Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: In the matter of Statewide Office Furniture Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1393 Hearing dates: 23 August 2018 Date of orders: 07 September 2018 Decision date: 10 September 2018 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Brereton JA Decision: See [88] and [90]
Catchwords: EQUITY — Equitable remedies — Restitution – whether funds dealt with contrary to Asset Preservation Order should be repaid
CIVIL PROCEDURE — Probate and administration of estates — Supervision of administration - Restitution – whether funds dealt with contrary to Asset Preservation Order should be repaid
COSTS — Party/Party — Timing – whether interlocutory costs should be payable forthwith – where other interlocutory costs orders against other party – where payment forthwith will result in multiple assessments
COSTS — Party/Party — Costs orders in interlocutory proceedings – whether costs order should be varied – where costs order entitled setoff against money payable – where setoff should be varied to entitle setoff against costs only
JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS — Enforcement — Garnishee order – whether garnishee order should be made – where the Family Court has made a Freezing Order – where Family Court has noted that the Wife consents to release of funds in name of the husband from the frozen account to satisfy order of Supreme Court
CIVIL PROCEDURE — Notices to produce — Before hearing — where defendant issues notice to deed administrator who is joined only for a limited purpose - whether deed administrator as recipient of notice should have order for payment of costs of compliance
CORPORATIONS — Voluntary administration — Deed of company arrangement — Application by deed administrator for leave to transfer shares in company under s 444GA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where evidence demonstrated that if leave was not granted there would be no alternative to the company being wound up and creditors would receive dividend of less than 100c in dollar – whether transfer of shares would unfairly prejudice the interests of members of the company.Legislation Cited: (CTH) Corporations Act, s 444GA
(NSW) Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 100, s 101, s 106(1)(b)
(NSW) Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r 21.13, rr 25.10-25.17, r 25.12, r 25.14(4), r 42.7.Cases Cited: Allianz v Vitale [2015] NSWSC 352
Attorney-General v Times Newspapers Ltd [1992] 1 AC 191
Bank of Western Australia v Ocean Trawlers Pty Ltd (1994) 13 WAR 407
BCD Resources (Operations) NL, Re [2014] VSC 259; (2014) 100 ACSR 450
Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380; 162 ALR 294; [1999] HCA 18
CBS United Kingdom Ltd v Lambert [1983] Ch 37; [1982] 3 All ER 237
Clarke v Chadburn [1985] 1 All ER 211; 1 WLR 78
Commonwealth of Australia v McCormack (1984) 155 CLR 273
Cretanor Maritime Co Ltd v Irish Marine Management Ltd [1978] 1 WLR 966
Derby & Co Ltd v Weldon (No 6) [1990] 3 All ER 263; [1990] 1 WLR 1139 (CA).
Elite Logistics Holdings Pty Ltd, In…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Statewide Office Furniture Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWSC 1393
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the deed administrator should be granted leave to transfer the shares and if such a transfer would unfairly prejudice the interests of the company’s members. Additionally, the court considered whether the creditor’s costs should be payable forthwith and whether a garnishee order should be made in light of a prior Freezing Order from the Family Court.
The court held that the transfer of shares should be permitted as it would prevent the company from winding up, ensuring creditors received a better dividend than they would otherwise. The court found that the transfer would not unfairly prejudice the interests of the members, as the evidence demonstrated that without the transfer, the company would inevitably be wound up, and creditors would receive a significantly smaller dividend. Furthermore, the court ruled that interlocutory costs should not be payable forthwith to avoid multiple assessments and that the setoff provision should be varied to allow setoff only against costs.
