. The plaintiffs' application for a declaration that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of the first defendant on 10 July 2019 are valid and of full force and effect is refused.

4. The third defendant's cross-claim for a declaration to the effect that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of directors of the first defendant on 16 July 2019 are valid and of full force and effect is refused.

5. There is liberty to apply limited to any relief sought relating to the proposed appointment of an independent chairperson for the general meetings of the members of the first defendant scheduled for 14 October 2019.

6. The claim and cross‑claim are otherwise dismissed.

7. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Background matters

[5]

Parties/persons

[5]

Governed by constitution

[10]

The involvement of Mr Bolton

[12]

Confidential transaction proposed by Mr Bolton shortly after appointment as CEO

[18]

Summary - the meeting of 10 July 2019

[21]

The 15 July 2019 letter from the ASX

[23]

Summary - the meeting of 16 July 2019

[25]

Trading suspended by ASX

[28]

Notices of general meeting

[29]

Event of default notices

[32]

Principles

[33]

Convening and conduct of directors' meetings

[34]

The chairperson

[51]

Rules

[51]

Role

[54]

Replacement of chair by election, 'choosing' or acquiescence

[57]

Termination of appointment of an alternate director

[61]

The statutory scheme to rectify irregularities - s 1322

[64]

The events

[69]

Witnesses

[69]

As to meetings of directors generally

[76]

30 June 2019

[83]

1 July 2019

[85]

Meeting of 2 July 2019

[89]

The draft announcement and the meeting of 3 July 2019

[91]

Events of 10 July 2019

[93]

Initial meeting

[101]

During the adjournment

[104]

The reconvened meeting

[110]

Between 10 July 2019 and 16 July 2019

[116]

Events of 16 July 2019

[126]

Consideration

[131]

The 10 July 2019 meeting

[131]

The 16 July 2019 meeting

[150]

The construction question as to alternate directors

[158]

The Corporations Act and the constitution

[160]

The parties' positions

[163]

Function of statutory definitions

[165]

The s 201K argument

[168]

Reference to the 'office' of director

[179]

Shadow directors

[181]

Construction of rule 8.14(i) of the constitution

[186]

Section 1322 relief

[192]

Conclusion

[200]

