BSO Network Inc and Anor v EMClarity Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

BSO Network Inc & Anor v EMClarity Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] QSC 192

PARTIES:

BSO NETWORK INC

(first plaintiff)

&

APSARA NETWORKS INC

(second plaintiff)

v

EMCLARITY PTY LTD

ACN 88 139 128 180

(defendant)

FILE NO:

BS12112 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application, continued as if commenced by way of Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

9 April 2021 (restricted to the parties)

28 July 2021 (redacted version for publication)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

20 – 23 July 2020, 19 August 2020; 21 and 22 October 2020 (further written submissions)     

JUDGE:

Ryan J

ORDERS:

The parties having agreed upon a less redacted version for publication of my Reasons delivered on 9 April 2021, I now publish those less redacted Reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – PARTICULAR PARTIES – PRINCIPAL AND AGENT – CREATION OF RELATIONSHIP OF AGENCY – FORMATION AND PROOF OF AGENCY –  where alleged principal wholly owned subsidiary of alleged agent – where alleged principal undisclosed to other contracting party – whether holding company negotiating “on behalf of” subsidiary created agency relationship

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – IMPLIED TERMS – whether contract an unconditional contract for supply of goods or a development contract, with supply to follow only if development successful – where, if an unconditional contract for supply, the contract was silent as to when the goods were to be delivered – whether a term requiring delivery within a reasonable time ought to be implied – determination of period of reasonable time – whether there had been failure to supply the goods within a reasonable time

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH – REPUDIATION AND NON-PERFORMANCE – REPUDIATION – DELAY AND PROVISIONS AS TO TIME – where defendant agreed to supply goods to second plaintiff – where defendant then unilaterally implemented a “Quality Review” of all its products and a pause on shipping until the review was complete – where defendant informed plaintiffs about Quality Review and pause on shipments but would provide no information to plaintiffs about when the review might be completed – where defendant cancelled orders for components for second plaintiff’s product –– whether conduct of defendant repudiatory

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH – where contract between first plaintiff and defendant contained obligation of confidence – where plaintiffs’ competitor acquired defendant – where, prior to acquisition, during due dilignce, defendant provided redacted versions of plaintiffs’ confidential information to plaintiffs’ competitor – where, after acquisition, defendant provided un-redacted copies of plaintiffs’ confidential information to plaintiff’s competitor – whether confidential information provided in breach of contractual obligation of confidence – whether contractual exceptions to obligation of confidence applied

EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – equitable obligation of confidence – whether equitable obligation of confidence co-exists with contractual obligation of confidence – whether, if co-existing, equitable obligation broader in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BSO Network Inc and Anor v EMClarity Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BSO Network Inc and Anor v EMClarity Pty Ltd (No 2) involved the parties BSO Network Inc, EMClarity Pty Ltd, and their respective subsidiaries. The dispute arose from a series of contractual and equitable obligations, including the creation of an agency relationship, the interpretation of the contractual terms, and the breach of obligations of confidence. The case was heard and decided in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues the court needed to resolve included whether an agency relationship was created between the parties, the interpretation of the contract regarding the delivery of goods, whether the defendant's conduct constituted repudiation, and the breach of both contractual and equitable obligations of confidence. The court also needed to determine whether there was a co-existence of contractual and equitable obligations of confidence and whether the equitable obligation could supersede the contractual one.

The court examined the relationship between the parties and found that there was no agency relationship created. The court then interpreted the contract, determining that a term requiring delivery within a reasonable time should be implied. Regarding the repudiation, the court found that the defendant's actions did not amount to repudiation. However, the court held that the defendant breached both the contractual and equitable obligations of confidence. The court concluded that the equitable obligation of confidence co-existed with the contractual one but did not supersede it.

The final orders of the court included the publication of the reasons with a less redacted version, as agreed upon by the parties. The court also found that the defendant breached the contractual and equitable obligations of confidence, and the defendant was liable for those breaches.

Orders

Orders of the court

The parties having agreed upon a less redacted version for publication of my Reasons delivered on 9 April 2021, I now publish those less redacted Reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