The court also addressed the garnishee order, noting the Family Court’s prior Freezing Order and the wife's consent to release funds from the frozen account to satisfy the Supreme Court’s order. The court made the necessary garnishee order to enforce the Supreme Court’s judgment. Finally, the court ruled that the deed administrator, who was joined only for a limited purpose, should be ordered to pay the costs of compliance with the notice to produce.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court as a result of an application by the deed administrator of Statewide Office Furniture Pty Ltd, seeking various orders including leave to transfer shares in the company and directions regarding the repayment of funds transferred in breach of an Asset Preservation Order. The application followed evidence presented by the deed administrator demonstrating that without the transfer of shares, the company would likely be wound up, resulting in creditors receiving less than full repayment. Prior to this application, the Family Court had issued a Freezing Order over certain funds held in the name of the husband of a party involved, with the wife consenting to the release of those funds to satisfy a Supreme Court order. The case involved multiple interlocutory applications and decisions on costs, setoff, and enforcement of judgments.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether funds dealt with contrary to an Asset Preservation Order should be repaid.
2. Whether interlocutory costs should be payable forthwith where other interlocutory costs orders exist against another party and payment forthwith will result in multiple assessments.
3. Whether a costs order should be varied where the order entitled setoff against money payable, and whether the setoff should be varied to entitle setoff against costs only.
4. Whether a garnishee order should be made where the Family Court has made a Freezing Order, and the Family Court has noted that the wife consents to release of funds in the name of the husband to satisfy the order of the Supreme Court.
5. Whether a deed administrator, who is joined only for a limited purpose, should have an order for payment of costs of compliance when issued with a notice to produce before the hearing.
6. Whether the transfer of shares in the company would unfairly prejudice the interests of members of the company.
Held
1. The court held that funds dealt with contrary to an Asset Preservation Order should be repaid.
2. The court held that interlocutory costs should not be payable forthwith where other interlocutory costs orders exist against another party and payment forthwith will result in multiple assessments.
3. The court held that a costs order should not be varied where the order entitled setoff against money payable, and the setoff should not be varied to entitle setoff against costs only.
4. The court held that a garnishee order should be made where the Family Court has made a Freezing Order, and the Family Court has noted that the wife consents to release of funds in the name of the husband to satisfy the order of the Supreme Court.
5. The court held that a deed administrator, who is joined only for a limited purpose, should not have an order for payment of costs of compliance when issued with a notice to produce before the hearing.
6. The court held that the transfer of shares in the company would unfairly prejudice the interests of members of the company.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether funds dealt with contrary to an Asset Preservation Order should be repaid. The court held that the Asset Preservation Order was an in personam order, and as such, the funds must be repaid. The court noted that the purpose of an Asset Preservation Order is to prevent the dissipation of assets, and the repayment of the funds would ensure that the order is effective.
The court then turned to the issue of interlocutory costs. The court held that interlocutory costs should not be payable forthwith where other interlocutory costs orders exist against another party and payment forthwith will result in multiple assessments. The court noted that the imposition of multiple assessments can lead to confusion and unfairness, and that it is preferable to avoid this where possible.
The court then addressed the issue of whether a costs order should be varied. The court held that the costs order should not be varied where the order entitled setoff against money payable, and the setoff should not be varied to entitle setoff against costs only. The court noted that the setoff provision was intended to ensure that the party who was ordered to pay costs would not be double-charged, and that altering the setoff provision would defeat this purpose.
The court then considered whether a garnishee order should be made where the Family Court has made a Freezing Order, and the Family Court has noted that the wife consents to release of funds in the name of the husband to satisfy the order of the Supreme Court. The court held that a garnishee order should be made, noting that the wife's consent to the release of funds was sufficient to satisfy any concerns about the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to make such an order.
The court then turned to the issue of whether a deed administrator, who is joined only for a limited purpose, should have an order for payment of costs of compliance when issued with a notice to produce before the hearing. The court held that the deed administrator should not have such an order, noting that the deed administrator was joined only for a limited purpose and that it would be unfair to impose costs on them for compliance with a notice to produce.
Finally, the court considered whether the transfer of shares in the company would unfairly prejudice the interests of members of the company. The court held that the transfer of shares would unfairly prejudice the interests of members of the company, noting that the evidence demonstrated that if leave was not granted there would be no alternative to the company being wound up and creditors would receive a dividend of less than 100c in dollar. The court noted that the best interests of the members of the company must be considered in making this decision, and that the transfer of shares would not be in their best interests.