CA & CA Ballan Pty Ltd v Oliver Hume (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2016 0050

CA & CA BALLAN PTY LTD (ACN 006 578 972) Applicant
v
OLIVER HUME (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 068 318 712) Respondent

S APCI 2016 0051

ELYSIAN GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 114 025 204) Applicants
v
OLIVER HUME (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 068 318 712) Respondent

S APCI 2016 0052

LAND SOURCE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 132 726 151) Applicants
v
OLIVER HUME (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 068 318 712) Respondent

---

JUDGES: REDLICH, TATE AND FERGUSON JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 8 November 2016
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 10 February 2017
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2017] VSCA 11
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2016] VSC 72 (Cameron J)

---

EQUITABLE REMEDIES – Rectification – Agents entered into written sales authorities with developers – Developers paid sales commissions to Agents who claimed owed further commissions – Developers alleged Agents not entitled to commission as sales authorities omitted information necessary to comply with Estate Agents Act 1980 – Developers seeking rectification to include that information to accord with common intention of parties –Availability where document does not reflect true agreement of parties due to mistake – Importance of common intention of parties – Whether rectification available in respect of collateral consequences of contract as written – Non-compliance with regulatory scheme not necessarily barrier to application for rectification – Nature and extent of contravention relevant – Simic v NSW Land and Housing Corporation (2016) 91 ALJR 108; Nelson v Nelson (1995) 184 CLR 538; The Club Cape Schanck Resort Co Ltd v Cape Country Club Pty Ltd (2001) 3 VR 526; GE Capital Finance Australasia Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2011) 219 FCR 420; Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) v Carlenka Pty Ltd (1995) 41 NSWLR 329; Mayo v W & K Holdings (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq) [2015] NSWCA 119; Wills v Gibbs [2007] EWHC 3361 – Estate Agents Act 1980 ss 49A, 50.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Pleadings – Whether leave to file amended pleading should be refused with no right to re-plead - High threshold to be overcome if leave to be denied with no right to re-plead – Relevant test ‘no real prospect of success’ – Courts should not strike out pleading if some factual matter could emerge at trial that might alter analysis – Proposed pleading not fanciful – Whether facts pleaded as to common intention could be established and whether those facts sufficient to support rectification sought are matters for trial - Appeal dismissed – General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125; Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62; Mutton v Baker [2014] VSCA 43 – Estate Agents Act 1980 ss 49A, 50.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For CA & CA Ballan Pty Ltd and Elysian Group Pty Ltd 

Mr D Batt QC with
Ms S Gory

Maddocks

For Land Source Australia

Mr PL Ehrlich Norton Gledhill
For the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CA & CA Ballan Pty Ltd v Oliver Hume (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] VSCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CA & CA Ballan Pty Ltd and CA Ballan Pty Ltd sought to rectify written sales authorities executed with Oliver Hume (Australia) Pty Ltd to include information omitted due to a mistake. The agents claimed further commissions were owed, while the developers argued the agents were not entitled due to the missing information. The dispute came before the court to determine the availability of rectification in this context. The central legal issues were whether the court could rectify the sales authorities to reflect the common intention of the parties, and whether non-compliance with regulatory provisions necessarily barred rectification. The court considered the nature and extent of the contravention relevant to the decision.

The court held that rectification was available if the document did not reflect the true agreement due to a mistake and the common intention of the parties was clear. The court found that the common intention could be ascertained from the evidence and the nature and extent of the contravention did not necessarily bar rectification. The court referred to established authorities, such as Simic v NSW Land and Housing Corporation and Mayo v W & K Holdings, to support its reasoning. The court also noted that the Estate Agents Act 1980 did not preclude rectification, even where the written agreement did not comply with its provisions. Regarding the pleadings, the court held that the threshold to deny leave to amend pleadings with no right to re-plead was high, and the proposed pleading was not fanciful. The court referred to General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways and Mutton v Baker to support its reasoning.

The court dismissed the appeal and remitted the matter to the lower court for trial. The court found that the facts pleaded as to the common intention could be established and whether those facts were sufficient to support the rectification sought were matters for trial. The court held that the developers' application to strike out the pleadings should be refused, and the agents should be granted leave to amend their pleadings. The court also held that the Estate Agents Act 1980 did not preclude rectification, even where the written agreement did not comply with its provisions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between CA & CA Ballan Pty Ltd (the Agents) and Oliver Hume (Australia) Pty Ltd (the Developers). The Agents are licensed real estate agents who entered into written sales authorities with the Developers for the sale of properties. The Developers paid sales commissions to the Agents based on the terms of these sales authorities. Subsequently, the Agents claimed that they were owed further commissions. The Developers, however, alleged that the Agents were not entitled to these additional commissions. Their contention was that the sales authorities omitted information necessary to comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980, and therefore, the Agents were not entitled to the commissions as claimed. The Developers sought an order for rectification of the sales authorities to include the omitted information, arguing that this would accord with the common intention of the parties. They sought to have the documents corrected to reflect the true agreement between the parties.