Background

Background to the litigation

In light of the pending general meetings, the matter has come before the Court on an expedited basis.BACKGROUND MATTERSParties/persons There were at the relevant time four directors of Keybridge. Simon Cato and the second plaintiff, William Johnson, were appointed in July 2016. They were originally nominated by a wholly owned subsidiary (Scarborough Equities Pty Ltd) of the first plaintiff, Bentley Capital Limited. Bentley holds around 20% of the issued shares in Keybridge. Mr Cato, Mr Johnson and Farooq Khan are directors of Bentley. John Patton and Jeremy Kriewaldt were appointed directors of Keybridge in August 2016 and October 2016 respectively. They were nominated by or on behalf of Australian Style Group Pty Ltd, which holds around 22% of the issued shares in Keybridge. There is a third large shareholder, being Wilson Asset Management Group, which also holds around 22% of the issued shares. On the same date that Mr Kriewaldt was appointed a director (13 October 2016), Mr Patton was appointed as the chairperson of Keybridge and Victor Ho was appointed as company secretary. Mr Ho is also the company secretary of Bentley. Relevantly, at a board meeting of 24 June 2019 Mr Khan was appointed an alternate director for Mr Cato for the fixed period 26 June 2019 to 18 July 2019, as Mr Cato was travelling to Europe during that time and had informed the board that he would not be accessing his emails during the trip. In essence, these proceedings have come about because of conflict between two camps, with Mr Johnson and Mr Khan in one camp, and Mr Patton and Mr Kriewaldt in the other. In these proceedings, Bentley and Mr Johnson as plaintiffs pursue certain relief, as does Mr Patton as third defendant. Keybridge was represented at the hearing by counsel but only for the purpose of indicating that it would abide the decision of the Court and wished to be heard on the issue of costs. Style Group has not participated in the proceedings. It indicated it would abide the decision of the Court. Mr Kriewaldt was called as a witness by Mr Patton and gave evidence, but otherwise did not participate in the proceedings and agreed to abide the decision of the Court.Governed by constitution Keybridge has a constitution which governs its internal management. All replaceable rules are excluded except so far as they are repeated in the constitution. I have set out in Annexure A the provisions of the constitution that are central to these reasons. In short they relate to the powers of the directors to call meetings and appoint/remove directors.The involvement of Mr Bolton In summary, the disharmony between the directors has at its heart concern about the appointment of Nicholas Bolton as the chief executive officer of Keybridge, his conduct in pursuing a particular transaction on behalf of Keybridge and disagreement as to the company's disclosure obligations to the market relating to that transaction. Mr Bolton has at various times in the past been a director and the managing director of Keybridge. Style Group is the parent company of the wholly owned subsidiary Australian Style Holdings Pty Ltd. The shares in Style Holdings are owned by Mr Bolton (as to 1 share) and his sister (as to 99 shares).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the contraventions complained of as to the conduct of the respective meetings that are the primary subject of these reasons are of a more significant nature.CONCLUSION The plaintiffs and Mr Patton seek declaratory relief by their respective claims and cross‑claims. The outcome is as follows:(a)the plaintiff's application for a declaration that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of Keybridge on 10 July 2019 are valid and of full force and effect is refused;(b)the plaintiff's application for a declaration that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of Keybridge on 16 July 2019 are invalid and of no force and effect is granted;(c)the third defendant's cross-claim for a declaration to the effect that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of directors of Keybridge on 10 July 2019 are invalid and of no force and effect is granted;(d)the third defendant's cross-claim for a declaration to the effect that the resolutions purportedly passed by the board of directors of Keybridge on 16 July 2019 are valid and of full force and effect is refused. The parties each sought additional relief. Before me they were uncertain as to whether further relief was in fact required. Having regard to my reasons and the declarations and orders proposed, I decline to make an order, as requested by the plaintiffs, restraining Mr Patton from acting as chairperson at the general meetings scheduled for 14 October 2019. I also decline to declare that Mr Patton is the validly appointed chairperson of Keybridge, a declaration he has requested. Such matters ought to now be addressed by the directors having regard to these reasons and the relevant provisions of the constitution. In any event, I understand that the issue as to who should chair the general meetings should no longer be live as the directors have (properly) resolved to appoint an independent chairperson for that purpose. There will be liberty to apply, limited to any relief sought that relates to the proposed appointment of an independent chairperson for the general meetings of the members of the first defendant scheduled for 14 October 2019. The claim and counterclaim are otherwise dismissed. As indicated at the hearing, I will hear the parties as to costs in due course.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Patton and Mr Kriewaldt then passed a number of resolutions. By those resolutions, the company declared void all resolutions passed by the board on and since 10 July 2019 except where they were passed by all four directors; appointed Mr Patton as company secretary; and instructed Mr Bolton and Mr Patton to navigate through the situation with the other directors.CONSIDERATIONThe 10 July 2019 meeting I find that the meeting of 10 July 2019 was a meeting of directors. It follows that I reject Mr Patton's evidence that it was no more than a discussion. Mr Patton sought to minimise the importance of the meeting by introducing evidence that he was not really able to hear what was going on, that he was doing other things at the time, and that it was another one of a number of repetitive telephone conversations 'on the same topic'. His evidence lacked credibility in this regard and was self‑serving. I have formed the view that the meeting was a meeting of directors taking into account that Mr Khan's email requests a quick board meeting; that Mr Ho's email arranging the teleconference refers to a teleconference meeting; and the email sent by Mr Ho during the meeting referred to the 'meeting' being 'adjourned'. I consider there was sufficient notice (that is, time given) that the meeting was to occur, taking into account the emails of the same day, the currency of the debate and the fact that Mr Khan's requests for information had been alive for some time. I accept that the constitution provides that notice of a meeting need not state the nature of the business to be transacted at the meeting. That does not prevent the directors from choosing to do so. Indeed, the Court in La Compagnie De Mayville v Whitley encouraged such a course, by saying that although it is not essential that a director be given notice of the business to be conducted at the meeting, it may be preferable and prudent to give notice of any special business. The issue of alleged 'ambush' and the nature of any notice that must be given as to business to be transacted at a meeting was at the heart of many of the parties' respective complaints. I accept that it was the practice of the directors of Keybridge to conduct meetings in two ways. I accept that there were regular meetings, attended with a degree of formality in that they were regular, diarised in advance and there was an agenda. I also accept that the directors had a practice whereby they would meet as and when necessary. How such meetings are named is not to the point. Mr Ho and Mr Kriewaldt described them as ad hoc and others referred to them at times as informal meetings. They are directors' meetings regardless. However, I find that the ad hoc meetings were not meetings that were called without any identified reason. The evidence, in particular that of Mr Kriewaldt, was that the usual practice of the Keybridge board was that an ad hoc meeting would be held only on a particular matter or matters that were known to the directors, and that resolutions would not be passed at such meetings without the attendance of all members of the board who could vote on those resolutions.