Borcherdt v Scott

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Borcherdt v Scott [2013] NSWSC 285
Hearing dates:25-26 March 2013
Decision date: 03 April 2013
Before: Adamson J
Decision:

(1) Appeal dismissed.

(2) Costs reserved.

Catchwords: APPEALS-interference with findings of fact-Fox v Percy
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW-apprehended bias-display of irritation does not generate apprehension
MAGISTRATES-appeals under s 39 and s 40 Local Courts Act 2007
PROCEDURE-imposition of time limitations-not procedurally unfair considering overriding purpose of Civil Procedure Act 2005
PROCEDURE-litigants in person-no obligation upon judicial officer to advise of forensic errors
PROCEDURE-judicial preparation in advance of hearing-no error
Legislation Cited: - Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s 44
- Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 56, s 57, s 58
- Local Court Act 2007, s 39, s 40
- Partnership Act 1892
Cases Cited: - Abalos v Australian Postal Commission [1990] HCA 47; 171 CLR 167
- Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 (HL)
- Devries v Australian National Railways Commission [1993] HCA 78; 177 CLR 472
- Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; 214 CLR 118
- Jones v Hyde [1989] HCA 20; 63 ALJR 349
- Kostas v HIA Insurance Services Pty Limited [2010] HCA 32; 241 CLR 390
- Russell v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] FCA 343; 168 FCR 330
- RJ Borcherdt and GP Scott trading as Nymboida Native Timbers and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 939
- Young v Queensland Trustees Limited [1956] HCA 51; 99 CLR 560
Texts Cited: Judicial Commission of New South Wales, Civil Trials Bench Book
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Robert John Borcherdt (Plaintiff)
Coswald Thomas Scott (Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
Plaintiff in person
M Boulton (Defendant)
Solicitors:
MJO Legal (Defendant)
File Number(s):2012/139576
Publication restriction:Nil
 Decision under appeal 
Jurisdiction:
9109
Date of Decision:
2012-04-04 00:00:00
Before:
Heilpern LCM
File Number(s):
2011/203244
2011/203267
2011/203279

Judgment

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff appeals to this Court pursuant to s 39 and s 40 of the Local Court Act 2007 (the Act) against a decision of Magistrate Heilpern (the Court below) to dismiss his claims against the defendant.

  1. In so far as the plaintiff raises a question of law he has a right to appeal to this Court: s 39 of the Act. In so far as the plaintiff's appeal raises a question of mixed law and fact or concerns an order for costs he requires leave to appeal: s 40 of the Act.

Facts

  1. In June 2011 the plaintiff commenced the following three proceedings in the Local Court at Grafton:

(1)   No. 203244 of 2011, claiming repayment of monies alleged to have been advanced to the defendant for purchase of, and repairs to, a Caterpillar D9 dozer (the Dozer Proceedings);

(2)   No. 203267 of 2011, claiming return of goods alleged to belong to the plaintiff which were left at the defendant's property at Nymboida (the Goods Proceedings); and

(3)   No. 203279 of 2011, claiming repayment of monies alleged to have been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borcherdt v Scott and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 285
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Borcherdt v Scott, the plaintiff, RJ Borcherdt, sought to challenge certain decisions made by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) through the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT upheld the ATO's decisions, leading to an appeal by the plaintiff to the Federal Court. The primary issues before the court were whether the trial judge had erred in their findings of fact and whether there were procedural irregularities in the lower court proceedings that impacted the outcome. The plaintiff argued that the lower court misconstrued the nature of the tax liability and denied procedural fairness by not allowing certain evidence to be presented.

The court examined whether the lower court's findings of fact were correct and if there was any procedural unfairness in the trial. Regarding the findings of fact, the court found no error in the lower court's decision that the tax liability was a present debt rather than a contingent one. The court also noted that the plaintiff had adequately cross-examined the relevant witness and put forward the necessary evidence, thereby negating claims of procedural unfairness. The court further held that the display of irritation by the trial judge did not constitute apprehended bias. Additionally, the court found no procedural unfairness in the lower court's handling of the case, including the time limitations imposed and the presentation of evidence.

The reasoning and outcome of the court were that the lower court did not err in its findings of fact or in the procedures followed. The appeal was dismissed, and no orders were made beyond the affirmation of the lower court's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The substance of the ATO letter is set out above. The plaintiff sought administrative review in the AAT of the ATO's decision as expressed in the letter (the objection decisions). The objection decisions under review were affirmed by the AAT: RJ Borcherdt and GP Scott trading as Nymboida Native Timbers and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 939 on the basis that the AAT was not persuaded that the Commissioner's decision was excessive or should have been made differently. The plaintiff informed me from the Bar table that he had appealed to the Federal Court from the decision of the AAT. Such an appeal is limited to questions of law: s 44 Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). After a hearing on 6 February 2013 the Federal Court reserved its decision. No judgment has yet been delivered. The plaintiff submitted that since no assessment had issued in relation to the objection decisions, there was no "debt" owing by the partnership and that therefore the Court below was in error in finding as follows: Glen Scott did not return the goods which were partnership property because of the amount which the ATO considered to be owing to it by the partnership, which had been the subject of an unsuccessful challenge by the plaintiff in the AAT. The Court below found, relevantly: Whether the liability of the plaintiff and Glen Scott was a present debt or a contingent liability that would not accrue until an assessment was issued which nominated a date on which the amount was due and payable was immaterial to the decision of the Court below, and also to Glen Scott's appreciation of his potential liability to the ATO. In addition, the plaintiff contended in his written submissions that: In this Court the plaintiff tendered the transcript of the AAT proceedings and contended that it was relevant material on which he was prevented by the Court below from relying and that his amounted to a denial of procedural fairness. The plaintiff contended that Glen Scott had admitted in the AAT proceedings that his father, the defendant, was part of the partnership. The plaintiff submitted that he wanted to put these matters to Glen Scott in the Court below but was denied the opportunity. This matter has already been dealt with in connection with the way in which the matter was heard. The transcript of the proceedings in the Court below establishes that the plaintiff drew Glen Scott's attention to the evidence he had given in the AAT and questioned him about it. Although it was examination in chief it was conducted as if it were a cross-examination. The plaintiff read out passages from the transcript and obtained Glen Scott's agreement to what had occurred in the AAT. In any event, the plaintiff put such matters to the defendant. No Browne v Dunn point was, or indeed could, in my view, have been, taken as to whether he should have put them more fully to Glen Scott. The transcript also reveals that the plaintiff put matters concerning a response, which was apparently written on behalf of Glen Scott by a Ms Hunter in response to the ATO letter. Glen Scott said that he did not know if he had seen a letter before. The plaintiff then continued to cross-examine him about the letter, Mr James then objected and the Court below noted that the plaintiff was:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established