The matter proceeded through several stages before reaching the appellate court. Initially, the Developers filed a claim for rectification in the trial court, seeking to have the sales authorities amended to reflect the omitted information. The Agents opposed the application for rectification and sought to have the Developers' pleadings struck out on the basis that they had no real prospect of success. The trial court denied the Agents' application to strike out the pleadings but allowed the appeal on the basis that the Developers had no real prospect of establishing the necessary facts for rectification. The Developers then appealed to the appellate court, challenging the trial court's decision to allow the appeal against rectification without a trial. The appellate court had to determine whether the trial court was correct in dismissing the Developers' application for rectification and whether the trial court erred in refusing leave to amend the pleadings with no right to re-plead.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether rectification is available where a document does not reflect the true agreement of the parties due to a mistake.
2. What is the importance of the common intention of the parties in an application for rectification?
3. Is rectification available in respect of the collateral consequences of a contract as written?
4. Does non-compliance with a regulatory scheme necessarily bar an application for rectification?
5. What is the nature and extent of the contravention relevant to the availability of rectification?
6. Whether leave to file amended pleading should be refused with no right to re-plead if the threshold of 'no real prospect of success' is not met.
7. Are the facts pleaded as to common intention capable of being established and are those facts sufficient to support the rectification sought matters for trial?

Held
1. Rectification is available where a document does not reflect the true agreement of the parties due to a mistake. The court concluded that rectification could be granted to include information omitted from the sales authorities.
2. The importance of the common intention of the parties in an application for rectification was underscored by the court, which found that the common intention of the parties was to comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980.
3. Rectification is not available in respect of the collateral consequences of a contract as written. The court held that rectification does not extend to resolving issues that arise as a consequence of the contract's terms, such as the developers' claim for overpaid commissions.
4. Non-compliance with a regulatory scheme does not necessarily bar an application for rectification. The court determined that failure to comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980 did not preclude the developers from seeking rectification.
5. The nature and extent of the contravention is relevant to the availability of rectification. The court found that the nature and extent of the contravention in this case did not prevent rectification from being available.
6. Leave to file amended pleading should not be refused with no right to re-plead unless the threshold of 'no real prospect of success' is met. The court held that the developers' proposed pleading was not fanciful and thus should not be dismissed outright.
7. Whether the facts pleaded as to common intention are capable of being established and whether those facts are sufficient to support the rectification sought are matters for trial. The court found that these issues should be determined at trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the issue of whether rectification was available where the written sales authorities did not reflect the true agreement of the parties due to a mistake. The court held that rectification could be granted as the sales authorities did not accurately represent the common intention of the parties to comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980. In reaching this conclusion, the court applied the principle that rectification is an equitable remedy that may be granted where there has been a mistake in the document which does not reflect the true agreement of the parties. The court distinguished cases where rectification was not available due to collateral consequences of the contract as written, holding that such consequences were not the focus of the rectification application.

The importance of the common intention of the parties was a central aspect of the court's reasoning. The developers argued that the sales authorities should be rectified to include information that would comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980. The court found that the common intention of the parties was to comply with the Act and thus supported the developers' application for rectification. The court applied the principle that the common intention of the parties must be ascertained and given effect to in the rectification process.

The court also addressed the developers' non-compliance with the regulatory scheme as a potential bar to rectification. The court held that non-compliance with the Estate Agents Act 1980 did not necessarily bar an application for rectification. The court found that the nature and extent of the contravention were relevant to the availability of rectification, but the developers' non-compliance did not prevent them from seeking rectification. The court applied the principle that non-compliance with a regulatory scheme is not an absolute bar to equitable relief where the party seeking rectification has a legitimate claim.

Further, the court examined the issue of whether leave to file amended pleading should be refused with no right to re-plead. The court held that the threshold for denying leave to amend pleadings with no right to re-plead was high and that the proposed pleading was not fanciful. The court applied the principle that courts should not strike out pleading if some factual matter could emerge at trial that might alter the analysis. The court also found that whether the facts pleaded as to common intention could be established and whether those facts were sufficient to support the rectification sought were matters for trial.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that rectification may be granted where a document does not reflect the true agreement of the parties due to a mistake, and the importance of the common intention of the parties must be ascertained and given effect to in the rectification process. Non-compliance with a regulatory scheme does not necessarily bar an application for rectification if the nature and extent of the contravention is relevant to the availability of rectification. Furthermore, the threshold for denying leave to amend pleadings with no right to re-plead is high, and the determination of whether facts pleaded as to common intention could be established and whether those facts are sufficient to support the rectification sought are matters for trial.