Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd v Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd v Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union [2009] FCA 194

CONTEMPT – court order - whether orders sufficiently clear to found proceedings for contempt – whether statement of charge adequate to found proceedings for contempt

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether the Australian Building Construction Commissioner should be heard as an intervener

Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) s 71
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 53(1)
Federal Court Rules O 40 r 5, O 40 r 6, O 40 r 7

Advan Investments Pty Ltd v Dean Gleeson Motor Sales Pty Ltd [2003] VSC 201
Australian Consolidated Press Ltd v Morgan (1965) 112 CLR 483
Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98
Concrete Constructions Pty Ltd v Plumbers and Gasfitters Employees’ Union (No 2) (1987) 15 FCR 64
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1758
Coward v Stapleton (1953) 90 CLR 573
Evenco Pty Ltd v Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation (Qld Branch) [2001] 2 Qd R 118
GTS Freight Management Pty Ltd v Transport Workers Union of Australia (1990) 25 FCR 296
Hanley v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2000) 100 FCR 530
Heatons Transport (St Helens) Ltd v Transport and General Workers’ Union [1973] AC 15
ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248
Levy v State of Victoria (1997) 189 CLR 579
Louis Vuitton Malletier SA v Design Elegance Pty Ltd (2006) 149 FCR 494
National Union of Workers v Davids Distribution Pty Ltd (1999) 91 FCR 513
Real Tech Systems Integration Pty Ltd v Meuross (1998) 82 FCR 150
RPS v R (2000) 199 CLR 620
Textile Clothing and Footwear Union of Australia v Morrison Country Clothing Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCA 1965
Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Sharman Networks Ltd (2006) 150 FCR 110

BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD v CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION

VID 114 of 2009

TRACEY J
4 MARCH 2009
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 114 of 2009

BETWEEN:

BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
Respondent

JUDGE:

TRACEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 MARCH 2009

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.It be declared that the respondent is not guilty of the charge which was filed with the applicant’s notice of motion dated 20 February 2009.

2.The further hearing of the applicant’s notice of motion dated 24 February 2009 be adjourned to 10:15 am on 12 March 2009.

3.On or before 5.00 pm on 6 March 2009 the respondent file and serve:

(a)any affidavits on which it proposes to rely at the penalty hearing; and

(b)an outline of its written submissions.

4.On or before 5.00 pm on 11 March 2009 the applicant:

(a)file and serve any answering affidavits on which it proposes to rely at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd v Construction Forestry Mining and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd brought an application against the Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) in the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking a finding of contempt of court. The dispute centred around alleged acts of contempt by the CFMEU in obstructing access to a construction site, in breach of court orders. The court had to determine whether the CFMEU had contravened the specific court orders by obstructing access to the site through the placement of marquees, tents, and vehicles.

The primary legal issue was whether the CFMEU had committed acts of contempt by obstructing access to the site on the dates specified in the charges. The court had to consider whether the CFMEU's actions constituted a wilful disobedience of the court's orders. The court examined the evidence provided and determined whether each element of the charges had been proven beyond reasonable doubt.

The court found that the first charge of contempt was not established as the evidence did not support the claim that the CFMEU had obstructed access by placing marquees or tents at the site entrance. However, the second charge was upheld for incidents on 19 and 23 February 2009, where vehicles were used to obstruct the entrance. The court was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the CFMEU had contravened the court orders by maintaining an obstruction to the movement of vehicles into the site.

The court ordered that the CFMEU was not guilty of the first charge and directed further proceedings for determining the penalty for the second charge. The court set deadlines for the filing of affidavits and written submissions from both parties in preparation for the penalty hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It be declared that the respondent is not guilty of the charge which was filed with the applicant’s notice of motion dated 20 February 2009.

2. The further hearing of the applicant’s notice of motion dated 24 February 2009 be adjourned to 10:15 am on 12 March 2009.

3. On or before 5.00 pm on 6 March 2009 the respondent file and serve:

(a) any affidavits on which it proposes to rely at the penalty hearing; and

(b) an outline of its written submissions.

4. On or before 5.00 pm on 11 March 2009 the applicant:

(a) file and serve any answering affidavits on which it proposes to rely at the penalty hearing; and