My identification and analysis of relevant communication and conduct follows. I then deal with each of the 19 issues in turn. Relevant background facts2017 – 2018: Discussions between Mr McGowan and Dr Baines In early 2017, it was rumoured that McKay Brothers was developing a lower-latency network in the NJ Equity Triangle. At that time, Mr McGowan worked for Apsara, which was interested in competitively “refreshing” its network. Mr McGowan was aware that the radios which EMClarity developed and produced could, with some adaptation, be used in the provision of ultra-low latency circuits between stock exchanges. He began to deal with Dr Baines in about June 2017. At the time, EMClarity’s E Band radios were subject to “exclusivity arrangements” which meant that they could not be supplied to Apsara. Accordingly, Dr Baines and Mr McGowan discussed other options, including the development of a new radio in W Band. After BSO acquired Apsara, Mr McGowan made it clear to BSO’s board that, to remain competitive, it had to develop an ultra-low latency, high capacity, wireless network. With the board’s approval, he continued discussing a W Band network with Dr Baines, having informed Dr Baines that BSO had acquired Apsara. I accept that Mr McGowan made it clear to Dr Baines that his objective was to develop a better network than McKay Brothers’ network and that a W Band product was necessary (from BSO’s point of view)[6] for it to do so. [6] In his affidavit, Mr Boyle expressed a negative opinion about a W Band product. On 10 February 2018, Mr McGowan told Dr Baines, in effect, that the success of the new network was vital to BSO and that BSO needed to deploy it within the next six months. On 14 March 2018, Dr Baines sent a proposal to Mr McGowan describing a certain approach to the development (which would involve a third party) and stating, in effect, that, on that approach, development time would be six months. Dr Baines told Mr McGowan that the work was not considered “high risk” and elaborated on the reasons why that was so. He proposed a “preliminary design phase” which would “quickly” prove the design approach. He said the preliminary design phase “would take one month from the placement of order”. Mr McGowan continued to negotiate with Dr Baines and, ultimately, Dr Baines sent Mr McGowan a final proposal on 20 April 2018. The proposal (entitled “Information and Pricing for BSO Networks Ultra-Low Latency W Band Equipment in 92-95 GHZ Band”) included the following (my emphasis). I note the optimistic tone of this proposal when it comes to time frames and its description as “low risk” – [redacted] The offer also included exclusivity on certain terms.[7] [7] And technical detail. BSO’s board determined to proceed with the proposal on 3 May 2018. An agreement reflecting the proposal, entitled the “W Band Radio Development Agreement Terms” was executed by BSO and EMClarity on 14 June 2018 (referred to in these reasons as the “W Band Radio Development Agreement” or the WBRDAT).The agency issue

Decision

Reasons for decision

The authorities which stated that the equitable obligation ought to go no further than the contractual one included Corporate Farming Pty Ltd v Eden Bay Pty Ltd, an unreported decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia on 28 January 1992, in which Murray J held as follows – I think it is the law that in circumstances where there is a contractual relationship between the parties a duty of confidentiality may nonetheless arise in equity and be owed by one party to the other …But as I understand the law, such an equitable duty may be relied upon where it would result in a position consistent with that provided for by the contract or where the contract is silent on the matter, but not to give a party a remedy in circumstances where the result would be directly inconsistent with the contractual arrangements.Discussion and conclusion Streetscape expressed a preference for Del Casale and noted its consistency with Deane J in Moorgate but the issue of the co-existence of contractual and equitable obligations did not arise because of the way in which the parties had proceeded on appeal. In Optus, the access agreement clearly contemplated remedies for breach of its terms beyond those provided in the contract. Whilst expressing doubt about the approach in Del Casale, the Full Court resolved matters by reference to the terms of the parties’ agreement. Other authorities to which I was referred go either way. My preference is for the approach in Del Casale, because of its consistency with Moorgate. But assuming that the correct approach is one which permits a co-existing equitable obligation of confidence, the more relevant question is whether that equitable obligation supersedes or overrides clause 7.3. The authorities to which I was referred emphasised the significance of the contract. The parties here were free to agree that certain conduct would not amount to a breach of the obligation of confidence. In my view, the equitable obligation would not operate to convert contractually authorised disclosure into unauthorised disclosure. In other words, in my view, paying due regard to the parties’ agreement, where certain disclosure would not amount to a breach of contract because it is authorised by clause 7.3, equity would not intervene to render that same conduct a breach of a broader equitable obligation. Issue 15: Was the contractual duty breached? The defendant asserts that none of the Customer Material, which EMClarity received from BSO (including the Site Location Data and the Path Analyses Information), was disclosed to McKay Brothers. The plaintiffs have made no submissions to me about the provision of Customer Material in breach of contract. I will therefore say nothing more about it. With respect to the provision of the ineffectively redacted, and un-redacted, copies of the WBRDAT, the defendant relies upon clause 7.3 of the WBRDAT. The defendant also observes that, because of clause 7.3, it was under no obligation to redact, or attempt to redact, the WBRDAT before providing it to Mr Boyle during due diligence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of agency, determining that the negotiations conducted by a wholly owned subsidiary of the alleged agent, without disclosing the principal, did not establish an agency relationship. This was due to the undisclosed nature of the principal to the other contracting party. Moving to the second issue, the court examined the nature of the contract and concluded that it was an unconditional contract for the supply of goods rather than a development contract. This conclusion was based on the clear terms and the absence of any conditional language regarding the success of the development. In considering whether to imply a term for delivery within a reasonable time, the court held that such a term should be implied into the contract, although it did not provide a specific time frame for what would constitute a reasonable period. Regarding the defendant's conduct, the court found that the unilateral implementation of a “Quality Review” and the pause on shipping, without providing a timeline for completion, amounted to repudiation. The court then turned to the issue of the breach of the obligation of confidence. It found that the provision of confidential information to a competitor indeed breached the contractual obligation of confidence. Furthermore, the court held that an equitable obligation of confidence co-existed with the contractual obligation, but clarified that the equitable obligation was not broader in scope than the contractual one. This interpretation was supported by the principle that equity would not intervene to render conduct a breach of a broader equitable obligation where it was authorised by contract. Finally, the court concluded that the provision of confidential information did breach the equitable obligation of confidence and that the defendant was likely to breach both the contractual and equitable obligations of confidence and exclusivity. The court's reasoning was grounded in the analysis of the contract terms, the parties' conduct, and the application of legal principles related to agency, contract interpretation, repudiation, and obligations of confidence.