(b) an outline of its written submissions.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This material was relied on in support of both notices of motion.THE EVIDENCE The uncontradicted evidence, which I accept, deals with events which occurred between 19-23 February 2009 inclusive.Thursday 19 February 2009 At approximately 5.30 pm on Thursday 19 February 2009, Mr Peterson returned from this Court to the site. Five cars were parked across the driveway which led to the main vehicle entrance gate on Flemington Road. The registration numbers of those cars were not recorded. Eight people were next to the cars, four or five of whom were sitting on chairs and the remainder were standing close by. Included in the eight were Ralph Edwards, President of the Victorian branch of the CFMEU, Matt Hudson, Vice-President of the Victorian branch of the CFMEU, and Derek Christopher, Gerard Benstead and Brendan Murphy each of whom are CFMEU officers or organisers. Mr Peterson told Mr Hudson, Mr Christopher and Mr Edwards that he had just been to Court, that the Court had made orders and that they needed to remove the cars from the driveway. Mr Hudson said that he hadn’t received any orders and that he would wait for instructions from his office. Mr Peterson attempted to give Mr Edwards a copy of the sealed Orders, but he would not accept them. Mr Peterson then attempted to give a copy of the Orders to Mr Hudson but, like Mr Edwards, Mr Hudson would not take the Orders. Following this, Mr Broadhead attempted to give Mr Christopher a copy of the Orders. When he would not accept them, Mr Broadhead dropped a copy of the Orders on Mr Christopher’s legs. Mr Christopher let it fall to the ground. Mr Broadhead then put a copy of the Orders on Mr Hudson’s lap. Mr Hudson also let the copy of the Orders fall to the ground. Mr Peterson indicated to Mr Hudson that Mr Hudson needed to call the CFMEU’s lawyers and that he would be given half an hour to do so, following which the police would be called and he would return to Court to get the people and vehicles moved. Mr Hudson replied with words to the effect “It’s do or die for us, you do what you have to do.” Again Mr Broadhead tried to give Mr Hudson a copy of the Orders, but Mr Hudson refused and said he would wait to hear from his office. At approximately 6.20 pm, the same five cars were still obstructing the vehicle entrance to the site. Mr Peterson recognised these cars as new model Commodore cars driven by CFMEU officials. Again, the registration numbers were not noted. Mr Broadhead asked Mr Hudson whether he (Mr Hudson) had contacted the CFMEU’s legal people. Mr Hudson said “No, but we’re not going anywhere.” Mr Peterson gave Mr Hudson a copy of the Orders and said he should read them. Mr Broadhead asked whether they were going to move the cars. Mr Hudson asked for half an hour to respond. At approximately 7.00 pm, Mr Peterson received a phone call from the driver of a waste truck who was scheduled to drop off bins on the site. The driver told Mr Peterson that he would be at the site in ten minutes. At this time, the entrance of the site was still obstructed by five or six parked Commodore vehicles. Some but not all of the cars were cars which had been observed earlier. Mr Peterson approached Mr Edwards and asked for Mr Hudson. He told Mr Edwards that Bovis had a delivery coming and that he needed Mr Edwards to move the cars. Mr Broadhead then asked Mr Edwards whether he had heard anything from his office and whether he was going to move the cars. Mr Edwards said words to the effect “No, we are not moving them.” When it arrived, the waste truck was unable, because of the parked cars, to drive through the vehicle entrance gate to the site. It left.

Decision

Reasons for decision

TRACEY J
I am satisfied that each element of the second charge has been established beyond reasonable doubt, but only in respect to the incidents on 19 and 23 February 2009 when vehicles were prevented from entering the site.CONCLUSION The CFMEU is not guilty of the first charge. The second charge has been established beyond reasonable doubt but only in relation to the two incidents which occurred, respectively, on 19 and 23 February 2009. I will give directions as to the steps which need to be taken in advance of the hearing on penalty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: TRACEY J

The second charge alleged that the CFMEU contravened the first order made by Marshall J by maintaining, on nominated dates, an obstruction or interference to the movement of persons (whether on foot or in a vehicle) into or out of the site. It is clear that this is an allegation of acts performed by the CFMEU acting, as it must, through individual officials. The particulars alleged that the obstruction and interference was caused by the marquee or tents placed at the entrance and by the parking of vehicles (some of which are identified by reference to their registration numbers) so as to interfere with and impede access to the site.CONSIDERATIONFunction of the Court Where an allegation of contempt of court is made, the court is required to examine the statement of charge and form a view, on the evidence, as to whether or not it has been established, beyond reasonable doubt, that the respondent engaged in the conduct which it is alleged constituted the contempt or failed to act as required.Inferences In seeking to make good each of the charges Bovis invites the Court to draw certain inferences. This invitation is made in circumstances in which none of the officials of the CFMEU who were present at the Parkville site at relevant times and who might reasonably have been expected to have knowledge of relevant events, gave evidence. No adverse inference can be drawn merely because the CFMEU has chosen not to call evidence in defence of the charges. The failure is nonetheless of potential significance. This is because, as the High Court explained in RPS v R (2000) 199 CLR 620 at 632-3:“…it will seldom, if ever, be reasonable to conclude that an accused in a criminal trial would be expected to give evidence. The most that can be said in criminal matters is that there are some cases in which evidence (or an explanation) contradicting an apparently damning inference to be drawn from proven facts could come only from the accused. In the absence of such evidence or explanation, the jury may more readily draw the conclusion which the prosecution seeks. As was said in Weissensteiner v The Queen: “[I]n a criminal trial, hypotheses consistent with innocence may cease to be rational or reasonable in the absence of evidence to support them when that evidence, if it exists at all, must be within the knowledge of the accused.” (Emphasis in original). (Footnote omitted). The inferences which Bovis invited the Court to draw are founded on uncontradicted evidence. In some instances I have not been prepared to draw the inferences which Bovis contended were open on the evidence. In each instance in which I have been prepared to draw a particular inference I have done so because I have been satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the inferences ought to be drawn, that the conclusions contended for by Bovis were supported by the evidence and that the evidence did not support a finding that there is any reasonable or rational hypothesis consistent with the CFMEU’s innocence.The First Charge